Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?


:rolleyes: indeed

If Tony were really serious about this, he would be talking with leading researchers and organizations and collaborating with them to reach a better understanding. Take a guy like Dr. Asif Usmani, who did a lot of the fire modeling research and work for NIST re the WTC complex. That man has published more papers on the topic of fire science than Tony or anyone here has ever even read. He's even the world's foremost expert in computer interpretation and simulation of the Cardington test results. If Tony had a serious, definable issue with the fire modeling that NIST did, wouldn't the obvious thing to do be to shoot Dr. Usmani an email and ask for his thoughts? That's how experts deal with issues in my professional field--exchange some emails and jump on a quick call if necessary. Yet, since Tony knows he cannot articulate the supposed issues he's found with such models in sufficient detail to actually have a meaningful conversation with an expert (he struggles to make detailed and consistent arguments here in a forum of non-experts, after all) about these subjects, he instead just bounces half baked theories off of us.

Moreover, as the 2015 ACEC grand award to WAI shows, there is great interest in the professional engineering community in understanding the myriad issues involved in the WTC 7 collapse. There are many people who take understanding these issues very seriously because they need to make design choices every day on structures that are susceptible to the same types of failures. You can see this keen interest even if you just read through the NIST report public comments. There are hundreds of professional engineers and firms represented in those comments. (Truther types should know this, given that they often cite David Chandler's questions from that record. Do they even realize the question before his came from an Arup expert?) And the professional conversation about these issues has continued for years in academic journals and trade publications. Last night I even stumbled upon the fact that Arup has even independently modeled and studied the twin tower collapses as well and participated in the conversation over appropriate design and code improvements. (See, e.g., http://www.controleng.com/single-ar...roofing/0f411f2439a4c297374772e5e3d75732.html, http://mosenltd.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/WTC-ten-years-on.pdf, https://www.iccsafe.org/cs/codes/Documents/2006-07cycle/ProposedChanges/volume_1/14-G163-G167.pdf)

Why don't Tony and Richard Gage et al ever start the conversation from an honest place and share with their fellow travelers all of the massive amount of professional opinion that exists re the fire induced collapse hypotheses?
 
Last edited:
Linear analysis is great UP TO YIELD.
However, yield in compression is a different value than yield in tension, which is different from yield in shear, and yield in bearing is a totally different breed of cat. All of these change with temperature.
So at that point you have to go nonlinear in material. But because the deflections start increasing, you also need to go nonlinear geometry.
Steel is tricky, because of the "knee" in the modulus value (FEM falls apart with negative slope) so you have to split it up a lot.
Last one of those I did required 18 hours of computation on a small model. (Like "only" 30000 degrees of freedom)(5000 nodes) I had to ignore local buckling effects to get that few...

Yes I am happy we have your experience as well as Ozzie's.

Tony can't possibly have accomplished what he claims to have.
 
15 years - no evidence for CD = infinite failure

Fantasy CD proponents with more BS about rational studies to cover their failure, they have zero evidence for CD.

What is the next tangent for failed CD claim pushers?

Why has 9/11 truth CD fantasy pushers failed to present evidence for CD? There is no evidence.

Can't provide evidence for CD, so attack other studies... 9/11 truth logic failure
 
Why don't Tony and Richard Gage et al ever start the conversation from an honest place and share with their fellow travelers all of the massive amount of professional opinion that exists re the fire induced collapse hypotheses?

At this point a question that doesn't need to be asked.............
 
Are you actually saying you can't figure out what the Weidlinger report means when it says " 4.5 hours of fire exposure" in the figures on page B-83 and B-84?

Oystein is either very confused because he is commenting too fast or he is asking intentionally ridiculous and inane questions, in an attempt to pretend I am holding something back, because he has nothing else to counter what I am saying.
Haha that's damned right: I have nothing to counter - because you made no claim that could be countered.
Why do you even suppose I wanted to counter anything?

I merely asked you to start off your thread by
FIRST: Citing properly the information you wish to debate (Author; Title; Year; Publisher; URL; ...) - ideally provide quotes.
SECONDLY: Explaining what the relevance of the cited information is
THIRDLY: Presenting a well-formed claim or argument, or asking a specific question (or several)

You had a bad start on first, and had totally failed at second and third.
This is embarrassing for someone professing to be an engineer.

Maybe he was confused by page 20. That is the pdf page. The page number at the bottom of the page I mean is page 18.
Hahaha YOU made this mistake, but I am the one confused? You are such a darling - never failing to be malevolently dishonest! :)

Figure 7 on page 18 (pdf 20) says

Steel temperature distribution (degrees C) prior to connection failure initiation on the east portion of the 10th floor. This occurs after 4.5 hours of continual heating due to fire.

Figure 60 on page B-85 says

Vertical velocity (in/msec) after 4.5 hours of heating. Peak velocity at the secondary beam south of column 80 illustrates that failure initiates here.

I think it is pretty clear what they mean.
Then say it - what, specifically, has been heated for 4.5 hours, and how? And where does this duration come from?

In other words: Summarize, for the benefit of those you want to pose questions to, the methodology of the WAI report. Not so much because we (e.g. I) can't figure it out, and more because we need to checl whether you understand it.

You see, you apparently insinuate that 4.5 hours of heating is somehow too long. So we must know what process thise number actually measures. You must know it. If you can't explain it, then I guess you don't understand it. Your question then should be "can anyone explain this to me, please?" ;)

If you still aren't sure maybe you guys/gals should take some classes from Crazy Chainsaw on thermal terms.
It's your thread. YOU should define context and terms. You weasle.
 
Not only that.

The method we use for safe destruction of HE stocks that are expired (believe it or not, explosive materials and many devices have expiration dates) is burning.

Any explosives that were waiting in the impact zone would have been burned off pretty quick.

Exposure to fire will often initiate conflagration in an explosive device before the detonator can do it's job.


It simply amazes me to think that despite WTC 7 burning for hours and the major impact damage imflicted on its southern wall, Truthers believe that explosives were used
 
NIST uses 4 hours of heating and Weidlinger uses 4.5 hours.
This is actually WRONG.
They "use" more hours of heating, it's just that 4/4.5 hours into simulated heating scenario, something of interest happened.

I would call those durations worst case based on the reality that office fires don't contain enough fuel to burn hot in a local area for more than 2 hours. This is what the Cardington tests showed.
What is "a local area"?
Do the 4/4.5 hours you refer to in the NIST/WAI report pertain to "fuel to burn hot in a local area" as per the Cardington test?

You ought to answer: "Clearly NOT!"

Additionally, one poster on here had been questioning where NIST says 4 hour heating. It is mentioned several times in NIST NCSTAR 1-9 chapters 11.3 and 11.4.
Please provide and explain the context.
Do these 4 hours describe "fuel to burn hot in a local area" as per the Cardington test?

You ought to answer: "Clearly NOT!"
 
Not only that.

The method we use for safe destruction of HE stocks that are expired (believe it or not, explosive materials and many devices have expiration dates) is burning.

Any explosives that were waiting in the impact zone would have been burned off pretty quick.

Exposure to fire will often initiate conflagration in an explosive device before the detonator can do it's job.

Where have I heard this before...

...ah yes! Danny Jowenko said this, 10 years ago, on Dutch TV, when he explained why WTC1+2 could not possibly have been explosive demolitions!

Tony, you are aware that Danny Jowenko explained 10 years ago that WTC1+2 could not possibly have been explosive demolitions, and why, right? RIGHT, Tony?

So since you heard Jowenko explain that fires destroy demo charges at temps under 300 °C - where would you have placed the demo charges in WTC7? :D

(Prediction: Tony will totally ignore this question in order to not acknowledge he knows that Jowenko truly said the above. No truther ever does. They are mortally afraid of the truth)
 
Last edited:
Wait a minute, aren't you the guy who was saying on the Political forum that ARUP and NIST both said the beam came off its seat here http://www.politicalforum.com/9-11/456693-tony-szamboti-discusses-his-wtc7-discovery-9.html?

Of course, it was the girder that they both say came off its seat, one says it was pushed to the west (NIST) and the other says it was pulled to the east (ARUP).

Tony, girders ARE beams!

A girder is a support beam used in construction.[1] It is the main horizontal support of a structure which supports smaller beams.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Girder

BTW, when are you going to demonstrate that a standing building is being accelerated to the Earth? :rolleyes:
 
Not only that.

The method we use for safe destruction of HE stocks that are expired (believe it or not, explosive materials and many devices have expiration dates) is burning.

And, believe it or not, you actually get more energy by burning most high explosives like TNT than by detonating them! (But not more power.) :)

According to lore, C-4 was widely used by G.I.s in Vietnam as fuel in cookstoves.
 
And, believe it or not, you actually get more energy by burning most high explosives like TNT than by detonating them! (But not more power.) :)

According to lore, C-4 was widely used by G.I.s in Vietnam as fuel in cookstoves.

That is not correct it was used to cook food, when it was to wet to light the normal fuel, do to the monsoon like rains.
 
And, believe it or not, you actually get more energy by burning most high explosives like TNT than by detonating them! (But not more power.) :)

According to lore, C-4 was widely used by G.I.s in Vietnam as fuel in cookstoves.

That is not correct it was used to cook food, when it was to wet to light the normal fuel, do to the monsoon like rains.


I think you guys just claimed the same thing............:cool:
 
And, believe it or not, you actually get more energy by burning most high explosives like TNT than by detonating them! (But not more power.) :)

According to lore, C-4 was widely used by G.I.s in Vietnam as fuel in cookstoves.

That's why they're disposed of in small batches as opposed to stacking up large quantities and putting the torch to 'em.

I've cooked with C4, brewed coffee w/ C4 and have heated meals on the exhaust manifolds of trucks.

It's the trifecta of improvised cooking techniques.
 
Wait a minute, aren't you the guy who was saying on the Political forum that ARUP and NIST both said the beam came off its seat here http://www.politicalforum.com/9-11/456693-tony-szamboti-discusses-his-wtc7-discovery-9.html?
Yup, that was me. Your attention to detail is just amazing Tony!

:rolleyes:

Of course, it was the girder that they both say came off its seat, one says it was pushed to the west (NIST) and the other says it was pulled to the east (ARUP).
Really? So you were confused when I said "beam" instead of "girder" when I posted a screenshot of ARUP's conclusion or when I said "the beam between column 79 and 44"? A girder is a type of beam is it not? Nice semantics game you play when cornered.

However, ARUP did show the NIST push-off to the west could not have occurred due to girder trapping behind column 79's side plate.
Yet you don't trust ARUP's report AND said you found fatal errors in it? How can you sit there and say that ARUP proved NIST wrong when you don't believe them AND found fatal errors in that report!

You obviously have the ARUP analysis, so the question is how did you miss that?
See above. You like ARUP's report when it agrees with you, but don't like it when it goes against you. What a joke.

Neither can provide an analysis that shows that even if the girder fell that it could break through the next floor down. I showed that could not happen and you know it. You sound like somebody that is just trying to confuse and give somebody else a hard time.
You've showed nothing Tony. That's why people here are clamoring for your models and analysis right? "You showed"... What a bunch of crap. All you have is a couple of "back of the napkin" calculations. What about your detailed explanation on how controlled demolition brought down WTC7 Tony? You won't present one because you KNOW it will be dismantled.

Goodbye Gamolon.
Typical truther tactic. When cornered, just leave.

You should have a little more respect for others than you do.
Oh I do have respect for others Tony. When they deserve it. You don't deserve it.
 
Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?
It strikes me that this is a definitive yes.

There are many examples of office fires lasting more than 4.5 hours including Delft University fire and the Windsor.

Many of these fires were investigated using a fire spread/intensity computer simulations.

Now what Tony actually means is "Is it valid to expect an office fire to burn, in one area, in a simulation, for 4.5 hours?"
However, do the NIST fire sims programs actually show any fire burning in ONE area for 4.5 hours? I don't think so. IIRC the graphics show the gas temps in the areas studied.
Seems to me, non-expert that I am, that this does not equate to something "burning" at any one spot, that the gas temp is affected by the gas/air/smoke currents in the room, by radiative effects from that matter which is burning, and by flashover at ceiling level as opposed to what is combusting at floor level.
 

double indeed

thum_304704ac5a5ea39338.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom