benthamitemetric
Muse
- Joined
- Dec 21, 2015
- Messages
- 572
If Tony were really serious about this, he would be talking with leading researchers and organizations and collaborating with them to reach a better understanding. Take a guy like Dr. Asif Usmani, who did a lot of the fire modeling research and work for NIST re the WTC complex. That man has published more papers on the topic of fire science than Tony or anyone here has ever even read. He's even the world's foremost expert in computer interpretation and simulation of the Cardington test results. If Tony had a serious, definable issue with the fire modeling that NIST did, wouldn't the obvious thing to do be to shoot Dr. Usmani an email and ask for his thoughts? That's how experts deal with issues in my professional field--exchange some emails and jump on a quick call if necessary. Yet, since Tony knows he cannot articulate the supposed issues he's found with such models in sufficient detail to actually have a meaningful conversation with an expert (he struggles to make detailed and consistent arguments here in a forum of non-experts, after all) about these subjects, he instead just bounces half baked theories off of us.
Moreover, as the 2015 ACEC grand award to WAI shows, there is great interest in the professional engineering community in understanding the myriad issues involved in the WTC 7 collapse. There are many people who take understanding these issues very seriously because they need to make design choices every day on structures that are susceptible to the same types of failures. You can see this keen interest even if you just read through the NIST report public comments. There are hundreds of professional engineers and firms represented in those comments. (Truther types should know this, given that they often cite David Chandler's questions from that record. Do they even realize the question before his came from an Arup expert?) And the professional conversation about these issues has continued for years in academic journals and trade publications. Last night I even stumbled upon the fact that Arup has even independently modeled and studied the twin tower collapses as well and participated in the conversation over appropriate design and code improvements. (See, e.g., http://www.controleng.com/single-ar...roofing/0f411f2439a4c297374772e5e3d75732.html, http://mosenltd.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/WTC-ten-years-on.pdf, https://www.iccsafe.org/cs/codes/Documents/2006-07cycle/ProposedChanges/volume_1/14-G163-G167.pdf)
Why don't Tony and Richard Gage et al ever start the conversation from an honest place and share with their fellow travelers all of the massive amount of professional opinion that exists re the fire induced collapse hypotheses?
Last edited:

