Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

Can you explain something please?

How in the world can you say this abpout the ARUP report:


...then this:


...and then turn around and use the ARUP report, a report you have admitted to having doubts about AND supposeldy contains FATAL (your words) errors, to use as proof that NIST was wrong?

Are you kidding me?

Wait a minute, aren't you the guy who was saying on the Political forum that ARUP and NIST both said the beam came off its seat here http://www.politicalforum.com/9-11/456693-tony-szamboti-discusses-his-wtc7-discovery-9.html?

Of course, it was the girder that they both say came off its seat, one says it was pushed to the west (NIST) and the other says it was pulled to the east (ARUP).

However, ARUP did show the NIST push-off to the west could not have occurred due to girder trapping behind column 79's side plate. You obviously have the ARUP analysis, so the question is how did you miss that?

Neither can provide an analysis that shows that even if the girder fell that it could break through the next floor down. I showed that could not happen and you know it. You sound like somebody that is just trying to confuse and give somebody else a hard time.

Goodbye Gamolon. You should have a little more respect for others than you do.

Edited by Agatha: 
Do not alter members' usernames
 
Last edited by a moderator:
NIST uses 4 hours of heating and Weidlinger uses 4.5 hours. I would call those durations worst case based on the reality that office fires don't contain enough fuel to burn hot in a local area for more than 2 hours. This is what the Cardington tests showed.

Additionally, one poster on here had been questioning where NIST says 4 hour heating. It is mentioned several times in NIST NCSTAR 1-9 chapters 11.3 and 11.4.

I think you generally want to believe what you were told, unfortunately what you were told was impossible.

Can you provide a source re the appropriate burn time for fires in an unfought office fire in a building the size of WTC 7 that contained the fire loads of WTC 7? I won't simply suppose that the chairman of the International Association for Fire Safety Science was completely off the mark in his assessment just on your say so and your laughable misapplication of the Cardington test results. For example, can you quote me where the Cardington test designers concluded they had deduced some sort of universal rule applicable to all types of office fires? It's funny how, after I pointed out on the first page of this thread how the Cardington tests showed that, even in that limited test environment, office fires could heat structural elements far hotter than was necessary to fail the elements in the ARUP, NIST or WAI models, you stopped trying to be specific about what you thought those tests showed with respect to whatever argument you think you are trying to make.

Also, it is worth pointing out how, if you look at the the actual temperature curves in the WAI paper, you will see that characterizing the fire as a "4.5 hour burn in a single location" is something you have simply spun up on your own. Those are the temperature curves of traveling fires that only reached peak intensity at the collapse areas within the hour or so before collapse initiated. You do see the hockey stick, yes?

Finally, I let you get away with dodging a lot of points in these back-and-forths, but I will continue to emphasize that you have not shown what would happen to the NIST model under ARUPs temperature assumptions, what would happen to the ARUP model under NIST's temperature assumptions, or anything else that would approach what would be necessary to actually compare the two head-to-head from a mechanic perspective. You are supposedly an engineer and yet you offer nothing more than a cartoon response based on an unproven assertion that, in a model with millions of variables, only one--the expansion of a single girder (under the ridiculous assumption that said girder would have a uniform temperature)--would trump the way all other elements behaved. It's a bridge too far and it's extremely dishonest for you to keep trying to walk across that bridge.

Re impossibility--not only have you not shown fire induced collapse to be impossible, you have not shown a single one of the fulsome finite element modeled collapse scenarios (Bailey, ARUP, NIST, or WAI) that are now publicly available to be impossible. And you certainly haven't shown controlled demolition to be possible. NIST gets published in JSE, WAI gets a prestigious engineering award from ACEC, ARUP continues to be the leader in the field of forensic engineering, and Bailey's career has flourished (as have the careers of nearly all the NIST authors and the other Aegis plaintiff experts). Have you and your fellow travelers received any accolades or other recognition from your peers for your engineering work re WTC 7? It looks like the professionals have spoken, no?
 
Last edited:
Then why are so many of you opposed to a new investigation?

It's a waste of money.

Money we can use for schools, infrastructure, libraries, parks, healthcare, and dozens of other things.

Seriously, investigating the collapse of a building that killed no one in an during an event which occurred on live TV, in front of thousands of FDNY, NYPD, & other federal and state law enforcement personnel has been a waste of time. The NIST report didn't satisfy the kooks, and there is no reason that a new investigation would change their minds based on the simple fact that it will not reveal CD or any nefarious actions beyond the hijacking of commercial jets and the murder of 3000 people.

This thread is yet another example of nitpicking and goal-post moving by TS. He's talks about an office fire as if it is on par with a bonfire. What happened in the NIST simulations ultimately doesn't matter, only what happened inside #7 matters. While there are many serious debates among engineering professionals, none centers around CD.:thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
Flying high there aren't we skybeagle409?

Flying high in the sky of reality, and it is apparent that you havne't a clue as to what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives.

Once again, I will pose this question to you. Have you ever wondered why a huge bomb failed to bring down WTC 1 in 1993? Think about it!
 
I think you generally want to believe what you were told, Unfortunately, what you were told was impossible but I doubt you can be brought to that realization.

I doubt that you can be brought to the realization that there are no magical silent, fireproof explosives, and no black ops ninjas wearing invisibility cloaks to plant them anyway. If you want to bring me to the realization that such things must exist, I'm afraid you'll need to eliminate virtually all other possibilities. And I'm afraid that will take much more than your own half-baked analysis and bare assertions. All that those really show is that you weren't "brought to that realization"; you started there.
 
NIST uses 4 hours of heating and Weidlinger uses 4.5 hours. I would call those durations worst case based on the reality that office fires don't contain enough fuel to burn hot in a local area for more than 2 hours. This is what the Cardington tests showed.

Additionally, one poster on here had been questioning where NIST says 4 hour heating. It is mentioned several times in NIST NCSTAR 1-9 chapters 11.3 and 11.4.

I think you generally want to believe what you were told, Unfortunately, what you were told was impossible but I doubt you can be brought to that realization.

Most offices are not City emergency management centers with tons of supplies stored in the buildings for that purpose.
That give additional fuel loading, in addition the fires in all the world trade center buildings were hot fuel rich fires, the intense black smoke and strong air currents points that out.
Looking at WT7 as a standard office building is the first lie you told.
You have no leg to stand on offering a limited case FEA, when NIST used super computer modeling.
You are essentially comparing mice to elephants Tony.
 
... office fires don't contain enough fuel to burn hot in a local area for more than 2 hours. This is what the Cardington tests showed.

<snip>

No. The fires in the Cardington did not show that office fires last a certain time. The fires in the Cardington tests were designed to last ("burn hot in a local area") for a specific time. This time would vary with the test being performed.

I worked with the people who performed those tests. They knew how to design the fire load (Hell, I've done similar things myself, on a smaller scale), it's not difficult with a timber crib. I assisted them with some of the instrumentation on some of the tests. I witnessed a couple of the tests.

(Note. I retired from working at the Fire Research Station/BRE ten years ago, so unfortunately I have no access to data now)

Dave Smit
 
Last edited:
No. The fires in the Cardington did not show that office fires last a certain time. The fires in the Cardington tests were designed to last ("burn hot in a local area") for a specific time. This time would vary with the test being performed.

I worked with the people who performed those tests. They knew how to design the fire load (Hell, I've done similar things myself, on a smaller scale), it's not difficult with a timber crib. I assisted them with some of the instrumentation on some of the tests. I witnessed a couple of the tests.

(Note. I retired from working at the Fire Research Station/BRE ten years ago, so unfortunately I have no access to data now)

Dave Smit

Yes they were highly controlled experiments designed for a specific type of burn at a given burn rate.
What I am trying to get Tony to understand is he is scientificly and engineeringly making false and inaccurate claims that falsify his assumptions.
 
Then why are so many of you opposed to a new investigation?

I'm not opposed to a new investigation. However, I would require that reasoning for this large expenditure be cogently expressed and formally submitted to the proper authorities.
Why don't you want to do that? Why doesn't AE911T want to do that?

You seem to think all that need be done is to figuratively yell and pout ion the internet and voila, a new investigation will be formed by someone. Then all will be sweetness and light.
 
................
Re impossibility--not only have you not shown fire induced collapse to be impossible, you have not shown a single one of the fulsome finite element modeled collapse scenarios (Bailey, ARUP, NIST, or WAI) that are now publicly available to be impossible. And you certainly haven't shown controlled demolition to be possible. NIST gets published in JSE, WAI gets a prestigious engineering award from ACEC, ARUP continues to be the leader in the field of forensic engineering, and Bailey's career has flourished (as have the careers of nearly all the NIST authors and the other Aegis plaintiff experts). Have you and your fellow travelers received any accolades or other recognition from your peers for your engineering work re WTC 7? It looks like the professionals have spoken, no?

As I said:
It's all just Tony saying that he and he alone, among thousands of engineers has managed to destroy the conclusions of three highly respected engineering firms. Tony is in fact a vastly superior engineer than almost anyone in the in the profession will give him credit for. It is that which has allowed him to utterly destroy NIST, Nordenson & Bailey, Weidlinger, and ARUP.
:rolleyes:
 
When components fail might there be the creation of such non-linear stress concentrations?

rhetorical question.

Yet AE911T and TSz wonder why the WTC7 sim gets further away from what actually happened the longer the sim runs.................

Yes that's why Tony's FEA is BS, even the people who wrote the FEA program, have stated that, it can not and should not be applied in the manor he applies it.

A weld can induce nonlinear stress as can heat effects, tony is using the wrong computer model to begin with.
 
No one knowledeable about explosives would have dared used explosives to demolish the WTC buidlings during the 9/11 attack because explosives leave behind lots of evidence that can be traced.

I might further add that a number of foreign intelligence sources including the Taliban and Russia have pointed their fingers at Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda, not at the Bush Administration. After 9/11, Osama bin Laden admitted that he was responsible, which confirms an earlier warning from the Taliban of Afghanistan to the United States that he was planning such an attack. That was underlined by al-Qaeda when they posted martyr videos of the 9/11 hijackers.

.

Not only that.

The method we use for safe destruction of HE stocks that are expired (believe it or not, explosive materials and many devices have expiration dates) is burning.

Any explosives that were waiting in the impact zone would have been burned off pretty quick.

Exposure to fire will often initiate conflagration in an explosive device before the detonator can do it's job.
 
Yes that's why Tony's FEA is BS, even the people who wrote the FEA program, have stated that, it can not and should not be applied in the manor he applies it.

A weld can induce nonlinear stress as can heat effects, tony is using the wrong computer model to begin with.

Linear FEAs do have their use of course. They do offer a good idea of what the reaction of a structure will be to a loss of a component. In the structural response FEAs that NIST and the others did, its the cumulative effects of the margins of error, and minor effects that are not modeled, and the introduction of non-linear effects over the course of the run, that cause the diversion from what we actually saw occur.

Yes, in the heated portions, your link specifically mentions that plastic realm includes non-linear effects.. Therefore a linear analysis will likely be off the mark.
 
Linear analysis is great UP TO YIELD.
However, yield in compression is a different value than yield in tension, which is different from yield in shear, and yield in bearing is a totally different breed of cat. All of these change with temperature.
So at that point you have to go nonlinear in material. But because the deflections start increasing, you also need to go nonlinear geometry.
Steel is tricky, because of the "knee" in the modulus value (FEM falls apart with negative slope) so you have to split it up a lot.
Last one of those I did required 18 hours of computation on a small model. (Like "only" 30000 degrees of freedom)(5000 nodes) I had to ignore local buckling effects to get that few...
 
Linear FEAs do have their use of course. They do offer a good idea of what the reaction of a structure will be to a loss of a component. In the structural response FEAs that NIST and the others did, its the cumulative effects of the margins of error, and minor effects that are not modeled, and the introduction of non-linear effects over the course of the run, that cause the diversion from what we actually saw occur.

Yes, in the heated portions, your link specifically mentions that plastic realm includes non-linear effects.. Therefore a linear analysis will likely be off the mark.

Yes so Tony could not have possibly, falsified NIST with just one simple FEA.
NIST was a super computer best fit model, not just a simple FEA, Tony doesn't even have the computing power to come close to it.:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom