Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

No one knowledeable about explosives would have dared used explosives to demolish the WTC buidlings during the 9/11 attack because explosives leave behind lots of evidence that can be traced.

I might further add that a number of foreign intelligence sources including the Taliban and Russia have pointed their fingers at Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda, not at the Bush Administration. After 9/11, Osama bin Laden admitted that he was responsible, which confirms an earlier warning from the Taliban of Afghanistan to the United States that he was planning such an attack. That was underlined by al-Qaeda when they posted martyr videos of the 9/11 hijackers.

.


Not to mention the failed 1993 attempt at taking them down. Truthers live in an absurd bubble.
 
...but what Tony needs is to keep his name in the lights with lots of people debating him and stroking his ego

......on things that do not make any difference to Tony's real claims.

............AND making sure that Tony's two or three real claims are not put under scrutiny.


He is winning at that game.

...which is why he'll be too cowardly to debate someone who doesn't have any interest in entertaining his life in the minutiae. Just like the rest of them.
 
The NIST WTC 7 report was shown to be invalid by the ARUP analyses, since the NIST push off can't work due to girder trapping. The ARUP analyses were then shown themselves to contain fatal errors by me and the Weidlinger report.

Can you explain something please?

How in the world can you say this abpout the ARUP report:
I also have my doubts that the girder would have been pulled off its seat but that is made moot by the fact that even if it did it could not cause a floor cascade and loss of lateral support for column 79. Therefore, it never buckles.

You don't even have a point when things are put in context.

...then this:
The ARUP analyses were then shown themselves to contain fatal errors by me and the Weidlinger report.

We are now looking at the Weidlinger report (October 2010) to see if it shows fire could have caused the collapse without any of the fatal flaws exhibited in the other two reports (NIST in November 2008 and ARUP in April 2010).

...and then turn around and use the ARUP report, a report you have admitted to having doubts about AND supposeldy contains FATAL (your words) errors, to use as proof that NIST was wrong?

Are you kidding me?
 
Can you explain something please?

How in the world can you say this abpout the ARUP report:


...then this:


...and then turn around and use the ARUP report, a report you have admitted to having doubts about AND supposeldy contains FATAL (your words) errors, to use as proof that NIST was wrong?

Are you kidding me?

It's all just Tony saying that he and he alone, among thousands of engineers has managed to destroy the conclusions of three highly respected engineering firms. Tony is in fact a vastly superior engineer than almost anyone in the pe in the profession will give him credit for. It is that which has allowed him to utterly destroy NIST, Nordenson, Weidlinger, and ARUP.
 
Engineers have a better way to remove uncertainty where we look to see if a worst or best case are impossible.

The NIST WTC 7 analysis is not valid in even the best case for their contention. It can simply never work because there will never be a situation where 600 degree C beams framing into it are pushing it while the girder remains near room temperature, so as to avoid the column 79 side plate.

It is as sure as saying no human being will ever walk on the sun. There is no need to do millions of calculations to show that to be true.

What was the worst case scenario for WTC 7 and how did you assess what was possible in that scenario? None of NIST, ARUP, Bailey, or WAI were looking at "worst case scenarios" and they all concluded there various fire induced collapse modes that could have initiated anyway. I somehow doubt that the building would have faired better under even worse fire scenarios. It seems, however, there is, at minimum, an ACEC grand award waiting for you if you have actually done the analysis necessary to show that.
 
Last edited:
Can you explain something please?

How in the world can you say this abpout the ARUP report:


...then this:


...and then turn around and use the ARUP report, a report you have admitted to having doubts about AND supposeldy contains FATAL (your words) errors, to use as proof that NIST was wrong?

Are you kidding me?

Tony illustrates "confirmation bias" like Donald Trump illustrates "Narcissistic Personality Disorder" -- basket textbook cases.
 
Last edited:
Then why are so many of you opposed to a new investigation?


Because it is a waste of time and money considering that it has been determined by experts, the WTC buildings collapsed due to fire, in conjunction with impact damage.
 
What experts? Where in the NIST report does it say that the WTC7 collapse was due to impact damage?


Structural and civil engineers, demolition experts, firefighters, and even seismograph experts whose seismographs were in operation that day.

They have stated for the record that their seismographs did not detect CD explosions as the WTC buildings collapsed and confirmed on a number of videos.
 
Last edited:
What was the worst case scenario for WTC 7 and how did you assess what was possible in that scenario? None of NIST, ARUP, Bailey, or WAI were looking at "worst case scenarios" and they all concluded there various fire induced collapse modes that could have initiated anyway. I somehow doubt that the building would have faired better under even worse fire scenarios. It seems, however, there is, at minimum, an ACEC grand award waiting for you if you have actually done the analysis necessary to show that.

NIST uses 4 hours of heating and Weidlinger uses 4.5 hours. I would call those durations worst case based on the reality that office fires don't contain enough fuel to burn hot in a local area for more than 2 hours. This is what the Cardington tests showed.

Additionally, one poster on here had been questioning where NIST says 4 hour heating. It is mentioned several times in NIST NCSTAR 1-9 chapters 11.3 and 11.4.

I think you generally want to believe what you were told, Unfortunately, what you were told was impossible but I doubt you can be brought to that realization.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom