Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

See this shows you aren't an engineer. We can apply bounds to things such as a worst or best case situation.

The NIST WTC 7 analysis is not valid in even the best case for their contention. It can simply never work because there will never be a situation where 600 degree C beams framing into it are pushing it while the girder remains near room temperature, so as to avoid the column 79 side plate.


If you don't think so, then, how about answering the questions that I have posed to you earlier.
 
The same way I stood today within 3 feet of 2800 degreeF heat and didn't burst into flame fires can have complex air flows.

I used a leaf blower to spray diesel fuel on stumps to burn the the temperature of a smokeless wood fire is 2800F.

Air is a good cooling fluid, it rushes into fires sometimes with 100 MPH or more speed, in a strong chimney effect.

A chimney effect fire sounds like a jet engine, I purposely Created a monster one to test Frank's Dr. Greening's fire chemistry Ideas Tony.

Man o man, you are the thermal man. I think anyone here who has a thermal problem should be seeking your advice.
 
Man o man, you are the thermal man. I think anyone here who has a thermal problem should be seeking your advice.

I have been working with fire since I was 14, in construction, air, metal working, and for fun.

I have used both thermite and napalm, and one of my first after school jobs was packing explosives for my cousin to shoot the oil wells, he leased. No 4 wheelers back then pull the rig in with a log skidder or dozer, set it up and pack in the explosives, gas, food, water and anything else they needed. Pack it though the snow and mud when the log skidder and dozer wouldn't go.
Haliburton made a great Monrue cutter charge, for shooting a new oil well.
So yah I know fire.

20141009_181117_zpsfxn6xram.jpg
 
I just don't see how you expect these types of things to happen to items in close proximity with a fire in their immediate area.


How about explaining how fire had resulted in the internal collapse of WTC 5.


Steel Beam Connection Failures

http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/wtc/fig-4-18.jpg


You will notice that the vertical steel beams acted as heatsinks as connections failed a short distance away.


Steel Column Collapse

http://911research.wtc7.net/mirrors/guardian2/wtc/fig-4-19.jpg
 
You need to understand the meaning of the word "citation" in the context of published engineering reports.
You still have not cited anything properly.
At the time, I didn't even have the WAI report, nor did I know where to find it. And you were too goddamned LAZY to simply link to it - as of you hoped no one would actually start reading it! Why, Tony?

But if you must:

Page 20 has nothing on "4.5 hours".

Pages B-83 to B-85 have figures that end at "4.5hour fire exposure".

What does "fire exposure" mean, and how did they arrive at this value? Please explain!
Bump for Tony. I'd also like to see his answers.
 
Bump for Tony. I'd also like to see his answers.

Are you actually saying you can't figure out what the Weidlinger report means when it says " 4.5 hours of fire exposure" in the figures on page B-83 and B-84?

Oystein is either very confused because he is commenting too fast or he is asking intentionally ridiculous and inane questions, in an attempt to pretend I am holding something back, because he has nothing else to counter what I am saying. Do you want to be considered being of the same mold?

Maybe he was confused by page 20. That is the pdf page. The page number at the bottom of the page I mean is page 18.

Figure 7 on page 18 (pdf 20) says

Steel temperature distribution (degrees C) prior to connection failure initiation on the east portion of the 10th floor. This occurs after 4.5 hours of continual heating due to fire.

Figure 60 on page B-85 says

Vertical velocity (in/msec) after 4.5 hours of heating. Peak velocity at the secondary beam south of column 80 illustrates that failure initiates here.

I think it is pretty clear what they mean. If you still aren't sure maybe you guys/gals should take some classes from Crazy Chainsaw on thermal terms.
 
Last edited:
The NIST WTC 7 report was shown to be invalid by the ARUP analyses, since the NIST push off can't work due to girder trapping. The ARUP analyses were then shown themselves to contain fatal errors by me and the Weidlinger report.

.

,,,and of course the later studies concluded that WTC7 must have been brought down using explosives......................
 
We have all heard that the fires will burn up the fuel in any one area in about 1 to 2 hours maximum and also that the fires reach temperatures above 600 degrees C for about 40 to 60 minutes and then start to cool. This was shown in the Cardington test data.


That's not a universal rule and it's not an experimental finding of the Cardington test. The Cardington test was designed to produce that result, by setting the compartment size, fuel load and ventilation to the appropriate values.

The original open [ventilation] area was reduced to give rise to a fire of sufficient duration and temperature to provide the required thermal input to the structural members.

See also appendix B of the document you linked to.

How do the compartment size, fuel loading, and ventilation area of the relevant floor(s) of wtc7 compare? Given those actual values, what time scale is predicted by the formulas used (though not explicitly given) in appendix B? You might need to recruit the relevant fire science expertise to answer those questions, before you go declaring what the time-temperature curves in building 7 should have been.

It's like saying we have all heard a block of ice takes an hour to melt. Meaningless. An ice cube in a highball glass might melt in ten minutes, while an iceberg in the North Atlantic can last for months. It depends on the conditions and scale.
 
I'm not an engineer, as I have told Mr. Szamboti before. I see him using weasel words like so-and-so "admitted" to there being 30 shear studs, etc. Might any of you engineers enlighten me as to why he is using measurements to the hundredth or thousandth of an inch. We are still discussing a giant office building on fire, leaning and deforming, with thousands of individual components being heated, bent, expanding, contracting, etc., right? Virtually nothing in this building was as built when the collapse occurred, so why are these precise measurements being conveyed? Could someone please help me with this? Am I mistaken in thinking that these are more vague weaselly non-claims being made by a representative of ae911truth?
 
So what, exactly, does Tony want from us? A gut-feeling guesstimate opinion whether those 4.5 hours are plausible or not? Without ... calculations??

Because 9/11 was a false flag in front of live cameras it was technically a theatrical performance shown on television. Shed loads of Unions and their rules are involved, but in the case of Fire it's the Screen Actor's Guild. By Guild rules Fire can only be made to work for 3 hours and then needs a two hour break in a trailer with a whole page of rider paragraph requirements. Fire is a pain in the ass the work with. Worse than children. That's why so many movies use CGI these days.
 
I'm not an engineer, as I have told Mr. Szamboti before. I see him using weasel words like so-and-so "admitted" to there being 30 shear studs, etc. Might any of you engineers enlighten me as to why he is using measurements to the hundredth or thousandth of an inch. We are still discussing a giant office building on fire, leaning and deforming, with thousands of individual components being heated, bent, expanding, contracting, etc., right? Virtually nothing in this building was as built when the collapse occurred, so why are these precise measurements being conveyed? Could someone please help me with this? Am I mistaken in thinking that these are more vague weaselly non-claims being made by a representative of ae911truth?

I'm with you. How can Tony consider this valid when he is considering the effect in isolation?

A truther needs to ignore a lot of evidence in order to make their stories work, and that merely prompts one to question their academic integrity.
 
Last edited:
Because 9/11 was a false flag in front of live cameras it was technically a theatrical performance shown on television.


No one knowledeable about explosives would have dared used explosives to demolish the WTC buidlings during the 9/11 attack because explosives leave behind lots of evidence that can be traced.

I might further add that a number of foreign intelligence sources including the Taliban and Russia have pointed their fingers at Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda, not at the Bush Administration. After 9/11, Osama bin Laden admitted that he was responsible, which confirms an earlier warning from the Taliban of Afghanistan to the United States that he was planning such an attack. That was underlined by al-Qaeda when they posted martyr videos of the 9/11 hijackers.

.
 
Last edited:
I'm not an engineer, as I have told Mr. Szamboti before. I see him using weasel words like so-and-so "admitted" to there being 30 shear studs, etc. Might any of you engineers enlighten me as to why he is using measurements to the hundredth or thousandth of an inch. We are still discussing a giant office building on fire, leaning and deforming, with thousands of individual components being heated, bent, expanding, contracting, etc., right? Virtually nothing in this building was as built when the collapse occurred, so why are these precise measurements being conveyed? Could someone please help me with this? Am I mistaken in thinking that these are more vague weaselly non-claims being made by a representative of ae911truth?


It is a game that Tony plays because no matter what you say, he will reject your presentation and sources if they do not point to CD explosives as responsible for the collapse of WTC 7.

Experts do not agree with him and the overwhelming evidence debunks the use of explosives.
 
I think it is pretty clear what they mean. If you still aren't sure maybe you guys/gals should take some classes from Crazy Chainsaw on thermal terms.


I'd noticed that you failed to respond to the data presentation that I had posted. Have you ever wondered why experts do not agree with you?

Now tell us, what do you think the following reports indicate?


WTC 7

WTC Building 7 appears to have suffered significant damage at some point after the WTC Towers had collapsed, according to firefighters at the scene. Firefighter Butch Brandies tells other firefighters that nobody is to go into Building 7 because of creaking and noises coming out of there. [Firehouse Magazine, 8/02]

Battalion Chief John Norman later recalls, "At the edge of the south face you could see that it is very heavily damaged." [Firehouse Magazine, 5/02]

Heavy, thick smoke rises near 7 World Trade Center. Smoke is visible from the upper floors of the 47-story building. Firefighters using transits to determine whether there was any movement in the structure were surprised to discover that it was moving.

"Surprised to discover that it was moving." A real structural engineer would understand what that means considering the extent of physical structural damage, structural buckling, and uncontrolled fires within WTC 7.
 
Last edited:
I'm not an engineer, as I have told Mr. Szamboti before. I see him using weasel words like so-and-so "admitted" to there being 30 shear studs, etc. Might any of you engineers enlighten me as to why he is using measurements to the hundredth or thousandth of an inch. We are still discussing a giant office building on fire, leaning and deforming, with thousands of individual components being heated, bent, expanding, contracting, etc., right? Virtually nothing in this building was as built when the collapse occurred, so why are these precise measurements being conveyed? Could someone please help me with this? Am I mistaken in thinking that these are more vague weaselly non-claims being made by a representative of ae911truth?

They're the result of calculations, and he doesn't seem to understand that he can't claim accuracy greater than the accuracy of the input figures.

If the calculation were 9.0 divided by 13.0, each accurate to one decimal place, the Szambotian result would be 0.692307692307 ;)
 
They're the result of calculations, and he doesn't seem to understand that he can't claim accuracy greater than the accuracy of the input figures.

If the calculation were 9.0 divided by 13.0, each accurate to one decimal place, the Szambotian result would be 0.692307692307 ;)

When I listen to Tony's fire knowledge, I think about this case in Texas.
Did Texas Execute an Innocent Man? Death by Fire …: http://youtu.be/FavPZqlVL-s

Tony has no knowledge in the behavior of fires.
 
Tony has no knowledge in the behavior of fires.
He doesn't need to - in fact the LESS correct his claims the easier for him to succeed at his current game.

Tony has always had a "game". His earlier years it was "Select false premises to support your pre-determined conclusion" with "Missing Jolt" as the prime example. That one served Tony's purpose for several years and still gets a re-run from time to time.

Then came WTC7 and his first few years of excursions into WTC7 and "Girder Walkoff" were similarly based on false foundations. He still gets mileage out of that nonsense.

His objective is consistent - get his opponents burrowing deep into details so that they lose sight of the reality that they are arguing the wrong issue - that Tony has them where he wants them - "in the wrong forest".

Tony's new "game plan" over recent monthn is a high level false dichotomy in this form:

"I have proved that [some expert authority] is wrong THEREFORE I - Tony Sz - am right!"

Utter hogwash. Whether NIST, Bazant, Nordenson, ARUP, Weidlinger, Crazy Chainsaw OR ozeco41 are right or wrong does not make Tony right.

...but what Tony needs is to keep his name in the lights with lots of people debating him and stroking his ego

......on things that do not make any difference to Tony's real claims.

............AND making sure that Tony's two or three real claims are not put under scrutiny.


He is winning at that game.
 
Last edited:
He doesn't need to - in fact the LESS correct his claims the easier for him to succeed at his current game.

Tony has always had a "game". His earlier years it was "Select false premises to support your pre-determined conclusion" with "Missing Jolt" as the prime example. That one served Tony's purpose for several years and still gets a re-run from time to time.

Then came WTC7 and his first few years of excursions into WTC7 and "Girder Walkoff" were similarly based on false foundations. He still gets mileage out of that nonsense.

His objective is consistent - get his opponents burrowing deep into details so that they lose sight of the reality that they are arguing the wrong issue - that Tony has them where he wants them - "in the wrong forest".

Tony's new "game plan" over recent monthn is a high level false dichotomy in this form:

"I have proved that [some expert authority] is wrong THEREFORE I - Tony Sz - am right!"

Utter hogwash. Whether NIST, Bazant, Nordenson, ARUP, Weidlinger, Crazy Chainsaw OR ozeco41 are right or wrong does not make Tony right.

...but what Tony needs is to keep his name in the lights with lots of people debating him and stroking his ego

......on things that do not make any difference to Tony's real claims.

............AND making sure that Tony's two or three real claims are not put under scrutiny.


He is winning at that game.

Agreed that is why I said Tony should title his FEA, a limited case he has no Idea, other than a limited hypothetical sinario.

He is just playing for points with truthers to sell a pamphlet for AE/911 twoof.
 
NIST has girder A2001 heated to 500 degrees C (932 degrees F). The girder is 531.625 inches long and at that length and temperature would grow 1.88 inches on each end.

The girder was only about 1.7 inches away from the column 79 flange and about the same from column 44's web, so it would be right up against each. The side plates on column 79 stuck out 1.8 inches. No matter how you look at it the girder could not be pushed past the side plate. ARUP showed this although it was already known and NIST just ignored it. There is no way to rehabilitate the NIST WTC 7 report on this issue unless you can somehow show the girder never got hotter than about 100 degrees C while it was being pushed by beams alleged to be at 600 degrees C.

The burning question you're ignoring is this:

So what?

None of that drivel even begins to draw a plausible alternate conclusion. It's just word salad, designed to make you feel superior to people like me, who aren't technical. Sorry kiddo. It's not working.

I can't stress that enough. You're not fooling ANYBODY.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom