Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?


The report cites an expert report by Dr. Craig Beyler (a world renowned fire science expert and Chair of the International Association for Fire Safety Science) that provides the basis for WAI's temperature model. The Beyler report is not independently available, as far as I know (like the main WAI report itself, it seems to have been prepared for the defense in the Aegis litigation but never ultimately filed with the court since that case was won on summary judgment, but it was not released with the WAI report). There are, however, references in the report to a 4.5 hour time frame for the peak temperatures in the collapse-initiating area resulting from the fires modeled. If you look at page 17 of the WAI report, fore example, you can get a sense for the fire modeled. Based on the hockey stick of the temperatures, it seems he was likely modeling a traveling fire that only reached peak intensity at the collapse area in the hour before the collapse initiated.
So what, exactly, does Tony want from us? A gut-feeling guesstimate opinion whether those 4.5 hours are plausible or not? Without ... calculations??
 
No, ARUP shows that in the specific heating scenarios they examined that the girder could not be pushed off to the west. They never independently tested NIST's heating scenario or any of the other infinite possible heating scenarios beyond their choice scenarios. If you put NIST's exact temperature model into the ARUP model and the girder got trapped, then you would have a good argument that ARUP showed NIST's model was flawed for omission of certain parts, but that's not what ARUP did.

NIST has girder A2001 heated to 500 degrees C (932 degrees F). The girder is 531.625 inches long and at that length and temperature would grow 1.88 inches on each end.

The girder was only about 1.7 inches away from the column 79 flange and about the same from column 44's web, so it would be right up against each. The side plates on column 79 stuck out 1.8 inches. No matter how you look at it the girder could not be pushed past the side plate. ARUP showed this although it was already known and NIST just ignored it. There is no way to rehabilitate the NIST WTC 7 report on this issue unless you can somehow show the girder never got hotter than about 100 degrees C while it was being pushed by beams alleged to be at 600 degrees C.
 
Last edited:
NIST has girder A2001 heated to 500 degrees C (932 degrees F). The girder is 531.625 inches long and at that length and temperature would grow 1.88 inches on each end.

The girder was only about 1.7 inches away from the column 79 flange and about the same from column 44's web, so it would be right up against each. The side plates on column 79 stuck out 1.8 inches. No matter how you look at it the girder could not be pushed past the side plate. ARUP showed this although it was already known and NIST just ignored it. There is no way to rehabilitate the NIST WTC 7 report on this issue unless you can somehow show the girder never got hotter than about 100 degrees C while it was being pushed by beams alleged to be at 600 degrees C.
How does this fit with the condition of the other members in the system? Are they pristine or are they also effected by the fires.
 
NIST has girder A2001 heated to 500 degrees C (932 degrees F). The girder is 531.625 inches long and at that length and temperature would grow 1.88 inches on each end.

The girder was only about 1.7 inches away from the column 79 flange and about the same from column 44's web, so it would be right up against each. The side plates on column 79 stuck out 1.8 inches. No matter how you look at it the girder could not be pushed past the side plate. ARUP showed this although it was already known and NIST just ignored it. There is no way to rehabilitate the NIST WTC 7 report on this issue unless you can somehow show the girder never got hotter than about 100 degrees C while it was being pushed by beams alleged to be at 600 degrees C.

No problem, air rushing into the fire passing the girder cools it.

Or soot ignites on the beams heating them without heating the girder.

Or how about a hydrogen reaction or carbon monoxide causing soot ignition on the beams and not on the girder?

Point is Tony there are ways that incident itself could have occurred, there is no way
CD occurred.
 
Last edited:
No problem, air rushing into the fire passing the girder cools it.

Or soot ignites on the beams heating them without heating the girder.

Or how about a hydrogen reaction or carbon monoxide causing soot ignition on the beams and not on the girder?

Point is Tony there are ways that incident itself could have occurred, there is no way
CD occurred.

Your thermodynamics are amazing. You seem to be able to heat anything to whatever you need and simultaneously cool anything in very close proximity to what you need. I am in awe.

You should realize that if you say the girder was at 100 degrees C or lower while the beams were at 600 degrees C that the NIST fire simulation was wrong. If they had you on the team maybe they wouldn't have had to ignore the column 79 side plates when they were saying the girder was pushed off to the west.
 
Last edited:
NIST has girder A2001 heated to 500 degrees C (932 degrees F). The girder is 531.625 inches long and at that length and temperature would grow 1.88 inches on each end.

The girder was only about 1.7 inches away from the column 79 flange and about the same from column 44's web, so it would be right up against each. The side plates on column 79 stuck out 1.8 inches. No matter how you look at it the girder could not be pushed past the side plate. ARUP showed this although it was already known and NIST just ignored it. There is no way to rehabilitate the NIST WTC 7 report on this issue unless you can somehow show the girder never got hotter than about 100 degrees C while it was being pushed by beams alleged to be at 600 degrees C.

Again, things like how quickly and at what time portions of the girder, and other elements near the girder, were heated matters. NIST and ARUP handled the heating of all of those elements differently. That you expect the systems modeled in both to react exactly the same is perplexing.

Maybe NIST's collapse initiation mode was in error and maybe ARUP could have shown that. But they didn't. You are again trying to make a bridge too far. You ever notice how all of these bridges too far you try to make all go in just one direction, by the way?
 
Again, things like how quickly and at what time portions of the girder, and other elements near the girder, were heated matters. NIST and ARUP handled the heating of all of those elements differently. That you expect the systems modeled in both to react exactly the same is perplexing.

Maybe NIST's collapse initiation mode was in error and maybe ARUP could have shown that. But they didn't. You are again trying to make a bridge too far. You ever notice how all of these bridges too far you try to make all go in just one direction, by the way?

Don't forget ARUP also refuted NIST by admitting there were 30 shear studs on the girder, which NIST had denied. The girder was only able to move back to the east in their analysis due to the shear studs being broken by thermal expansion of the girder.

If the girder was cool enough to get past the column side plates the shear studs don't break and the girder can't be pushed or pulled anywhere.

The NIST analysis has no way to go. It is invalid and the ARUP analysis showed that in a final way by admitting to the shear studs and girder trapping at the column side plate.
 
Last edited:
Your thermodynamics are amazing. You seem to be able to heat anything to whatever you need and simultaneously cool anything to what you need. I am in awe.

I have heated one side of a steel tube with a torch while cooling the otherside with dry ice, to get it to bend into shape to weld.

If you looked into heat straitening, you would discover how heat really effects steel.

I have been sitting on a dozer backed into the shade after shoving up a huge brush pile, and watched the dozer track pads glow dull red.
Caused the chains to streach and had to replace them.

Fires are complex events, stop looking for easy solutions, they don't work in real fires.
 
And another load of truther BS.

Tony, CD is dumb. Why can't you understand that simple fact? Controlled demolition on 9/11 is the fantasy of the individual who cannot think.
 
Tony, please focus.

You invoked certain intervals of heating of 4 and 4.5 hours, and asked for opinions about them.

You have not yet explained why you would pick out such numbers at random from lengthy reports. What is the relevance, and why, exactly, are you interested?

Please explain what these 4/4.5 hours represent, how they were derived, by whom, when, for what purpose, and how you see a problem there.

Because your own topic remains woefully undefined. That's unworthy of an engineer.
 
I have heated one side of a steel tube with a torch while cooling the otherside with dry ice, to get it to bend into shape to weld.

I just don't see how you expect these types of things to happen to items in close proximity with a fire in their immediate area.
 
Tony, please focus.

You invoked certain intervals of heating of 4 and 4.5 hours, and asked for opinions about them.

You have not yet explained why you would pick out such numbers at random from lengthy reports. What is the relevance, and why, exactly, are you interested?

Please explain what these 4/4.5 hours represent, how they were derived, by whom, when, for what purpose, and how you see a problem there.

Because your own topic remains woefully undefined. That's unworthy of an engineer.

You tell me to focus and in a post above claim that I did not tell you where to find the pages in the Weidlinger report that showed 4.5 hours of heating from fire. I did tell you in post #5 it was pages 20, B-83, B-84, and B-85 and in post #16 you said I didn't tell you.
 
Last edited:
Don't forget ARUP also refuted NIST by admitting there were 30 shear studs on the girder, which NIST had denied. The girder was only able to move back to the east in their analysis due to the shear studs being broken by thermal expansion of the girder.

If the girder was cooler the shear studs don't break and the girder can't be pushed or pulled anywhere.

The NIST analysis has no way to go. It is invalid and the ARUP analysis showed that in a final way by admitting to the shear studs and girder trapping at the column side plate.

The girder was never a uniform temperature, nor were the elements around it. If you really drill down deeply into the NIST and ARUP temperature analyses, you will see the size of subsections for temperature purposes is just another of the great difference between the models. They heat the elements with different temperature curves, they heat the elements at different locations, and they handle localized heating with different levels of granularity. There is no reason to expect the same outcome. These not-so-subtle differences, by the way, carry with them a pretty potent lesson in general why you cannot say any single modeled temperature profile is the way the collapse must have happened. It seems the people writing the reports you are citing keenly understand that. Are you really reading what they are sayin closely?
 
I just don't see how you expect these types of things to happen to items in close proximity with a fire in their immediate area.

Ignore CC. He is clearly on an irrelevant side path.
You want to discuss certain values that arose as NIST and WAI were running models - they surely did not model all the quirks and side effects that CC invokes. So ignore all that!

Define your topic!
What are the 4 hours that you talk of in the NIST model - where can I find them, and what do they mean, in your opinion? How did they arise, and why do you suspect there may a problem with them?

What are the 4.5 hours that you talk of in the WAI model - where can I find them, and what do they mean, in your opinion? How did they arise, and why do you suspect there may a problem with them?

In other words: What the hell is the objective and subject of this thread, and why?

Focus, Tony!
 
The girder was never a uniform temperature, nor were the elements around it. If you really drill down deeply into the NIST and ARUP temperature analyses, you will see the size of subsections for temperature purposes is just another of the great difference between the models. They heat the elements with different temperature curves, they heat the elements at different locations, and they handle localized heating with different levels of granularity. There is no reason to expect the same outcome. These not-so-subtle differences, by the way, carry with them a pretty potent lesson in general why you cannot say any single modeled temperature profile is the way the collapse must have happened. It seems the people writing the reports you are citing keenly understand that. Are you really reading what they are sayin closely?

You should realize that any little bit of expansion of girder A2001 would have caused it to be trapped by the column 79 side plate due to the column geometry and proximity of the girder to the column.

Are you willing to say that girder A2001 could have possibly cleared the column 79 side plates while being pushed by beams which needed to be 600 degrees C to get even near enough expansion?
 
Last edited:
You should realize that any little bit of expansion of girder A2001 would have caused it to be trapped by the column 79 side plate due to the column geometry and proximity of the girder to the column.

Are you willing to say that girder A2001 could have possibly cleared the column 79 side plates while being pushed by beams which needed to be 600 degrees C to get even near enough expansion?

I would need to do millions of calculations to answer that given the different temperatures and distortions of the girder and the elements around it. It's possible that the east side of the girder got heated first, or the middle, or the west side. That's why the experts run fulsome finite element models--to do those calculations. Given that no one--not NIST and certainly not ARUP--has run such a model using NIST's temperature curve and all of the building elements, no one can say exactly what those millions of calculations would portend. I don't think a best guess based on a single, overly simplified calculation of girder expansion given a uniform girder temperature is sufficient to say for sure. I don't think you think that either.
 
You tell me to focus and in a post above claim that I did not tell you where to find the pages in the Weidlinger report that showed 4.5 hours of heating from fire. I did tell you in post #5 it was pages 20, B-83, B-84, and B-85 and in post #16 you said I didn't tell you.

You need to understand the meaning of the word "citation" in the context of published engineering reports.
You still have not cited anything properly.
At the time, I didn't even have the WAI report, nor did I know where to find it. And you were too goddamned LAZY to simply link to it - as of you hoped no one would actually start reading it! Why, Tony?

But if you must:

Page 20 has nothing on "4.5 hours".

Pages B-83 to B-85 have figures that end at "4.5hour fire exposure".

What does "fire exposure" mean, and how did they arrive at this value? Please explain!
 
I would need to do millions of calculations to answer that given the different temperatures and distortions of the girder and the elements around it. It's possible that the east side of the girder got heated first, or the middle, or the west side. That's why the experts run fulsome finite element models--to do those calculations. Given that no one--not NIST and certainly not ARUP--has run such a model using NIST's temperature curve and all of the building elements, no one can say exactly what those millions of calculations would portend. I don't think a best guess based on a single, overly simplified calculation of girder expansion given a uniform girder temperature is sufficient to say for sure. I don't think you think that either.

Engineers have a better way to remove uncertainty where we look to see if a worst or best case are impossible.

The NIST WTC 7 analysis is not valid in even the best case for their contention. It can simply never work because there will never be a situation where 600 degree C beams framing into it are pushing it while the girder remains near room temperature, so as to avoid the column 79 side plate.

It is as sure as saying no human being will ever walk on the sun. There is no need to do millions of calculations to show that to be true.
 
Last edited:
I just don't see how you expect these types of things to happen to items in close proximity with a fire in their immediate area.

The same way I stood today within 3 feet of 2800 degreeF heat and didn't burst into flame fires can have complex air flows.

I used a leaf blower to spray diesel fuel on stumps to burn the the temperature of a smokeless wood fire is 2800F.

Air is a good cooling fluid, it rushes into fires sometimes with 100 MPH or more speed, in a strong chimney effect.

A chimney effect fire sounds like a jet engine, I purposely Created a monster one to test Frank's Dr. Greening's fire chemistry Ideas Tony.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom