Are 4 to 4.5 hour office fire simulations valid?

Guys,

could you please please please all refrain from entertaining Micah's and Criteria's derails of Tony's fail?

The topic is the duration of certain fire sims - NOT another general "all things WTC7" mole slap fest.

Unless you wish to provide Tony with an escape.

My apologies, I won't participate in the derails any longer and just watch as Tony continues to dodge your posts yet again. :)
 
...

How could unfought office cubicle fires miraculously create the CD-kick that booted an ‘8-story chair’ out from under the upper portion of WTC7 resulting in an amazingly level ‘drop’, for over 2 seconds?
Add "level" the the long list of things 9/11 truth believers don't understand.

Why are 9/11 truth claims dumber than dirt. Is your fantasy CD silent explosives or thermite?

Got any evidence to help Tony's fantasy CD claims? No

Now an off topic grip about NIST is made because no CD evidence exists.
 
You failed to answer my second question:

Please answer now: Do you believe you are debating on topic?


Do you believe you are debating on topic?


Do you believe you are debating on topic?


Do you believe you are debating on topic?


Just responding.
 
Your belief that roaming office cubicle fires induced WTC7’s swan dive has never been proven beyond conjecture.

Controlled demolition is unquestionably the most logical explanation for what befell WTC7.

'Swan dive', I love the outrageous hyperbole you guys employ.

CD is an irrational idea which lacks any physical evidence. I'd say that pretty well disqualifies it immediately as a logical explanation.

I can't even understand how a rational individual could embrace such an unrealistic and illogical story. It is just silly.

Why is it that 9/11 truth hold onto such silly ideas in the face of other rational explanations? Is their hatred of 'da gubmint' so ingrained in their psyche that reason has become an irrelevance?
 
We just got the Weidlinger report in June and that is being scrutinized and already has a controversial issue with its 4.5 hour heating.


There seems to be a problem with what you say. Look what just one hour of fire exposure can do to steel.


Bending Steel Rails by Hand

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMrUBFDYe0U


Tell us who long it took for this steel beam to buckle due to direct fire exposure.


Video: What fire can do to a steel beam

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N2TMVDYpp2Q
 
Last edited:
Guys,

could you please please please all refrain from entertaining Micah's and Criteria's derails of Tony's fail?

The topic is the duration of certain fire sims - NOT another general "all things WTC7" mole slap fest.

Unless you wish to provide Tony with an escape.

It appears that Tony, having lost this debate, is no longer posting in it.

Dave
 
I never claimed silent explosives, just pointing out that demolition theorists have tended to think that something exotic was used, like a hypothetical device where the weld point of the columns are directly heated to extremely high temperature before a final explosive blow is delivered.
My mistake then. Rather than hush-a-boom explosives, you give credence to magic.

How does this fit into a coherent explanation that includes the bright flashes of light (which aren't fire), and apparent dismemberment of the actual steel structure (not just gypsum wallboard)?

How does it not? Upper section comes down, expels air(it has to go somewhere)from an area that is on fire and rubblized. Smoke, dust and debris are expelled with said air which flows around the corner columns and out of the building. The upper section and lower sections collide while now wrapped in a cloak of dust. Connections break and the building comes apart at the collapse front.

To understand the unlikelihood of your argument, we must examine video footage. First, check out this opposite angle showing the explosion on the NE corner: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPB9MHgHWB

Here's a compilation of South Tower collapse footage: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qhyu-fZ2nRA
"That video does not exist"

This is an online utility to watch Youtube videos frame-by-frame: http://rowvid.com/?v=qhyu-fZ2nRA
Ok I saw what you must be referring to. Sunlight glinting off of shattering windows or twisting window frames.
Pay close attention to the upper portion, going through footage frame-by-frame, to see the flashes of light in the windows.

Not seeing what you refer to in the upper portion. However, again, sunlight glinting off of windows that are either changing their angle to the sun or simply shattering.

Dust needs time to move through the building.

You apparently do not understand what I am saying. Why is it not possible for a floor to collapse further down and expel dust and air prior to, but not necessarily immediately prior to, full collapse initiation? The building was suffering from the effects of the fire over the course of time between impact and collapse. All the nasty stuff need not have occurred at the same time.
jaydeehess
I simply don't see the corner column being "dismembered". What I see is expulsion of material around the corner column leading the exterior collapse zone where the building exterior is coming apart.
There are no slender "corner columns". There are large spandrel plates that are welded and bolted on the corners to join the perimeter wall units.
How is your response in any way connected to what I said?



Not like you're saying. See further above.

Spell it out for me please. What is your theory on where these smaller, quiet explosives placed?

The footage was taken right after the North Tower collapsed.
Ok, and so what? Fires cannot ignite until after x number of seconds(minutes?). I also asked a question referring to the significance of smoke coming from the federal building. I asked when it collapsed?

jaydeehess
You do know what the NIST and ARUP and others say is the most probable sequence of collapse is, right? Column 79 fails low down in the structure and floors begin failing above that point as col 79 draws down. You for some reason expect that a) column 79 failing shouldn't be noisy, and b ) that it's failure should instantaneously transmit to the roof and cause the EPH to fall immediately.
If the east corner of WTC 7 was gutted in a progressive collapse, the noise of this event should not have been louder than the noise of the entire rest of the structure falling to the ground.
As I said, that ONE video you posted does have a low rumble during collapse that isn't less loud than the low booms prior to the EPH falling in. Both are barely above street noise but one, the low booms, have silence before and after while the rumble of collapse has the much louder voice of the camera owner before and a continuous rumble.

At any rate you managed to simply ignore much of what you quoted of my post. Why do you expect a low failure to immediately transmit to an effect on the rooftop level?
For that matter explain to me why CD is a plausible counter to the several professional engineering firms which have prepared reports on the collapse of WTC7. You know of an equally detailed and concise paper on the collapse of WTC7 that includes an explosive demolition sequence?


jaydeehess
BTW you did not answer the question, you do know what a 50 ton press is and that you could put one in your garage. I suppose I should also ask how you know for certain that no one found a badly damaged 50 ton press that you claim was in WTC7? (or was it in WTC1 or 2?)
What is so difficult about these questions?
Do you know that a 50 ton press does not actually weigh 50 tons? Easy question..........
Yes there was a press in one of the WTC building's basement levels. Do you know which one? Easy question.....
You brought it up and seemed to be implying that said press was pulverized and never found. Is that or is that not what you were saying? Easy question.....


Now I shall read the replies of others, should be sport.
 
Last edited:
There seems to be a problem with what you say. Look what just one hour of fire exposure can do to steel.


Bending Steel Rails by Hand

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMrUBFDYe0U


Tell us who long it took for this steel beam to buckle due to direct fire exposure.


Video: What fire can do to a steel beam

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N2TMVDYpp2Q
I see it now. Tony is questioning where or not a fire simulation run of 4.0 to 4.5 MINUTES is common. Somehow I kept reading that he was asking about 4.5 HOURS :D

<<sarcasm of course in case anyone cares to take me to task for the hyperbole.>>
 
Last edited:
Guys,

could you please please please all refrain from entertaining Micah's and Criteria's derails of Tony's fail?

The topic is the duration of certain fire sims - NOT another general "all things WTC7" mole slap fest.

Unless you wish to provide Tony with an escape.

You might read the topic, and knock it off with the *********** derail...
True that. My bad.

Done and done.
@MichJava & @Criteria, if you want to discuss other aspects may I suggest a thread in which that is the topic.
 
Tony,

please go back to August 9 in this thread, and find out that at least 3 posters have already tried to SCHOOL you on a simple error you committed:

the 4.5 hours do NOT refer to "fire duration in a single location". They refer to the run time of a simulation. During that runtime, modeled fires moved from location to location, and distribution of hot gases and radiation was tracked.
Please find at least MY posts from last week, quote them, and answer the questions I asked you, lest you create the impression you run away from those questions.

You have NOT scrutinized anything. You merely compared an apple with a computer simulation of an apple tree, and insinuated vaguely something sinister because the tree is older than the apple.
You never, however, really spelled out what your question is, your scope, your beef.

I do not recall Tony ever addressing this matter either.

May we get a comment from the only active engineer in AE911T, please.
 
If you are speaking of me, I have certainly done analyses showing the NIST and ARUP reports have fatal flaws and are thus non-explanatory. Don't put words in my mouth either. I never conceded what you are saying. You are starting to spin things. Why?

We just got the Weidlinger report in June and that is being scrutinized and already has a controversial issue with its 4.5 hour heating.

You act as though you don't know these reports are highly controversial and that they are somehow beyond reproach. Unfortunately, nothing could be further from the truth.

What is the fourth report on WTC 7 you are referring to? FEMA?

You do understand that none of that drivel above, or anything you or any other twoofer has provided, comes close to proving controlled demolition, its even further away from providing a complete alternative narrative.

Why?
 
Guys,

could you please please please all refrain from entertaining Micah's and Criteria's derails of Tony's fail?

The topic is the duration of certain fire sims - NOT another general "all things WTC7" mole slap fest.

Unless you wish to provide Tony with an escape.


It doesn't matter what anyone writes, or where they write it. Tony and his ilk will always invent an escape.
 
You do understand that none of that drivel above, or anything you or any other twoofer has provided, comes close to proving controlled demolition, its even further away from providing a complete alternative narrative.

Why?

Well, Tony may complain that he is only one person. That producing an in depth report on par with the detail of any of the other reports on WTC 7 requires more manpower. However, I note that there is at least an apparent pool of a few thousand other engineers he could request assistance from. ,,, and a carpenter or two.
 
Well, Tony may complain that he is only one person. That producing an in depth report on par with the detail of any of the other reports on WTC 7 requires more manpower. However, I note that there is at least an apparent pool of a few thousand other engineers he could request assistance from. ,,, and a carpenter or two.

No, the carpenter uses MSPaintFire.
 
We just got the Weidlinger report in June and that is being scrutinized and already has a controversial issue with its 4.5 hour heating.

You act as though you don't know these reports are highly controversial and that they are somehow beyond reproach. Unfortunately, nothing could be further from the truth.

1. What is the controversial issue with the 4.5 hour heating?

2. The furthest thing from the truth is CD.
 
1. What is the controversial issue with the 4.5 hour heating?

2. The furthest thing from the truth is CD.
The controversy arises from the absolute fact that if 99% of scientists find evidence supporting the earth being an oblate spheroid, and 0.001% state " year, verily, I say unto you that it is indeed flat like unto a pancake " then the controversy is real and must be reinvestigated...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom