Another Vaccination Scare?

Yours is a vague, useless, definition of "science." It could apply to any philosophy, or New Age nonsense. Today, science is a well-honed method for accepting or rejecting data, and the data so-obtained.
Wrong: Science is from latin "Scientia" which simply means "knowledge". Equalling science with the scientific method means confusing the goal with the method.
Don't you ever feel embarassed when promoting your ignorance? Universities date to the 14th century.
Even far more back than that. I didn't say the first university started in 1848 though, I said "the universities, and with them, science's ivory tower".

Which is roughly true, before the mid 1800s, most intellectuals were aristocrats who were manually educated by other intellectuals, and communicated with each other via letters, mostly. While the aristocracy may have been a world for itself, science wasn't. That only began with the universities become more widespread.
Are you well-informed on any topic?
Not to my knowledge.
Popper was a philospher, not a scientist; and his musings have had little effect on what scientists do, since few of us care about philosophy. I am baffled by your reference to him. On the other hand, you don't seem to understand much, either.
Popper was a philosopher who wrote some of the most important pieces on the theory of science and the scientific method.

His strong advocation of a comprehensible science may in part stem from his extensive contact with the german "Dialektik" type philosophy, which was essentially the art of saying nothing in a completely different language, as dialectical philosophical topics became more abstract and arcane since they were to be solved purely within the realm of language.
 
Wrong: Science is from latin "Scientia" which simply means "knowledge". Equalling science with the scientific method means confusing the goal with the method.
Which is exactly my point. You are encroaching on science as known to mdicine (and Popper) and you don't understand it.
Even far more back than that. I didn't say the first university started in 1848 though, I said "the universities, and with them, science's ivory tower".
You said universities date to the mid-1800s, you were hundreds of years off the mark, what date do you claim? I cited the date of the appearance of the word "university" in print in English.
Which is roughly true, before the mid 1800s, most intellectuals were aristocrats who were manually educated by other intellectuals, and communicated with each other via letters, mostly. While the aristocracy may have been a world for itself, science wasn't. That only began with the universities become more widespread.
A citation would help with our understanding of what you imagine.
Not to my knowledge.
Unconvincing, since we have established that you do not have very much knowledge.
Popper was a philosopher who wrote some of the most important pieces on the theory of science and the scientific method. {snip}
It's nice that he was an influential philosopher; however, scientists don't much care.

Let's cut to the chase- you don't know anything about vaccination (or homeopathy); yet you are willing to argue about them. Sophomoric.
 
Nah, I don't know anything. But here's an interesting piece on the original cowpox/smallpox vaccine. Link
Hadwen provides a rare window into the medical research of a century ago, one that has not received the usual whitewash. He tells the amazing story about Prussia, the most vaccinated country in Europe during the 1800s - also the country which kept the best records. Hadwen had access to these medical records before the media had the sense to suppress them. Here's what they showed:

It happened that Prussia passed a mandatory vaccination law in 1834 for smallpox. The law provided that every infant be vaccinated, and then revaccinated when starting school. After graduation the child had to be vaccinated again, and then once more upon entering the Army! And all healthy males had to go into the Army. Anyone who refused the vaccination was to be "held down and vaccinated by force; and so thoroughly was it done that he was vaccinated in ten places on each arm." [14]

OK, so we get the idea that almost 100% of Prussians got Jenner's smallpox vaccine. So what happened in Prussia 35 years after this vaccination law? A smallpox epidemic which killed "124,978 of her vaccinated and re-vaccinated citizens after thirty-five years of compulsory vaccination!" [14]

Also contains some... "tasty" information on how they created the smallpox vaccine in the 1800s:
From an original monograph by Dr Walter Hadwen, here is an account of how smallpox vaccine was first made:

1. A 3 month old calf was tied down on its side.
2. 30 - 50 one inch incisions were made in its stomach
3. Smallpox pus rubbed into each incision
4. Calf is returned to its pen, restrained so as to be unable to lick the sores
5. Wait one week.
6. Smallpox pustules form
7. Calf strapped down again
8. Encrusted pus is scraped off each sore and the remaining blood, lymph, and pus is then drained out.
9. It is placed in a crucible and heated, adding glycerine as a binder
10. Mixed and strained to remove hair and dead flesh.
11. Poured into tubes as sold as pure calf lymph - or smallpox vaccine.

Very scientific. This formula was used for decades, even up to modern times, continuing with Dryvax in 1944. [34] The new smallpox vaccines are still made from this 'purified calf lymph' but with one modern twist: the post 9/11 vaccine is now cultured on the cells of an aborted human fetus. [35].
(Back then, Cowpox and smallpox was believed to be the same disease, which is why the calf was contaminated with smallpox rather than cow pox)
 
Nah, I don't know anything. But here's an interesting piece on the original cowpox/smallpox vaccine. Link


Also contains some... "tasty" information on how they created the smallpox vaccine in the 1800s:
(Back then, Cowpox and smallpox was believed to be the same disease, which is why the calf was contaminated with smallpox rather than cow pox)

Dabljuh... are you that gullible to use that site as a source?

Oh yes. Let's listen to what this expert in disease has to say:
http://thedoctorwithin.com/index_fr.php?page=curriculum_vitae.php

Even if one was to get past this blog author's complete dementia...
Anyone else see a complete lack of education (presuming he even has that much since he lies throughout the blog) in medicine?

This one's my favorite:
Medical Advisory Board - Orassure Group - Holistic Dentistry 2000
 
Last edited:
Dubya, you seem to have difficulty in citing valid scientific sources. Crackpot websites abound on the net - linking us to one does not count as evidence. Here we tend to accept evidence that is peer reviewed and published in a biomedical or science journal.
I would not expect you to believe me if I linked you to a reference that consisted of some anecdotal report, or heresay, or a book or web site - absolutely anyone can write one of these, and their mere existence does not validate their claims.
So you should not expect me to believe any of this type of "evidence" either.

PS: I am disconcerted you rubbish something like the Mayo Clinic Proceedings Journal as "complete BS", yet avidly lap up what "the doctor within" spews out as pure gospel.
 
Last edited:
This one's my favorite:
Medical Advisory Board - Orassure Group - Holistic Dentistry 2000
You do realize that "holistic dentistry" means probably eating less sugar and more calcium, and brushing your teeth?

(As opposed to just brushing your teeth and having a doc fix your cavities)

(You might wanna look up "holistic" once in a while)

Also, the doctor is actually referencing a source for the prussian statistics there. I found the source: here
 
Last edited:
I tend to accept evidence that is peer reviewed and published in a biomedical or science journal.
(fixed)
Yeah I know you're naive, and not particularly bright etc... You might wanna check this out though. (cited by the doctor you dismiss in the link in my sig)
PS: I am disconcerted you rubbish something like the Mayo Clinic Proceedings Journal as "complete BS", yet avidly lap up what "the doctor within" spews out as pure gospel.
The guy seems to be a believer in chiropractice, but other than that, his webpage is extermely informative. The problem with chiropractice is that it sometimes tries to explain *all* malignant conditions with spinal issues, which is not what he does.
 
Last edited:
You do realize that "holistic dentistry" means probably eating less sugar and more calcium, and brushing your teeth?

(As opposed to just brushing your teeth and having a doc fix your cavities)

(You might wanna look up "holistic" once in a while)

Oh I don't know... I actually took the time to read this:
http://thedoctorwithin.com/index_fr.php?page=articles/agenda_american_dentistry.php
And concluded that this nutjob believes there is some great fluoride conspiracy and that cavities should not be filled.

"In the Water chapter ? www.thedoctorwithin.com - we saw tons of referenced information on the stupidity of adding fluoride to city water systems. We also uncovered the important role played by the American Dental Association in promoting the lie that fluoride protects teeth."
"In the burgeoning field of holistic dentistry, Hansen modernizes the pioneering ideas of Weston Price and Hal Huggins. One idea is to minimize or eliminate drilling."
I post these here to alleviate the suffering of anyone else who might be tempted to follow the link. I must be a holistic poster.
 
Oh I don't know... I actually took the time to read this:
http://thedoctorwithin.com/index_fr.php?page=articles/agenda_american_dentistry.php
And concluded that this nutjob believes there is some great fluoride conspiracy and that cavities should not be filled.
I don't know about cavities, I haven't read that article yet. But fluoridation actually is a conspiracy, by the master himself: Bernays.

The point of fluoridation isn't to make people compliant or some other conspiracy ********. Back then, bernays was given a simple task by the chemical industry. They had a little environmental problem with a highly toxic chemical waste product named fluoride and turned to Bernays to improve the PR of fluoride.

In the most stunning PR campaign ever, Bernays convinced the american public that fluoride is "good for children" and that it should be put into drinking water in low doses, elegantly "solving" the waste problem.

Ergo everyone who would complain about (very real) fluoride poisoning would basically be laughed out of a court, since "everybody knows" fluoride is good for children, like a vitamin.

edit: I did read the article's section on fluoridation now, and It's pretty much right on. Also skimmed over the part about amalgams releasing mercury. I've read some stuff about this before, its just that while amalgam may not be the ideal substance to fill cavities with, its still cheap and affordable, and the released amount of mercury is very small, at least to people who don't have their entire mouth filled with the stuff. Removing amalgam fillings is going to release more mercury into your system than keeping them in, which is why I think dentists who promote replacement of amalgam fillings are quacks.

Interestingly, the article says that "Quack" stems from "Quecksilber", the german word for mercury (quicksilver), and where I live, the term for a fraudulent Doc is "Quacksalber"
 
Last edited:
Off topic ...

.. Also skimmed over the part about amalgams releasing mercury. I've read some stuff about this before, its just that while amalgam may not be the ideal substance to fill cavities with, its still cheap and affordable, and the released amount of mercury is very small, at least to people who don't have their entire mouth filled with the stuff. Removing amalgam fillings is going to release more mercury into your system than keeping them in, which is why I think dentists who promote replacement of amalgam fillings are quacks.
..

Mercury fillings are bad.

Governments worldwide are banning amalgam fillings. Sweden, Norway, Germany, Denmark, Austria, Finland and Canada all have completed steps to halt their use. As of 2000, you can’t get a mercury filling in Sweden, Austria or Germany. In California, state law requires a disclosure form signed by all patients who are going to have fillings, letting them know that their dentist is about to put a controversial material in their mouth. Other states are introducing similar legislation.


Even if you ignore all the evidence that mercury is bad to put in your body, (I know, I know, some people really believe mercury is safe, what can you do?), Mercury fillings are bad. For a very practical reason. Because Mercury fillings do not bond to a tooth, a chamber must be cut into the tooth that is larger than the exterior. This “undercut” keeps the filling in the tooth. In simple terms, even a small cavity has to be enlarged enough to use a mercury filling. Modern materials, which bond to the tooth, and contain nothing toxic, don't need a lot of drilling to use. And the filling won't come out later, or allow decay to occur around or under the filling.

But this deserves an entire topic, rather than sidetrack this highly intelligent discussion. :wackywink:
 
Last edited:
I don't know about cavities, I haven't read that article yet. But fluoridation actually is a conspiracy, by the master himself: Bernays.

The point of fluoridation isn't to make people compliant or some other conspiracy ********. Back then, bernays was given a simple task by the chemical industry. They had a little environmental problem with a highly toxic chemical waste product named fluoride and turned to Bernays to improve the PR of fluoride.

In the most stunning PR campaign ever, Bernays convinced the american public that fluoride is "good for children" and that it should be put into drinking water in low doses, elegantly "solving" the waste problem.

Ergo everyone who would complain about (very real) fluoride poisoning would basically be laughed out of a court, since "everybody knows" fluoride is good for children, like a vitamin.

Completely, utterly incorrect.
http://www.nidcr.nih.gov/HealthInformation/DiseasesAndConditions/Fluoride/StoryFluoride.htm
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm4841a1.htm
 
Mercury fillings are bad.

Even if you ignore all the evidence that mercury is bad to put in your body, (I know, I know, some people really believe mercury is safe, what can you do?), Mercury fillings are bad. For a very practical reason. Because Mercury fillings do not bond to a tooth, a chamber must be cut into the tooth that is larger than the exterior. This “undercut” keeps the filling in the tooth. In simple terms, even a small cavity has to be enlarged enough to use a mercury filling. Modern materials, which bond to the tooth, and contain nothing toxic, don't need a lot of drilling to use. And the filling won't come out later, or allow decay to occur around or under the filling.

But this deserves an entire topic, rather than sidetrack this highly intelligent discussion. :wackywink:
Alright (I didn't really do much research about it, there's too many more interesting topics to investigate, only enough to get to the conclusion that while new fillings shouldn't be amalgams if it can be avoided, replacment of old ones is pretty superfluous)
You're cute. Is it so hard to believe that those "opinions" were bought and paid for?

I guess it is. If you can't even trust the government, who can you trust? The Doctor Within? ;)
 
(fixed)
Yeah I know you're naive, and not particularly bright etc... You might wanna check this out though. (cited by the doctor you dismiss in the link in my sig)
Questions:

1. What do you think that paper actually means? (I would really like to know)

2. How does it relate to my statement about what I accept as valid evidence?

3. Why do you refer to this quack as a "doctor" when you know he is just a chiropractor whose actual medical "experience" seems limited to being accreditied to take blood by phlebotomy?

4. Do you not realise that this "doctor" is merely running a self-promotional web site which sells his books, CDs, detox and vitamin cures, and that a consultation even by phone costs $175 an hour?

5. How could you read his introductory "Mission Statement" and not let even a flicker of an ironic smile flit across your face? (Samples:"Today the field of alternative medicine is like a wild jungle, full of unsubstantiated claims, junk science, and marketing hype." and "There is no disease, no illness, no physical imbalance which will not respond to the innate, healing power of nature, once it is summoned. Once it is set free.")

:rolleyes:

I am not trying to ad hom him, just pointing out the obvious. You seem to dismiss all medical scientists as being in it for the money, or being corrupt and bought out by big pharma, so how does this square with "thedoctorwithin's" own transparent monetary interests?
 
[said to a regular, practising doctor, while recommending the outpourings of some chiropractor quack]
(fixed)
Yeah I know you're naive, and not particularly bright etc... You might wanna check this out though. (cited by the doctor you dismiss in the link in my sig).


Welcome to my ignore list.

I think the only other person on it is Iamme, you should get on like a house on fire.

Rolfe.
 
Questions:

1. What do you think that paper actually means? (I would really like to know)

2. How does it relate to my statement about what I accept as valid evidence?

3. Why do you refer to this quack as a "doctor" when you know he is just a chiropractor whose actual medical "experience" seems limited to being accreditied to take blood by phlebotomy?

4. Do you not realise that this "doctor" is merely running a self-promotional web site which sells his books, CDs, detox and vitamin cures, and that a consultation even by phone costs $175 an hour?

5. How could you read his introductory "Mission Statement" and not let even a flicker of an ironic smile flit across your face? (Samples:"Today the field of alternative medicine is like a wild jungle, full of unsubstantiated claims, junk science, and marketing hype." and "There is no disease, no illness, no physical imbalance which will not respond to the innate, healing power of nature, once it is summoned. Once it is set free.")

:rolleyes:

I am not trying to ad hom him, just pointing out the obvious. You seem to dismiss all medical scientists as being in it for the money, or being corrupt and bought out by big pharma, so how does this square with "thedoctorwithin's" own transparent monetary interests?
There is a large number of far more profitable venues if you just want to make money. This person is deeply convinced of what he does, has spent a lifetime researching the topics he talks about, much further than what anyone would do for mere money, and he exhibits exemplary amounts of critical thinking in the process.

Consider the following scenario.

Say, you write a website that attacks the mainstream medicine. And the stuff you write is good, real good. As the website gains in popularity, more and more people ask you for advice, I mean, boring stuff. "My kid's got a cold, should I give it antibiotics" when that is already sufficiently explained in the article.

There needs to be some way to curb this. Best way: Make people pay money for personal advice, and I mean, outrageous amounts of money. Then, only the people who really read through your entire site, and haven't found the answer they seek, will bother you personally.

His analysis is not wrong. The field of alternative medicine, just as much as the field of school medicine, is full of quackery and fraud. It takes a lot, and I mean, a lifetime of work, separating the gems from the worthless stuff. Differentiation between useful practice and bad practice, instead of claiming all alternative practices are worthless or all school medicine is dangerous, like many many folks, you undoubtedly included do, is a good thing.

Oh, and I call him not a "doctor" but "the doctor" because his website is called "the doctor within" - I simply believe that even a lay person who has never seen a indoctrination center (you'd call it an university) from the inside can gain useful insight on things. And sometimes, insights that someone from the inside has a lot more trouble in gaining.

The paper documents the intensive financial ties publications of medical journals have with the drug companies. Your stubborn belief in the infallibility of the current mechanism of peer reviewed journals can be dispelled by this simple mechanism: Money buys opinions.
 
The paper documents the intensive financial ties publications of medical journals have with the drug companies. Your stubborn belief in the infallibility of the current mechanism of peer reviewed journals can be dispelled by this simple mechanism: Money buys opinions.


This paper looked at interactions between authors who produced clinical practice guidelines and the pharmaceutical industry. It found:
Eighty-seven percent of authors had some form of interaction with the pharmaceutical industry. Fifty-eight percent had received financial support to perform research and 38% had served as employees or consultants for a pharmaceutical company.
Seven percent thought that their own relationships with the pharmaceutical industry influenced the recommendations and 19% thought that their coauthors' recommendations were influenced by their relationships.

This actually has absolutely nothing to do with peer review of medical journals, so it is a singularly bad example of why I should not rely on peer-reviewed journal publications for evidence. Clinical Practice Guidelines are not peer-reviewed. They are treatment guidelines written by doctors with expertise in drugs and medical therapies, so links with the industry are almost inevitable, though regrettable. As the article concludes:
Our study highlights the need for appropriate disclosure of financial conflicts of interest for authors of CPGs and a formal process for discussing these conflicts prior to CPG development.


May I ask what you rely upon for evidence, Dubljuh?
We gather that:
Any source with a potential conflict of interest is a no-no.
Any source that is peer-reviewed is dismissable.
Any source that is official or linked with any government agency is untrustworthy.

You cannot rely on "thedoctorwithin", because of his financial conflict of interest.

Who will you turn to?
 
I know you don't understand this, but I don't give any instance credit with finding the absolute truth. Even (and especially so) my own opinion may be flawed. Bring me some good arguments, some actually good arguments, and not the pseudoscientific stuff you've offered so far. The NHS? Because the NHS writes it, it's true? No.

I consider my approach superior to your unquestioning acceptance of anything that you consider an authority. I don't believe in authorities in the field of science. Peer review doesn't make a system bad, but it doesn't guarantee that it's good, either. Your blind faith in peer reviewed journals is scientifically unsound. It's still too easy to suppress information and let fraudulent papers go through unnoticed.

A large number of seriously bad papers, I mean, METRIC TONS OF ****CRAP get published in so called peer reviewed journals every month. I've got a vested interest in many topics on medical science, and I've seen so much hilarious bunk that got actually published I can barely believe peer review involves more than a spell check. Except for the politics, of course. If your opinion is politically unpopular, it may be super-scientific, it won't get published. Even if, you have 20 crappy papers supporting one theory, and 1 good paper supporting the opposite, you believe the 20 crappy papers, because most optimistically, you're gonna read 3, and might never see the 1 good paper. And then they make a large-ass study, faking half the data and you think one of the bunk papers is actually the 1 good one.

I find the approach of the internet (Memetic Networking) far superior, you can't censor anything, good sources get linked to and read, and bad sources get forgotten about and die.

Well, better have a small number of brain washed drug reps control what is supposed to be accepted as scientific truth, huh?
 
Last edited:
I know you don't understand this, but I don't give any instance credit with finding the absolute truth. Even (and especially so) my own opinion may be flawed. Bring me some good arguments, some actually good arguments, and not the pseudoscientific stuff you've offered so far. The NHS? Because the NHS writes it, it's true? No.

I consider my approach superior to your unquestioning acceptance of anything that you consider an authority. I don't believe in authorities in the field of science. Peer review doesn't make a system bad, but it doesn't guarantee that it's good, either. Your blind faith in peer reviewed journals is scientifically unsound. It's still too easy to suppress information and let fraudulent papers go through unnoticed.

A large number of seriously bad papers, I mean, METRIC TONS OF ****CRAP get published in so called peer reviewed journals every month. I've got a vested interest in many topics on medical science, and I've seen so much hilarious bunk that got actually published I can barely believe peer review involves more than a spell check. Except for the politics, of course. If your opinion is politically unpopular, it may be super-scientific, it won't get published. Even if, you have 20 crappy papers supporting one theory, and 1 good paper supporting the opposite, you believe the 20 crappy papers, because most optimistically, you're gonna read 3, and might never see the 1 good paper. And then they make a large-ass study, faking half the data and you think one of the bunk papers is actually the 1 good one.

I find the approach of the internet (Memetic Networking) far superior, you can't censor anything, good sources get linked to and read, and bad sources get forgotten about and die.

Well, better have a small number of brain washed drug reps control what is supposed to be accepted as scientific truth, huh?

So let me get this straight. We both read the same research articles but I am "blindly accepting the carefully crafted medical-industrial-complex propaganda" while you are "ferreting out the real truth hidden amongst the dross as you are not bogged down by knowledge and understanding"? That would make sense of your posts, but then why do you call yourself a troll?

Linda
 
Come on people, of course vaccinations are all a fraud. Seriously, if vaccines work, how come we still have millions of people dying every year from smallpox TB whooping cough measles polio flu... erm, carry on.
 
So let me get this straight. We both read the same research articles but I am "blindly accepting the carefully crafted medical-industrial-complex propaganda" while you are "ferreting out the real truth hidden amongst the dross as you are not bogged down by knowledge and understanding"? That would make sense of your posts, but then why do you call yourself a troll?

Linda
On the web, I get called a troll all the time, I have no idea why. Except that I tend to write provocatively, and am not afraid to talk about the weirdest topics, like circumcision, aids, child porn/rape laws, or fringe economical theories such as keynesianism.

So I figured I'd call myself "troll" sort of preventively and save some time.

Come on people, of course vaccinations are all a fraud. Seriously, if vaccines work, how come we still have millions of people dying every year from smallpox TB whooping cough measles polio flu... erm, carry on.
Funny that you mention it. They call that AIDS nowadays. :duck:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom