Another Vaccination Scare?

...Your methodology is extremely flawed, and you are utterly naive.

Then educate us with more preciseness.

Start out by telling us which vaccines in the present pediatric schedule are more dangerous than the actual diseases they prevent. Be sure to post your sources and references.

For instances, if you tell that getting an MMR jab is more dangerous than getting measles be sure to post the research papers that show this to be true. Make sure it is a true and verifiable source, not a book by someone like Halvorson.

Be sure to include reasons why it is safer to skip the MMR and to actually get mumps. Even though last year mumps caused four people to lose their hearing in the USA. See I have the evidence right here:
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm55d518a1.htm

From that it says...
Parotitis was reported in 870 (66%) of the 1,327 patients for whom such data were available. Data regarding mumps complications and hospitalizations are incomplete. However, complications have included 27 reports of orchitis, 11 meningitis, four encephalitis, four deafness, and one each of oophoritis, mastitis, pancreatitis, and unspecified complications. A total of 25 hospitalizations were reported, but insufficient data were provided to determine whether mumps caused all the hospitalizations. No deaths have been reported.

Have you started to read the Pink Book yet?
 
Start out by telling us which vaccines in the present pediatric schedule are more dangerous than the actual diseases they prevent. Be sure to post your sources and references.
I don't know. I'd like to know, but only the medical establishment as a whole would be capable of conducting a large scale review of vaccinations and their success rates. And they have several conflicting interests. Vaccines make money (Its treatment the HEALTHY, for chrissake) and have long been touted as a cornerstone of modern medicine. If they were revealed to perform pretty poor, or that more, the the risk outstripped the advantages, the scientific medical establishment would be questioned as a whole by society. Ergo, a large scale effort to that end would be systemically biased by the establishment's unwillingness to find anything at fault with vaccines.

Luckily, society as a whole does perform a constant check, the free market. Every time someone turns his back to conventional medicine and instead seeks help with homoepathy woos and other alternative medicine quacks, this means, this person is REALLY disappointed with conventionalk medicine. With a huge, and increasing number of people (the majority in some countries) seeking help from alternative medicine, its a pretty big indicator that something's wrong with conventional, "scientific" medicine.

For instances, if you tell that getting an MMR jab is more dangerous than getting measles be sure to post the research papers that show this to be true. Make sure it is a true and verifiable source, not a book by someone like Halvorson.
A book can be a "true and verifiable" source, regardless of who wrote it.

Be sure to include reasons why it is safer to skip the MMR and to actually get mumps. Even though last year mumps caused four people to lose their hearing in the USA. See I have the evidence right here:
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm55d518a1.htm
I don't know if it's safer to skip, but I would like to. Due to the previously mentioned systemic bias, I find it impossible to get reliable information from the scientific establishment.

Furthermore, 4 instances of hearing loss? All the infant vaccines combined probably cause more instances of hearing loss than that each year.

Have you started to read the Pink Book yet?
That'd be like asking creationists about the history of earth. Government agencies are heavily lobbied by the pharmaceutical industry, and have a vested financial and social interest themselves to keep the public perception of vaccines to be one of safety and effectivity.
 
But apart from being touted as a prophylactic treatment by the medical profession, I see little that circumcision has in common with vaccination:confused:
Maybe 25 years ago, circumcision was about as strongly supported by medical journals as vaccinations are now. Studies that say otherwise, such as Gairdner, were largely ignored (and they still are) The result of this collective delusion were a vast number of studies advocating circumcision, that greatly outnumbered the ones that said otherwise.

Remember, 50 years ago, a famous paper that circulated the journals was concluding "A pack of cigarettes a day keeps lung cancer away"

Do you think the medical establishment suddenly found conscience and integrity in the last 50 years? I'm saying: They only got better at selling bogus stuff to suckers.
 
Remember, 50 years ago, a famous paper that circulated the journals was concluding "A pack of cigarettes a day keeps lung cancer away"

Do you think the medical establishment suddenly found conscience and integrity in the last 50 years? I'm saying: They only got better at selling bogus stuff to suckers.

Smoking cigarettes was not very common until the early 1900s. Within 20 to 30 years of this the first provable correlations were being made between cigarette smoking and lung cancer. Thus I doubt you could find a copy of said pro-smoking paper (approximately 50 years in age).
Look... I searched the NY Times archives and as early as the 1930s there were health articles on how studies showed they do cause cancer, and by 1940 it was an undisputed fact.
http://select.nytimes.com/gst/abstract.html?res=F00F10FF3A5A11728DDDAF0A94D8415B8088F1D3

But again, like the circumcision thing, you're going off on tangents.
Gold Five: It's no good down here, I can't maneuver!
Gold Leader: Stay on target.
Gold Five: *We're too close!*
Gold Leader: Stay on target!

I don't know. I'd like to know, but only the medical establishment as a whole would be capable of conducting a large scale review of vaccinations and their success rates.

They have and continue to do so.

And they have several conflicting interests. Vaccines make money (Its treatment the HEALTHY, for chrissake) and have long been touted as a cornerstone of modern medicine. If they were revealed to perform pretty poor, or that more, the the risk outstripped the advantages, the scientific medical establishment would be questioned as a whole by society. Ergo, a large scale effort to that end would be systemically biased by the establishment's unwillingness to find anything at fault with vaccines.
Ah should we move this post into the Conspiracy Theories forums along with your assertion that the government blew up WTC 7?
I really think other people have done a better job of explaining this to you:
"(Its treatment the HEALTHY, for chrissake)"
But I am just boggled by the statement.

Do you not visit the dentist until you get a cavity too? It's called PREVENTATIVE care. That and nobody likes a carrier.

Luckily, society as a whole does perform a constant check, the free market. Every time someone turns his back to conventional medicine and instead seeks help with homoepathy woos and other alternative medicine quacks, this means, this person is REALLY disappointed with conventionalk medicine. With a huge, and increasing number of people (the majority in some countries) seeking help from alternative medicine, its a pretty big indicator that something's wrong with conventional, "scientific" medicine.

Or an indication that there are many gullible people that are not very well versed in medical matters.

Does these poll results:
http://www.religioustolerance.org/ev_publi.htm
Mean that there is something wrong with evolution? Or do they tell you something about the people who were polled?

A book can be a "true and verifiable" source, regardless of who wrote it.
What? So if I write a book on nuclear engineering (which I know nothing about) you would use it to build a reactor?

I don't know if it's safer to skip, but I would like to. Due to the previously mentioned systemic bias, I find it impossible to get reliable information from the scientific establishment.
It's there. People have shown it to you. You have to not discard it as part of a conspiracy theory.

Furthermore, 4 instances of hearing loss? All the infant vaccines combined probably cause more instances of hearing loss than that each year.
Again... ear infections are bacterial.
http://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/hearing/otitismedia.asp

That'd be like asking creationists about the history of earth. Government agencies are heavily lobbied by the pharmaceutical industry, and have a vested financial and social interest themselves to keep the public perception of vaccines to be one of safety and effectivity.

You could just as easily say governments have a vested financial and social interest to keep people healthy or there is no tax base. That is not to say lobbying for profit does not exist. But in order to validly make the extreme claim about some vast conspiracy to hide the dangers of vaccination you need to provide some extreme proof. Otherwise you're just ranting.
 
I don't know. I'd like to know, but only the medical establishment as a whole would be capable of conducting a large scale review of vaccinations and their success rates.

The medical establishment (whatever that is) as a whole? Individuals and small groups of researchers can and do conduct large scale reviews of vaccinations and their success rates. I have done so myself, even - it's not that hard if you know what you're doing.

And they have several conflicting interests. Vaccines make money (Its treatment the HEALTHY, for chrissake) and have long been touted as a cornerstone of modern medicine. If they were revealed to perform pretty poor, or that more, the the risk outstripped the advantages, the scientific medical establishment would be questioned as a whole by society. Ergo, a large scale effort to that end would be systemically biased by the establishment's unwillingness to find anything at fault with vaccines.

This is obviously incorrect. Established medical treatments have been revealed to perform poorly without leading to collapse of the medical establishment. There are hundreds of research articles documenting specific faults of vaccines. Physicians and researchers are just as interested as everyone else in the instant fame garnered from overthrowing conventional wisdom.

Luckily, society as a whole does perform a constant check, the free market. Every time someone turns his back to conventional medicine and instead seeks help with homoepathy woos and other alternative medicine quacks, this means, this person is REALLY disappointed with conventionalk medicine. With a huge, and increasing number of people (the majority in some countries) seeking help from alternative medicine, its a pretty big indicator that something's wrong with conventional, "scientific" medicine.

You are assuming a zero-sum game, which is incorrect. People seek out non-evidence-based-medicine and evidence-against-based-medicine in addition to conventional medicine. People continue to expand their use of evidence-based treatments, while also expanding their use of other treatments for conditions at the bottom of the death-disability-disease-discomfort-dissatisfaction hierachy. The market reflects a shift in how people choose to treat their dissatisfaction, not their disease.

A book can be a "true and verifiable" source, regardless of who wrote it.

You missed the point. The statement was "a book by Halvorson", not "a book".

I don't know if it's safer to skip, but I would like to. Due to the previously mentioned systemic bias, I find it impossible to get reliable information from the scientific establishment.

But all the actual information I've seen you quote has come from the scientific establishment (albeit misused and misunderstood)?

Furthermore, 4 instances of hearing loss? All the infant vaccines combined probably cause more instances of hearing loss than that each year.

Deafness from vaccines is due to the disease that the vaccine is meant to prevent. The rate of deafness from mumps is 25 times higher than the rate of deafness from mumps vaccine. The use of absolute numbers in this situation is nonsensical.

That'd be like asking creationists about the history of earth. Government agencies are heavily lobbied by the pharmaceutical industry, and have a vested financial and social interest themselves to keep the public perception of vaccines to be one of safety and effectivity.

But individual physicians are the ones who are called upon to implement the recommendations, and they generally have no vested interest. They have access to the same information that the physicians on the committee have access to, and they are free to disagree. Recommendations that run contrary to what can be reasonably inferred from the research will be vehemently protested or at least ignored. Which makes it necessary for the committee (which isn't actually a government agency, but an independent collection of experts) to remain honest. Your idea also ignores other countries where the recommendations come from groups that are completely independent from the government and which are not subject to lobbying from the pharmaceutical industry, that come to very similar conclusions.

Linda
 
Maybe 25 years ago, circumcision was about as strongly supported by medical journals as vaccinations are now.

That is incorrect. Twenty-five years ago, the advantages of circumcision were considered inadequate to routinely recommend the practice.

Studies that say otherwise, such as Gairdner, were largely ignored (and they still are) The result of this collective delusion were a vast number of studies advocating circumcision, that greatly outnumbered the ones that said otherwise.

That is incorrect. Gairdner has not been ignored. Twenty-five years ago, and now, he was/is included in the information used to support the recommendation against routine infant circumcision by the "medical establishment".

Remember, 50 years ago, a famous paper that circulated the journals was concluding "A pack of cigarettes a day keeps lung cancer away"

Fifty years ago, the harm from cigarettes was well-recognized by physicians and the bulk of published research reflected this. Your example is incorrect because it is unrepresentative.

Do you think the medical establishment suddenly found conscience and integrity in the last 50 years? I'm saying: They only got better at selling bogus stuff to suckers.

Where does the evidence that this stuff is bogus come from?

Linda
 
Gold Five: It's no good down here, I can't maneuver!
Gold Leader: Stay on target.
Gold Five: *We're too close!*
Gold Leader: Stay on target!
Huh? Star Wars?
Or an indication that there are many gullible people that are not very well versed in medical matters.

Does these poll results:
http://www.religioustolerance.org/ev_publi.htm
Mean that there is something wrong with evolution? Or do they tell you something about the people who were polled?
The scientific establishment as a whole has a problem that it is largely detached from everyday people - the so called ivory tower. Science as an institution, not a method, is extremely hierarchical and loves to dismiss outsiders, not giving their arguments the hearing they deserve. If you (like I do) view skepticism as a fundamental part of science, it is not hard to see that the institution of science is, at large, non-ideal and unscientific.

Example of this, an experience of mine. I'm very knowledgeable on the subject of circumcision, and I have probably made clear that I am rather skeptical of the procedure. I've discussed it with a local (yurop) doctor (who didn't know more on the subject than the average teenager) and he dismissed my arguments solely on the fact that I have no formal medical training. That the subject was not his specialty (not pediatrics, not urology, not surgery either) and that he had no experience with the procedure didn't bother him when he dismissed my claims. This is an ad hominem fallacy, and the institution of science commits it every day. Of course I can always argue that the didactic I employ can be improved, i.e. that I could be "more convincing".

Regarding the polls. So only 9% of the people basically believe in evolution? Look, polls like that are always fixed. Depending on the way you formulate the question, you can get vastly different results on basically the same questions. I wouldn't attribute such a statistic with much value.
What? So if I write a book on nuclear engineering (which I know nothing about) you would use it to build a reactor?
You don't write a book on nucular engineering while knowing nothing about it. You simply wouldn't know what to write. If you had a personal hypothesis, say, uranium pixies generating energy magically, and advocated this hypothesis in the book in great length, it would not be difficult for someone with just basic training in the natural sciences like me, or even basic literacy to identify that it's a load of crap. But that's not what you suggest, judging a book purely by its cover.
 
Last edited:
That is incorrect. Gairdner has not been ignored. Twenty-five years ago, and now, he was/is included in the information used to support the recommendation against routine infant circumcision by the "medical establishment".

Linda

So 60%+ of male infants in the US being circumcised is not classed as "routine"?

If the US "medical establishment" does not think infants should be routinely circumcised, they should be doing something about bringing the numbers in the US who still are down.
 
Last edited:
The scientific establishment as a whole has a problem that it is largely detached from everyday people - the so called ivory tower.
Could it be that everyday people are, by the choices they make, detached from science?
Science as an institution, not a method, is extremely hierarchical and loves to dismiss outsiders, not giving their arguments the hearing they deserve.
Browsing the racks at my favorite bookstore or library, I use some simple rules of thumb in deciding which books deserve a closer look. I exhibit a certain bias towards works by authors already familiar to me or who have been recommended by someone whose judgement I trust in such matters. There are only so many hours in a human lifetime, and if I spent all of them reading I could never get through more than the tiniest fraction of all the books I'd like to read, let alone all that have been written. I usually have a lengthy list of books I already know I want to read, and for this reason I tend to be selective in choosing new ones to add -- but I'm always looking, because I know that somewhere out there is a book that I want to read very badly, though I don't know it yet, because I haven't found it. If it's hiding somewhere in the romance section, or in westerns, that's a pity; I'm never going to find it. Never mind judging a book by the cover; I'll never even SEE the cover, because I avoid those sections entirely.

Scientific ideas are like books. For every one that has merit, there are a thousand that have none -- and separating one from the other cannot be accomplished by a brute-force search.
 
The scientific establishment as a whole has a problem that it is largely detached from everyday people - the so called ivory tower. Science as an institution, not a method, is extremely hierarchical and loves to dismiss outsiders, not giving their arguments the hearing they deserve.

Scientists deal with highly specialized knowledge. What you call dismissing outsiders is really recgonizing that those without specialized knowledge do not understand what the argument is about.

If you (like I do) view skepticism as a fundamental part of science, it is not hard to see that the institution of science is, at large, non-ideal and unscientific.

Example of this, an experience of mine. I'm very knowledgeable on the subject of circumcision, and I have probably made clear that I am rather skeptical of the procedure. I've discussed it with a local (yurop) doctor (who didn't know more on the subject than the average teenager) and he dismissed my arguments solely on the fact that I have no formal medical training.

It is possible that he dismissed your arguments on the fact that you mostly say things that are incorrect (if he had any previous experience with you), rather than lack of formal training on your part (although saying incorrect things and lack of formal training are not independent). Even if I recognize that my knowledge is deficient in a specific area, I am going to look towards a reliable source to fill me in, not just anyone.

That the subject was not his specialty (not pediatrics, not urology, not surgery either) and that he had no experience with the procedure didn't bother him when he dismissed my claims. This is an ad hominem fallacy, and the institution of science commits it every day.

You could accurately call it an ad hominem, but in this case it does not qualify as a fallacy. In science, in particular, the quality of the opinion can very much be based upon whether or not the person has the requisite, specialized understanding. I'm not saying that he necessarily thought that he did, but rather that he recognized that you did not.

Linda
 
....
Here's an example: "During a measles outbreak, more cases occurred in those receiving vaccine when less than 12 months old than in those vaccinated at greater than or equal to 12 months" ... "Thus, a single measles vaccination of children less than 12 months old does not protect [this group]"

(Of course the paper concludes that then you need to perform additional vaccinations since obviously, doing only one didn't do ****, or worse, and the group that got less measles from multiple vaccinations was too small to be statistically significant.)
....
What kind of twisted logic is this? The vaccine isn't as effective when given at less than 12 months so we vaccinate at 15 months and give 2 doses. During an outbreak you vaccinate as early as 6 months and still give the other 2 doses.

Your logic is naive. You seem to think we are vaccinating against a disease which doesn't exist. We don't vaccinate kids too young except during active local outbreaks. But if we quit vaccinating the disease would eventually infect everyone, with measles, that is literal.

Before the vaccine almost 100% of the human population was infected by age 30. That's why most people born before 1957 are immune. Virtually every one of them had the infection.

Now this is a really bizarre point of view, Dabljuh:
The scientific establishment as a whole has a problem that it is largely detached from everyday people - the so called ivory tower. Science as an institution, not a method, is extremely hierarchical and loves to dismiss outsiders, not giving their arguments the hearing they deserve. If you (like I do) view skepticism as a fundamental part of science, it is not hard to see that the institution of science is, at large, non-ideal and unscientific.
I'm not quite sure why you think all the doctors and nurses are detached from everyone else and living in an ivory tower. It's either that or you think none of us can read the scientific literature or weigh the evidence. That's a really big ivory tower you've decided the entire medical community must be in. Don't you know any one in the health care field who might be down on the ground you live on?
 
Last edited:
What I'm saying is, that the "Law of similiars" is pretty much the same as the "Law of vaccination" - It was found in the same year, implying roughly the same scientific standard, and with about the same success. And it may be just as bunk.
...ad.

Prove it.

Show that the "Law of Similars" has some kind of scientific proof.

Compare it against:
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?tool=pubmed&pubmedid=16303052

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=ShowDetailView&TermToSearch=12962524

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=ShowDetailView&TermToSearch=16371870

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=AbstractPlus&list_uids=17272598

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=ShowDetailView&TermToSearch=11731639

http://books.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=11234

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&Cmd=ShowDetailView&TermToSearch=16826309

Now show us that the "Law of Similars" is something other than a wild-donkey guess.
 
What I'm saying is, that the "Law of similiars" is pretty much the same as the "Law of vaccination" - It was found in the same year, implying roughly the same scientific standard, and with about the same success. And it may be just as bunk. {snip}
I have kept out of this because I saw how resistant you are to education from other posters here. However, since Hydrogen Cyanide cited this boner, thus bringing it to my attention, I have to say something (I hope I am not repeating anyone).

There must be some Latin name for your infraction; but I am a simple guy so I will simply label it profoundly sophomoric.

Where do you get the idea that you know anything about these subjects? There is no "Law of Vaccination" comparable to the "Law of Similars." If you want some accurate information on vaccines, read Vaccine by Arthur Allen http://www.amazon.com/Vaccine-Contr...0948863?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1186322912&sr=1-1

Pre-scientific "medicine" brought us all sorts of things- citrus in sailor's diets, vaccination- bleeding and violently toxic purgatives and emetics. We still have the former two because they work; we scrapped the latter, along with homeopathy, because they don't work.

Rather than objecting, try reading and learning here.
 
Pre-scientific "medicine" brought us all sorts of things- citrus in sailor's diets, vaccination- bleeding and violently toxic purgatives and emetics.

Small point, but important, and a little known fact. The discovery that citrus cured and prevented the condition known as "scurvy" was made by a scientific experiment, the first recorded incidence of a scientific test of a remedy in fact.
 
You aren't getting my point. All of those papers, all that "evidence" is post 1800 - Meaning, when they were conceived, the "law of vaccines" and the "law of similiars" had exactly the same things speaking for them, i.e. a successful case study.

Only in time, homeopathy grew to be dismissed, and vaccination grew to be accepted.

I'm saying: At 1800, vaccinations were just as "wild-donkey-guess" as homeopathy.

Pre-scientific "medicine" brought us all sorts of things- citrus in sailor's diets, vaccination- bleeding and violently toxic purgatives and emetics. We still have the former two because they work; we scrapped the latter, along with homeopathy, because they don't work.

Rather than objecting, try reading and learning here.
Science didn't start somewhere in the mid 1800s. Science is just the trying to get ahold of good knowledge, scientific experiments were already performed by the cavemen (wild baseless assumption) or in the antiques (not wild baseless assumption)

What started in the mid 1800s were the universities, and with them, science's ivory tower. I'm more with Karl Popper there, saying science must be part of every day life, and may not detach itself from the people, and must not hide behind incomprehensibility.
 
Last edited:
...
I'm saying: At 1800, vaccinations were just as "wild-donkey-guess" as homeopathy.

....

Now you really are showing how clueless you are. Or you have now realized you have dug a really deep hole for yourself, and are trying to climb out by digging deeper?

Do you think Jenner just guessed that cowpox would give immunity to smallpox?

Try doing some reading: http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/historic_figures/jenner_edward.shtml
In 1796 he carried out his now famous experiment on eight-year-old James Phipps. Jenner inserted pus taken from a cowpox pustule and inserted it into an incision on the boy's arm. He was testing his theory, drawn from the folklore of the countryside, that milkmaids who suffered the mild disease of cowpox never contracted smallpox, one of the greatest killers of the period, particularly amongst children. Jenner subsequently proved that having been inoculated with cowpox Phipps was immune to smallpox. He submitted a paper to the Royal Society in 1797 describing his experiment but was told that his ideas were too revolutionary and that he needed more proof. Undaunted, Jenner experimented on several other children, including his own 11-month-old son. In 1798 the results were finally published and Jenner coined the word vaccine from the Latin 'vacca' for cow.

Even before 1800 people were using varioliation to prevent smallpox: http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/empire_seapower/smallpox_01.shtml
Variolation was a process developed in the 10th century in China and India. It involves taking pus from the pocks of someone suffering from smallpox and inoculating healthy people with it. Usually a mild case of smallpox developed, giving lifelong immunity afterwards. There was a risk of death from this, but in a world where smallpox was rife the odds made it worthwhile; about 0.5-2 percent of people died after variolation, compared with 20-30 per cent after natural smallpox.

There is more history of the actual science in the book Vaccine, and some more detailed on the science conducted in the 20th century in Vaccinated.

Have you finished reading the Pink Book? No excuses for not having even tried, it is freely available online.

Now compare Jenner's tests to Hahnemann's wild donkey guess about the "Law of Similars", which actually may have been an allergic reaction to quinine: http://www.angelfire.com/mb2/quinine/allergy.html
 
Small point, but important, and a little known fact. The discovery that citrus cured and prevented the condition known as "scurvy" was made by a scientific experiment, the first recorded incidence of a scientific test of a remedy in fact.

The BBC history pages has a good description of the experiment at http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/historic_figures/lind_james.shtml
Lind selected 12 men from the ship, all suffering from scurvy, and divided them into six pairs, giving each group different additions to their basic diet. Some were given cider, others seawater, others a mixture of garlic, mustard and horseradish. Another group of two were given spoonfuls of vinegar, and the last two oranges and lemons. Those fed citrus fruits experienced a remarkable recovery. While there was nothing new about his discovery - the benefits of lime juice had been known for centuries - Lind had definitively established the superiority of citrus fruits above all other 'remedies'.
 
Another little known fact, soon after the British switched to the cheaper limes, which have far less Vitamin C, and not only did Scurvy show up again, the British sailors got the nickname "Limeys" as well.
 
{snips throughout} Science didn't start somewhere in the mid 1800s. Science is just the trying to get ahold of good knowledge, scientific experiments were already performed by the cavemen (wild baseless assumption) or in the antiques (not wild baseless assumption)
Yours is a vague, useless, definition of "science." It could apply to any philosophy, or New Age nonsense. Today, science is a well-honed method for accepting or rejecting data, and the data so-obtained.

What started in the mid 1800s were the universities, and with them, science's ivory tower. I'm more with Karl Popper there, saying science must be part of every day life, and may not detach itself from the people, and must not hide behind incomprehensibility.
Don't you ever feel embarassed when promoting your ignorance? Universities date to the 14th century.

Are you well-informed on any topic?

Popper was a philospher, not a scientist; and his musings have had little effect on what scientists do, since few of us care about philosophy. I am baffled by your reference to him. On the other hand, you don't seem to understand much, either.

Give a child an Internet account, and it will be amazed for a while, teach someone to type, and s/he will be amazed for a lifetime.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom