Another Vaccination Scare?

...
Isn't vaccination basically the same idea as homeopathy (giving someone a minute/inert dose of something that would make him sick to cure/immunize him)
...

As I understand it:
Vaccination targets immunity. It activates the patient's immune system by introducing the disease in minute amounts.
Homeopathy targets symptoms. It uses absurdly diluted poisons [or disease residue] that would produce symptoms similar to the patient's, if the poison hadn't been diluted to 'nothing', on the theory that what would cause a well person to be sick will cause a sick person to be well.
Vaccines are tested to see if they stimulate the production of antibodies in the patient; homeopathic "vaccines" (nosodes) are assumed to rebalance the patient's energy -- or something(?) -- antibodies are irrelevant.
They may seem a bit similar by treating like with like, but the underlying theory, and the effects I suspect, are much different.
 
Last edited:
Just to clarify that these idiots like Halvorsen are full of sheeeet.
Hey Eos - I see you slipped that past the new Rule 8 militia!

Halverson:
"I have been told that there is no one study that can disprove that MMR may cause 10% of autism cases in this country in susceptible children. Studies can show that MMR does not cause all autism. That's not good enough, and when I found that out I offered patients measles, mumps and rubella vaccines singly."


Dork.

Well, I have been told there is no one study that can disprove that MMR may cause methane aggregations in the Kuiper Belt. Studies can show that MMR does not cause all Kuiper Belt anomalies. But that's not good enough for me, no sireee!- We must stop MMR right now if we wish our solar system to survive beyond the next decade. Instead, let's use single dose measles vaccine, which coincidentally I sell for profit,
VISA and Amex accepted, no cheques please.

If his book is filled with logical fallacies of such transparency, perhaps it can become the new manual for "How not to think critically".

Re: Overloading the immune system:
This paper from Pediatrics - you just have to read it - explains how there are currently fewer than 45 antigens administered within the current UK infant immunisation schedule, compared to over 3000 which were contained in the vaccines used in children 40 years ago.

It suits many people to conflate individual vaccines, which as Rolfe says are extremely "pure" nowadays, with antigens, and claim we are overloading the immune system, which is patently nonsense.

Oh, And Dublya, vaccination is nothing like homeopathy. Get a grip.
 
Well, I have been told there is no one study that can disprove that MMR may cause methane aggregations in the Kuiper Belt. Studies can show that MMR does not cause all Kuiper Belt anomalies. But that's not good enough for me, no sireee!- We must stop MMR right now if we wish our solar system to survive beyond the next decade.

Point well made, with recourse to one of the oddest examples I have ever read, anywhere!

:clap:
 
By the way, it's cowpox that's given to immunize against smallpox.
...

I engineer... I no spell write... :p

Oh, and Jenner's cowpox method is actually older than Hahnemann's homeopathy wild-donkey* speculation (the "Law" of Similars and the "Law" of Infinitesimals were not real scientific laws, but wild imaginary speculations).

Oh, and it is now called vaccinia. From http://www.bt.cdc.gov/agent/smallpox/vaccination/live-virus.asp :
-The vaccinia virus, the virus in the smallpox vaccine, is another "pox"-type virus.
-Vaccinia is related to smallpox, but milder.
-The vaccinia virus may cause rash, fever, and head and body aches. In certain groups of people, complications from the vaccinia virus can be severe.

Definitely not homeopathic!

*donkey is a Rule-8 word substitute
 
No one knows exactly what vaccinia is, either. It's either a hybrid of several orthopox viruses, or an orthopox that simply no longer exists in nature. When you look into some of the manufacturing practices from the olden days, it looks like the former theory is more likely. (to me, at least).
 
So far, *twitch* I've had *twitch* no problems at *twitch* all *twitch twitch*
:D
That's good to hear. But you're an adult, you probably can take it, especially when you've come into contact with the actual pathogens and have grown a real immune response. What about an infant?

See what bothers me about vaccinations is the idea of injecting stuff. I personally hate needles with a passion, and naturally, pathogens don't enter the blood stream (if they do, its called Sepsis, and you are seriously ****ed) as a human you come into contact with those pathogens via the mouth, lungs, mucus... Where for example the langerhans cells are located, which is a "premature" stage of lymphocytes (white blood cells) that are basically just collecting pathogens there.

I'm just saying. I'm not convinced vaccines have a much better track record than homeopathy, and they are certainly not as safe (with homeopathic "remedies" really being 100% safe)

I'd suspect that the homoepathy-guy developed his "law of similiars" theory at least some way based on the cow pox vaccine success story. Back then, they didn't have the germ theory of disease, so scientifically, injecting yourself with cow pox would've been roughly equal to eating chinin.

Regarding the OP: Is there anything that hasn't been blamed with increasing autism diagnoses? I'm not saying vaccinations do, I'm just firmly convinced that this increasing number of tarded people has to do with the decreasing number of active pirates on the seas.
 
Last edited:
See what bothers me about vaccinations is the idea of injecting stuff. I personally hate needles with a passion, and naturally, pathogens don't enter the blood stream (if they do, its called Sepsis, and you are seriously ****ed)

That's not true. There a stage of viremia with a lot of the viruses that's pretty standard. You've had viral pathogens in your blood many, many times, I bet.

Back then, they didn't have the germ theory of disease, so scientifically, injecting yourself with cow pox would've been roughly equal to eating chinin.

Germ theory predates Jenner, too.
 
No better track record than homeopathy? People surviving high-mortality illnesses like smallpox is no better to you than absolutely nothing? By the way, vaccines don't tend to be intravenous, they tend to be intramuscular.

Autism =/= retarded.
 
I'd suspect that the homoepathy-guy developed his "law of similiars" theory at least some way based on the cow pox vaccine success story.


No, he really, really didn't.

The origin of homoeopathy is very well known and well documented. You can find it easily if you look it up, there's stacks of stuf on the net. So you don't need to "suspect" anything. Go out and find out the truth.

The rest of your post has about as much foundation to it as your "suspicion" that Samuel Hahnemann knew anything about the cowpox episode. But that's the neat thing about the internet, it's so easy to find out the facts, you don't need to suspect, and make things up. Google is your friend.

You could start here. Here is good too.

Rolfe.
 
...I'd suspect that the homoepathy-guy developed his "law of similiars" theory at least some way based on the cow pox vaccine success story. Back then, they didn't have the germ theory of disease, so scientifically, injecting yourself with cow pox would've been roughly equal to eating chinin....


What part of the fact that the "Law of Similars" was a wild-donkey guess did you miss? It is not a scientific law, it is some wild imaginary goof ball guess!

Did you even attempt to read the Pink Book?
 
That's not true. There a stage of viremia with a lot of the viruses that's pretty standard. You've had viral pathogens in your blood many, many times, I bet.
Certainly, but vaccinations aside, the pathogens first come in contact with the specialized mucus membranes, the skin, the lungs, the mouth, the intestines and esophagus. Its a difference.
Germ theory predates Jenner, too.
Really? If so, I humbly apologize, but a brief skim through Wikipedia is saying:
"Germ Theory of Disease": Bassi 1836, Snow 1854, 1860 Pasteuer, 1875 Koch.
"Law of Similiars" Hahnemann 1796
Vaccinia Jenner 1796

No better track record than homeopathy? People surviving high-mortality illnesses like smallpox is no better to you than absolutely nothing? By the way, vaccines don't tend to be intravenous, they tend to be intramuscular.
I'm not saying homeopathy is any good or vaccination never works. It apparently worked for cowpox vs smallpox. But using this one success story to develop an entire model, similiar to the "Law of Similiars" ?

Don't you understand, that scientifically, there's no difference between observing that cowpox immunizes against smallpox, and then concluding that you can immunize people against disease by giving them a small injection of another agent, or eating chinin, and then concluding that a small dose of what makes you sick, can cure you.

If you have the germ theory of disease in the back, then it looks different. Or if you have a 200 years success story with one theory, and 200 years of laughter with the other.

Or if you have 100's of working vaccines. But: Do we? Would you know if vaccines are really bad, overall, except for maybe one or two types that have merit under certain circumstances?

If you're now pointing at peer-reviewed journals, I actually read them a lot. Reading them is not a reason to say "but we have 100's of success stories with vaccination"

Autism =/= retarded.
Sorry for not being politically correct.

No, he really, really didn't.
The origin of homoeopathy is very well known and well documented. You can find it easily if you look it up, there's stacks of stuf on the net. So you don't need to "suspect" anything. Go out and find out the truth.

The rest of your post has about as much foundation to it as your "suspicion" that Samuel Hahnemann knew anything about the cowpox episode. But that's the neat thing about the internet, it's so easy to find out the facts, you don't need to suspect, and make things up. Google is your friend.

You could start here. Here is good too.
Why the truck would I want to read about homeopathy? Is that your favourite remedy? Stop pushing your snake oil on me.

Oh and btw: Homeopathy isn't nearly as elegant as Vaccination, where you can sell stuff to people that are healthy!

What part of the fact that the "Law of Similars" was a wild-donkey guess did you miss? It is not a scientific law, it is some wild imaginary goof ball guess!
Um... Unless the predictions made are tested, all proposed hypothesis, including vaccinia, gravitation, and a round earth, that orbits around the sun, are wild imaginary guesses.
 
Why the truck would I want to read about homeopathy? Is that your favourite remedy? Stop pushing your snake oil on me.


Maybe so you can stop "suspecting" all sorts of wrong things, and get on to knowing?

Um... Unless the predictions made are tested, all proposed hypothesis, including vaccinia, gravitation, and a round earth, that orbits around the sun, are wild imaginary guesses.


Damme, it is a troll.

Rolfe.
 
Regarding the OP: Is there anything that hasn't been blamed with increasing autism diagnoses? I'm not saying vaccinations do, I'm just firmly convinced that this increasing number of tarded people has to do with the decreasing number of active pirates on the seas.
Calling autists "retards" isn't politically incorrect. It's incorrect period. As in wrong, mistaken, not true, erroneous, fallacious, false, inaccurate....
 
Certainly, but vaccinations aside, the pathogens first come in contact with the specialized mucus membranes, the skin, the lungs, the mouth, the intestines and esophagus. Its a difference.

So you've never cut yourself?
 
...
I'm just saying. I'm not convinced vaccines have a much better track record than homeopathy, and they are certainly not as safe (with homeopathic "remedies" really being 100% safe)
...

...
I'm not saying homeopathy is any good or vaccination never works. It apparently worked for cowpox vs smallpox. But using this one success story to develop an entire model, similiar to the "Law of Similiars" ?
...

Maybe I'm misunderstanding your concerns... if so I apologize. But it sounds like you're saying other than the smallpox vaccine there's no proof vaccination is an effective preventative method and that all other vaccinations are done to patients on a whim.
They test vaccines before administering them in large numbers. If they are not effective they do not administer them.

I think you're forgetting a whole legion of proven prevention success rates in vaccination. Small Pox is just one of many.

Small Pox
Polio
Pertussis
Diphtheria
Rubella
Tetanus
Varicella
Hepatitas A
Hepatitas B
Measels
Mumps
Influenza

and likely on the verge of success:
Malaria (clinical trials continue)
Tuberculosis (clinical trials continue)

And that's just humans.
What about:
Feline Infectious Peritonitis
Feline Leukemia
Panleukopenia
Rhinotracheitis
Calcivirus
Chlamydia
Rabies

Homeopathic remedies are not 100% safe.
They can forestall effective treatment
They can (in the form of herbal remedies with no quality control or certification) contain chemicals which may not be inert.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=AbstractPlus&list_uids=14705842
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=AbstractPlus&list_uids=1839288
 
Last edited:
There is no effective vaccine for Feline Infectious Peritonitis. Trust me on this. There is something marketed in the US as an FIP vaccine. It doesn't work.

However, there are squillions of animal vaccines. I don't have time to go through the data sheets right now but it's a lot. One of the things that drives me insane about "organic" farming is the antivax stance, and the avoidance or banning of vaccines. As if a vaccinated animal was in some way inferior in their eyes.

Rolfe.
 
There is no effective vaccine for Feline Infectious Peritonitis. Trust me on this. There is something marketed in the US as an FIP vaccine. It doesn't work.

However, there are squillions of animal vaccines. I don't have time to go through the data sheets right now but it's a lot. One of the things that drives me insane about "organic" farming is the antivax stance, and the avoidance or banning of vaccines. As if a vaccinated animal was in some way inferior in their eyes.

Rolfe.

Ah you're quite right.
http://www.veterinarypartner.com/Content.plx?P=A&A=234&S=2
I was wondering why neither of my cats had ever received it.
 
Last edited:
This stuff has no product licence in Britain, and is not used. I asked a Merikan colleague why it was sold in the US, and he said that there was no requirement to prove efficacly in vaccines, only safety. :jaw-dropp

I've since heard that disputed, and I don't know the full story. I do know that the US had vaccines for FeLV that didn't work way before the present effective vaccines were developed. And I think there's an FIV vaccine now in the same category. I heard a practitioner ask at a conference, why can't we license it anyway, as we've got nothing else. The immunologist said, why don't you just give your patients an injection of saline then, it would do just as much good.

Not all the antivax camp's criticisms are unfounded.

Rolfe.
 
That's good to hear. But you're an adult, you probably can take it, especially when you've come into contact with the actual pathogens and have grown a real immune response. What about an infant?

Well, considering that my body will, in general and naturally, run into aa handful of new pathogens per day...while the infant, with no pre-existing immune responses, will run into thousands of new pathogens per day, they'd probably handle it much better (they seem to do so in nature, after all).

See what bothers me about vaccinations is the idea of injecting stuff. I personally hate needles with a passion, and naturally, pathogens don't enter the blood stream (if they do, its called Sepsis, and you are seriously ****ed) as a human you come into contact with those pathogens via the mouth, lungs, mucus... Where for example the langerhans cells are located, which is a "premature" stage of lymphocytes (white blood cells) that are basically just collecting pathogens there.

Already addressed by others. So, you hate vaccinations because you're afraid of needles. How about oral polio? IN any case, only some pathogens are through membranes. MANY pathogens enter breaks in the skin. And, as others have mentioned, you have pathogens in your bloodstream RIGHT NOW. Sepsis is not "pathogens in the blood stream". Sepsis is an overwhelming, systemic infection, spread throughout the circulatory system, that your body cannot effectively fight. It's a wide step from one to the other.

I'm just saying. I'm not convinced vaccines have a much better track record than homeopathy, and they are certainly not as safe (with homeopathic "remedies" really being 100% safe)

Then you've done no research on the subject. Homeopathy has no record of success whatsoever. Vaccines have eradicated some diseases entirely, as well as greatly reducing the effects of many, many others. Even a cursory look at the available scientific evidence shows this. Statements like this are what convince me you simply haven't looked into it, and are speaking from a position of ignorance.

I'd suspect that the homoepathy-guy developed his "law of similiars" theory at least some way based on the cow pox vaccine success story.

And you'd be wrong. Again, you're showing that you haven't looked into this at all, you're simply putting forth your opinion as if it were fact.

Back then, they didn't have the germ theory of disease, so scientifically, injecting yourself with cow pox would've been roughly equal to eating chinin.

Regarding the OP: Is there anything that hasn't been blamed with increasing autism diagnoses? I'm not saying vaccinations do, I'm just firmly convinced that this increasing number of tarded people has to do with the decreasing number of active pirates on the seas.

Autism is not retardation. And, quite frankly, that's a highly offensive way of phrasing that. You'd do better to keep your mouth closed and do some research, instead of attempting to show everyone your own "tardedness".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom