Another Vaccination Scare?

Maybe I'm misunderstanding your concerns... if so I apologize. But it sounds like you're saying other than the smallpox vaccine there's no proof vaccination is an effective preventative method and that all other vaccinations are done to patients on a whim.
What I'm saying is, that the "Law of similiars" is pretty much the same as the "Law of vaccination" - It was found in the same year, implying roughly the same scientific standard, and with about the same success. And it may be just as bunk.
They test vaccines before administering them in large numbers. If they are not effective they do not administer them.
As we just learned, they don't
I think you're forgetting a whole legion of proven prevention success rates in vaccination. Small Pox is just one of many.

Small Pox
Polio
Pertussis
Diphtheria
Rubella
Tetanus
Varicella
Hepatitas A
Hepatitas B
Measels
Mumps
Influenza

and likely on the verge of success:
Malaria (clinical trials continue)
Tuberculosis (clinical trials continue)

And that's just humans.
What about:
Feline Infectious Peritonitis
Feline Leukemia
Panleukopenia
Rhinotracheitis
Calcivirus
Chlamydia
Rabies
I suspect that if you would investigate half of these with utmost scrutiny, you'd figure out that one half of them didn't work, and that most of them have the potential to cause serious injury.
Homeopathic remedies are not 100% safe.
They can forestall effective treatment
They can (in the form of herbal remedies with no quality control or certification) contain chemicals which may not be inert.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=AbstractPlus&list_uids=14705842
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=AbstractPlus&list_uids=1839288
The argument that fake treatment prevents effective treatment is bunk. It's much better to give fake treatment that is harmless, than giving fake treatment that is dangerous. The most important fragment of the hyppocratic oath is not "Do treat", its "do no harm". The "Do treat" stance is not one that serious doctors advocate, its the pharmaceutical industry that prefer to sell their snake oil without stupid things like "effectivity" and "safety" being regulated.

And, well, such accidents aside still say that homoepathic treatments are a lot safer than any vaccine, or pretty much any treatment. If you regulated homeopathy (making sure it really didn't contain anything but sugar) this sort of stuff wouldn't happen.

On the other hand, side effects from vaccines are pretty damn common.

This stuff has no product licence in Britain, and is not used. I asked a Merikan colleague why it was sold in the US, and he said that there was no requirement to prove efficacly in vaccines, only safety. :jaw-dropp

I've since heard that disputed, and I don't know the full story. I do know that the US had vaccines for FeLV that didn't work way before the present effective vaccines were developed. And I think there's an FIV vaccine now in the same category. I heard a practitioner ask at a conference, why can't we license it anyway, as we've got nothing else. The immunologist said, why don't you just give your patients an injection of saline then, it would do just as much good.

Not all the antivax camp's criticisms are unfounded.

Rolfe.
That actually made me sad.
 
Last edited:
I suspect that if you would investigate half of these with utmost scrutiny, you'd figure out that one half of them didn't work, and that most of them have the potential to cause serious injury.

Since apparently you have, please elaborate on this. Show us the stats on the likelihood and severity of negative reactions. SHow us the stats on "effectivity" of these vaccines that show they don't work. You've researched this, right?

Or are you simply talking out of your *** based on your pre-concieved conclusions?

The argument that fake treatment prevents effective treatment is bunk. It's much better to give fake treatment that is harmless, than giving fake treatment that is dangerous. The most important fragment of the hyppocratic oath is not "Do treat", its "do no harm". The "Do treat" stance is not one that serious doctors advocate, its the pharmaceutical industry that prefer to sell their snake oil without stupid things like "effectivity" and "safety" being regulated.

You really have done no research at all, have you? What the **** is the FDA? Safety and "effectivity" (known as efficacy) ARE regulated in the U.S. It's the herbal and supplement industries that scream and yell against any hit of regulation for their snake oils, while at the same time trying to say the pharma companies are the ones selling untested junk.

And, well, such accidents aside still say that homoepathic treatments are a lot safer than any vaccine, or pretty much any treatment. If you regulated homeopathy (making sure it really didn't contain anything but sugar) this sort of stuff wouldn't happen.

Only in a very narrow definition of safety. If you actually want to test which one is safer, you need to do an actual, worthwhile comaprison. Use a control population, a vaccinated population, and a homeopathically treated population, all of similar characteristics. See how many are killed/maimed/injured from the particular disease. ALl of those in the homeopathy group that died from the disease that the vaccinated peopel didn't die from? They count against the safety of homeopathy, sorry.

And vaccines are capable of complications, yes. But at a very low rate. Even a low number of those are serious complications. Really, have you even done a google search and read anything except alt-med sites?

On the other hand, side effects from vaccines are pretty damn common.

Bullcrap. You're full of it. Serious side effects are very, very rare in vaccinations. You're as likely to get mauled by a bear as to have a serious reaction to the anthrax vaccine, for example, and even THAT one is not given to civillians as it's considered too risky.

If you mean you run a half-degree fever for 12 hours after getting a live virus vaccine, then yeah, okay, I'llgive you that. But that isn't what we're concerned about here.
 
Since apparently you have, please elaborate on this. Show us the stats on the likelihood and severity of negative reactions. SHow us the stats on "effectivity" of these vaccines that show they don't work. You've researched this, right?

Or are you simply talking out of your *** based on your pre-concieved conclusions?
No, I raise suspicion. I am not talking out of my ass or making assertions that are patently untrue (Unless I do, in which case I'm sorry)

You really have done no research at all, have you? What the **** is the FDA? Safety and "effectivity" (known as efficacy) ARE regulated in the U.S. It's the herbal and supplement industries that scream and yell against any hit of regulation for their snake oils, while at the same time trying to say the pharma companies are the ones selling untested junk.
Please investigate what it takes for a vaccine to get admitted in the US.
Only in a very narrow definition of safety. If you actually want to test which one is safer, you need to do an actual, worthwhile comaprison. Use a control population, a vaccinated population, and a homeopathically treated population, all of similar characteristics. See how many are killed/maimed/injured from the particular disease. ALl of those in the homeopathy group that died from the disease that the vaccinated peopel didn't die from? They count against the safety of homeopathy, sorry.
Actually I'd rather test an unvaccinated population against a vaccinated one, and cut the homeopath bullcrap. Even if the vaccines were 100% safe, if they failed to work, they were still full of ****.

Here's an example: "During a measles outbreak, more cases occurred in those receiving vaccine when less than 12 months old than in those vaccinated at greater than or equal to 12 months" ... "Thus, a single measles vaccination of children less than 12 months old does not protect [this group]"

(Of course the paper concludes that then you need to perform additional vaccinations since obviously, doing only one didn't do ****, or worse, and the group that got less measles from multiple vaccinations was too small to be statistically significant.)

And vaccines are capable of complications, yes. But at a very low rate. Even a low number of those are serious complications. Really, have you even done a google search and read anything except alt-med sites?

Bullcrap. You're full of it. Serious side effects are very, very rare in vaccinations. You're as likely to get mauled by a bear as to have a serious reaction to the anthrax vaccine, for example, and even THAT one is not given to civillians as it's considered too risky.
I am someone who had some rather severe complications with vaccines himself. A flu shot caused chronic ear infections, for years, with hearing loss until today as a result. I simply refuse to accept that I am to be "one of a million", instead I suspect a systemic bias against diagnosing a condition as a result of a vaccination, which is also something I have experienced.
 
No, I raise suspicion. I am not talking out of my ass or making assertions that are patently untrue (Unless I do, in which case I'm sorry)
But there is no basis for you suspicions.

Please investigate what it takes for a vaccine to get admitted in the US.
It requires the following:
http://www.fda.gov/cber/vaccine/vacappr.htm
That was too difficult for you to find?

Actually I'd rather test an unvaccinated population against a vaccinated one, and cut the homeopath bullcrap. Even if the vaccines were 100% safe, if they failed to work, they were still full of ****.

Here's an example: "During a measles outbreak, more cases occurred in those receiving vaccine when less than 12 months old than in those vaccinated at greater than or equal to 12 months" ... "Thus, a single measles vaccination of children less than 12 months old does not protect [this group]"

(Of course the paper concludes that then you need to perform additional vaccinations since obviously, doing only one didn't do ****, or worse, and the group that got less measles from multiple vaccinations was too small to be statistically significant.)

Seems to me the paper does not conclude the measel vaccination is ineffective but rather that it is more effective when given to children after their first year. Or better still given both before and after one year.

I am someone who had some rather severe complications with vaccines himself. A flu shot caused chronic ear infections, for years, with hearing loss until today as a result. I simply refuse to accept that I am to be "one of a million", instead I suspect a systemic bias against diagnosing a condition as a result of a vaccination, which is also something I have experienced.

Coincidental? How do you know this is the case?
Ear infections are bacterial by the way.
 
I just finished reading this book. On the whole, I thought it was pretty balanced. Parents should make informed decisions about vaccines and I think that is is impossible to do solely on the information provided by the NHS. In a way, they are just as bad as the extreme "anti-vaccine" people. Parents should be provided with facts, not fear-mongering leaflets designed to "sell" vaccines.

I also agree with him that parents should be provided with some choice in what vaccines they give to their children. In the UK, we don't have much any more. In order to vaccinate your child against tetanus, diphtheria and polio, for example, you also have to vaccinate them against pertussis and Hib as Pediacel (The '5 in 1') is the only vaccine available on the NHS (although you can get a DTaP privately).

Vaccination is a hard decision for parents. You have to cut through all the crap on both sides to find information you can use to make decisions for your child with. I think parents have a duty to be a little more informed about vaccines than most currently are. Most of the parents I know have no idea what vaccines their child has received - they blindly go along with the "NHS schedule", without determining if that is in their child's best interests.
 
They might also consider the best interests of other children. Children who for good reason were not vaccinated have been disabled and even killed by measles, which was allowed into their community by healthy unvaccinated children. It is important to have a sufficiently high level of immunity in the population to keep the infection out of the population as a whole. There will always be some who are unprotected unavoidably (the very young, the immunosuppressed and so on). They rely on the healthy members of their society being immune. If someone has decided that "their" child doesn't need the vaccine, they may not realise that it could be someone else's child who is harmed.

Rolfe.
 
No, I raise suspicion. I am not talking out of my ass or making assertions that are patently untrue (Unless I do, in which case I'm sorry)

Please investigate what it takes for a vaccine to get admitted in the US.
Actually I'd rather test an unvaccinated population against a vaccinated one, and cut the homeopath bullcrap. Even if the vaccines were 100% safe, if they failed to work, they were still full of ****.

Here's an example: "During a measles outbreak, more cases occurred in those receiving vaccine when less than 12 months old than in those vaccinated at greater than or equal to 12 months" ... "Thus, a single measles vaccination of children less than 12 months old does not protect [this group]"

(Of course the paper concludes that then you need to perform additional vaccinations since obviously, doing only one didn't do ****, or worse, and the group that got less measles from multiple vaccinations was too small to be statistically significant.)
As BlackKat said, this paper is about timing of immunisation, not whether it is effective per se.

The problem with some childhood vaccines like measles is that the infant possess passively-transferred maternal antibody for the first few months of life. This will protect the infant against catching measles, even without vaccination (ie it is a good thing). However, this maternal protection starts to wane after about 3-4 months, and by age 10-12 months has disappeared entirely.

This natural immunity will also impair the response to a measles vaccine if it is given in the first year of life (it will be increasingly less effective the earlier it is given after birth).

So the decision as to when to immunise the child is a judgement call - vaccinate too early and it won't take properly, but leave it too long (until say 15-18 months) and you risk the child catching measles in the longish time gap between waning maternal immunity and first measles vaccination.
In highly prevalent measles areas like Africa, it is sensible to vaccinate fairly early, and give boosters later. In countries which see very little measles, one can wait for 12-18 months before giving the first vaccine, as the chances the child will be exposed before then is very slim.
 
One of the things that drives me insane about "organic" farming is the antivax stance, and the avoidance or banning of vaccines. As if a vaccinated animal was in some way inferior in their eyes.

Ugh, do they really? And even ban it in some places?
 
Example with circumcision.

Circumcision of newborns decreases the chance you'll get UTIs and penile cancer. Really, does. Like a vaccine!

Logically, every kid should be circumcised, right? Like a vaccine!

Nope. Why? Because the complication rate of circumcision alone is larger than the UTI risk, UTIs that apparently are prevented by circumcision actually turn into much more severe conditions (sepsis) and penile cancer is something that affects 1 in 600 men, 80% of them over the age of 70.

Arguing for forcing everyone to vaccinate to achieve "herd immunity" is basically saying "Vaccines are worthless" - if they worked, you wouldn't need to vaccinate >96% of the population to achieve anything. It'd be in the individual interest of every child to vaccinate.

Furthermore, a lot of the "evidence" pointing towards vaccines working is pretty bogus: in many population based or cohort studies, when kids get for example a measles shot and are then still infected with measles, they no longer get diagnosed with measles, since, after all, they were vaccinated, so it can't be measles, right? So it must be something else. As a result the study shows a decrease in measles incidence in the vaccinated cohort, due to lack of proper controls and double blinding. And it's pretty hard to do double blinding for vaccines.
 
I just finished reading this book. On the whole, I thought it was pretty balanced. Parents should make informed decisions about vaccines and I think that is is impossible to do solely on the information provided by the NHS. In a way, they are just as bad as the extreme "anti-vaccine" people. Parents should be provided with facts, not fear-mongering leaflets designed to "sell" vaccines.

Welcome to the forum.

I agree parents should make informed decisions about vaccines. However, I am at complete odds with you as to where these parents get their information from. The NHS produces comprehensive guidance for parents which is freely available (and is factually correct and evidence-based). If you have evidence of an NHS publication that does not provide facts and scare-mongers people into taking vaccines, please provide the evidence for it.

The NHS does not "sell" vaccines. It has one ulterior motive - to promote the continued good health of the population in the UK. Products that do not do what they are meant to do soon get discarded. vaccines prevent huge amounts of future illness which would burden the NHS/the taxpayer considerably. It is in the best interests of the NHS to promote safe and effective remedies.

Those who do scaremonger and who literally "sell" vaccines of their own for personal gain are people like Halverson. If you cannot see the obvious conflict of interest here, then you are visiting the wrong internet forum, and perhaps my welcome was premature....
 
Dubya, you persist in thinking vaccines cause more problems than they solve, and have a high side effect rate (after all, you got ill after one didn't you - what more evidence do we need than the veracity of this single anecdote!?)

Perhaps you would like to discover what the side effects after MMR vaccination were in Finland, using 3 live vaccines and subjecting poor Finnish infants to the side effects of 3 different pathogens.

Well, after 3 million vaccines were given, there were 169 reported serious adverse events. Following investigation there were only 95 attributable to the vaccine. The rate for any complication was less than 1 per 100 000 doses of vaccine.

One thing that really, really, really cracks me up is how antivaxers carry on about how terrible vaccine side effects are if they do occur. You know, the child with encephalitis from rubella vaccine and so on.

Well, dur-brains, these side effects are the mild equivalent of a complication of the natural illness that is being prevented by the vaccine. Without the vaccine, all children would get the infection, and so many would get a far more serious case of encephalitis than you'd ever get from the vaccine. Yet antivaxers loudly proclaim the naturally acquired infections are "entirely harmless" and so there is no point protecting against them, blissfully unaware of their paradoxical and illogical thinking.


Arguing for forcing everyone to vaccinate to achieve "herd immunity" is basically saying "Vaccines are worthless" - if they worked, you wouldn't need to vaccinate >96% of the population to achieve anything. It'd be in the individual interest of every child to vaccinate.

Of course vaccine protects the individual who is vaccinated, so it is very worthwhile.

Herd immunity does not protect the vaccinated individual. It is an altruistic concept (go look it up) whereby individuals who cannot be vaccinated for some reason (eg a medical condition that is a contraindication for vaccine) can stay healthy because there is minimal chance of them encountering the disease for real.

This is not some wishy-washy concept. It cost one poor child in the UK his life, when he caught measles from one of his unvaccinated contacts who caught measles from someone else. The child could not get vaccinated because of a contraindication to vaccine, so relied on herd immunity to protect him. His friend's air-headed parents effectively signed his death warrant when they decided not to immunise their own child, who caught measles and passed it on to the vulnerable boy. How would you feel right now if you were the parent of either of these children? My guess is the antivax parents have brushed it aside, blaming something else for the death to absolve their guilt.
(Rolfe has the details on this one I think - I can't find the reference just now)
 
Last edited:
What's the lethality of newborn circumcision? If you ask the AMA, its about 1:500'000. How did they get this figure? They performed such-and-such many circumcisions and only got a handful of reports of newborns dying due to the procedure. That is their official figure nowadays.

A more realistic figure is more like 1:5000 deaths per circumcision performed on infants ages 0-5. A brit carefully investigated the risky procedure, with controls and all. Why the big discrepancy?

No hospital reports a death attributed to a procedure they performed. Liability. Its always "inexplicable", or some other, secondary condition. No, not circumcision. Everyone knows that's completely safe and harmless.

What's the chance of something happening if you merely poke someone with a needle in a hospital setting, not injecting anything, or just saline?

Your methodology is extremely flawed, and you are utterly naive.
 
UTIs that apparently are prevented by circumcision actually turn into much more severe conditions (sepsis)...

I don't understand what you are trying to say with that statement. UTI's can lead to more severe sequelae (including sepsis) in infants. A reduction in the absolute number of UTI's would lead to an equivalent absolute reduction in the number of UTI's leading to sepsis.

Arguing for forcing everyone to vaccinate to achieve "herd immunity" is basically saying "Vaccines are worthless" - if they worked, you wouldn't need to vaccinate >96% of the population to achieve anything. It'd be in the individual interest of every child to vaccinate.

"Herd immunity" refers to protecting those who cannot be vaccinated and to protecting the small proportion of people who did not develop protective antibodies after their vaccination (there's some in every crowd).

Furthermore, a lot of the "evidence" pointing towards vaccines working is pretty bogus: in many population based or cohort studies, when kids get for example a measles shot and are then still infected with measles, they no longer get diagnosed with measles, since, after all, they were vaccinated, so it can't be measles, right? So it must be something else.

That is incorrect. Kids and adults are diagnosed with measles regardless of whether or not they were vaccinated. I have first-hand knowledge and experience in this area. The presence of a history of vaccination is not considered sufficient to rule-out the presence of a particular disease.

As a result the study shows a decrease in measles incidence in the vaccinated cohort, due to lack of proper controls and double blinding. And it's pretty hard to do double blinding for vaccines.

The use of the term "double blinding" is nonsensical in the type of study you have described above.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Dabljuh vbmenu_register("postmenu_2829585", true);

The topic here is vaccination. Moreover, your statements are meaningless without citations.
 
What's the lethality of newborn circumcision? If you ask the AMA, its about 1:500'000. How did they get this figure? They performed such-and-such many circumcisions and only got a handful of reports of newborns dying due to the procedure. That is their official figure nowadays.

The figure is based on no deaths in 500,000 consecutive circumcisions performed in New York.

A more realistic figure is more like 1:5000 deaths per circumcision performed on infants ages 0-5. A brit carefully investigated the risky procedure, with controls and all. Why the big discrepancy?

I presume you are referring to Gairdner, 1949. You are incorrect about the use of controls (there were none). The deaths were due to the use of general anaesthesia, which probably accounts for the discrepancy. Although, one could also hypothesize that there had been advances in surgical technique in the intervening decades, as well.

No hospital reports a death attributed to a procedure they performed.

That is incorrect. Coding and reporting follow specific rules, and most hospitals and physicians are actively involved in improving care, one component of which is accurate reporting.

Linda
 
And it says it's a troll. I'm inclined to agree.

Deetee, the incident in London involved two boys, both kidney transplant recipients, both doing well but obviously immunosuppressed. One boy caught measles from another child at his school. The reason the measles was there in the first place was that only just over half the children in that particular area of London were vaccinated, and as a result there was a mini-epidemic going on.

The boy who caught the disease at school attended a renal follow-up clinic while still incubating the virus, and passed it on to his friend, the other transplant patient. One of these boys is now blind and the other permanently confined to a wheelchair. If vaccination rates had been up to target, both would have been protected because the virus would not have got a foothold in the community.

The death was in Dublin, and it was of a baby too young to have received her first MMR dose. Which I believe has led to some discussion as to whether, of there is measles in the community, an extra dose should be given to infants. Previously it was believed that the danger period was starting school, and infants were not at significant risk. However, if the vaccination rate drops too low then they become at risk, and thus an extra dose may be required to ensure protection. Is this what you've understood?

Rolfe.
 
fls said:
I don't understand what you are trying to say with statement. UTI's can lead to more severe sequelae (including sepsis) in infants. A reduction in the absolute number of UTI's would lead to an equivalent absolute reduction in the number of UTI's leading to sepsis.

I think what Dabljuh was trying to say was circumcision provides ~1% absolute risk reduction for UTI, but has ~2% complication rate.

But apart from being touted as a prophylactic treatment by the medical profession, I see little that circumcision has in common with vaccination:confused:
 
And it says it's a troll. I'm inclined to agree.

Deetee, the incident in London involved two boys, both kidney transplant recipients, both doing well but obviously immunosuppressed. One boy caught measles from another child at his school. The reason the measles was there in the first place was that only just over half the children in that particular area of London were vaccinated, and as a result there was a mini-epidemic going on.

The boy who caught the disease at school attended a renal follow-up clinic while still incubating the virus, and passed it on to his friend, the other transplant patient. One of these boys is now blind and the other permanently confined to a wheelchair. If vaccination rates had been up to target, both would have been protected because the virus would not have got a foothold in the community.

The death was in Dublin, and it was of a baby too young to have received her first MMR dose. Which I believe has led to some discussion as to whether, of there is measles in the community, an extra dose should be given to infants. Previously it was believed that the danger period was starting school, and infants were not at significant risk. However, if the vaccination rate drops too low then they become at risk, and thus an extra dose may be required to ensure protection. Is this what you've understood?

Rolfe.
Thanks Rolfe - I knew you had detailed this case before but couldn't recall the exact details.

There appear to have been 3 Dublin deaths - one over 15 months old, one 15 months old and one 12 months old. All unvaccinated, but I would imagine the vaccination age would have been 12 months as it has been in the UK, so this child may never have got around to having the vaccine. It would make sense in an epidemic to reduce vaccination age to 6-9 months and then boost later on.

This is what the Green Book has to say:
The first dose of MMR should be given at any time after the first birthday,
ideally at 13 months of age. Immunisation before 13 months of age provides earlier protection in localities where the risk of measles is higher, but residual maternal antibodies may reduce the response rate to the vaccine. The optimal age chosen for scheduling children is therefore a compromise between risk of disease and level of protection.
​


If a dose of MMR is given before the first birthday, either because of travel to an endemic country, or because of a local outbreak, then this dose should be ignored, and two further doses given at the recommended times after the first birthday and pre-school.
A second dose is normally given before school entry but can be given routinely at any time from three months after the first dose. Allowing three months between doses is likely to maximise the response rate, particularly in young children under the age of 18 months where maternal antibodies may reduce the response to vaccination (Orenstein et al., 1986; Redd et al., 2004; De Serres et al., 1995). Where protection against measles is urgently required, the second dose can be given one month after the first (Anon., 1998). If the child is given the second dose less than three months after the first dose and at less than 18 months of age, then the routine pre-school dose (a third dose) should be given in order to ensure full protection.​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom