Another Vaccination Scare?

They are mostly complaining that not enough adverse reactions, etc. were reported? Maybe there weren't any more to report, showing the safety.

The way it's phrased:


The design and reporting of safety outcomes in MMR vaccine studies, both pre- and post-marketing, are largely inadequate.

Makes me think they weren't satisfied with the way the outcomes were gathered. I'll try to find the fulltext to see what they meant exactly, though.
 
You can figure out the effectiveness of the three components from studies outside the clinical trials, though. That's why it's not a matter of great debate. (sans mumps, which is complicated).
studies outside clinical trials, you mean population based studies and cohort studies. These are flawed. It is possible to correct for all kinds of factors, have any result you want, and still get it published with peer review, as long as it shows that vaccines are super duper effective.

Show me a population based study that suggests the possibility that the vaccine didn't do anything, and improved sanitation and nutrition did the trick of making the incidence of certain conditions disappear.

This is a very real possibility, but if you even consider it, you can never publish it in medical journals.
 
Why, do you think ignoring toys is the same thing as "mental disturbance" or something? Or that lack of response is the same as memory loss?

Autism is quite specific, with a known age of onset. PDD certainly doesn't include muscle weakness. I don't any autistic person with muscle weakness either, any I've encountered are very strong.
It's not enough when one points it out to you, one has to actually take your head and ram it in there. I expected as much and have already enhanced the post for your better understanding.

And as I said, mercury poisoning may cause different things in infants than in adults. For example, infants don't have much of a memory to lose.
 
Last edited:
Improved sanitation helped the spread of polio. We didn't even get vaccines until sanitation was improved in the Americas. Do you really think it was that dirty in the 1940s compared to the 1950s & 1960s?
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Diphtheria:[/FONT]
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Before vaccines:[/FONT]
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]15,000 deaths in U.S. each year. Outbreak in Washington State during 1970s.[/FONT]
​
After vaccines:
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]40 cases in U.S. 1980-93. [/FONT]​


[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]With decreased immunizations, over 50,000 cases in the former Soviet Union and Eastern Europe in 1995.[/FONT]
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]
gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Death: 1 in 10[/FONT]
[/FONT]
​
​
​
[/FONT]​
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]​
http://www.metrokc.gov/health/immunization/compare.htm​
[/FONT]
 
Last edited:
It's not enough when one points it out to you, one has to actually take your head and ram it in there. I expected as much and have already enhanced the post for your better understanding.
Apparently my question was very upsetting, but I didn't think so.
 
Show me a population based study that suggests the possibility that the vaccine didn't do anything, and improved sanitation and nutrition did the trick of making the incidence of certain conditions disappear.

Damn. If only I'd been washed better as a kid I wouldn't have gotten chickenpox.:rolleyes:
 
Damn. If only I'd been washed better as a kid I wouldn't have gotten chickenpox.:rolleyes:
I had it too as a kid. Merely looked like an idiot for a couple days (some would say, I still do, though)

No, sanitation = good. Eating other people's feces because of a lack of sewer systems and the like = bad.
 
Improved sanitation helped the spread of polio. We didn't even get vaccines until sanitation was improved in the Americas. Do you really think it was that dirty in the 1940s compared to the 1950s & 1960s?
Find me a chart that displays the incidence of polio from 50 years before the vaccine was developed, to today.

Found it myself. link
 
Last edited:
38,000 cases per year prior to vaccine, including 21,000 cases with paralysis. 58,000 cases in 1952.

gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Permanent paralysis: 1 in 100[/FONT]
gray-bullet.gif
[FONT=Arial,Helvetica,Geneva,Swiss,SunSans-Regular]Death: 1 in 20 children and 1 in 4 adults with paralytic polio.[/FONT]

O cases in Canada and the USA now after polio vaccination, and now it is almost eradicated in the rest of the world too, no matter what kind of sanitation they have.
 
O cases in Canada and the USA now after polio vaccination, and now it is almost eradicated in the rest of the world too, no matter what kind of sanitation they have.
I told you, you'd need the developement of at least 50 years prior to the introduction of the vaccine. My Link is a lot better at explaining what happened.
 
In 1916 a polio epidemic in the United States killed 6 000 people and paralyzed 27 000 more. By the early 1950's there were more than 20 000 cases of polio each year. Polio vaccination began in 1955. By 1960 the number of cases had dropped to about 3 000 each year, and by 1979 there were only about 10 cases a year. The success of polio vaccination in the USA and other countries sparked a world-wide effort to eliminate polio.
http://www.thevaccinesite.org/resources/res3/killer.htm with a graph

http://www.thevaccinesite.org/resources/res3/killer.htm
 
Dab's sources of information are apparent. He won't believe anyone but liars like Weil, Geier, and Mercola.

His ridiculous link says DDT is the cause of polio.

My link shows that the 50s were inundated with polio until the vaccine was introduced in 1955. I don't think the sanitation between 1948 and 1955 was that different.

Another graph more accurately depicting the 1916 outbreak compared to dab's crazy source:
http://www.healthsentinel.com/graphs.php?id=51&event=graphs_print_list_item

yeah that's 40 cases per 100,000 (not 4,000,000 cases)
 
Last edited:
Dab's sources of information are apparent. He won't believe anyone but liars like Weil, Geier, and Mercola.
I just did a picture search and looked for a graph that went at least 50 years back. It's also in higher resolution than the other graphs. I never heard of DDT causing polio ever before. Edit: According to the link's hypothesis, the "polio" was caused by DDT poisoning that accumulated in cow's milk.

Well, your sources simply suck at delivering useful information.

Edit: Here's the complete link
Test results on the Salk vaccine were biased by throwing out polio cases 'after the first vaccination'. Test results were also biased by including only data from the '11 most accurate states' while ignoring the data from the other 33 states included in the test. What would the '33 least accurate states' data have shown?
Haha, good stuff.
 
Last edited:
Like I said dab, with the sources you rely on for information you might as well hang your head in shame for all it is doing for you.

Do you have any idea what "reliable source" refers to?

I have a swamp, er nice piece of land over here to sell you. I also have this Eiffel tower for cheap too.

I don't know if I should feel sorry for him, or if I should tar and feather him. Are you gullible or incredulous dab? Ignorant or low-intelligence?
 
Last edited:
My link shows that the 50s were inundated with polio until the vaccine was introduced in 1955. I don't think the sanitation between 1948 and 1955 was that different.

Actually, they did change the diagnostic criteria for polio after the Salk vaccine (the original IPV) showed up, which gave an illusion of a decrease in polio that wasn't real in the late 50's.
But in the early-mid 60's the Sabin (the live, highly effective OPV) vaccine started being used, which really did eliminate polio.

(I've got photobucket links from the Illinois Medical Journal from May of 1960, kinda long but really interesting, where they talk about it.)


ETA:
Here it is, in case anyone cares. The quality goes up after the first couple of pages. It's really interesting. I promise. :)


http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV601.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV602.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV603.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV604.jpg

Here's where they talk about the diagnostic change.
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV605.jpg

http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV606.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV607.jpg

On this page they mention that sometimes the Salk vaccine actually caused antibody mediated disease enhancment.
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV608.jpg

http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV609.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6010.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6011.jpg

This page says that a lot of the Salk field trials vaccines were full of live viruses, and that great antibody response and effectiveness he reported was due to this.
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6012.jpg

Here they go more into antibody mediated enhancement again. (they don't call it that, but that's what the phenomenon is known as today).
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6013.jpg

http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6014.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6015.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6016.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6017.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6018.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6019.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6020.jpg
http://i45.photobucket.com/albums/f71/Angladrion/PSOPV6021.jpg
 
Last edited:
Like I said dab, with the sources you rely on for information you might as well hang your head in shame for all it is doing for you.

Do you have any idea what "reliable source" refers to?

I have a swamp, er nice piece of land over here to sell you. I also have this Eiffel tower for cheap too.

I don't know if I should feel sorry for him, or if I should tar and feather him. Are you gullible or incredulous dab? Ignorant or low-intelligence?
If you haven't understood yet, why a medical journal can be (and often is) an unreliable source, and a random whackjob on the internet can be dead on, (and often is) then you need to learn a lot more about the politics of science.

Science isn't a holy process of gathering knowledge, it is a business. The power goes where the money goes, and whoever has the power is going to do everything to consolidate it. Many scientists aren't happy with this, as they see science still as a way to find truth and stuff. They are driven so mad by the business of science that they prefer to work on the fringes of the institution rather than to have their jobs dependant on people who tell them what the results of their findings should be, rather they would live the rest of their lives being constantly bullied and attacked vigorously than to surrender their scientific integrity to the politics of science.

Of course this is the minority, the vast majority of scientists simply prefers a 9-to-5 job that pays well and has some prestige.

You don't have that on the outskirts of what's accepted by the scientific institution. If scientist rejects a mainstream hypothesis that has good amounts of money behind it, the only option those people have is to basically spread their particular understanding of the truth on their own, on the internet. How do you differ the good scientist there from the actual whackjob? Only by investigating their every argument.

Sometimes, sound science gives it away: A good scientist that leaves the mainstream has surrendered all the benefits of "orderly" science in order to spread his findings: You simply don't do that easily, if only for a cause that you are deeply convinced of, and solely for the purpose to be freed of the shackles of the politics of science. Yes, even "good" lone wulf scientists can be wrong. But how often, compared to the mainstream where there are the bounds and shackles of the politics of science?

A real whackjob will not "selectively cite studies", and provide ample evidence he benefitted from a sound scientific training, he won't even know what a damn study is, won't be able to tell you what "Energy" is, because his theories stem from ignorance, i.e. are all out of his butt.

But I understand it is too complicated if there's all those different theories and different arguments and stuff, how should you know which ones are right? Not knowing what's right and what's wrong is certainly a frightening state, I understand you chose the easier path and instead unquestioningly accept what the majority of scientists subscribe to.
 
Last edited:
Actually, they did change the diagnostic criteria for polio after the Salk vaccine (the original IPV) showed up, which gave an illusion of a decrease in polio that wasn't real in the late 50's.
But in the early-mid 60's the Sabin (the live, highly effective OPV) vaccine started being used, which really did eliminate polio.

(I've got photobucket links from the Illinois Medical Journal from May of 1960, kinda long but really interesting, where they talk about it.)


The irrefutable proof is that sanitation did not eradicate polio. Vaccines did. And polio viruses look the same and do the same things to the body, no matter what. Please let me know what they called the illness to make it seem like rates were going down. I'm sure you'll understand if I find that whole claim far-fetched. The more credible graphs do show that polio was a problem until after 1963.

Dab, oy, dab is totally going off the deep end though. *shakes head*
How do you differ the good scientist there from the actual whackjob?

Easily, but looking at how they make their claims and how they try to back them up. If it is a nutjob not following protocols, it becomes apparent very quickly. Do you really think DDT can be mistaken for a polio virus? Do you really think DDT will put you in an iron lung? Do you really think we can't figure out what is causing Polio outbreaks in other parts of the world NOW? Do you really think we can't isolate the virus and see it with our very own eyes?
They are driven so mad by the business of science that they prefer to work on the fringes of the institution rather than to have their jobs dependant on people who tell them what the results of their findings should be.

:boggled: Science doesn't work that way. Does your high school offer biology or chemistry courses? Does your local college offer any? Take some courses and find out how it really works. It's cool, fun, and you'll find out how it really works. Then you'll understand why people like mercola and weil are so unethical.

No scientists accepts another unquestioningly. Do you know how long it took some scientists to show how a certain bacteria can cause ulcers? They managed to show it with evidence. Evidence. Something people can see with their own eyes. Studies must be replicated by others to show how it actually works, and that something didn't go wrong. Evidence with another's own eyes. Everything is double checked, and NOTHING is accepted unquestioningly.

It's only the whackjobs that fail to provide evidence that go whining to the public instead, because they couldn't convince others with the same knowledge base. The public doesn't know the difference between evidence and anecdotes. The laypublic doesn't know the difference between hydrogen monoxide and carbon monoxide just by their names. You can convince people to take action against dihydrogen monoxide with a good anecdote!

Your accusation that I'm only following other scientists unquestionably is beyond ignorance (and ironic since you actually do that by following any bad source of information ignorantly), and just a stab because you keep coming up short. Why not listen and learn for a change instead of making accusations? Why not try to learn from us instead of embarrasing yourself with bad sources of information? Why not finally read OUR sources of information instead of flailing around in woo land sources? The internet is the worst place to try to find information, so why not take a real biology course instead? Then one day you just might be able to tell the bad sources from the good, just by knowing what to look for.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom