Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

I think what's wrong with your argument is it doesn't build a solid case based on th history of supreme court interpretations
You keep saying this and yet I have quoted the relevant Supreme Court decisions, and I have addressed each of Epstein's citations. So I don't know what "build a solid case" could mean if it doesn't mean precisely what I did.

the attorney for government's case didn't help much in his recent arguments.
I think he was hamstrung by politics. He was told not to call the fine a "tax" because it was feared it would turn public sentiment against the mandate. And Scalia had fun making him squirm. It's what Scalia enjoys doing. He does it to lawyers all the time regardless of their position.

Oral argument is not always a very good bellwether of how the case will turn out. That said, I still don' think he did a great job, but given his limitations, I think he did a good job.
 
....I think he was hamstrung by politics. He was told not to call the fine a "tax" because it was feared it would turn public sentiment against the mandate. And Scalia had fun making him squirm. It's what Scalia enjoys doing. He does it to lawyers all the time regardless of their position.

Oral argument is not always a very good bellwether of how the case will turn out. That said, I still don' think he did a great job, but given his limitations, I think he did a good job.
"Turn public sentiment?"???

Bamster got himself ELECTED based on saying over and over he would not raise taxes on anyone making less than 250K.

Hamstrung by politics?

"Turn public sentiment against the mandate"?

I guess if trying to double cross a couple hundred million people without trying to look like you are double crossing a couple hundred million people creates difficulties, they why, exactly should you sympathize with the guy saying "given his limitations, I think he did a good job?"
 
You keep saying this and yet I have quoted the relevant Supreme Court decisions, and I have addressed each of Epstein's citations. So I don't know what "build a solid case" could mean if it doesn't mean precisely what I did.....
What you are trying to claim is that since we've bent the Commerce clause a little bit, and then a little bit more, and then a little bit more, it's okay that we just bend it a lot.

That's not a Constitutional interpretation at all. It may be a handy dandy and useful rationalization to "get what you want".

But why? Suppose it went this way and you "got what you wanted".

You are (let's say) a partisian Democrat. Why would you give that sort of unbridled federal power to your opponents, the Republicans?

That's what you'd be doing. Because they get elected routinely, just like the Democrats do. Why would the net outcomes from that be better than restraining the federal activities, such that there is restraint on power hungry SOB's in both parties?
 
What you are trying to claim is that since we've bent the Commerce clause a little bit, and then a little bit more, and then a little bit more, it's okay that we just bend it a lot.
No. I'm claiming the Commerce Clause hasn't been bent as it applies to the Health Care Act.

Epstein makes a big deal about how Wickard changed jurisprudence on the Commerce Clause, but Wickard was dealing with the "commerce" part. There is no doubt that the Health Care Act regulates "commerce" as that word has always been defined, even if the pre-Wickard cases were operative.

The Health Care Act also regulates commerce that is "interstate" as that has always been defined.

So, no. I am not saying that Wickard and its progeny justifies the Health Care Act. I'm saying that Wickard is irrelevant and that you and Epstein are making a fallacious analogy that because Wickard changed the analysis of "commerce" that was set forth in E.C. Knight, that somehow any analysis of the Health Care Act is also suspect.

But neither he nor you have ever connected those dots. It's an appeal to emotion. The New Deal messed up the Commerce Clause. The Health Care Act is based on the Commerce Clause. So if it's upheld it must be because of those New Deal cases. Except the actual text of those cases doesn't justify this argument.

Gibbons v. Ogden established the analysis of the Commerce Clause and it predates E.C. Knight and Wickham. And the Health Care Act is perfectly valid under a Gibbons analysis, and neither the E.C. Knight nor the Wickham cases affect that analysis at all.

If the Health Care Act is to be ruled unconstitutional, the Justices have to either 1) find some other provision of the Constitution that bars it, or 2) change the analysis set forth in Gibbons, which would be a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. I have seen nobody identify any other provision of the Constitution that applies and I cannot find one, so all that leaves is judicial activism.

So, it is not I but you who is making the fallacious argument. Your argument seems to be that since the liberals used Wickham (1942) to overturn E.C. Knight (1895), the conservatives are justified in using this case (2012) to overturn Gibbons v. Ogden (1822).

You are (let's say) a partisian Democrat. Why would you give that sort of unbridled federal power to your opponents, the Republicans?
I'm not giving anybody anything. Chief Justice Marshall -- the same fellow who drafted Marbury v. Madison -- interpreted the Constitution to have this broad authority way back in 1822. This is the power the Congress has always had.

Why would the net outcomes from that be better than restraining the federal activities, such that there is restraint on power hungry SOB's in both parties?
If the people wanted to limit the broad definition of "interstate" that Chief Justice Marshall announced 190 years ago in Gibbons, they had almost two centuries to rectify it through Constitutional Amendment.
 
If the Health Care Act is to be ruled unconstitutional, the Justices have to either 1) find some other provision of the Constitution that bars it, or 2) change the analysis set forth in Gibbons, which would be a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. I have seen nobody identify any other provision of the Constitution that applies and I cannot find one, so all that leaves is judicial activism.

So Brown v. Board was a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. Got it.

If the people wanted to limit the broad definition of "interstate" that Chief Justice Marshall announced 190 years ago in Gibbons, they had almost two centuries to rectify it through Constitutional Amendment.

"Interstate" isn't the issue here. I'm not sure what ever made you think it was.
 
No. I'm claiming the Commerce Clause hasn't been bent as it applies to the Health Care Act.

Epstein makes a big deal about how Wickard changed jurisprudence on the Commerce Clause, but Wickard was dealing with the "commerce" part. There is no doubt that the Health Care Act regulates "commerce" as that word has always been defined, even if the pre-Wickard cases were operative.

The Health Care Act also regulates commerce that is "interstate" as that has always been defined.

So, no. I am not saying that Wickard and its progeny justifies the Health Care Act. I'm saying that Wickard is irrelevant and that you and Epstein are making a fallacious analogy that because Wickard changed the analysis of "commerce" that was set forth in E.C. Knight, that somehow any analysis of the Health Care Act is also suspect.

But neither he nor you have ever connected those dots. It's an appeal to emotion. The New Deal messed up the Commerce Clause. The Health Care Act is based on the Commerce Clause. So if it's upheld it must be because of those New Deal cases. Except the actual text of those cases doesn't justify this argument.

Gibbons v. Ogden established the analysis of the Commerce Clause and it predates E.C. Knight and Wickham. And the Health Care Act is perfectly valid under a Gibbons analysis, and neither the E.C. Knight nor the Wickham cases affect that analysis at all.

If the Health Care Act is to be ruled unconstitutional, the Justices have to either 1) find some other provision of the Constitution that bars it, or 2) change the analysis set forth in Gibbons, which would be a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. I have seen nobody identify any other provision of the Constitution that applies and I cannot find one, so all that leaves is judicial activism.

So, it is not I but you who is making the fallacious argument. Your argument seems to be that since the liberals used Wickham (1942) to overturn E.C. Knight (1895), the conservatives are justified in using this case (2012) to overturn Gibbons v. Ogden (1822).


I'm not giving anybody anything. Chief Justice Marshall -- the same fellow who drafted Marbury v. Madison -- interpreted the Constitution to have this broad authority way back in 1822. This is the power the Congress has always had.


If the people wanted to limit the broad definition of "interstate" that Chief Justice Marshall announced 190 years ago in Gibbons, they had almost two centuries to rectify it through Constitutional Amendment.
Marksman, just wanted to say thanks for the info. Much appreciated.
 
So Brown v. Board was a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. Got it.
No, Plessy v. Ferguson was a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. Brown v. Board of Education overturned that pernicious decision. In contrast, nobody contends that Gibbons v. Ogden was an exercise of judicial activism. However, to declare this Act unconstitutional due to the Commerce Clause, I see no way aroudn it other than modifying the 190'year old precedent of Gibbons. And that certainly would constitute judicial activism.

"Interstate" isn't the issue here. I'm not sure what ever made you think it was.
There are only two relevant elements: "interstate" and "commerce". Since the act regulates the purchase and sale of insurance it undeniably regulates commerce under Gibbons v. Ogden. That only leaves the "interstate" component, with the argument being that the purchase, sale, or refusal to purchase health insurance is a wholly intrastate affair. And that does appear to me to be the crux of the arguments made in the Court. But the expansive language of Gibbons makes that issue fairly well-settled in favor of Constitutionality.
 
No, Plessy v. Ferguson was a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. Brown v. Board of Education overturned that pernicious decision. In contrast, nobody contends that Gibbons v. Ogden was an exercise of judicial activism. However, to declare this Act unconstitutional due to the Commerce Clause, I see no way aroudn it other than modifying the 190'year old precedent of Gibbons.
Not at all. The SC has gone back a forth with the limitations to the commcerce clause. Gibbons v. Ogden survived until 1895, when the court began to limit the congressional power with the case of United States v. E. C. Knight Co. This marked the start of a 40-year period of history during which the Supreme Court limited the federal government's ability to regulate under the Interstate Commerce Clause. During the 1930s the Supreme Court changed course again and began to grant more federal authority under Commerce Clause, going beyond even the authority recognized in Gibbons v. Odgen. The Court went so far as to say that even activity entirely within one state could be regulated by the federal government if the activity had an effect on interstate commerce.

Note that in Gibbons v. Ogden the court specifically stated there are limits upon the federal commerce power, but chose not to put into detail what those limits were aside from goods specifically made, moved, and sold within one state were exclusively beyond the reach of the federal commerce power. This part of the Gibbons ruling stands in direct contrast to the decision in Wickard v. Filburn.

So here we are, once again the court will look at the limits to that federal power. This is neither activism nor "unprecedented" as BO described it.
 
Not at all. The SC has gone back a forth with the limitations to the commcerce clause. Gibbons v. Ogden survived until 1895, when the court began to limit the congressional power with the case of United States v. E. C. Knight Co.
I've already gone through this. E.C. Knight was discussing the "commerce" part of the interstate commerce clause. E.C Knight did not limit Gibbons because Gibbons wasn't addressing "commerce", but the "interstate" portion.

I went through this in detail and I even quoted the cases. It's really frustrating when people can't even bother to read the thread before commenting.

Note that in Gibbons v. Ogden the court specifically stated there are limits upon the federal commerce power, but chose not to put into detail
Right. That's known as "dicta" and it's nonbinding statements because they are not relevant to the case before the court.

This part of the Gibbons ruling stands in direct contrast to the decision in Wickard v. Filburn.
That part of the decision is not a "ruling" because it established no "rule". That's what makes it dicta!
 
No, Plessy v. Ferguson was a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. Brown v. Board of Education overturned that pernicious decision. In contrast, nobody contends that Gibbons v. Ogden was an exercise of judicial activism. However, to declare this Act unconstitutional due to the Commerce Clause, I see no way aroudn it other than modifying the 190'year old precedent of Gibbons. And that certainly would constitute judicial activism.

But you're wrong that Gibbons v. Ogden would need to be overturned in order to rule against the mandate based on the commerce clause. All one would need to do is rule that a lack of commerce cannot be regulated under the commerce clause, and that the mandate regulates a lack of commerce. That would have no impact on Gibbons.
 
I've already gone through this. E.C. Knight was discussing the "commerce" part of the interstate commerce clause. E.C Knight did not limit Gibbons because Gibbons wasn't addressing "commerce", but the "interstate" portion.
I understand that. My point was that the SC has in fact nuanced back an forth. They have not simply held that the commerce clause gives congress unlimited power, nor have that narrowly restricted it. The ruling before them would not be activism nor unprecedented should it go against Obamacare.
 
I understand that. My point was that the SC has in fact nuanced back an forth. They have not simply held that the commerce clause gives congress unlimited power, nor have that narrowly restricted it. The ruling before them would not be activism nor unprecedented should it go against Obamacare.
The scope and size of the activist legislation involved certainly is unprecedented, though.
 
....The ruling before them would not be activism nor unprecedented should it go against Obamacare.
The scope and size of the activist legislation called Obamacare is unquestionably unprecedented.

This is all starting to remind me more and more of the death throes of HillaryCare.
 
No, Plessy v. Ferguson was a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. Brown v. Board of Education overturned that pernicious decision. In contrast, nobody contends that Gibbons v. Ogden was an exercise of judicial activism. However, to declare this Act unconstitutional due to the Commerce Clause, I see no way aroudn it other than modifying the 190'year old precedent of Gibbons. And that certainly would constitute judicial activism.

The government's own argument, that they aren't regulating the not buying of insurance, but the decision to not buy doesn't bother you as brand new and precedence-setting itself?

Recent cases where the majority, in its decisions, challenged the dissenting justices to find any examples at all that might be barred, which they couldn't, are bad enough. This kind of sophistry should scare the hell out of people.




Let's take a deep breath. People waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaant it. Therefore they rub their chins, put on blinders, and declare it's A-Ok with the Constitution. That's the actual state of mental processes going on here, such as it is.
 
The government's own argument, that they aren't regulating the not buying of insurance, but the decision to not buy doesn't bother you as brand new and precedence-setting itself?

Recent cases where the majority, in its decisions, challenged the dissenting justices to find any examples at all that might be barred, which they couldn't, are bad enough. This kind of sophistry should scare the hell out of people.




Let's take a deep breath. People waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaant it. Therefore they rub their chins, put on blinders, and declare it's A-Ok with the Constitution. That's the actual state of mental processes going on here, such as it is.

Some people want it. A minority.

If that dog of a bill passes SC review, that opens the door to any and all crony capitalist's lobbyists to move to force any and every product or service they gain from down on people in this country.

Seems like all sides politically should be a bit concerned about that.

Why couldn't the religious right, if they were owed a favor by the politicians in power, have an earmark attached to a bill that forced everyone to buy a bible? (please don't answer this with an argument about the "establishment clause", as I assure you I can nimbly dance around it as surely as Obamacare advocates drunkenly stumble and careen around the Commerce clause).

:)
 
Let's take a deep breath. People waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaant it. Therefore they rub their chins, put on blinders, and declare it's A-Ok with the Constitution. That's the actual state of mental processes going on here, such as it is.
I honestly don't think it is as black and white as you suppose. I suspect SCOTUS will decide against it but also suspect that it won't be unanimous. If we follow your logic those who vote against it will do so simply because they want it. I've watched interviews with legal scholars who don't think it is unconstitutional.

I also suspect that if the roles were reversed as the once were (the mandate is a GOP invention) it would be considered constitutional by many in the GOP who now say it isn't. And vice versa for the Dems. Much like gas prices not being the fault of the president.
 
Cherry picking along with the perfect solution fallacy. Power combo!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom