What you are trying to claim is that since we've bent the Commerce clause a little bit, and then a little bit more, and then a little bit more, it's okay that we just bend it a lot.
No. I'm claiming the Commerce Clause hasn't been bent as it applies to the Health Care Act.
Epstein makes a big deal about how
Wickard changed jurisprudence on the Commerce Clause, but
Wickard was dealing with the "commerce" part. There is no doubt that the Health Care Act regulates "commerce" as that word has always been defined, even if the pre-
Wickard cases were operative.
The Health Care Act also regulates commerce that is "interstate" as that has always been defined.
So, no. I am not saying that
Wickard and its progeny justifies the Health Care Act. I'm saying that
Wickard is irrelevant and that you and Epstein are making a fallacious analogy that because
Wickard changed the analysis of "commerce" that was set forth in
E.C. Knight, that somehow any analysis of the Health Care Act is also suspect.
But neither he nor you have ever connected those dots. It's an appeal to emotion. The New Deal messed up the Commerce Clause. The Health Care Act is based on the Commerce Clause. So if it's upheld it must be because of those New Deal cases. Except the actual text of those cases doesn't justify this argument.
Gibbons v. Ogden established the analysis of the Commerce Clause and it predates
E.C. Knight and
Wickham. And the Health Care Act is perfectly valid under a Gibbons analysis, and neither the
E.C. Knight nor the Wickham cases affect that analysis at all.
If the Health Care Act is to be ruled unconstitutional, the Justices have to either 1) find some other provision of the Constitution that bars it, or 2) change the analysis set forth in
Gibbons, which would be a pernicious exercise in judicial activism. I have seen nobody identify any other provision of the Constitution that applies and I cannot find one, so all that leaves is judicial activism.
So, it is not I but you who is making the fallacious argument. Your argument seems to be that since the liberals used
Wickham (1942) to overturn
E.C. Knight (1895), the conservatives are justified in using this case (2012) to overturn
Gibbons v. Ogden (1822).
You are (let's say) a partisian Democrat. Why would you give that sort of unbridled federal power to your opponents, the Republicans?
I'm not giving anybody anything. Chief Justice Marshall -- the same fellow who drafted
Marbury v. Madison -- interpreted the Constitution to have this broad authority way back in 1822. This is the power the Congress has always had.
Why would the net outcomes from that be better than restraining the federal activities, such that there is restraint on power hungry SOB's in both parties?
If the people wanted to limit the broad definition of "interstate" that Chief Justice Marshall announced 190 years ago in
Gibbons, they had almost two centuries to rectify it through Constitutional Amendment.