Why not? Is the government constitutionally required to hire a taxman to take the money from you and give it to an insurance company they want to provide you insurance? Or can they simply cut out the middleman and have you pay the company directly?redefine taxation as requiring people to give money to a private company. And that simply isn't taxation.
So what? As I said, the Commerce Clause only establishes the subject matter that Congress can regulate. It does not set limits on the regulation. Other provisions of Constitution do establish limits on Congress' power to regulate interstate commerce, primarily the Bill of Rights, the 14th Amendment, and several provisions related to taxation.And it isn't exactly "the right" that focused on the interstate commerce clause, that's exactly the clause under which the Bamster and cronies thought they do these forcings. "The right" has simply responded to this reality.
If the Court were to determine that the Commerce Clause has an implicit limitation on Congress' power to regulate interstate commerce that inhibits requiring affirmative actions, that would be unprecedented. Literally unprecedented.
The reason the Court isn't examining the traditional limitations on Congressional power, I suspect, is because 200 years of jurisprudence establishes that this provision would comply with such requirements.
If the Court rules this way, I shall decry it as an exercise in actual judicial activism, just as I have when the left-wing of the Court did it. Unfortunately, "judicial activism" has become a codeword for "unsatisfactory decision", and we simply slouch again towards dismantling the rule of law.