Affordable Care Supreme Court Case . . .

redefine taxation as requiring people to give money to a private company. And that simply isn't taxation.
Why not? Is the government constitutionally required to hire a taxman to take the money from you and give it to an insurance company they want to provide you insurance? Or can they simply cut out the middleman and have you pay the company directly?

And it isn't exactly "the right" that focused on the interstate commerce clause, that's exactly the clause under which the Bamster and cronies thought they do these forcings. "The right" has simply responded to this reality.
So what? As I said, the Commerce Clause only establishes the subject matter that Congress can regulate. It does not set limits on the regulation. Other provisions of Constitution do establish limits on Congress' power to regulate interstate commerce, primarily the Bill of Rights, the 14th Amendment, and several provisions related to taxation.

If the Court were to determine that the Commerce Clause has an implicit limitation on Congress' power to regulate interstate commerce that inhibits requiring affirmative actions, that would be unprecedented. Literally unprecedented.

The reason the Court isn't examining the traditional limitations on Congressional power, I suspect, is because 200 years of jurisprudence establishes that this provision would comply with such requirements.

If the Court rules this way, I shall decry it as an exercise in actual judicial activism, just as I have when the left-wing of the Court did it. Unfortunately, "judicial activism" has become a codeword for "unsatisfactory decision", and we simply slouch again towards dismantling the rule of law.
 
...the Commerce Clause only establishes the subject matter that Congress can regulate. It does not set limits on the regulation. Other provisions of Constitution do establish limits on Congress' power to regulate interstate commerce, primarily the Bill of Rights, the 14th Amendment, and several provisions related to taxation.

If the Court were to determine that the Commerce Clause has an implicit limitation on Congress' power to regulate interstate commerce that inhibits requiring affirmative actions, that would be unprecedented. Literally unprecedented.

The reason the Court isn't examining the traditional limitations on Congressional power, I suspect, is because 200 years of jurisprudence establishes that this provision would comply with such requirements.
Please the Richard Epstein essay I linked earlier. Until the New Deal, lots of commercial activity fell outside "interstate commerce". If all commerce is "interstate commerce" then the adjective "interstate" is redundant. Every activity affects commerce somehow, and so qualifies as "commerce" by the standard that makes a decision not to buy insurance "commerce". If all commerce is interstate commerce and all activity is commerce, then a list of Congressional powers that includes the power to regulate interstate commerce is a power to regulate anything and everything, and a list of enumerated powers makes no sense. So much for Constitutionally limited government.
If the Court rules this way, I shall decry it as an exercise in actual judicial activism, just as I have when the left-wing of the Court did it. Unfortunately, "judicial activism" has become a codeword for "unsatisfactory decision", and we simply slouch again towards dismantling the rule of law.
Laws bind people if people obey laws. Constitutions bind governments if government actors obey constitutions. Governments would find the task of following their own laws easier if there were fewer laws. With intrusive government comes lawless government.
 
Please the Richard Epstein essay I linked earlier.
I read it. Now you go back and read my post where I talk about that fact that before interstate commerce became ubiquitous, it was much easier to exclude activities from interstate commerce, which is consonant with Epstein's citations.

If all commerce is "interstate commerce" then the adjective "interstate" is redundant.
Sometimes reality overtakes the legal theory. In the 19th century, fewer activities implicated interstate commerce. As the world has gotten smaller, commercially speaking, those distinctions become harder to locate. The justices are confronting the fact that modern society is much more fluid than it used to be.

At any rate, the idea that health care insurance is not interstate commerce doesn't make sense anymore. Health care is managed by national corporations. The field of healthcare is interstitial. The only issue should be whether Congress' regulation of it violates other limitations on its powers.
 
By the way, you linked to the wrong Epstein essay in your prior post. The one you meantto cite was this one. Epstein relies on two cases for his argument. However, neither of them advocate for the narrow reading of the Commerce Clause he advocates. THe first, Gibbons v Ogden (1824) upholds the COngressional exercise of power and states that the definition of interstate commerce is "restricted to that commerce which concerns more States than one". Of course, health care does concern more States than one. He doesn't really explain why the Gibbons definition would exclude the Health Care Act.

The second case E.C. Knight (1895) simply holds that manufacture is not interstate commerce, even if the goods are to be sold interstate. And then he cites US v. Lopez, a 1995 decision that holds that the federal government cannot use the commerce clause to ban the use of guns near schools. But that decision was not dealing with the "interstate" part of the act, but the "commerce" The gun law didn't regulate commerce. But the Health Care Act clearly regulates commerce.

The two cases he cites stand for the notion that Congress must be regulating commerce, which it indisputably is in the Health Care Act

Epstein's argues from his conclusions and he simply dismisses the many decisions with which he disagrees as some sort of watershed in New Deal jurisprudence. But no such thing was employed. Interstate commerce was always broad. If the Court were to rule that interstate commerce governed not only the field that can be regulated but what can be regulated, then they will have changed COmmerce Clause jurisprudence stretching back to Gibbons v. Ogden.

As much as he criticizes former Reagen-era Solicitor General Charles Fried when he said “Health care is interstate commerce. Is this a regulation of it? Yes. End of story.," Fried is right. Epstein's tortured cal for a return to 1824 jurisprudence that never existed should not avail him. I really hope the Court doesn't go that direction.
 
Last edited:
Why not? Is the government constitutionally required to hire a taxman to take the money from you and give it to an insurance company they want to provide you insurance? Or can they simply cut out the middleman and have you pay the company directly?
.....
Actually, I believe they are constitutionally required to take the money from you, and then turn around and give it to those they need to for whatever services are incurred.


I dunno. To me, "tax" means any State-mandated surrender of resources. It does not matter if the surrender takes the form of a check to the IRS, a State-mandated employer-funded benefit program, or a blue law (no liquor sales on Sunday). Some taxes make sense and some do not. That's the real argument, not whether to call a mandate or a fine a "tax".
Tax is a compulsary taking from the individual or business into government coffers.

If (hypothetical) a state had a workman's compensation tax, but the employer was able to opt out by showing he had a private plan or was self insured, the costs for those are not taxes.
 
Last edited:
...
If the Court rules this way, I shall decry it as an exercise in actual judicial activism, just as I have when the left-wing of the Court did it. Unfortunately, "judicial activism" has become a codeword for "unsatisfactory decision", and we simply slouch again towards dismantling the rule of law.
I believe that would be justified on your part if you - or someone else defending the Bamstercare scheme - could show clearly that it DID APPEAR to be Constitutional.

That's the problem. You can't just claim they are activitists because they interpret something as being Constitutional. That's what they are supposed to do.

Anyway, that's my point of view. Oh - one other thing - the States brought this suit, and that meant it was going to wind up before the SC. So it wasn't any sort of activism that brought the suit...
 
...Tax is a compulsary taking from the individual or business into government coffers. ...If (hypothetical) a state had a workman's compensation tax, but the employer was able to opt out by showing he had a private plan or was self insured, the costs for those are not taxes.
That "into the government coffers" is a problem. Here's Merriam Webster: Tax (noun) "1. a charge usually of money imposed by authority on persons or property for public purposes."
Corvee labor is a tax. State-mandated employer-funded medical insurance is a tax.
 
Obama the law professor has apparently forgotten little things like Marbury v. Madison...


A Federal Appellate Court Judge decided to make the Department of Justice clarify their boss's position:

On Monday, Obama issued a direct challenge to the Supreme Court, saying he didn't believe the high court would take the "unprecedented" step of overturning a law passed by a strong majority of Congress.

"I want to be sure that you are telling us that the Attorney General and the Department of Justice do recognize the authority of the federal courts through unelected judges to strike acts of Congress or portions thereof in appropriate cases," Smith said.

A somewhat surprised Kaersvang told Smith the Justice Department does recognize this power by the courts and made reference to a landmark 1803 case [Marbury v. Madison] that formed the basis for judicial review.


This part made me laugh:

However, Smith ordered Kaersvang to submit a letter to the appeals court by Thursday stating the position of U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder and the Justice Department on the concept of judicial review.

"The letter needs to be at least three pages, single spaced, no less and it needs to be specific. It needs to make specific reference to the president's statements," Smith said.


http://news.yahoo.com/judge-upset-obamas-comments-health-care-law-010429840.html
 
A Federal Appellate Court Judge decided to make the Department of Justice clarify their boss's position:

This part made me laugh:
Egos, "he said what"? "Oh no he didn't". "Dude, you don't **** with SCOTUS"
 
I have since confirmed that Obama did indeed make that statement as quoted above.

As someone with a passing connection to the legal field, I'm embarrassed for him.
 
I have since confirmed that Obama did indeed make that statement as quoted above.

As someone with a passing connection to the legal field, I'm embarrassed for him.
Good, given Romney, Santorum, Gingrich, Bachmann, Perry, it's high time the GOP got a feel good reason for feeling embarrassed for Obama. The GOP is about to be handed its bet news in a long, long time. Enjoy it.
 
On a serious note. I think Obama's words were imprudent and I can't fathom the calculations for them. No good can come from taking on the court head on. I don't get it.
 
By the way, you linked to the wrong Epstein essay in your prior post. The one you meant to cite was...
The one I linked.
Epstein relies on two cases for his argument. However, neither of them advocate for the narrow reading of the Commerce Clause he advocates. THe first, Gibbons v Ogden (1824) upholds the Congressional exercise of power and states that the definition of interstate commerce is "restricted to that commerce which concerns more States than one". Of course, health care does concern more States than one. He doesn't really explain why the Gibbons definition would exclude the Health Care Act.

The second case E.C. Knight (1895) simply holds that manufacture is not interstate commerce, even if the goods are to be sold interstate. And then he cites US v. Lopez, a 1995 decision that holds that the federal government cannot use the commerce clause to ban the use of guns near schools. But that decision was not dealing with the "interstate" part of the act, but the "commerce" The gun law didn't regulate commerce. But the Health Care Act clearly regulates commerce.
Thanks for the link to the other essay. In the essay I linked, Epstein cites Wickard v. Filburn, a case from the New Deal era in which the court held that growing your own food (animal fodder, actually) fell under the Congressional power to regulate, under the commerce clause, because the fodder that the farmer would have purchased had he not grown his own fodder would have entered interstate commerce. Okay. That ruling turned Commerce clause jurisprudence on its head. Everything is related to everything else. That's the original stoned revelation. All commerce is interstate commerce and every activity is commerce, so the Constitution places no limits on Federal authority.

That's not the legal regime I want to see any time before I die. Many of my fellow citizens endorse it. They should read Hayek, The Road to Serfdom, The Constitution of Liberty, Barmine, One Who Survived, and Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago (everything, actually).
 
On a serious note. I think Obama's words were imprudent and I can't fathom the calculations for them. No good can come from taking on the court head on. I don't get it.


Yeah, Obama's poor understanding of judicial review aside, basically daring the Court to overturn this legislation didn't strike me as very wise. If the Court overturns the legislation, he'll look worse for it. But, then again, he still might win. If so, his current posturing could be interpreted as though he put the Court in its place.
 
Yeah, Obama's poor understanding of judicial review aside, basically daring the Court to overturn this legislation didn't strike me as very wise. If the Court overturns the legislation, he'll look worse for it. But, then again, he still might win. If so, his current posturing could be interpreted as though he put the Court in its place.
Good point. A long shot in my limited understanding.
 
I believe they are constitutionally required to take the money from you, and then turn around and give it to those they need to for whatever services are incurred.
What Constitutional provision requires that middleman?

I believe that would be justified on your part if you - or someone else defending the Bamstercare scheme - could show clearly that it DID APPEAR to be Constitutional.
But I did. The commerce clause has always been interpreted to authorize federal regulation of fields of commerce that affects interstate commerce. The only cases that have found that Congress lacks such authority is when the activity being regulated is not commerce. There has been no Supreme Court case holding that Congress failed to demonstrate that commerce was "interstate".

Here, Congress is regulating the buying, selling, or refusal to buy healthcare insurance. It is not disputed that such commerce affects interstate commerce. It is not disputed that this constitutes commerce. Based on Constitutional precedent, Congress is authorized to regulate healthcare.

Once Congress is authorized, the examination then turns to whether other provisions of the Constitution limit how that regulation can manifest. Nobody has cited any other provision of the Constitution that prevents Congress from doing what it did in the Health Care Act and I can't find any. Thus, I conclude the statute is Constitutional.

If you think that there is a Supreme Court case that has identified commerce that is not "interstate commerce" then I'd like to see it. If you can find a different Constitutional provision that prohibits the Health Care Act, I'd like to see that too.

the States brought this suit, and that meant it was going to wind up before the SC. So it wasn't any sort of activism that brought the suit...
I didn't say the litigants were being activist. I mentioned "judicial activism". That refers to the judges being activists by ignoring precedent and the rule of law and making rulings based on what they think the law should be, rather than upholding the law as it exists. Judicial activism occurs when the judiciary infringes on the role of the legislature or, in the case of Constitutional interpretation, the States, who collectively have the power to amend the Constitution. Judicial activism is an abrogation of the separation of powers.

The one I linked.Thanks for the link to the other essay. In the essay I linked, Epstein cites Wickard v. Filburn, a case from the New Deal era in which the court held that growing your own food (animal fodder, actually) fell under the Congressional power to regulate
Yes, but that dealt with the "commerce" part of the interstate commerce clause and is completely irrelevant here because it cannot be disputed that the buying and selling of healthcare is commerce. Buying and selling is the very definition of commerce and has been since Gibbons.

Wickard (1942) specifically referenced six Supreme Court cases that struck down statutes for exceeding the authority of the Commerce Clause. All of them deal with things that aren't commerce: E.C. Knight (manufacture) (1895); Employers' Liability (employee relations) (1908); Hammer (child labor) (1918); Railroad Retirement Board (pensions) (1935); Schechter (poultry safety) (1935); and Carter (mining) (1936). It can certainly be said that Wickard overturned 47 years of Constitutional jurisprudence. But Wickard, and the line of cases it overturned, have no application here because what Wickard did was change the definition of "commerce" to include things other than buying or selling. But the Healthcare Act is specifically about buying and selling. The issue is whether the commerce if "affects" is "interstate", and that has always been interpreted expansively.

If you want to overturn Wickard, more power to you. This is not the case that should do it, though.

That ruling turned Commerce clause jurisprudence on its head. Everything is related to everything else.
Everything is not related to everything else. Law is not some magic mumbo jumbo exercise. Concepts should be analyzed separately and they don't always lead you to the results you want. That's the price we pay for living in a nation governed by the rule of law and not the whim of magistrates.
 
...The commerce clause has always been interpreted to authorize federal regulation of fields of commerce that affects interstate commerce. The only cases that have found that Congress lacks such authority is when the activity being regulated is not commerce.1 There has been no Supreme Court case holding that Congress failed to demonstrate that commerce was "interstate".

Here, Congress is regulating the buying, selling, or refusal to buy healthcare insurance. It is not disputed that such commerce affects interstate commerce. It is not disputed that this constitutes commerce. Based on Constitutional precedent, Congress is authorized to regulate healthcare.2...
Everything is not related to everything else. Law is not some magic mumbo jumbo exercise. Concepts should be analyzed separately and they don't always lead you to the results you want. That's the price we pay for living in a nation governed by the rule of law and not the whim of magistrates.3
1. The weasel word is "affects". If I cross my living room, I "affect" the orbit of Jupiter. Not enough for an astronomer to care. Not enough to exert a measurable difference in the eccentricity of its orbit.
2. "Affects" again. That "interstate" adjective matters. According to Epstein, the Court has addressed the difference between "interstate" and intrastate commerce:
Before those revolutionary decisions, Supreme Court doctrine was faithful to the text and purpose of the Commerce Clause when it divided commerce into three parts. There was local commerce that led up to interstate commerce; there was commerce among the several states during any journey that crossed state lines; and there was local commerce once the interstate portion of the journey was over. In other words, Congress could not regulate the local taxi or bus service that takes people to the train station or airport for an interstate trip. It could regulate that trip, but it could not regulate the continuation of the journey once the train or plane reached its destination. By that test, the role of Obamacare in the national market would be to supply medical service for people struck ill in interstate journeys.

Thus it is no surprise that in Gibbons, Chief Justice Marshall wrote without embarrassment that “the completely interior traffic of a State” was beyond the power of commerce ("Congress"?)to regulate. A fortiori, the regulation of manufacture, agriculture, mining, or health care was far outside the scope of Congressional regulation.
3. You're making the oppositions' case, here. "Related" and "affects" name continuous variables (related to a degree, affects to a degree). Lines may be arbitraty, but where the law draws them makes a material difference.
 
1. The weasel word is "affects".
That "weasel word" is the word used in Gibbons v Ogden, the first decision interpreting the Commerce Clause:

The genius and character of the whole government seem to be, that its action is to be applied to all the external concerns of the nation, and to those internal concerns which affect the States generally; but not to those which are completely within a particular State, which do not affect other States, and with which it is not necessary to interfere, for the purpose of executing some of the general powers of the government.​

The Court here is, of course, discussing the "interstate" portion of the Commerce Clause, and, since it upheld the Act, this language is not dicta. Interstate commerce is commerce that "affects" the States generally and does not occur within one State without "affect[ing] other States." That's the standard that defined "interstate" since 1824, a scant 21 years after development of judicial review.

Does the sale and purchase of health insurance "affect the States generally"? Yes. Is the sale and purchase of health insurance confined to one State without affecting other States? No.

According to Epstein, the Court has addressed the difference between "interstate" and intrastate commerce
Epstein is wrong. I've read each of the cases he cited and the definition of "interstate" is only ever referenced in "dicta", which means commentary extraneous to the holding at hand. Each and every time someone challenges federal regulation on the "interstate" portion of the "interstate commerce" clause, the statute is either upheld entirely, or overturned on grounds unrelated to the Commerce Clause.

Epstein is cherry-picking dicta to make his case.

Lines may be arbitraty, but where the law draws them makes a material difference.
Yes, they are. And the Health Care Act sits on the "valid" side of Commerce Clause jurisprudence.
 
That "weasel word" is the word used in Gibbons v Ogden, the first decision interpreting the Commerce Clause:

The genius and character of the whole government seem to be, that its action is to be applied to all the external concerns of the nation, and to those internal concerns which affect the States generally; but not to those which are completely within a particular State, which do not affect other States, and with which it is not necessary to interfere, for the purpose of executing some of the general powers of the government.​

The Court here is, of course, discussing the "interstate" portion of the Commerce Clause, and, since it upheld the Act, this language is not dicta. Interstate commerce is commerce that "affects" the States generally and does not occur within one State without "affect[ing] other States." That's the standard that defined "interstate" since 1824, a scant 21 years after development of judicial review.

Does the sale and purchase of health insurance "affect the States generally"? Yes. Is the sale and purchase of health insurance confined to one State without affecting other States? No.


Epstein is wrong. I've read each of the cases he cited and the definition of "interstate" is only ever referenced in "dicta", which means commentary extraneous to the holding at hand. Each and every time someone challenges federal regulation on the "interstate" portion of the "interstate commerce" clause, the statute is either upheld entirely, or overturned on grounds unrelated to the Commerce Clause.

Epstein is cherry-picking dicta to make his case.


Yes, they are. And the Health Care Act sits on the "valid" side of Commerce Clause jurisprudence.
I think what's wrong with your argument is it doesn't build a solid case based on th history of supreme court interpretations that step by step, shows why the Heath Care Act is on the "valid" side. Unfortunately, the attorney for government's case didn't help much in his recent arguments.

Why do you think that might be? I assumed that he simply had no case. Was he just incompetent, and a brilliant lawyer could have done better?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom