Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

Ending a life without a just cause IS ALWAYS bad and the wrong choice.

And yet many states in the US do that. Who gets to decide what is a just cause?

No it is not. It is vitally important that government act to protect those too weak to protect themselves (the pre-born).

We've seen societies where women don't have the right to "murder the unborn" and it is never pretty.

Pre-born and unborn are political terms. If you're referring to a zygote or embryo or fetus, why not say so?
 
Last edited:
It kills someone who did no wrong for no reason other than they are inconvenient.

Even if that were true - that is has anything to do with killing, then so what?
The point is that the Foetus is 100% dependant on the use of the womb, and that gift is in the hands of the woman. It is her right to choose.
You would be in a state of contradiction if you take on the right to demand that the women carries the foetus to term. You can't justify the right to protect a potential life by potentially destroying the well being of another - the woman.
 
Ending a life without a just cause IS ALWAYS bad and the wrong choice.

SImply NO. Shouting does not make it true. It is not for you to say whether or not the woman has or has not a just cause.
Killing is often prosecuted without cause. What make the ending of a potential life wholly dependant on the complicity of the woman?




No it is not. It is vitally important that government act to protect those too weak to protect themselves (the pre-born).

We've seen societies where women don't have the right to "murder the unborn" and it is never pretty.

We've seen societies where there is no respect for the basic rights of man (including life) and it is far FAR worse.[/QUOTE]
 
Science can define anything it wants. It has been consulted on this very issue as have philosophers and theologians.

Science has no business being consulted in the matter of morals and ethics, because science by nature is amoral at best.
 
And yet many states in the US do that. Who gets to decide what is a just cause?

If you are referring to legalized abortion, that is begging the question.

if you are (as I suspect) running up the death penalty flag, you have changed the question. A capital criminal has been subject to due process, tried, conviceted by a court of law of a crime society deems so heinous that forfeiture of life is the proper penalty.

A pre-born baby has committed no crime whatsoever, let alone a capital one.

Pre-born and unborn are political terms. If you're referring to a zygote or embryo or fetus, why not say so?

No, they are CORRECT terms. I refuse to cede one inch to your agenda by agreeing to use your deliberately dehumanizing terms for human beings.
 
Here's the problem that you anti-abortion posters are sidestepping completely with this specific issue. You believe that abortion should be illegal. However, it isn't. The courts have ruled on why it isn't. What SD is doing is a different issue than if you think abortion should be legal or not, but the legality and justness of what SD is doing to make it so women can't do what they are legally allowed to do. All this other talk is a side track at best.
 
It is not for you to say whether or not the woman has or has not a just cause.

If it is not to save her literal life, it is prima facie not a just cause.

Killing is often prosecuted without cause.

Yes, we call that act murder, and we punish it.

What make the ending of a potential life wholly dependant on the complicity of the woman?

The pre-born is not "potential" life. He/she is a living human being with his/her own distinct genetic code, a discrete identifiable body, and an existence that differs from your or mine only in that said existence is at an earlier stage of development.
 
Here's the problem that you anti-abortion posters are sidestepping completely with this specific issue. You believe that abortion should be illegal. However, it isn't. The courts have ruled on why it isn't.

The courts have ruled on many things that were wrongly decided ("seperate but equal", etc) Stare decisis only applies once the right precedent is set.

What SD is doing is a different issue than if you think abortion should be legal or not, but the legality and justness of what SD is doing to make it so women can't do what they are legally allowed to do..

Lie.

SD still permits the abortions, but only after the woman is fully informed and educated as to the realities of what she is considering to do.
 
SD still permits the abortions, but only after the woman is fully informed and educated as to the realities of what she is considering to do.

Why doesn't the state ensure others are fully informed about other medical procedures?
 
mulder.....the solution is simple.
don't get pregnant, then you will not have to choose.
other than that, what a women does to and with her body is none of your business.

keep your theology outa a woman's body.

why is it you insist on controlling other's lives?
christians need to tend to their own garden, and quit interfering in the lives of others.
 
SD still permits the abortions, but only after the woman is fully informed and educated as to the realities of what she is considering to do.
Ah yes, because women are so like children. Evil, sinful, slutty children. They need somebody to explain to them that they're being sinful, and they probably still won't understand (it's just so hard without pictures sometimes!), so they need to make sure that they hear it twice. And those nice people at the crisis pregnancy centre will probably have lots of pictures and people who speak in Mr. Rogers voices that child-women will understand. Not like those doctors who use big words!

Thanks for looking out for me, South Dakota. I'm really too stupid to understand what's happening in my own body and what a special gift I've been given in spite of my lack of understanding.
 
Last edited:
SD still permits the abortions, but only after the woman is fully informed and educated as to the realities of what she is considering to do.

You know what needs to be a law? Women who choose to continue with their pregnancy should be required to be informed and educated as to the realities of what it's really like, and not the ******** Norman Rockwell image of the happy smiling earth mother that way too many anti-choice people seem to think it's like.

Doctors should be required to tell women:

1. Your crappy insurance will probably not pay for a good portion of the prenatal care.

2. Your prenatal vitamins are likely to make you violently ill.

3. The intense nausea and vomiting in the first 4 months of pregnancy probably will leave you unable to eat anything other than dry toast without heaving. Oh, and your insurance will not pay for any anti-nausea treatment (not that it works, anyway.)

4. Sciatica in even the second trimester can leave you darn-near paralyzed and in constant pain when walking, sitting, sleeping, breathing. Ladies who make their living doing anything physical should have to sign a waiver acknowledging that they not only won't be able to work, but are perfectly okay with the loss of income for 8-10 months, if not more.

5. The "precious" little thing growing in your abdomen is likely to throw your thyroid completely out of whack, requiring yet another prescription drug, monthly tests, and weeks/months of either sleeplessness or exhaustion -- neither of which your employer is likely to give care one about.

6. Even though you've never suffered from high blood pressure or diabetes, there's a good chance you'll develop both of them during your pregnancy, throwing your systolic blood pressure into the high 180s, leaving you at major risk for a stroke and other health problems.

7. You'll most likely have back and leg pain on par with Dengue fever.

8. Hormonal changes can leave you massively depressed, even suicidal. But nobody around you will care or take you seriously because motherhood is a gift from god and all.

9. You'll probably suffer constipation so severe it will put you off eating anything but broth.

10. Did I mention the tachycardia and breathlessness for no apparent reason, that make the walk from your car to your front door feel like it will trigger a heart attack? Yes, that should be on the list.

... and about a thousand financial issues that nobody warned you about.

Oh, and docs should have to inform you of your risk of having a seriously disabled child, requiring hundreds of thousands of dollars of medical care or years of specialized and individualized attention, so you know just what kind of "parenting" will be required of you, if the child lives long enough. They should also be required to line up one of the anti-choice activists to adopt each of these children.



You're absolutely right -- informing and educating women on the reality of pregnancy is a GREAT idea! If someone had told me I'd be just disabled enough by my pregnancy to not be able to do my job and earn a living (but not disabled "enough" to qualify for any assistance) you'd better believe I'd be rethinking my decision to continue this pregnancy!

Edited by Locknar: 
Edited, breach of rule 10; please do not curse in your posts or mask such words in an attempt to by-pass the auto-censor.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Science has no business being consulted in the matter of morals and ethics, because science by nature is amoral at best.

it has a busuness being consulted when it is about embryology for example, when it is about the developement of the nervous system in a fetus. Science can tell us from what week on is a fetus able to feel, when do organs start working, when is the brain connected to the nervous system etc.

who else would you want to consult?
 
SD still permits the abortions, but only after the woman is fully informed and educated as to the realities of what she is considering to do.

Correction, the law permits abortions, but only after the woman is "informed" about the consequences (which may or may not actually exist) by a pro-life advocate whose goal is to talk her out of obtaining an abortion. After this discussion, the pro-life advocate is supposed to give the woman a document to give to her abortion provider, stating that she has seen and spoken to the pro-life advocate. The doctor then accepts the document and performs the abortion.

But there is nothing in the law stating that the pro-life advocate is obligated to provide this document.

Think about it Muldur. Suppose that before a woman gets an abortion, she has to allow you personally to try to talk her out of it for an hour. Then you have to fill out a form giving her permission to have an abortion. You talk to her for an hour and fail to convice her. Would you fill out the permission form for her to have an abortion even though you are under no obligation to?

Of course not. You are morally opposed to abortion.

The form does not get signed, the woman does not get an abortion. The South Dakota law is a de facto abortion ban.
 
Correct. The law may as well say "you can have an abortion, if you pay one-hundred million dollars to the church first."

The women pay a pro-lifer for a "waiver" so they can get an abortion. The pro-lifer doesn't actually have to give them said waiver. If they do pay for the waver, the funds are going towards more efforts to get abortion completely banned.

This SD law is immoral and unConstitutional. I don't know if it will be challenged with the current theocratic leaning Supreme Court though.
 
The courts have ruled on many things that were wrongly decided ("seperate but equal", etc) Stare decisis only applies once the right precedent is set.



Lie.

SD still permits the abortions, but only after the woman is fully informed and educated as to the realities of what she is considering to do.

If the woman is to be "fully informed" then why is she being fed misleading data? Why isn't she being counseled by a doctor? What right does the state have to mandate attendance at lecture which does not offer factual information?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom