Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

Less dramatic reason: Abortions cost money.

Considering that 60% of women who have an abortion already have one or more children and that 40% of women who have an abortion have an income below the poverty line, this is a primary reason for reducing the number of abortions necessary.

Not quite sure how that will happen now that the anti-choice people have also decided to get into the anti-family planning game.
 
It seems to me that there is an easy way out of this mess. All that has to happen is that a group of pro-choice people set up their own "crisis pregnancy centre" to educate women "as to the realities of what she is considering to do" and hand her the form that she went there. Doesn't seem so different from what Planned Parenthood already does, the pregnancy centre just needs some legal independence from it.

Interesting. I wonder if South Dakota bill specifies an anti-abortion pregnancy center?
 
Interesting. I wonder if South Dakota bill specifies an anti-abortion pregnancy center?

From the bill:

The Department of Health shall maintain a registry of pregnancy help centers located in the

- 6 - HB 1217
state of South Dakota. The Department shall publish a list of all pregnancy help centers which
1
submit a written request or application to be listed on the state registry of pregnancy help
2
centers. All pregnancy help centers seeking to be listed on the registry shall be so listed without
charge, if they submit an affidavit that certifies that:
4
(1) The pregnancy help center has a facility or office in the state of South Dakota in
5
which it routinely consults with women for the purpose of helping them keep their
6
relationship with their unborn children;
7
(2) That one of its principal missions is to educate, counsel, and otherwise assist women
8
to help them maintain their relationship with their unborn children;
(3) That they do not perform abortions at their facility, and have no affiliation with any
10
organization or physician which performs abortions;
11
(4) That they do not now refer pregnant women for abortions, and have not referred any
pregnant women for an abortion at any time in the three years immediately preceding
13
July 1, 2011;
14

Sorry for the disjointed copy/paste. It's a pdf document, and starts on page 6.
 
Last edited:
If the issue were returned to voters, I would vote against abortion, although I am sure that most areas would vote to keep it legal.

it is not the business of the voters.
it is not the business of anyone but the woman.
abortion is an issue that is only relevant to the woman and her doctor.
as a man, it is certainly none of my *********** business what a woman does with her own body.
if you are a man, then it is none of your *********** business either.
 
my support for the cuban revolution is in no way equal to 'advocating totalitarianism'.
to advocate is to actively work towards something.
i do not advocate or actively work towards promoting totalitarianism.

retract your lie.

Advocate:

1ad·vo·cate
noun \ˈad-və-kət, -ˌkāt\
Definition of ADVOCATE
1
: one that pleads the cause of another; specifically : one that pleads the cause of another before a tribunal or judicial court
2
: one that defends or maintains a cause or proposal
3
: one that supports or promotes the interests of another

I'll stop saying you advocate totalitarianism when you stop singing the praises of totalitarian governments at every opportunity. You cannot support the Cuban revolution and oppose totalitarianism at the same time.
 
it is not the business of the voters.
it is not the business of anyone but the woman.
abortion is an issue that is only relevant to the woman and her doctor.
as a man, it is certainly none of my *********** business what a woman does with her own body.
if you are a man, then it is none of your *********** business either.

Great, I can only assume this means that you will cease and desist forming opinions about things that do not affect your body as they are none of your ******* business.
 
Great, I can only assume this means that you will cease and desist forming opinions about things that do not affect your body as they are none of your ******* business.

then you would be wrong.
obviously a voice of reason is needed to counter all of those that wish to tell a woman what she may or may not do with her body.
since people like you are willing to take away her rights, i'm here to defend those rights.

what a woman does with her body is her business.
when others want to interfere, i will make that my business.
 
Disgusting, and immoral. Not to mention unconstitutional. I'm glad that, for once, it's not my red state trying to pass this ********.

I'm too tired to double check now, but I'm fairly certain PP is planning a legal challenge.
 
then you would be wrong.
obviously a voice of reason is needed to counter all of those that wish to tell a woman what she may or may not do with her body.
since people like you are willing to take away her rights, i'm here to defend those rights.

what a woman does with her body is her business.
when others want to interfere, i will make that my business.

I hardly meant for that to apply to just this issue. By your reasoning, you should not voice an opinion on any subject that does not affect your body because it is none of your ******* business.

And for that matter, nothing I am saying here affects your body so you prove yourself to be a hypocrite each time you respond.
 
Advocate:

1ad·vo·cate
noun \ˈad-və-kət, -ˌkāt\
Definition of ADVOCATE
1
: one that pleads the cause of another; specifically : one that pleads the cause of another before a tribunal or judicial court
2
: one that defends or maintains a cause or proposal
3
: one that supports or promotes the interests of another

I'll stop saying you advocate totalitarianism when you stop singing the praises of totalitarian governments at every opportunity. You cannot support the Cuban revolution and oppose totalitarianism at the same time.

time for a grammar lesson.

you said, "This from a communist who advocates totalitarianism?"
in this case, 'advocates' is a verb, not a noun.
your definition was for the noun.
i am an 'advocate' for the cuban revolution, because it works. (noun)
i do not 'advocate' totalitianism. (verb)

here endeth the lesson.
 
time for a grammar lesson.

you said, "This from a communist who advocates totalitarianism?"
in this case, 'advocates' is a verb, not a noun.
your definition was for the noun.
i am an 'advocate' for the cuban revolution, because it works. (noun)
i do not 'advocate' totalitianism. (verb)

here endeth the lesson.

Advocate (verb)

: to plead in favor of.

Like singing the praises of a totalitarian Cuban government. Bang up job.
 
Ending a life without a just cause IS ALWAYS bad and the wrong choice.

Why? Explain to me why a woman in poverty with an abusive partner should be forced to bring a child into that situation? Why should a woman that absolutely does not want a child, for whatever reason, be forced to carry the child she doesn't want to term?

No it is not. It is vitally important that government act to protect those too weak to protect themselves (the pre-born).

Why? Why should a disorganized bunch of human DNA that might become a person one day deserve to be treated as if they are already fully functioning sentient beings?

We've seen societies where there is no respect for the basic rights of man (including life) and it is far FAR worse.

And yet societies that allow abortions have a much higher standard of living and lower crime rates than societies that do not. There is an intrinsic link between successful societies and abortion. Take away abortion and watch society implode as we become overrun with unwanted, mistreated children that will inevitably become scourges.
 
No it is not. It is vitally important that government act to protect those too weak to protect themselves (the pre-born).

You know, I've considered calling zygotes "pre-brained" but I'm sure someone would think of it as an insult.
 
time for a grammar lesson.

you said, "This from a communist who advocates totalitarianism?"
in this case, 'advocates' is a verb, not a noun.
your definition was for the noun.
i am an 'advocate' for the cuban revolution, because it works. (noun)
i do not 'advocate' totalitianism. (verb)

here endeth the lesson.

:rolleyes: this "revolution" was totalitarian.

and no it doesn't work. they have no freedom no self determination and are not paid properly for their work. It worked for Fidel and a few of his buddies. But it sucked for the rest. as to be expected under a totalitarian regime.
 
Science has no business being consulted in the matter of morals and ethics, because science by nature is amoral at best.

So what.? Everyone one disagrees with your characterisation. Science has much to offer the debate. It would be foolish to ignore the evidence of Foetal development.= Evidence which both sides use.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom