bookitty
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2009
- Messages
- 5,732
Correction, the law permits abortions, but only after the woman is "informed" about the consequences (which may or may not actually exist) by a pro-life advocate whose goal is to talk her out of obtaining an abortion. After this discussion, the pro-life advocate is supposed to give the woman a document to give to her abortion provider, stating that she has seen and spoken to the pro-life advocate. The doctor then accepts the document and performs the abortion.
But there is nothing in the law stating that the pro-life advocate is obligated to provide this document.
Think about it Muldur. Suppose that before a woman gets an abortion, she has to allow you personally to try to talk her out of it for an hour. Then you have to fill out a form giving her permission to have an abortion. You talk to her for an hour and fail to convice her. Would you fill out the permission form for her to have an abortion even though you are under no obligation to?
Of course not. You are morally opposed to abortion.
The form does not get signed, the woman does not get an abortion. The South Dakota law is a de facto abortion ban.
Having been on many a clinic defense line, I am afraid this will be common scenario. People on both sides of the issue have become personally, emotionally invested. Give any sort of power to the anti-choicers and they
will abuse it. (Unless it's one of their own and then they understand that it's sad, so sad but a totally different situation.)