Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

Correction, the law permits abortions, but only after the woman is "informed" about the consequences (which may or may not actually exist) by a pro-life advocate whose goal is to talk her out of obtaining an abortion. After this discussion, the pro-life advocate is supposed to give the woman a document to give to her abortion provider, stating that she has seen and spoken to the pro-life advocate. The doctor then accepts the document and performs the abortion.

But there is nothing in the law stating that the pro-life advocate is obligated to provide this document.

Think about it Muldur. Suppose that before a woman gets an abortion, she has to allow you personally to try to talk her out of it for an hour. Then you have to fill out a form giving her permission to have an abortion. You talk to her for an hour and fail to convice her. Would you fill out the permission form for her to have an abortion even though you are under no obligation to?

Of course not. You are morally opposed to abortion.

The form does not get signed, the woman does not get an abortion. The South Dakota law is a de facto abortion ban.

Having been on many a clinic defense line, I am afraid this will be common scenario. People on both sides of the issue have become personally, emotionally invested. Give any sort of power to the anti-choicers and they
will abuse it. (Unless it's one of their own and then they understand that it's sad, so sad but a totally different situation.)
 
The South Dakota law is a de facto abortion ban.
Courts have overturned de facto segregation:
The Court has ruled in Milliken v. Bradley (1974) that courts of law can remedy de facto segregation only if it was caused by specific acts of government.
However, I'm not sure de facto is the best description, since for segregation, it was also used for neighborhoods that clumped one race together "naturally," that is, not by law, but custom.

Perhaps a better description of this situation is that government has said, "Sure, anyone can have an abortion, as long as you complete this impossible task first."
 
i never said it did. i do say one can use embryology to determine from when on a fetus can be regarded as a person.

on what do you base your oppinion? why do you never answer the questions directed at you?

You have looked at embryonic development and picked a point where you are no longer comfortable with abortion to assign the status of personhood. It is not a scientific distinction, it is a matter of opinion based on what you feel comfortable with. Similar to the way that opposition to abortion increases in popular opinion the more a fetus looks like it will after birth. It is emotion and feeling that directs such views, not science. And I have already told you that I cannot find any compelling reason to assign different classes of personhood to humans, meaning I do not find your claim that personhood starts with brain development to have any more validity than Travis' claim that personhood starts with significant knowledge of ones own existence and rights. You have claimed that his view is extreme, but have not and cannot provide any reason to believe that your view is any better. Largely, because this concept of personhood you guys keep citing has no basis in biology, rather you vary so much with it because it is a concept only brought up to justify abortion ("sure, a human dies but no one should be critical of it because the dead human didn't qualify as a person yet because they lacked a nervous system, ability to do calculus etc") to a point where the arguer is no longer comfortable with abortion. As such, any rights that we consider universal should apply to the fetus too, unlike meaningless undefinable distinctions about who is good enough to qualify as a person, it is definitely a human organism. If it has no right to live on that basis, then no one else does.
 
Do YOU think it should be illegal?

If yes: what should be the punishment - and who gets it?
If no: what would you propose to stop abortions, then?

If the issue were returned to voters, I would vote against abortion, although I am sure that most areas would vote to keep it legal.
 
Even if that were true - that is has anything to do with killing, then so what?
The point is that the Foetus is 100% dependant on the use of the womb, and that gift is in the hands of the woman. It is her right to choose.
You would be in a state of contradiction if you take on the right to demand that the women carries the foetus to term. You can't justify the right to protect a potential life by potentially destroying the well being of another - the woman.

Seeing as how the entire purpose of an abortion is the kill the child it is fairly clear that it has quite a bit to do with killing.

And I never said that not allowing abortion would not restrict the rights of the mother, quite the contrary, I have repeatedly said that forcing her to carry the child would violate her rights. And her having an abortion violates the rights of the child. Which is why I say that there is no easy, correct answer, someone will have their rights violated either way. I am more prone to erring on the side of the child, as death cannot be overcome, but I can see why many go the other way as well. What I get sick of is when people make up imaginary classes of humans to skip around the moral dilemma entirely.
 
If the issue were returned to voters, I would vote against abortion, although I am sure that most areas would vote to keep it legal.

That doesn't answer those questions at all. Here they are again.

Do YOU think it should be illegal?

If yes: what should be the punishment - and who gets it?
If no: what would you propose to stop abortions, then?
 
That doesn't answer those questions at all. Here they are again.

Sure it does, I don't think it is up for me to decide it for everyone else with king-like powers.

I suppose you are looking for answers where abortion was determined to be illegal though. Okay, considering the cultural norms, the punishment should not be as stiff as it would be for drowning a two year old, but would have to be significant enough to make people think twice about having an illegal medical procedure. What exactly it should be would require some serious study. Stripping doctors of their medical licenses would be more straight forward.

If abortion is legal, but unwanted, what could be done? Better sex education seems obvious enough, as well as the state doing a better job of taking care of orphaned children, both through their own efforts and by helping private charities and adoption services who do such work. That would at least somewhat counter the idea that abortion would be better than bringing a child into poverty.
 
You have looked at embryonic development and picked a point where you are no longer comfortable with abortion to assign the status of personhood. It is not a scientific distinction, it is a matter of opinion based on what you feel comfortable with. Similar to the way that opposition to abortion increases in popular opinion the more a fetus looks like it will after birth. It is emotion and feeling that directs such views, not science. And I have already told you that I cannot find any compelling reason to assign different classes of personhood to humans, meaning I do not find your claim that personhood starts with brain development to have any more validity than Travis' claim that personhood starts with significant knowledge of ones own existence and rights. You have claimed that his view is extreme, but have not and cannot provide any reason to believe that your view is any better. Largely, because this concept of personhood you guys keep citing has no basis in biology, rather you vary so much with it because it is a concept only brought up to justify abortion ("sure, a human dies but no one should be critical of it because the dead human didn't qualify as a person yet because they lacked a nervous system, ability to do calculus etc") to a point where the arguer is no longer comfortable with abortion. As such, any rights that we consider universal should apply to the fetus too, unlike meaningless undefinable distinctions about who is good enough to qualify as a person, it is definitely a human organism. If it has no right to live on that basis, then no one else does.

I am pro-choice. The point at which I am comfortable with abortion starts and stops with my own body.

I have opinions about abortion in general. I would prefer that they don't happen at all. If it is necessary, I would prefer that it happen within the first 16 weeks of development. But it's just my opinion. I would never be so arrogant as to think that my opinion trump's some stranger's autonomy over their own body.

Especially because abortion is safer than pregnancy, especially in the USA. It is not right to demand a woman to risk her life or her health for a two-inch blob of tissue that weighs less than an ounce simply because it could grow into a human.
 
You have looked at embryonic development and picked a point where you are no longer comfortable with abortion to assign the status of personhood. It is not a scientific distinction, it is a matter of opinion based on what you feel comfortable with. Similar to the way that opposition to abortion increases in popular opinion the more a fetus looks like it will after birth. It is emotion and feeling that directs such views, not science. And I have already told you that I cannot find any compelling reason to assign different classes of personhood to humans, meaning I do not find your claim that personhood starts with brain development to have any more validity than Travis' claim that personhood starts with significant knowledge of ones own existence and rights. You have claimed that his view is extreme, but have not and cannot provide any reason to believe that your view is any better. Largely, because this concept of personhood you guys keep citing has no basis in biology, rather you vary so much with it because it is a concept only brought up to justify abortion ("sure, a human dies but no one should be critical of it because the dead human didn't qualify as a person yet because they lacked a nervous system, ability to do calculus etc") to a point where the arguer is no longer comfortable with abortion. As such, any rights that we consider universal should apply to the fetus too, unlike meaningless undefinable distinctions about who is good enough to qualify as a person, it is definitely a human organism. If it has no right to live on that basis, then no one else does.

i have reasons why i think before a certain point a fetus is not a person. you don't , you just think its from perception on and you have no reasoning why that is so.
 
I am pro-choice. The point at which I am comfortable with abortion starts and stops with my own body.

I have opinions about abortion in general. I would prefer that they don't happen at all. If it is necessary, I would prefer that it happen within the first 16 weeks of development. But it's just my opinion. I would never be so arrogant as to think that my opinion trump's some stranger's autonomy over their own body.

Especially because abortion is safer than pregnancy, especially in the USA. It is not right to demand a woman to risk her life or her health for a two-inch blob of tissue that weighs less than an ounce simply because it could grow into a human.

Are you saying it is a necessary evil?
 
Sure it does, I don't think it is up for me to decide it for everyone else with king-like powers.

I suppose you are looking for answers where abortion was determined to be illegal though. Okay, considering the cultural norms, the punishment should not be as stiff as it would be for drowning a two year old, but would have to be significant enough to make people think twice about having an illegal medical procedure. What exactly it should be would require some serious study. Stripping doctors of their medical licenses would be more straight forward.

If abortion is legal, but unwanted, what could be done? Better sex education seems obvious enough, as well as the state doing a better job of taking care of orphaned children, both through their own efforts and by helping private charities and adoption services who do such work. That would at least somewhat counter the idea that abortion would be better than bringing a child into poverty.

Yes, because we have so much historical precedent for humane orphanages. :rolleyes:

Funding is being cut for WIC, for head start programs, for schools and for Title X funding (family planning and education.) What makes you think that more state-run orphanages could even be implemented? The same people who want to outlaw abortion also want to make family planning difficult, and to ensure that children raised in poverty have no access to the nutrition and education they need to thrive.

It's not about the babies.
 
Are you saying it is a necessary evil?

No, I do not think abortion is evil. Women spontaneously abort all the time. However, induced abortion is a medical procedure, one that is less dangerous than pregnancy but carries some risk. Access to legal abortion is difficult in many areas and it can be an excessive cost for some. Birth control and education are less expensive and invasive options.

But if an abortion is necessary, then it is a necessary good.
 
Yes, because we have so much historical precedent for humane orphanages. :rolleyes:

Funding is being cut for WIC, for head start programs, for schools and for Title X funding (family planning and education.) What makes you think that more state-run orphanages could even be implemented? The same people who want to outlaw abortion also want to make family planning difficult, and to ensure that children raised in poverty have no access to the nutrition and education they need to thrive.

It's not about the babies.

Clearly being dead is superior.
 
No, I do not think abortion is evil. Women spontaneously abort all the time. However, induced abortion is a medical procedure, one that is less dangerous than pregnancy but carries some risk. Access to legal abortion is difficult in many areas and it can be an excessive cost for some. Birth control and education are less expensive and invasive options.

But if an abortion is necessary, then it is a necessary good.

Then why did you say that you would prefer there be no abortions? If there is nothing wrong with it, why not prefer that there is no change in abortion rates or even that there be more?
 
Then why did you say that you would prefer there be no abortions? If there is nothing wrong with it, why not prefer that there is no change in abortion rates or even that there be more?

If bookitty thinks the same way as me it is because an unwanted pregnancy is always traumatic and I would prefer that the decision never had to be made - either because of a decrease in unplanned pregnancies or an decrease in the conditions that make it more difficult to raise a child. But many of the groups that are against abortion are also against contraception and effective teaching about contraceptives...
 
Last edited:
Then why did you say that you would prefer there be no abortions? If there is nothing wrong with it, why not prefer that there is no change in abortion rates or even that there be more?

Because it's always better if people can avoid a medical procedure.

Let's say I have fair skin and a family history of melanoma. I can use sunblock every time I leave the house and reduce my chance of skin cancer. Perhaps I'll get lucky and I will never have skin cancer. But if I do get skin cancer, surgery will be necessary. That does not make it evil.
 
It seems to me that there is an easy way out of this mess. All that has to happen is that a group of pro-choice people set up their own "crisis pregnancy centre" to educate women "as to the realities of what she is considering to do" and hand her the form that she went there. Doesn't seem so different from what Planned Parenthood already does, the pregnancy centre just needs some legal independence from it.
 
If bookitty thinks the same way as me it is because an unwanted pregnancy is always traumatic and I would prefer that the decision never had to be made - either because of a decrease in unplanned pregnancies or an decrease in the conditions that make it more difficult to raise a child. But many of the groups that are against abortion are also against contraception and effective teaching about contraceptives...

Because it's always better if people can avoid a medical procedure.

Let's say I have fair skin and a family history of melanoma. I can use sunblock every time I leave the house and reduce my chance of skin cancer. Perhaps I'll get lucky and I will never have skin cancer. But if I do get skin cancer, surgery will be necessary. That does not make it evil.

Less dramatic reason: Abortions cost money.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom