Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

are you claiming there is no difference between you and a fertilized egg? :rolleyes:

Of course there is a difference, we are at much different stages in development. That does not inform our rights.
 
just because you do not accept it, does not mean it is not a science.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fields_of_science

but that's OT.

Click the link and "Not considered a science by some thinkers, instead considered a precursor of it" pops right up. Archeology, history, political science, linguistics, economics and sociology are generally considered to be the social sciences last I checked. Good to know that you consider metaphysics and claims of thinking therefore you are to be science though.
 
Are you serious?

i wonder if you are serious if you really try ro run with the nonsense, its Human so its a Human.

not everything human is considered a person. and a fetus is one of those things.
 
Click the link and "Not considered a science by some thinkers, instead considered a precursor of it" pops right up. Archeology, history, political science, linguistics, economics and sociology are generally considered to be the social sciences last I checked. Good to know that you consider metaphysics and claims of thinking therefore you are to be science though.

as asked on Wiki, who?
citation needed. and just because some believe it not to be a science, doesn't mean ti is not a science.

:rolleyes:
 
i wonder if you are serious if you really try ro run with the nonsense, its Human so its a Human.

not everything human is considered a person. and a fetus is one of those things.

See my last post.
 
as asked on Wiki, who?
citation needed. and just because some believe it not to be a science, doesn't mean ti is not a science.

:rolleyes:

Philosophy covers topics that are not scientific in any sense and has no requirement to follow the scientific method. I don't care if some knuckle dragging retards on Wikipedia included it as a possible science, it is not one because it does not follow the rules of science. For instance, many claims in philosophy are not falsifiable. If you consider philosophy to be science you do not know what science is.
 
Embryology does not make claims about personhood, you are lying.

i never said it did. i do say one can use embryology to determine from when on a fetus can be regarded as a person.

on what do you base your oppinion? why do you never answer the questions directed at you?
 
Philosophy covers topics that are not scientific in any sense and has no requirement to follow the scientific method. I don't care if some knuckle dragging retards on Wikipedia included it as a possible science, it is not one because it does not follow the rules of science. For instance, many claims in philosophy are not falsifiable. If you consider philosophy to be science you do not know what science is.

it is a science. but again this is OT.
 
I think it should be decided locally barring an amendment, I find the dissents from Roe v. Wade to be far more compelling than the majority.

Mostly I wish that people would recognize that it is not a simple question. Making up classes of humanity to skip around the moral problem with abortion is a cheap cop out used by the weak of mind (likewise, saying that stopping a woman from doing what she wants because one or more gods forbid it is also a cheap cop out). There is no correct answer, but that doesn't excuse nonsense to justify cheap certainty.

Do YOU think it should be illegal?

If yes: what should be the punishment - and who gets it?
If no: what would you propose to stop abortions, then?
 
It's not academic at all. That is just what people tell themselves to justify their position.. in their own mind.

Because the entire argument that it's just a slug is nothing more than an attempt to minimalize and trivialize the procedure down to a level where it can be justified and exonerated of any sense of it being "bad".

Proof? Answer this question honest. At the end of the day, what is the point of an abortion? What is the woman setting out to do? What is the goal she is setting out to accomplish?

If you are honest, you won't say it's to have some worthless/useless slug pulled from her body. It's the deliberate act of purposely destroying a growing human embryo for the purpose of NOT delivering a child. For whatever reasons, good or bad... the desired outcome is "I do not want to have this baby".

Yep, that's exactly what it is. They are making the choice to not bring that child into the world. A choice they should have because a person that doesn't want to bring a baby into this world should not have to.

You are not going to scare either me or her with a choice of words.

Call it whatever you want: baby butchering, murdering the unborn. Whatever. You are not going to phase me about this procedure. Yes you are ending what would likely have been a person one day if you hadn't had the procedure but that doesn't make it "bad" nor does it mean it was the "wrong" choice. In fact it is vitally important that women retain the right to not give birth to these "people."

We've seen societies where women don't have the right to "murder the unborn" and it is never pretty.
 
Yes you are ending what would likely have been a person one day if you hadn't had the procedure but that doesn't make it "bad" nor does it mean it was the "wrong" choice.

Ending a life without a just cause IS ALWAYS bad and the wrong choice.

In fact it is vitally important that women retain the right to not give birth to these "people."

No it is not. It is vitally important that government act to protect those too weak to protect themselves (the pre-born).

We've seen societies where women don't have the right to "murder the unborn" and it is never pretty.[/QUOTE]

We've seen societies where there is no respect for the basic rights of man (including life) and it is far FAR worse.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom