Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

it is a concept based on Science and used by laws.
there are scietific reasons why abortion is legal here untill week 12, and in some rare cases even later.

there are certain stages of developement that have to be completed before the fetus gets protected by laws.

LOL. Science does not define personhood.
 
LOL. Science does not define personhood.

what does define it then? here science was used to set the legal timespan in wich it is legal to abort. i dont see what is wrong about it.

what is defining personhood if not science?
 
what does define it then? here science was used to set the legal timespan in wich it is legal to abort. i dont see what is wrong about it.

what is defining personhood if not science?

You are using the term as a philosophical concept, not a scientific one.
 
You are using the term as a philosophical concept, not a scientific one.

philosophy is a field of science.

but to create the legal framework on abortion, science (embryology) was used to define untill what week it is ok to abort.
the fetus is not able to feel yet nor is the nervus system developed yet.
so it is surely not a person yet.

ETA: btw, i asked you a question, why don't you answer it?

what is defining personhood in your oppinion?
 
Last edited:
philosophy is a field of science.

but to create the legal framework on abortion, science (embryology) was used to define untill what week it is ok to abort.
the fetus is not able to feel yet nor is the nervus system developed yet.
so it is surely not a person yet.

Philosophy is not science. Using embryology to determine where a majority is politically comfortable with killing a fetus does not create a new clade in biology. Personhood is not a scientific concept.
 
So respect, do you think Abortion should be illegal?

If Yes, what should be the punishment for women who get one?
 
Philosophy is not science. Using embryology to determine where a majority is politically comfortable with killing a fetus does not create a new clade in biology. Personhood is not a scientific concept.

sure it is a science. its a social science.

the rest is just a strawman, i never claimed it creates a new clade in biology. nobody did here.
 
So respect, do you think Abortion should be illegal?

If Yes, what should be the punishment for women who get one?

I think it should be decided locally barring an amendment, I find the dissents from Roe v. Wade to be far more compelling than the majority.

Mostly I wish that people would recognize that it is not a simple question. Making up classes of humanity to skip around the moral problem with abortion is a cheap cop out used by the weak of mind (likewise, saying that stopping a woman from doing what she wants because one or more gods forbid it is also a cheap cop out). There is no correct answer, but that doesn't excuse nonsense to justify cheap certainty.
 
I think it should be decided locally barring an amendment, I find the dissents from Roe v. Wade to be far more compelling than the majority.

Mostly I wish that people would recognize that it is not a simple question. Making up classes of humanity to skip around the moral problem with abortion is a cheap cop out used by the weak of mind (likewise, saying that stopping a woman from doing what she wants because one or more gods forbid it is also a cheap cop out). There is no correct answer, but that doesn't excuse nonsense to justify cheap certainty.

like claiming something Human is a Human? :rolleyes:
 
You were mentioning strawmen?

my sperm is human, yes or no?
according to you this means, it is a Human.

maybe you do now realize how stupid and oversimplyfied your concept of a human is?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom