Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

ìt is a living organism and it is from the Human species. but in the first weeks of the developement of a fetus, it is not able to feel yet nor to survive without its mother. It is not yet a person.

Well, at least you aren't trying to claim it is a different species than its parents like bookitty and EvilSmurf. Unfortunately, "person" is not a definitively definable standard, the moral dilemma is still present. Indeed, your standard of personhood is much stricter than many pro-choice advocates. There is no compelling reason to determine that your arbitrary distinction is correct and travis' is wrong for example.
 
Well, at least you aren't trying to claim it is a different species than its parents like bookitty and EvilSmurf. Unfortunately, "person" is not a definitively definable standard, the moral dilemma is still present. Indeed, your standard of personhood is much stricter than many pro-choice advocates. There is no compelling reason to determine that your arbitrary distinction is correct and travis' is wrong for example.

where did EvilSmurf claim it is a different species?
he didn't in any of his 3 posts in this thread.
 
no he didn't, dang, its a simple compilation of pictures, and you dont get it?

It was implied with his response. I get it fine, a nonsense standard of personhood is applied to avoid the moral questions of abortion entirely.
 
It was implied with his response. I get it fine, a nonsense standard of personhood is applied to avoid the moral questions of abortion entirely.

are you claiming the illustration in EvilSmurf's picture is a Person?
do you believe a person can split in two and become two persons?
 
1. The child being aborted and generally the child's father are not given a choice.

2. Abortion is not the only issue in existence, how "pro-choice" are you really?
The embryo is not aware of its own existance andthe father's rights end at the extrenal terminus of his urethra. If he is married to the pregnant woman, I am totally cool with a law that makes that legal grounds for an annulment of the marriage.
 
Besides that that isn't what he responded to, such a distinction is completely arbitrary and has no real meaning.

this distinction has a very important meaning. Just becuase you do not accept it, doesn't mean it has no meaning.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom