Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

Just make your positions clear, children are punishment for being a slut.

No, children are a wonderful gift and awesome responsibility in one package. If a woman does not wish to receive the gift of or accept the responsibility that accompanies a baby, her best option would be to NOT do that which "puts her on the list" to obtain one.

Once the baby is conceived, at a minimum, she has the obligation to bring that life fully into the world if doing so would not kill her. Her baby should not lose it's life for her decisions, questionable or otherwise.
 
Are we ready to outlaw male masturbation and menstrual cycles that don't result in implantation? Cause those kill potential little people too.
 
who in hell are you to dictate what another person's obligations are?
you have dominion over your own life and actions.
those of others are none of your damn business.

This from a communist who advocates totalitarianism?
 
Are we ready to outlaw male masturbation and menstrual cycles that don't result in implantation? Cause those kill potential little people too.

One of the strawmen is still twitching, get him.
 
By that standard, even POST-birth baby killing would be acceptable up until cognition sets in.

No sane person supports THAT definition of "person".

In another thread he did claim that babies are not people although he did not clarify if he thought aborting babies, the mentally ill etc would be okay, just that they do not qualify for the nonexistent class of personhood.
 
One of the strawmen is still twitching, get him.

Aww, or it was just a joke.

People who advocate for complete abolishment of abortion are sad, sad individuals who have a disturbing desire to control other people's bodies. They can tell themselves it's about morality but the truth is they just don't like something so they want to tell everyone else they can't do it too. I guess authoritarianism is alive and kicking.
 
Aww, or it was just a joke.

People who advocate for complete abolishment of abortion are sad, sad individuals who have a disturbing desire to control other people's bodies. They can tell themselves it's about morality but the truth is they just don't like something so they want to tell everyone else they can't do it too. I guess authoritarianism is alive and kicking.

Are you seriously suggesting that people who favor abortion don't want to tell others what to do?
 
Are you seriously suggesting that people who favor abortion don't want to tell others what to do?
If by "people who favor abortion", you mean people who demand people abort their pregnancies then those people absolutely are telling people what to do (these people are usually made of straw).

If you mean people who want people to be able to choose whether to continue their own pregnancy, then no. That's kind-of the point to being pro-choice.
 
Last edited:
1273518679186.jpg
 
If by "people who favor abortion", you mean people who demand people abort their pregnancies then those people absolutely are telling people what to do (these people are usually made of straw).

If you mean people who want people to be able to choose whether to continue their own pregnancy, then no. That's kind-of the point to being pro-choice.

1. The child being aborted and generally the child's father are not given a choice.

2. Abortion is not the only issue in existence, how "pro-choice" are you really?
 
Rephrased: Are you an anarchist or an authoritarian?

You can keep saying the words, but they don't follow from what was said. That's called a non sequiter. It's a fallacy, and a, somewhat hit and miss, comic strip.
 
You can keep saying the words, but they don't follow from what was said. That's called a non sequiter. It's a fallacy, and a, somewhat hit and miss, comic strip.

You said that opposition to abortion is authoritarian because pro-life/anti-choice people (however you want to put it) want to place legal restrictions on abortion, limiting the mother's choices, is that fair? Presumably you do favor many laws that limit people's choices, only anarchists do not. Unless you are an anarchist, you are undoubtedly anti-choice on many issues, which would make you an authoritarian under your argument.
 
When discussing reproductive freedom, "pro-choice" has a very clear meaning. It doesn't mean "Yes, I support paedophiles choosing to molest" or any such thing.

Do you want people to be extremists on an issue in order to not be hypocrites? Can't people use a combination of reason and value judgments to find exceptions?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom