Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

You said that opposition to abortion is authoritarian because pro-life/anti-choice people (however you want to put it) want to place legal restrictions on abortion, limiting the mother's choices, is that fair? Presumably you do favor many laws that limit people's choices, only anarchists do not. Unless you are an anarchist, you are undoubtedly anti-choice on many issues, which would make you an authoritarian under your argument.

So what you're trying to do is distract from the fact that pro-life people have a sick desire to control the bodies of other people for no real reason?
 
So what you're trying to do is distract from the fact that pro-life people have a sick desire to control the bodies of other people for no real reason?

You may not agree, but to pretend they have no reason is absurd.
 
When discussing reproductive freedom, "pro-choice" has a very clear meaning. It doesn't mean "Yes, I support paedophiles choosing to molest" or any such thing.

Do you want people to be extremists on an issue in order to not be hypocrites? Can't people use a combination of reason and value judgments to find exceptions?

Obviously the terms "pro-choice" and "pro-life" have well known meanings. However, he added that anyone who did not agree with his pro-choice view is an authoritarian because they want laws restricting what others can do. He was specific about that. It stands to reason then that he should be an anarchist or admit he is an authoritarian under that claim.

Clearly, the pro-life position is that the zygote/fetus/etc is a human deserving of protection and that it's right to live is a superior claim to the woman's right to not let it live in her until birth. You can certainly disagree and argue that the woman's claim is superior, but to say that the pro-life movement is an authoritarian movement aimed at controlling others' bodies is dishonest.
 
A valid reason with any sound rationalization behind it? None that I've seen.

A fetus is a living organism and obviously the same species as its parents, you may not agree that its right to live trumps the mother's right to do what she sees fit with her body, but you should recognize that that is what the question is. Someone must have their rights violated, who should the law protect?
 
Clearly, the pro-life position is that the zygote/fetus/etc is a human deserving of protection and that it's right to live is a superior claim to the woman's right to not let it live in her until birth. You can certainly disagree and argue that the woman's claim is superior, but to say that the pro-life movement is an authoritarian movement aimed at controlling others' bodies is dishonest.

It is not dishonest. It accepting biological facts like what the fetus is and what a human is.

When it comes down to it, pro-life people regularly demonstrate that they don't care one whit about the mother or child, they just say it's "wrong" and demand that another person do what they say.

ETA: My favorite silly little misconception is the "life begins" lie. Demonstrates a poor understanding of "life".
 
Last edited:
It is not dishonest. It accepting biological facts like what the fetus is and what a human is.

When it comes down to it, pro-life people regularly demonstrate that they don't care one whit about the mother or child, they just say it's "wrong" and demand that another person do what they say.

A fetus is a living human, anyone who can pass a third grade biology class could tell you that, hence the added standard of "personhood" often added by pro-choice advocates.
 
Please explain when you think life begins.

Think?

Dude, life began a long, long time ago. It's all just a continuation of the same chain of life. It never "starts", it just reproduces and continues.
 
Think?

Dude, life began a long, long time ago. It's all just a continuation of the same chain of life. It never "starts", it just reproduces and continues.

You were saying about distracting from the issue?
 
A fetus is a living human, anyone who can pass a third grade biology class could tell you that, hence the added standard of "personhood" often added by pro-choice advocates.

No. A fetus is a developing human. It will not be a human until it has finished that development. The fact that it is a brewing batch of human DNA doesn't make it special.
 
It's not a baby. It's a fetus. It is not a person. It doesn't have a soul because no one has a soul.

And anyone that wants to get rid of said fetus should be able to do so.

Either both you AND the pre-born baby are persons or neither of you are.

Nope. Try again. Only one of us has higher cognitive functions. Only one of us can even fear the prospect of death.

By that standard, even POST-birth baby killing would be acceptable up until cognition sets in.

That's right. Did you think I wasn't aware of that?

No sane person supports THAT definition of "person".

I do.

And again...YOU were once exactly as that baby is.

And if someone had wanted to do away with me at that age I wouldn't have even comprehended it and it wouldn't have been that big of a deal.

We are ALL "acutal" people. Either we ALL have value or none of us do.

Do you consider a stomach tumor to be a "person" as well? What about a parasitic twin? What about the unfertilized eggs? Or the individual sperm?
 
Last edited:
All the above is, of course, academic as we are talking about something with less personhood than a slug.

It's not academic at all. That is just what people tell themselves to justify their position.. in their own mind.

Because the entire argument that it's just a slug is nothing more than an attempt to minimalize and trivialize the procedure down to a level where it can be justified and exonerated of any sense of it being "bad".

Proof? Answer this question honest. At the end of the day, what is the point of an abortion? What is the woman setting out to do? What is the goal she is setting out to accomplish?

If you are honest, you won't say it's to have some worthless/useless slug pulled from her body. It's the deliberate act of purposely destroying a growing human embryo for the purpose of NOT delivering a child. For whatever reasons, good or bad... the desired outcome is "I do not want to have this baby".

But people continue to believe that your argument is some brilliant way of cutting the legs out from under all pro life positions. When it's nothing more than brutal intellectual dishonesty.

The end result is a child not being born that otherwise would likely have been born. Period. You think you can drag it down to some other level, where you can justify it. But you can't. It's completely intellectually dishonest. You know why abortions happen. Don't try to make it into something else to justify it.


So, are you saying that in an either mom or foetus situation, you'd kill mom? Lovely. You don't much like women, do you?

And here is the other pathetic strawman that always rears it's ugly head (I've had it shot at me more times than I can count on these forums). Just muddying the waters and deliberately poisoning the well. Legitimate logical fallacies. Purely an attempt to emotionalize the argument, and make the person on the other end a victim, rather than someone making a horrible decision.

It makes me sick when people do what you just did. Whether it's attempting to handwave any right wing concern as being ultimately just racism against Obama, or however it manifests. It's pitiful! People should be ashamed to even try such arguments. Especially on a forum dedicated to rational thought and skepticism.

I'm sorry for being personal, but this subject makes me very angry. It has made me angry as long as I've been a member here. It goes right to the argument that often comes up about liberal "intellectualism" or "intellectual elite" mentality. It seems many here don't understand what the right mean when they say those things. I see things here like "I don't get it, don't they WANT the best and smartest people in positions of power"?

That statement actually is a strongly ironic misunderstanding of the entire point. When people on the right bemoan intellectuals, it's being done from a position of extreme sarcasm and rejection of such claims. That we consider it laughable that anyone considers themselves anyones intellectual superior, when their positions are so stupid and indefensible to begin with. The word "intellectual" is said with venomous sarcasm, because it's being rejected.

So much of what liberals stand for is nothing more than rejection of traditional values and beliefs. They think they are smarter, and know better.. those ideals are all archaic and dated and wrong. And yet their own ideas are nothing more than rationalizing and moral equivication and trivializing of issues down to a level where it can be considered justifiable.

I said I wasn't going to rant anymore on this sub forum, but I can't help myself here. This is just wrong. What you said above, is wrong.

I do feel a need to close by pointing out, again (to try avoid stupid strawmen and personal attacks) that I recognize the need for abortion in todays world. I recognize it's reality, and will happen whether it's legal or not. I recognize that if it was made illegal, there would be many people who would injure themselves trying to have back alley abortions and the like.

I do NOT want that. I am pro-choice right now. But only out of recognition of the horrible reality this world currently is. I believe in changing minds about abortion, so a day comes humanities future where they recognize that they were wrong to do so, and simply choose not to have them. That it won't be necessary to outlaw it, it will simply become as repugnant and unwelcome, to everyone, as it SHOULD ALREADY BE.

Anyone (and I mean anyone) who has had an abortion, for no other reason than their own personal convenience.. If their life was not in jeopardy.. if the childs life was not in jeopardy.. if the abortion was only because said person didn't want the child.. I hold that person as a bad person. I don't care how they justify it to themselves.

And no matter how much any of you personally attack me, question my feelings on women, or womens rights.. none of that has any bearing for me. I couldn't care less.

Nope. Try again. Only one of us has higher cognitive functions. Only one of us can even fear the prospect of death.

Given the appropriate amount of time, both will have the same functions and appreciation. Again, you guys on the left are so desparate to defend your sacred cow (abortion) you will continually attempt to turn abortion away from what it really is (killing of an unborn child, the real desired outcome of an abortion) into this "OH, it's just a non viable lump of tissue". It's just minimalizing and trivializing it down to a level you can justify.

The end result is the reality of the situation.


EDIT: As far as I'm concerned, arguments of that like can be reasonably extended to the idea that it's ok to kill a helpless unconscious person lying on the side of the road, or in a hospital bed. Or at the very least, a person who is retarded or otherwise incapacitated, mentally. After all, they aren't at the same level of cognitive function as you, and certainly can't fear something that they don't even know is coming at them.

And hell, by that argument, any single animal on this planet is completely fair game for death at any whim we have... They don't rise to our cognitive level. They probably can't see the prospect of death coming either. They may not even understand that concept of death at all. But yet I see liberals freaking out over the killing of domesticated housepets all the time. It's such a ridiculous double standard. Holding outrage for ************ cats and dogs more than an unborn child.

It's a flawed, stupid argument. It's just an attempt to justify and rationalize an otherwise heinous or unjustifiable act. It's the height of intellectual dishonesty to continually attempt to portray abortion in such a light.

You guys know what the reality of an abortion is, what it sets out to do, and what it accomplishes. Please don't pretend otherwise.
 
Last edited:
No. A fetus is a developing human. It will not be a human until it has finished that development. The fact that it is a brewing batch of human DNA doesn't make it special.

Sorry, but it doesn't work that way. A fetus is not a non-human species that later becomes human. Hence the "personhood" assignment that most pro-choicers make, few actually try to argue that a fetus is somehow not a member of the homo sapiens.
 
Sorry, but it doesn't work that way. A fetus is not a non-human species that later becomes human. Hence the "personhood" assignment that most pro-choicers make, few actually try to argue that a fetus is somehow not a member of the homo sapiens.

ìt is a living organism and it is from the Human species. but in the first weeks of the developement of a fetus, it is not able to feel yet nor to survive without its mother. It is not yet a person.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom