Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

I think we should just set up a "Berlin airlift" and offer to drive women from SD to someplace civilized where they can choose for themselves.

The sad thing about your comment is that women of means probably can and do leave the state and obtain an abortion. This will affect poorer women.

This is not the first time abortion has been a flash point for the state. With only one abortion clinic and numerous restrictions, it’s one of the most difficult states in the country for a woman to obtain an abortion. In 2006 and again in 2008, South Dakota made news with far-reaching voter referendums that would have outlawed abortions. Despite being a very conservative, largely anti-abortion state, voters rejected the ballot initiatives by at least a 10-point margin in both cases.

“People are tired of this issue coming up again and again and again, because they believe the people of South Dakota have spoken soundly,” says Jan Nicolay, cochair of the South Dakota Campaign for Healthy Families, which opposed the bill.

http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/2011/0322/South-Dakota-anti-abortion-law-breaks-new-ground
 
How does a 'crisis pregnancy center' get approved to provide counseling? What type of hoops does a doctor or counselor need to go through to be authorized so that a woman can get an abortion? I'd think that if the state law only approved counseling centers that would refuse to confirm the counseling, that would be cause for challenge. Why can't a branch of Planned Parenthood offer the same services, or set up branches just across the state line in several places, or for that matter, set up a traveling van?
 
Isn't it ironic that the Tea Partier's common theme is to reduce government intervention? Why would they want their government to take away women's reproductive rights?
 
That's not hard to defeat, women can just get a D&C, it's effectively the same as an abortion, and so long as it's within the first trimester; perfectly legal. Alternatively they can just leave the state and get an abortion.
 
That's not hard to defeat, women can just get a D&C, it's effectively the same as an abortion, and so long as it's within the first trimester; perfectly legal.

It's actually one of the methods used to abort a fetus. How many MDs will perform it, knowing a woman is pregnant? How much will they charge? Do you think an MD will just perform the procedure without a reason?

Alternatively they can just leave the state and get an abortion.

As I previously posted, women of financial means probably do.

Do you have any idea who the clientele of PP is? How much money do they earn? Are they married? Can they get enough time off from their jobs to travel out of state? What about child care--if they have other children?
 
What's going on in this part of the country (I live in Nebraska) is beyond ridiculous. Every other week there is new anti-abortion legislation. We have one abortion provider in the state and yet the legislature, which has only one chamber and convenes part time has devoted a huge chunk of their time to these petty laws. Meanwhile our schools have sunk almost to the bottom of the country, an oil company wants to build a pipeline that could poison the groundwater of the entire high plains and there's a budget problem despite huge windfalls in farming. I digress...

What worries me more than abortion and other reproductive services being effectively outlawed or otherwise unavailable in red states is what happens if Obama has the chance to change the balance of power in the SC. There's going to be a hugely destructive battle to overturn all these laws which will have had time to become entrenched in the states. It's not hard to see that powder is being added to a keg that won't take much to light. I'd like to think this is simply a case of Republican state legislatures grandstanding on a free issue, but there's a disturbing rift growing and behind it are well funded, unwavering zealots.
 
So, the Tea-Party is ok with government bureaucracy coming between a patient and her doctor?

Yes, they are. While they have the brand of only being about fiscal responsibility, the TP candidates have been all about these social issues since they took office.
 
Ultimately, all this dancing around about "reasonable restrictions" is just avoiding one simple, clear issue: the fundamental right to life of the unborn baby. No person has the right to take an innocent life.

Period.

The circumstances in which an abortive procedure (such as ectopic pregnancies) are necessary are such that the baby will die either way, as it cannot be carried to term successfully, and will kill the mother in the process.

In all other cases, that baby is an individual human being, and has it's own individual right to live that the government has not only the right, but the duty to protect.
 
Ultimately, all this dancing around about "reasonable restrictions" is just avoiding one simple, clear issue: the fundamental right to life of the unborn baby.

No.

No person has the right to take an innocent life.

What do you consider innocent? A tumour doesn't know it's evil. Parasites are only trying to live their lives in your body. They don't understand that they poison you, make you blind and ultimately kill you.

The above handflapping means nothing in the context. It's just a pathetic attempt at making a blanket assertion that presumably can't be legitimately opposed.

Except it can. You know, here in Europe we very firmly believe that no person has the right to take a "guilty" life either. You seem to feel otherwise.

Both assertions are just that - assertions from your personal ethics.

Any person has the same right to take an "innocent" life as to take a "guilty" life.

All the above is, of course, academic as we are talking about something with less personhood than a slug.


No, I think the periods will usually have stopped by then. But thanks for showing off your extended knowledge of the female body. Really. Sex ed must have been brilliant where you were spawned.

The circumstances in which an abortive procedure (such as ectopic pregnancies) are necessary are such that the baby will die either way, as it cannot be carried to term successfully, and will kill the mother in the process.

Not all mother's-life-saving procedures hold this premise. There are several situations where the foetus could be valid but still threaten mum's life. In fact, in any normal preganancy there is always that risk even if hygiene and better care makes it less prevalent.

So, are you saying that in an either mom or foetus situation, you'd kill mom? Lovely. You don't much like women, do you?

In all other cases, that baby is an individual human being, and has it's own individual right to live that the government has not only the right, but the duty to protect.


Ah. I see where your confusion stems from: No, it is not. No it hasn't and no, they don't. Oh. I know YOU think they do. But they don't.
 
Ultimately, all this dancing around about "reasonable restrictions" is just avoiding one simple, clear issue: the fundamental right to life of the unborn baby. No person has the right to take an innocent life.

It's not a baby. It's a fetus. It is not a person. It may be a potential person. It doesn't have a soul because no one has a soul.

And anyone that wants to get rid of said fetus should be able to do so.


:rolleyes:

The circumstances in which an abortive procedure (such as ectopic pregnancies) are necessary are such that the baby will die either way, as it cannot be carried to term successfully, and will kill the mother in the process.

In all other cases, that baby is an individual human being, and has it's own individual right to live that the government has not only the right, but the duty to protect.

It doesn't become a person until it is self aware. Until then it is little more than a parasite.

Why do you want the world to be crushed by overpopulation Muldur? Do you care nothing for the quality of life for actual people?
 
This is a tough situation. Laws like South Dakota's are clearly illegal under current precedent, but any challenges will inevitably end up in front a Court that could overturn existing abortion law.
It needs to be challenged anyway. See what Kennedy will say.
 
The Supreme Court does tend to hate overturning earlier Supreme Court rulings.
 
Ultimately, all this dancing around about "reasonable restrictions" is just avoiding one simple, clear issue: the fundamental right to life of the unborn baby. No person has the right to take an innocent life.

SO how much do you get behind forced kidney donations? You care about lives right?

Just make your positions clear, children are punishment for being a slut.
 

Then NO one (as you point out yourself below) has any fundamental right to live. What is to stop someone from defining YOU as "not human" and taking your life?

What do you consider innocent? A tumour doesn't know it's evil. Parasites are only trying to live their lives in your body. They don't understand that they poison you, make you blind and ultimately kill you.

A baby is not a tumor, nor a parasite. Using those words in this context can only be taken as a deliberate attempt at de-humanizing a human being.

Some of your fellow "Continentals" once decided Jews were the moral equivalent of "tumors" and "parasites", as were the disabled, gypsies, and any number of other people.

Is that the doctrine you wish to embrace?

The above handflapping means nothing in the context. It's just a pathetic attempt at making a blanket assertion that presumably can't be legitimately opposed.

You're right, it CAN'T be legitimately opposed, because there is no situation that justifies the taking of an innocent life barring direct, provable circumstances where said life is not viable, and a direct immanent threat to another.

Except it can. You know, here in Europe we very firmly believe that no person has the right to take a "guilty" life either.

And look where it's gotten you.

Both assertions are just that - assertions from your personal ethics.

The ethics our nation was founded upon:

We hold these truths to be self evident: that all men [humans] are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the persuit of happiness.

Any person has the same right to take an "innocent" life as to take a "guilty" life.

Not so. Executing guilty capital criminals is right. Soldiers killing enemy combatants in war is right. Murdering an unborn baby that is neither a criminal NOR an enemy combatant is wrong.

All the above is, of course, academic as we are talking about something with less personhood than a slug.

YOU were once such...are YOU not a person? The only difference is time and development. You existed as a unique individual human being from the moment sperm fertilized egg.

So, are you saying that in an either mom or foetus situation, you'd kill mom? Lovely. You don't much like women, do you?

No, I already said saving the mother's life was a legitimate (and tragic) reason to abort.

Ah. I see where your confusion stems from: No, it is not. No it hasn't and no, they don't. Oh. I know YOU think they do. But they don't.

And Jews only THOUGHT they had human rights in 40s Germany...same logic you use to deny the rights of the pre-born.
 
Travis;7179074[STRIKE said:
]It's[/STRIKE] were not a baby. It's YOU wer a fetus. It isYou are not a person. It doesn't have a soul because no one has a soul.

And anyone that wants to get rid of said fetus you should be able to do so.

Either both you AND the pre-born baby are persons or neither of you are.


It doesn't become a person until it is self aware. Until then it is little more than a parasite.

By that standard, even POST-birth baby killing would be acceptable up until cognition sets in.

No sane person supports THAT definition of "person".

And again...YOU were once exactly as that baby is.

Why do you want the world to be crushed by overpopulation Muldur? Do you care nothing for the quality of life for actual people?

We are ALL "acutal" people. Either we ALL have value or none of us do.
 
Last edited:
The Supreme Court does tend to hate overturning earlier Supreme Court rulings.

So? When those rulings are wrong they SHOULD be overturned...or is "seperate but equal" to return to the education system? Are blacks to be re-enslaved to restore rulings supporting slavery and the forced return of runaway slaves?
 
abortion is the domain of a woman.
it's her body...it's her business.
everything else is just bafflegab.

But her decision to abort affects ANOTHER person's body--the baby's. Who speaks for the baby (who cannot speak for themselves)?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom