Abortion effectively outlawed in S.Dakota

Why should a disorganized bunch of human DNA that might become a person one day deserve to be treated as if they are already fully functioning sentient beings?
So only fully functioning sentient beings deserve to live? Advocates of the handicapped might disagree.

If you don't support abortion, don't have one.
You don't support bestiality, don't do it. Don't complain about the rights of others to enjoy it.
 
I know republicans hate women...what I don't understand is why there are any women republicans...there must be self hatred involved somehow.

Back on topic. Really don't know what republicans expect to accomplish. it's not like eliminating legal abortions would actually stop abortions from taking place...they'll just move "back" to the back alleys and use clothes hangers.

What's next for the idiot republicans...mandatory life sentences for any woman who has an abortion?

Of course the rich will ALWAYS receive abortions on demand...money talks, while the poor get screwed.
 
Last edited:
If it's none of a man's business, does that mean it's OK for a majority of women to outlaw abortion?

I don't like the reasoning, really.
 
But her decision to abort affects ANOTHER person's body--the baby's. Who speaks for the baby (who cannot speak for themselves)?

A fetus is not a person.

I know we all were one once, and that colors our perceptions, but do you remember being a fetus? I don't. As far as I am concerned, I began to exist at about age three.
 
Last edited:
If it's none of a man's business, does that mean it's OK for a majority of women to outlaw abortion?

I don't like the reasoning, really.

No, it has already been established as a Right. You cannot outlaw it without either a constitutional amendment or an abandonment of stare decisis by the Supreme Court. And I do not think that either would be the correct decision.
 
gee....now, that's relevant......................NOT!
Apparently the similarities elude you. I'll make it easy. Arguing that if you don't like abortion, then don't do it ignores the ethics involved. Laws by design prevent people from doing certain things. Even though you don't abuse children or advocate others to do so, doesn't mean society should allow others to do so. That's why we make laws. That's why the pro-abortion argument that "it has nothing to do with men, so they should shut up", or "if you are against it, don't do it" is sophomoric.
 
Apparently the similarities elude you. I'll make it easy. Arguing that if you don't like abortion, then don't do it ignores the ethics involved. Laws by design prevent people from doing certain things. Even though you don't abuse children or advocate others to do so, doesn't mean society should allow others to do so. That's why we make laws. That's why the pro-abortion argument that "it has nothing to do with men, so they should shut up", or "if you are against it, don't do it" is sophomoric.

thanks for making my point.
bestiality is not related to abortion, in any way, shape or form.
derail noted.
 
thanks for making my point.
bestiality is not related to abortion, in any way, shape or form.
derail noted.
Thanks for making my point, that you are clueless to the underlying ethics involved, then again ethics seem to be on hold with people that support Castro's slaughter of 50,000+ people.
 
So at what level of mental or physical disability should it be permissible to kill someone?

How about "before they have any brain function" or "after they no longer have any brain function"?

They measure the end of human life with brain function, why not the beginning?
 
So at what level of mental or physical disability should it be permissible to kill someone?

When they are brain dead or are so brain dead that a feeding tube is necessary to keep them alive.
 
How about "before they have any brain function" or "after they no longer have any brain function"?

They measure the end of human life with brain function, why not the beginning?

Isn't a major difference is they do not expect the brain function to return when death is determined by brain function (I am not sure death is measured that way anyway) whereas in a developing human it is expected to function in the future.

When does brain function begin and what exactly would brain function be?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom