A skeptic tests psychic ability

Wow - 140 posts on a late Friday/Saturday. You guys are dedicated!

Martin - I read through your site and your posts here and had many comments. But they were already well covered in responses in this thread. The meat of the matter as I see it lies in this quote from your site:
ZENER CARDS
Last week we tried to do a little telepathic development work with zener type cards (not true zener but close enough). What we found very interesting in discussion and results that almost everyone was doing very poorly (ie statistical results).
Most people in our group personally said they also had a history of doing poorly with these tests. We decided we want to try with a richer dataset such as photographs, etc.

That little paragraph is very telling and perfectly illustrated in this thread. When confined to narrow possibilities with clear right or wrong answers you fail. What allows you to feel you succeed - confirmation bias, if you will - is the "richer dataset" of photographs that allows you to offer something vague like "orange" and "curve" and then search the photo for anything that might be orange-ish or have a curve. As has been pointed out here already, any test protocol must have simple, known items that cannot be confused with each other and for which there is but one correct answer. If you cannot do it with Zener cards you cannot do it with anything else.

As an aside, I notice in one of the links form your site that you post of photo of yourself with the caption "cool photo... orbs floating around me". Would you care to offer an explanation of these "orbs"? Are they at all related to your abilities?

As a further aside: I note you are the founder of Everytrust, described here as "a trillion dollar non-profit organization that provides health, education, food, housing, and employment benefits to all 6.6 billion people of the world, with 950 offices in 250 countries". I would love to have an in depth discussion with you regarding everytrust over in the business section. Would that be amenable to you?
 
I really liked the protocol Rasmus came up with or something similar. I welcome coming up with a rock solid test.

The folks in this thread have been really working hard on coming up with ideas and I wanted to thank everyone.

You're welcome.

With regards to the calibration, what does the group think. Was LL a good sender? I thought his sending was sort of ok but the data I got did not seem to impress anyone.

You are the one who must judge that, with regards to the protocol you agree on. It shouldn't be important what anyone else thinks.

So the question is, do we consider the hits close enough with LL, or do we say they were complete misses and pick a new target person?

No, the question is, do you think his sending was good enough that you could have identified the objects he send from a previously agreed upon list?

I am volunteering here to do something that I think I can't do, and thus have no clue how to do it. I can't "send" you my thoughts. I can sit down and look at an object, hold, or touch it. I can try to think about it, or repeatedly mumble it's name. But I cannot consciously send any thoughts. If I can send thoughts, I will be unaware of that. So, it will be up to you to decide if during the calibration you can reliably tune in to my thoughts and read them well enough to select the object from a list.

With a good protocol, it will no longer matter, if anyone "considers" anything a hit or miss. It will be, a s pointed out before, self-evident.

I would randomly pick one of the object, for which there exists a unique label.

So I could pick
Screwdriver (Phillips head. Black and silver tip, red and black handle)

If and only if your answer is "Screwdriver" will it be a hit.

There will be no room for ambiguities. If you see "tool" you will have to decide if that is the screwdriver, or maybe the crayon or electric iron before submitting your answer.

So, you decide if you can do that with whatever it is you saw coming from LL.

Yes, you can poke a stick at me and say obviously it me, but what fun is that. If we start from an assumption that what I do as a receiver does not work and will not ever work, then we might as well stop now. If we work from a point of what I can do is not great right now, but leave room that it could be tuned up, then we have some room to work.

I am assuming that you cannot do what you claim you do. But I am being fair and giving you every chance in the world to demonstrate that I am wrong.

I will want to stop working on this if
- if turns out that I am a bad sender and others are better at it than I am.
- if it turns out that there are, apparently, no good senders at all. (In which case I would conclude that you really can't do what you say you can do - but it won't matter if you agree to it.)
- if you begin to come up with excuses why you can't do a test now, whilst being perfectly able to write a million posts. If you begin to explain why e should disregard result after result. If, in short, this ends like every other such experiment I've seen carried out in the forums before.

So back to the test protocols. The idea of having a fixed set of objects, then the sender sends one of the objects, and i have to match those objects sounds like it would produce a much more reliable hit than, "Curvy, blue, metal...."

Yes, because "curvy, blue, metal" is utterly useless.

Trying to triple blind it is awesome. Let's see what we can come up with.

If you trust the senders, then running the tests like that would be simpler. I would send a post when I am starting to hold the object and then sign off 5 minutes later. (or 7 or 10, or whatever)

You would then post your guess.

After that, I'll post what I have been holding.

There would be possibilities to cheat - mostly for me - but since nobody can control if you and I secretly communicate, we will not be able to do much about it.

This process seems sufficiently blind to me.

Oh, you should try and describe the process of sending to us, so that we do it right. Can I stay near the computer? Should I turn off other appliances, especially a TV or radio that might distract me? Should I sit still, or can I walk around? Eyes open or closed? May any of the other objects be in my field of vision so long as I don't touch them? Can I let go of the object throughout the experiment, or would that invalidate the test? Is touching it enough, or must I be holding it up the entire time? (The electric iron might be out of the question, then, e.g.)
 
BTW - In one of your pictures you mention you have "orbs" around you

Oh no, not the orb thing again. Of course it's a dark room with closed blinds, and the camera flash makes a dust particle become an "orb". Credibility of people seeing "orbs" floating around them => 0.

And big applause to Ron_Tomkins, he nailed it: These kind of threads tend to go on and on forever.
 
As a further aside: I note you are the founder of Everytrust, described here as "a trillion dollar non-profit organization that provides health, education, food, housing, and employment benefits to all 6.6 billion people of the world, with 950 offices in 250 countries". I would love to have an in depth discussion with you regarding everytrust over in the business section. Would that be amenable to you?

I agree, I would like to explore this.
 
Rats. I really wanted my three questions answered. Boo hoo.

Hrm... I wonder, though, if that may be a good hook for a mentalist trick. Hrm... *ponders*
 
Would you care to offer an explanation of these "orbs"? Are they at all related to your abilities?

Yes, please tell...
As a further aside: I note you are the founder of Everytrust, described here as "a trillion dollar non-profit organization that provides health, education, food, housing, and employment benefits to all 6.6 billion people of the world, with 950 offices in 250 countries". I would love to have an in depth discussion with you regarding everytrust over in the business section. Would that be amenable to you?

Perhaps you're not the only here, either......:p
 
Oh no, not the orb thing again. Of course it's a dark room with closed blinds, and the camera flash makes a dust particle become an "orb". Credibility of people seeing "orbs" floating around them => 0.

And big applause to Ron_Tomkins, he nailed it: These kind of threads tend to go on and on forever.
I'm just asking the question is all *lol*; he is the one that points out the "orbs" in the pic not me.

And yep, Ron wins a cookie :) These thread never end because the claime never concedes the point...regardless of the evidence to the contrary, number of failures they incur, etc. the claime always maintains "but I have paranormal powers" (ferj, for example).

Of course, perhaps MartinV really does have "powers"; I'd love to be proven wrong...this all assumes he can master the "calibration" process...and he does not raise any new "oh I forgot to mention" things.

MartinV - Anytime you are ready, drop me a PM or yahoo me and we can start the "calibration" process (which if we do off-line I'll report back here on the results).
 
I'm just asking the question is all *lol*; he is the one that points out the "orbs" in the pic not me.

Oops, sorry my post was badly worded. I certainly did not mean you, I merely muttered into my non-existent beard that people who think they see orbs in pictures of them are by default not very high on my credibility scale.
 
I am a psychic, medium, and skeptic

Stop right there.
Might as well save this thread from going to 30 or more pages right from the get-go.

A skeptic is someone who doesn't necessarily trust others' conclusions or findings.
However, a skeptic is not skeptical of things that they have determined to their own satisfaction.

There are two methods of acquiring this proof for oneself
(1) Scientific Proof

(2) Direct experience
Outside of these two methods, someone with a skeptical personality would be skeptical.

It is thus perfectly possible to be a skeptic and also to have 'direct experience' in some areas, which others might not share.
 
Last edited:
A skeptic is someone who doesn't necessarily trust others' conclusions or findings.
However, a skeptic is not skeptical of things that they have determined to their own satisfaction.

There are two methods of acquiring this proof for oneself
(1) Scientific Proof

(2) Direct experience
Outside of these two methods, someone with a skeptical personality would be skeptical.

It is thus perfectly possible to be a skeptic and also to have 'direct experience' in some areas, which others might not share.
I disagree. If Number 2 conflicts with Number 1, and you accept 1, you're more likely a deluded person. (By the way, I'd change the word "proof" to "evidence".)

Being a skeptic is something you can be all the time. It does not mean rejecting any particular proposition. It means you follow the evidence. Even when there is enough evidence to accept a proposition, the skeptic accepts it provisionally. You don't stop being skeptical when you provisionally accept a proposition. If contrary evidence comes to light, the skeptic will change views appropriately.
 
Hi All, I am back.
Watching the kids right now.

Lots of interesting posts. Lots of name calling. Lots of fallacies.
And I was surprised how many posts talk about quitting/stopping.
But it does sound like the key players are still looking to move on.

I started this thread for a reason - to come up with some good protocols and tests. So far, I think we are running about 30% on topic, not great, but we are still moving ahead.

I am going to try to stay on topic in this thread. In the JREF forums, If someone is interested in my activities outside this thread contact me and we can see how you can help me in those areas.

I will briefly address one topic brought up in this thread.
1. Orbs in my photo.
a. I work with the woo-woo crowd. They like this stuff. Here were 2 in a photo of me. That's it.
b. No claims. No explanation. Just here they are.
c. Lying in wait for skeptics to make their claims and woo-woo to make theirs.
d. I have no position, just observation on them.

I ask that if people have an opinion on them, JREF has plenty of posts to go there. Please stay on topic with me.

I only have a short time on any given day to be here.

For the folks that think this is a waste of time. Please don't waste the others time here, we are making progress.

For the folks who comment how long this thread is getting, all I ask is you look at who is posting what. This thread would be a lot shorter if we all stayed on topic.

I do ask that posting stay on topic of either designing the protocol or or being a participant in the testing.

I love reading all the other ideas floating in this thread, but can we stay on point.
 
Last edited:
For the folks that think this is a waste of time. Please don't waste the others time here, we are making progress.
Speaking of which, you have yet to contact me wrt this "calibration" testing you apparently need to accomplish the task at hand. Why is that?

BTW - I'm be back by 3pm, and then here for the test of the day...and all day tomorrow. Hopefully you (MartinV) have time in your busy schedule?

Oh...and you didn't answer the "orb" question; your comments would be appreciated.
 
I disagree. If Number 2 conflicts with Number 1, and you accept 1, you're more likely a deluded person. (By the way, I'd change the word "proof" to "evidence".)

Being a skeptic is something you can be all the time. It does not mean rejecting any particular proposition. It means you follow the evidence. Even when there is enough evidence to accept a proposition, the skeptic accepts it provisionally. You don't stop being skeptical when you provisionally accept a proposition. If contrary evidence comes to light, the skeptic will change views appropriately.

I agree with this. I will cite a case in point for me personally and why I say I am a psychic, medium and skeptic.

I have personally had psychic experiences. The best ones do not come in "testing" conditions. I still get good ones in tests and I am willing to work from that for this forum.
I feel I might be able to work with a few die-hard skeptics to see if we can put something concrete together. That is working nicely here.

Now here is the skeptic part. I have had many medium type experiences. I define medium as what the popular culture, the woo-woo culture and the published authors say. Here is my skeptical problem.

The medium experiences I have can only be explained to me as what I have received psychically. This matches what was covered in Chopra vs Shermer debate.

http://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/debates/afterlife.html

Problem is that is a debate.

As a skeptic, I would like to believe that a medium can in fact contact a true spirit in the afterlife. I have known people in my group who have said they can see them as clear as you or I, but I do not have that direct experience.

As a medium, I can get facts and other information about people who I have never met from someone who sits down with me and tells me nothing. Don't jump on me, I know the difference in the cold stuff. I am talking about specific stuff like their job, types of clothes they wore, and other details. Yes I do get cold types of stuff in the readings but I have to discard them, too hard to discern from me or not.

The skeptic in me says, is their anything that I can contribute to this debate in a constructive way to help at least me make a better decision.

For me, I have to accepted the medium stuff to be just psychic. Psychic I have good experiential evidence. I do not have good evidence that medium is anything beyond psychic. And from what I can tell in the literature, it does not sound very promising. But I would still love to try.

So here is where I stand. When I say I am a psychic, medium and skeptic, this gives you a good idea of what I mean.
I have had direct psychic experiences first hand.
I have had direct medium experiences first hand.
Medium experiences are described as what popular culture defines as medium.
I cannot produce evidence (yet) that the medium stuff is not anything more than psychic.

This would be another thread another time. How cool would it be to take the ideas of Chopra and Shermer and test them to the extremes. I think that would be great.

So back to where I started. I have always been a skeptic. I accept that which I have had good evidence to myself and others. I prefer backed by science, but I will still accept a well supported theory until another one presents itself.
For example I except the theory that electrons spin around in orbits around an nucleas. I even accept that they can move from one orbit to another. Science cannot yet explain how an electron can move from one orbit to another, yet have no intermediate state or transition. It just is in one orbit than instantly in another. I still am willing to accept electricity and chemistry even though scientists still cannot determine the exact nature of an electron. Sometimes its a wave, sometimes it is a particle, sometimes it is both, sometimes it is neither. Hard to believe that the science we believe so hard in can't even nail down the stupid electron. It is still very heavy in the theory stage.

Sorry I went off topic. But sometimes it is fun to just be the skeptic.
 
A skeptic is someone who doesn't necessarily trust others' conclusions or findings.
However, a skeptic is not skeptical of things that they have determined to their own satisfaction.

There are two methods of acquiring this proof for oneself
(1) Scientific Proof

(2) Direct experience
Outside of these two methods, someone with a skeptical personality would be skeptical.

It is thus perfectly possible to be a skeptic and also to have 'direct experience' in some areas, which others might not share.


I disagree. If Number 2 conflicts with Number 1, and you accept 1, you're more likely a deluded person. (By the way, I'd change the word "proof" to "evidence".)

'Evidence' is a word used in Science rather than 'Direct Experience'.
Direct Experience' can give 'personal' proof, rather than just mere evidence

The purpose of my post was to clarify the 'meaning of words', and that it was possible in theory to be both a Skeptic and a Psychic.
The possibility of someone suffering from delusions, is a diffeent subject.
The probability of this particular person being a Skeptic and a Psychic, is not the issue I was addressing - merely clarifying use of words.
 
Oh...and you didn't answer the "orb" question; your comments would be appreciated.

My position on the orbs is very clear
d. I have no position, just observation on them.

I have seen a lot of great evidence on dust and stuff.
That makes a lot of sense especially with digital cameras.

Please, lets leave the orb stuff for other threads.
Not related to this threads topic.
My time is really getting wasted again. And we have not even spent any time on the test stuff.
 
Hi All,
I love you guys. Some are taking this seriously, others are just seriously funny. I am seeing "Appeal to Ignorance", "Ad Hominem", "Appeal to Authority", "Non-Sequitur" and a couple of others so far.

If you have a problem with logical fallacies, then stop posting them. :rolleyes:
 
You claim you have little time. Yet you waste in on commenting on signal-to-noise levels, on posting styles and a host of other things.

Just do the experiments!

What's holding you back?

Answer the pending questions wrt to procedures (raised here, e.g.), select items from the list I suggested here or ask questions about the items, or amend the list with items you feel more confident about.

Worries about the protocol? Name them! Your PhD's should have no trouble at all to either confirm that the protocols are sufficiently tight or to name the points that worry them.

Do you want to eliminate the senders' possibility to cheat and report misses when you actually had a hit? Just say, we can amend the protocol in a way that the right answer has to be published in decrypted form first. No problem at all.

What are you waiting for? What's holding you back?

I am, of course and as always, not speaking for the JREF, but I can only imagine that a successful test here in the forums would get you very, very close to the actual million dollars. I don't care if you're not doing it for the money. I simply don't believe that you couldn't put an extra million bucks to good use.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom