I agree with this. I will cite a case in point for me personally and why I say I am a psychic, medium and skeptic.
I have personally had psychic experiences. The best ones do not come in "testing" conditions. I still get good ones in tests and I am willing to work from that for this forum.
I feel I might be able to work with a few die-hard skeptics to see if we can put something concrete together. That is working nicely here.
Now here is the skeptic part. I have had many medium type experiences. I define medium as what the popular culture, the woo-woo culture and the published authors say. Here is my skeptical problem.
The medium experiences I have can only be explained to me as what I have received psychically. This matches what was covered in Chopra vs Shermer debate.
http://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/debates/afterlife.html
Problem is that is a debate.
As a skeptic, I would like to believe that a medium can in fact contact a true spirit in the afterlife. I have known people in my group who have said they can see them as clear as you or I, but I do not have that direct experience.
As a medium, I can get facts and other information about people who I have never met from someone who sits down with me and tells me nothing. Don't jump on me, I know the difference in the cold stuff. I am talking about specific stuff like their job, types of clothes they wore, and other details. Yes I do get cold types of stuff in the readings but I have to discard them, too hard to discern from me or not.
The skeptic in me says, is their anything that I can contribute to this debate in a constructive way to help at least me make a better decision.
For me, I have to accepted the medium stuff to be just psychic. Psychic I have good experiential evidence. I do not have good evidence that medium is anything beyond psychic. And from what I can tell in the literature, it does not sound very promising. But I would still love to try.
So here is where I stand. When I say I am a psychic, medium and skeptic, this gives you a good idea of what I mean.
I have had direct psychic experiences first hand.
I have had direct medium experiences first hand.
Medium experiences are described as what popular culture defines as medium.
I cannot produce evidence (yet) that the medium stuff is not anything more than psychic.
This would be another thread another time. How cool would it be to take the ideas of Chopra and Shermer and test them to the extremes. I think that would be great.
So back to where I started. I have always been a skeptic. I accept that which I have had good evidence to myself and others. I prefer backed by science, but I will still accept a well supported theory until another one presents itself.
For example I except the theory that electrons spin around in orbits around an nucleas. I even accept that they can move from one orbit to another. Science cannot yet explain how an electron can move from one orbit to another, yet have no intermediate state or transition. It just is in one orbit than instantly in another. I still am willing to accept electricity and chemistry even though scientists still cannot determine the exact nature of an electron. Sometimes its a wave, sometimes it is a particle, sometimes it is both, sometimes it is neither. Hard to believe that the science we believe so hard in can't even nail down the stupid electron. It is still very heavy in the theory stage.
Sorry I went off topic. But sometimes it is fun to just be the skeptic.