A skeptic tests psychic ability

Sorry, never claimed to be perfect.

I have chores to do around the house.

I will be back Monday sometime.

Talk with everyone then. Bye

This sounds a lot like ferj. He has only a limited time to be on the forum, but spends that time complaining rather than getting things going with a protocol.
 
I agree with this. I will cite a case in point for me personally and why I say I am a psychic, medium and skeptic.

I have personally had psychic experiences. The best ones do not come in "testing" conditions. I still get good ones in tests and I am willing to work from that for this forum.
I feel I might be able to work with a few die-hard skeptics to see if we can put something concrete together. That is working nicely here.

Now here is the skeptic part. I have had many medium type experiences. I define medium as what the popular culture, the woo-woo culture and the published authors say. Here is my skeptical problem.

The medium experiences I have can only be explained to me as what I have received psychically. This matches what was covered in Chopra vs Shermer debate.

http://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/debates/afterlife.html

Problem is that is a debate.

As a skeptic, I would like to believe that a medium can in fact contact a true spirit in the afterlife. I have known people in my group who have said they can see them as clear as you or I, but I do not have that direct experience.

As a medium, I can get facts and other information about people who I have never met from someone who sits down with me and tells me nothing. Don't jump on me, I know the difference in the cold stuff. I am talking about specific stuff like their job, types of clothes they wore, and other details. Yes I do get cold types of stuff in the readings but I have to discard them, too hard to discern from me or not.

The skeptic in me says, is their anything that I can contribute to this debate in a constructive way to help at least me make a better decision.

For me, I have to accepted the medium stuff to be just psychic. Psychic I have good experiential evidence. I do not have good evidence that medium is anything beyond psychic. And from what I can tell in the literature, it does not sound very promising. But I would still love to try.

So here is where I stand. When I say I am a psychic, medium and skeptic, this gives you a good idea of what I mean.
I have had direct psychic experiences first hand.
I have had direct medium experiences first hand.
Medium experiences are described as what popular culture defines as medium.
I cannot produce evidence (yet) that the medium stuff is not anything more than psychic.

This would be another thread another time. How cool would it be to take the ideas of Chopra and Shermer and test them to the extremes. I think that would be great.

So back to where I started. I have always been a skeptic. I accept that which I have had good evidence to myself and others. I prefer backed by science, but I will still accept a well supported theory until another one presents itself.
For example I except the theory that electrons spin around in orbits around an nucleas. I even accept that they can move from one orbit to another. Science cannot yet explain how an electron can move from one orbit to another, yet have no intermediate state or transition. It just is in one orbit than instantly in another. I still am willing to accept electricity and chemistry even though scientists still cannot determine the exact nature of an electron. Sometimes its a wave, sometimes it is a particle, sometimes it is both, sometimes it is neither. Hard to believe that the science we believe so hard in can't even nail down the stupid electron. It is still very heavy in the theory stage.

Sorry I went off topic. But sometimes it is fun to just be the skeptic.

Excuse me, but you really don't have a clue do you? Go away and come back when you can think rationally, have some understanding of statitics and have read about science actually is.

Oh, and why on earth with your obvious lack of education do you think that you can repeat experiments that hundreds of more qualifiied people have tried with any more success than they had?

:boggled::boggled::boggled::boggled:
 
'Evidence' is a word used in Science rather than 'Direct Experience'.
Direct Experience' can give 'personal' proof, rather than just mere evidence
But it doesn't. When you see a really good magician perform a vanish, is that personal experience proof of vanishing or teleportation?

If you have a hallucination is that proof that the thing you see is real?
Evidence and direct experience are NOT the same thing.
The purpose of my post was to clarify the 'meaning of words', and that it was possible in theory to be both a Skeptic and a Psychic.
The possibility of someone suffering from delusions, is a diffeent subject.
The probability of this particular person being a Skeptic and a Psychic, is not the issue I was addressing - merely clarifying use of words.
In this way, anything is possible. (For psychic abilities to be real, we'd need to revise a lot of other well-supported science, but that IS possible.) So what use is it to say it's possible? I pointed out that it's also possible and MUCH more likely that someone who relies on personal experience that contradicts compelling evidence is deluded.
 
My position on the orbs is very clear


I have seen a lot of great evidence on dust and stuff.
That makes a lot of sense especially with digital cameras.

Please, lets leave the orb stuff for other threads.
Not related to this threads topic.
My time is really getting wasted again. And we have not even spent any time on the test stuff.
The "orbs" are a very fair question, as you mentioned them on the websites you posted. You don't want them mentioned then don't go posting links to your comments everyplace.

However...just cause you asked nice like, I've started a new thread just for you and your "orbs" here.

As to wasting time...my you complain a lot about that, yet do little to remedy the situation. Odd time did not become a concern until after you started to get pined down demonstration wise don't you think?

In any event...I'm ready for you to "calibrate" to me anytime; PM me here, or hit me on yahoo (locknar123) and we can press forward...unless you just want to continue to blather on about "wasting time" that is.

Speaking of "calibration" stuff....I still have a hard time with this. For example:
As a medium, I can get facts and other information about people who I have never met from someone who sits down with me and tells me nothing.

<snip>

For me, I have to accepted the medium stuff to be just psychic.

<snip>

I have had direct psychic experiences first hand.
I have had direct medium experiences first hand.
So you claim you get "facts and other information" from folks that just sit down (or in chat rooms as you've previously mentioned), but you need to do this whole "calibration" first? Funny how you keep leaving that part out don't you think?

In another thread, how about detailing some of your "first hand" psychic and medium experiences...if you have time that is.
 
Last edited:
I was going join in as a psychic but first I want to know what this Everytrust thing is. Are you just another profits for prophets spammer and scammer?
 
Last edited:
Gord_in_Toronto,
Thanks for the welcome. I certainly do have an attitude, but in this case I was doubly irritated by the silly taunts and gratuitous use of Randi’s name.

... You hold up 5 fingers, I pick you pointer finger (actually probably would have been another one, but we will leave that for another day)...

This suggests to me that you are aware that in avoidance of the obvious, subjects will give you an advantage when guessing. If you have done these tests for some time, perhaps you have built a compendium of such information. In combination with retrofitting, your chances of a hit will be increased. You are almost certainly fooling yourself.

During the previous test, I was looking around for objects that would fit in my hand, yet not have any likely characteristics. I found myself excluding common objects such as round, square, mugs, pens…..AK47. Perhaps you could ‘reverse engineer’ my thinking, and so increase your chances.

Is this why you can say;
"I will get stuff like soft, tan, person, stuff like that"

Your posts suggest that you have caricatured the scientific method and mistaken that for the real thing. You use logic attributively, as if you have just found a new toy.

(almost) Sorry to be cheap, but in your 'orb' pic, (#141) is the “advanced member” in your hand ?


Constructive bits:-
Credit for risking being wrong, but so far, not convinced.
Carping afterwards - bad form
Use one of the suggested rigid protocols
Make a definite time for tests. Should history wait for chores ?
 
Last edited:
Hi All, I am back.
Watching the kids right now.

Lots of interesting posts. Lots of name calling. Lots of fallacies.
...

Martin,
I notice you get quite caught up in identifying fallacies. Thats not going to win you a lot of support here, or anywhere else. People see it as whining and a way of avoiding the actual query or accusation.

If I say "you're deluded" that is not an ad hom fallacy. Its simply my opinion. It becomes ad hominen when I say, or suggest, that because you are deluded your arguments are invalid. In a similar vein, if I spell out a cogent argument with the conclusion that you must be deluded that is also not an ad hom attack unless it asks that other arguments of yours be discounted because of the claimed delusion. I've not really seen that happen yet in this thread.

Lots of folks here cry "ad hom!" when they are being challenged thinking this should shield them from scrutiny. But, when someone claims paranormal abilities the discussion necessarily revolves around them and their claims. If they cry "ad hom!" each time they are challenged it only serves to cement the suspicion that they are either dishonest or delusional.

So, rather than searching each post for logical fallacies why not simply answer the question or respond to the charge? The logical fallacy parry is not something you can get away with using all that often. If you are spending too much time searching for logical fallacies then you are working too hard to avoid responding to the points and counter points being made.

Rise above the fray. You're a smart guy and you know what questions are being asked. Don't avoid them.

(and yes, this has been one long ad hominem....)
 
As a further aside: I note you are the founder of Everytrust, described here as "a trillion dollar non-profit organization that provides health, education, food, housing, and employment benefits to all 6.6 billion people of the world, with 950 offices in 250 countries". I would love to have an in depth discussion with you regarding everytrust over in the business section. Would that be amenable to you?
I think a trillion dollar organization with 950 offices in 250 countries is worthy of discussion. I've started a thread in the Business Forum.
 
I have no doubt in my mind that this guy will not actually agree to be tested by the JREF.
 
I have no doubt in my mind that this guy will not actually agree to be tested by the JREF.

There's a thread in Forum Help & Member Support called "Custom title, please?". With your previous remark, you are entitled to apply for "Captain Obvious" as your custom title to replace the generic Penultimate Amazing. :thumbsup:

j/k. I thinketh you are righteth.
 
I have no idea what happened in this thread. It's too long.

All I know is that you ask someone which sounds smaller... tiny or teeny... teeny will be the answer 99% of the time.

And you can prove to entire audience that you control thier minds by doing the first 5 syllables of "Shave and a Haircut", and leave them hanging on the "two bits". EVERYONE (with any knowledge of the diddy) will HAVE TO finish it in their head.
 
There's a thread in Forum Help & Member Support called "Custom title, please?". With your previous remark, you are entitled to apply for "Captain Obvious" as your custom title to replace the generic Penultimate Amazing. :thumbsup:

j/k. I thinketh you are righteth.

It is a pretty obvious observation. But the post was meant to inform the OP that I know he's insincere. We'll need a bulldozer to clear out the bovine fecal matter he's vomited in the forum by the time he's done.
 
In light of recent discoveries regarding your credibility Martin, who are these PHD's & what are their areas of expertise?
 
Can we get back to the protocol that Rasmus suggested? Martinv has already said he really liked it. We could proceed like this:

- Each person interested in participating collects ten obviously different objects.
- Each person works out together with martinv a time slot where they can both be at their computers (use the world clock to sort out different time zones).
- Within the time period martinv and the participant go through as many test runs as they have time for.
- The tests would be done openly on this thread (or maybe another one set up just for the experiment) so that anybody interested could follow in real time, but for the duration of a test only martinv and the participant would post.

Shall we try it?
 
At the risk of over simplifying things, he has inferred that he can see colors, so wouldn't a simple test have 4 disks (like a wooden nickel), each a separate distinct color (cyan, magenta, yellow & black) & 4 numbered boxes. One person puts the disks in the boxes, out of sight of the claimant, the claimant is brought in & notes on a pad of paper what color is in what box. Boxes are opened one at a time & compared to the notepad, it is either the correct color (hit) or not (miss). Repeat for requisite number of trials
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom