A skeptic tests psychic ability

So for example with color there would need to be a defined range of a color symbol, with an upper bound and lower bound value. Because, I bet I could bring in 5 sheets of paper into everyones office, and very few would write down the same color. So we need a way to translate a subjective value to an objective value.

Please don't say real science does not do that. You experience it everyday. Your computers use 0 volts for off, and 5 volts for on.

Anyone have some good ideas here we can use?

This problem is very easy to solve. The remote viewer knows the set of possible objects beforehand - he can even bring them himself. So, before the test, two objects are selected, maybe the tangerine and a pair of scissors or whatever else is the testee feels is easy to distinguish.

Then you take two rooms, maybe in the same building but in that case definitely some distance apart. During the test, any windows must be blinded and all doors closed (ideally, you'd have the "receiving" room fitted with a faraday cage, but we can skip this for now). The testee gets to inspect the objects and the "sending" room, and when ready goes to the "receiving" room.

The test proper consists of repeating the following twenty times:

- in the "sending" room, a tester decides by coin flip or dice roll what object goes on the table. The other gets wrapped in a black bag and put in a closed drawer or similar. Which object it is is noted by checkmark on a prepared sheet.

- in the "receiving" room, the testee now has three minutes to try to view the selected object. At the end of the three minute period, or any time during, he checks what he thinks it is on a similar sheet.

- The "sending" room now has two minutes in which to randomise and prepare. It probably won't take that long, but the test proper begins after exactly two minutes, and goes on for three minutes.

With that timing method in place, the test can be done with synchronised clocks. I'd probably want some sort of signaling device installed as well, preferably a two-way telegraph / beeping intercom. This signal is used to signal "ready" before the first randomisation only, and in case the deadlines are not met. If it is used outside of signalling "ready", that's taken as "abort", so the test is considered invalid and must be redone. In a setting like the MDC, both the testee and the JREF would have representatives present in both rooms, to ensure that the protocol is followed.

The details are open to discussion, like if the time allotted is enough. It's a balance of giving the testee the optimal environment in which to perform, practical considerations, and eliminating all other explanations than the paranormal. To get really significant results, you'd probably want to increase the number of tests, or the number of objects.

... the results are self-evident to _____ (who)
what does self-evident mean? Yes I know what it means, but if you were in a court of law.

This point is really simple as well. You design your test so that you end up with two lists of numbers. You then see to which degree the numbers match - in this scenario you don't even have to know which list is which.

This means that you'd have the testee commit to an answer - but with him knowing the set of possible answers beforehand, this is not a problem. In other words, maybe the testee gets the "curved, orange" impression. That would require him to interpret that as either "tangerine" or "pair of scissors" during the test, before the lists are compared.

Dead simple.
 
This works for me.

In a way, though, it's the same as mine. He does his vague reading first ("round, light colored, not a Prussian soldier, not an albino rattlesnake"), then has to match that to one of the known objects.

I must admit I hadn't read your post. Yes, the approaches are similar. You have the advantage of having a neutral observer to make cheating more difficult for both sides. My making the list public to begin with would probably leave out a few steps of communication throughout.

His claim would be to get more correct than would be probable due to chance with some degree of confidence.

Yes.

I think this should be a good basis for a trial, regardless of the specific needs of the psychic.
 
Damn it, this thread moves fast. When I started typing up that response, it was at page two!

Well, maybe I'm a slow typer.
 
Last edited:
A non-psychic might design a test, with absolutely outstanding experimental design and get a perfect "no" answer and think they have now shown something. But imagine a person who has never seen a color trying to create a scientific test to determine color or some other sense. They might come up with questions like:
what does green smell like? How tall is a c# note?
They run their tests, triple blind, and the get the absolute perfect answer that green does not have a smell. Or C# does not have a height. Great question, built on a poor foundation.

Sorry to dredge up the opening post this late in the game, but it seems there are some pretty fundamental misconceptions here about the nature of science.

If a scientist is trying to test the nature of something, he will first ask himself the question: "What is it about this phenomenon that is objective; that is, the same for everyone?" If there is a measurable quality to the phenomenon, then it doesn't matter if the scientist can't detect it directly (otherwise, how do we know what "color" quarks are?).

On the other hand, if there IS no measurable quality, then the phenomenon is not of any interest to science.

In the case of the color green or the note C#, the measurable quality is, coincidentally, frequency. The color green is a frequency of light, and the note C# is a frequency of sound. The "tallness" of the note or the smell of the color would not be of interest in any well-designed experiment, for they are not measurable and therefore meaningless.

The idea of a test with an "excellent experimental design" that tests for non-measurable things such as the smell of a color is pure gibberish. It's a smokescreen, in my opinion, to cover up the weakness of the OP's entire premise.
 
Although I did every single thing that was asked of me, I must say that I am not very impressed with these tests. Martinv claimed he was just "calibrating," which gave him an easy out. Either he got the answer right, in which case he could claim to be psychic, or he got the answer wrong, in which case he could claim the "calibration" did not work. He created a situation where he could not lose.

This is in line with my theory that Martinv is more interested in twisting experiments until he gets answers that conform to his preconceptions than he is in actually proving anything objectively.

Despite the fact that he got "nasal bulb" perfectly, his other guesses were failures in my estimation. Judge for yourselves:


The director I am most closely related to is not Tarrentino. It is Oscar nominated documentary filmmaker Nanette Burstein.


For the record, Nanette is amazingly soft.


It is a plastic water bottle. It is not ceramic, not white and is almost devoid of vertical lines.

But if you bend down at look at it just so, does it look faintly dinosaur like?

Obviously a recalibration is required. Give up on Rhine and call in Ignacio Swan. He can correct the supposed birthtime to your actual birthtime by Remote Viewing.

Why do skeptics bother? I mean other than the amusement factor?
:boggled:
 
Last edited:
An initial display of bravado, followed by failure.
As always, the problem is not of "logical fallacies", but self deception.
 
An initial display of bravado, followed by failure.
As always, the problem is not of "logical fallacies", but self deception.

Welcome Humber. With an attitude like that, you'll have a lot of fun here. I know I do. :eye-poppi
 
Hi All,
It's 10:44pm and I am back. Sounds like lot of good stuff while I was gone. I won't be able to stay long tonight, maybe 15 or 20 minutes. I may have a few moments here and there on Sun on this thread, but can't say exactly when. Probably Tue evening is best shot for some serious time to run some more tests.
 
I really liked the protocol Rasmus came up with or something similar. I welcome coming up with a rock solid test.

The folks in this thread have been really working hard on coming up with ideas and I wanted to thank everyone.

With regards to the calibration, what does the group think. Was LL a good sender? I thought his sending was sort of ok but the data I got did not seem to impress anyone.

So the question is, do we consider the hits close enough with LL, or do we say they were complete misses and pick a new target person?

Yes, you can poke a stick at me and say obviously it me, but what fun is that. If we start from an assumption that what I do as a receiver does not work and will not ever work, then we might as well stop now. If we work from a point of what I can do is not great right now, but leave room that it could be tuned up, then we have some room to work.

I have already been willing to call myself
"Martin, the bad psychic"
so that shows I am willing to poke fun at myself. You can too, but that does not move us forward.

So back to the test protocols. The idea of having a fixed set of objects, then the sender sends one of the objects, and i have to match those objects sounds like it would produce a much more reliable hit than, "Curvy, blue, metal...."

Trying to triple blind it is awesome. Let's see what we can come up with.
 
Last edited:
With regards to the calibration, what does the group think. Was LL a good sender? I thought his sending was sort of ok but the data I got did not seem to impress anyone.

So the question is, do we consider the hits close enough with LL, or do we say they were complete misses and pick a new target person?
That is for you to decide...feel free to post the answers to my questions here in the thread, or send to LL if you like.

I said I would hold/touch/look at objects directly related to my questions, which I will do tomorrow morning at 10am. If it helps you, I'm in Dunkirk.

Of you just wanna call this little test DOA at this point?
 
That is for you to decide...feel free to post the answers to my questions here in the thread, or send to LL if you like.

I said I would hold/touch/look at objects directly related to my questions, which I will do tomorrow morning at 10am. If it helps you, I'm in Dunkirk.

Of you just wanna call this little test DOA at this point?

I am happy to calibrate on you. Do you want to use up your questions as objects in the calibration, or on an actual test? Does not matter to me.

I would prefer 2 practice shots down range, then we can try the real targets.

We still have to find out a protocol for your tests. Sounds like the color, shape stuff is not strong enough - I agree.

So what do you have that we can do to make the questions part of a closed set of objects with a way we can all confirm a hit.

Also, we need spread out the time. 5 objects exactly at 10 won't work for me.
 
That is for you to decide

Locknar, specifically what was your personal opinion on the calibration test. Keep or not keep LL.

Yes, I will make the final decision. I wanted to get your skeptical opinion. You matter. You have been an important contributor here.
 
I just noticed the time. 11:30pm, it is a half hour later than I wanted to be up. Going to bed now.

I will check back in the morning.

Maybe we can get something figured out so we can get some shots down range at 10am.
 
Locknar, specifically what was your personal opinion on the calibration test. Keep or not keep LL.

Yes, I will make the final decision. I wanted to get your skeptical opinion. You matter. You have been an important contributor here.
Being blut, my skeptical opinion is you are looking for wiggle room to justify when you fail; and you will fail, as there is nobody on the planet that has "paranormal" powers.

You want to "calibrate" on me, have at it....tell me what you want/need...but the results will be the same.

Anything you "calibrate" on is really independent of the questions; that is to say they may or may not be one in the same.

I do find it odd that you readily accepted this test, claimed you do it in chat rooms, etc. and now suddenly requires a fairly extensive "calibration" period....and you are not around to do it. Seems a bit intellectually dishonest you didn't mention all this before don't you think?

BTW - In one of your pictures you mention you have "orbs" around you; do you make any claim as to what those orbs are?
 
Last edited:
You know, one of these days I'm gonna come up with a different kind of challenge. Something along the lines of: Any person claiming to have supernatural powers must start by posting 1)what he claims he can do,2) how he intends to do it, and 3)post some evidence such as videotaped tests and other types of valid demonstrations.... before the thread reaches page 2.

As soon as the rambling and the useless gibberish extends to page 2, the participant has lost.




By the way, you have lost.
 
Here is a direct quote from the MDC application.

On the surface this seems reasonable, however, their is a clause missing in that statement.

... the results are self-evident to _____ (who)
what does self-evident mean? Yes I know what it means, but if you were in a court of law.
There is no clause missing. Self-evident. The claimant succeeds or fails according to the protocols and pre-agreed definition of success. The tests are designed so that no judging or interpretation of success is required by anyone.

Is this clear?

Again: do you agree that naming your paranormal research organization after James Randi may cause unnecessary confusion and may be ethically and legally wrong to do? If so, will you change the name?
 
I really liked the protocol Rasmus came up with or something similar. I welcome coming up with a rock solid test.
I like his best myself too. I think what the objects are should be agreed on ahead of time. (Obviously you wouldn't want to get "billiard ball solid orange with number 5, billiard ball orange striped with number 13, billiard ball solid red with number 7, billiard ball solid green with number 6, etc" for a set of "different" objects.)
With regards to the calibration, what does the group think. Was LL a good sender? I thought his sending was sort of ok but the data I got did not seem to impress anyone.

So the question is, do we consider the hits close enough with LL, or do we say they were complete misses and pick a new target person?
What hits? You gave a few words that might describe the bulb syringe thing after he'd identified it for you and provided a photo. The other one was obviously a miss.

This is the sort of stuff you can completely leave off the protocol.

If we start from an assumption that what I do as a receiver does not work and will not ever work, then we might as well stop now. If we work from a point of what I can do is not great right now, but leave room that it could be tuned up, then we have some room to work.
What any of us assume or believe is irrelevant.
Here's the correct starting point: you are making a claim and setting about providing a demonstration of it. Until said demonstration, no one has any reason to accept your claim.

So back to the test protocols. The idea of having a fixed set of objects, then the sender sends one of the objects, and i have to match those objects sounds like it would produce a much more reliable hit than, "Curvy, blue, metal...."
That's almost right. You'd have to do it more than once for it to mean anything. We'd need someone to figure out the numbers.

Trying to triple blind it is awesome. Let's see what we can come up with.
Once again, you don't seem to understand what "double blind" means in a controlled study. (There is no "triple blind".)
Your explanation of triple blind (from the jref thread) has no relationship whatsoever to actual double blinding:
Triple blind. The objects are dropped randomly into paper bags, the bags are placed on a table out of site of the subjects. They are randomized by shuffling them on the table. Contents are similar size and weight and are slid into box so I won't know what is in container either.
Blind #1: Test giver is blind to contents
Blind #2: Subjects are blind to contents
Blind #3: I will post my results blind to this forum so the community can be the statistician. Therefore statistician is blind.
And it's tremendously misleading. You ("test giver") are the one with the objects, and you "randomly" place them into paper bags and that somehow leads to "Blind #1" you not knowing which object is which when you pick up a paper bag and put it in the box?

Yeah, I'm sure JREF would go for that!
 
Last edited:
You know, one of these days I'm gonna come up with a different kind of challenge. Something along the lines of: Any person claiming to have supernatural powers must start by posting 1)what he claims he can do,2) how he intends to do it, and 3)post some evidence such as videotaped tests and other types of valid demonstrations.... before the thread reaches page 2.

As soon as the rambling and the useless gibberish extends to page 2, the participant has lost.

By the way, you have lost.

:cheerleader2

I think I'll save this one for future use, just in case I'm in on the first page of a thread. Not often I get post #2 as in this thread, but I think it is valid just the same.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom