A skeptic tests psychic ability

I am not returning. This is my last post. Bye


Rats. I just waded through five pages of this thread only to find that this most recent self-professed psychic ran away after failing spectacularly. Gee, who could have seen that coming? ;)
 
Wow, he didn't last long! Starts posting on Friday, gone on Monday. Don't most of the "psychics" try a bit harder than that?
 
As was his attempt to paint himself as a skeptic. :D

Oh, and I just noticed your signature Locknar. If you're going make a WWF(or WWE these days) tie-in and base it around Brock you'd be better off going with his nickname than Steve Austin's.

Hence, "The Next Big Thing Brick Locknar."
[derail]
The "Brick" reference is from a typo of Fran's a while ago...then between Fran, JJ and others the various suggested nick names to go with it :)
[/derail]

Good point, his actions clearly demonstrated his "I"m a skeptic" claim was false as well. I'd say, a complete failure on all counts.
 
Last edited:
At the very least he was coherent. And I don't recall him using the word "quantum" in any way.
 
At the very least he was coherent. And I don't recall him using the word "quantum" in any way.


He didn't say the word "quantum" but he came pretty close:


For example I except the theory that electrons spin around in orbits around an nucleas. I even accept that they can move from one orbit to another. Science cannot yet explain how an electron can move from one orbit to another, yet have no intermediate state or transition. It just is in one orbit than instantly in another. I still am willing to accept electricity and chemistry even though scientists still cannot determine the exact nature of an electron. Sometimes its a wave, sometimes it is a particle, sometimes it is both, sometimes it is neither. Hard to believe that the science we believe so hard in can't even nail down the stupid electron. It is still very heavy in the theory stage.
 
To me it just looked like an argument of ignorance "I don't understand quantum physic, ( which I won't even name it), so it is all crap.". But then again it is probably on "par" with his definition of skepticism...


I think he was doing the opposite. I think he was making an argument from analogy.

1. We don't understand how an electron can go from one orbit to the other without traveling between them.
2. But the electron does do that.
3. We don't understand how thoughts can be transmitted without energy or physical manifestation.
4. Like the electron, the fact that we don't understand it doesn't mean it isn't true.
5. Therefore, my claims are true.

3 through 5 were only inferred by me but my sense is that this is what he was subtly trying to imply.
 
I think he was doing the opposite. I think he was making an argument from analogy.
I think you're right.
Loss Leader said:
1. We don't understand how an electron can go from one orbit to the other without traveling between them.
2. But the electron does do that.
And I think this is where his biggest problem is. He's using the solar system model of the atom, which doesn't really work well to understand quantum theory. It would be more accurate to say that the electron has varying probabilities of existing in certain places (and with other certain characteristics) in the electron cloud. The "orbitals" aren't really orbits--like a planet going around the sun--but different kinds of probability clouds.

Although I'm certain somehow who knows more will correct me. At least I know the solar system idea is an out-moded way of understanding this. So an analogy based on the failures of an outmoded model are pretty useless. (Especially since, as LL points out, he uses the outmoded model to show our supposed ignorance. Then argues from ignorance to support his nutty idea.)
 
Last edited:
Joe, the description is accurate enough. The solar system model (or bohr model) is often used in popular culture. Look at the "classic" representation of an atom : 3e- orbitting in ellipse around an atom. It is also easier to grasp and understand than a cloud of probability (or density of probability which might even be harder to understand).

I would wager that you might be right on whether it was an argument by analogy, but it is still based on ignorance of current model (yeah I am grasping at straw too ;)).
 
Here is the crux of woo - atoms are amazing things, complex, awe inspiring - one of the many real world things we have difficulty grasping because they dont fit the normal physical model we have evolved to understand (ie, 3 dimensional objects that have a definite location, direction and speed).

Instead of marveling at this wonder of modern understanding (in that atoms are not a complete mystery to us), woosters make crap up. Instead of enjoying the amazing stuff that surrounds them, they make up other 'amazing' stuff. Why are they not satisfied with the level of "awesome" in the real world?

Ive never understood it, and I dont think I ever will.
 
I would wager that you might be right on whether it was an argument by analogy, but it is still based on ignorance of current model (yeah I am grasping at straw too ;)).
I missed your earlier comment that it's an argument from ignorance. Even the way LL stated it, it's an argument from ignorance. You're definitely right about that.

The old "science can't explain x, therefore y" argument. . .
 
I think he was doing the opposite. I think he was making an argument from analogy.

1. We don't understand how an electron can go from one orbit to the other without traveling between them.
2. But the electron does do that.
3. We don't understand how thoughts can be transmitted without energy or physical manifestation.
4. Like the electron, the fact that we don't understand it doesn't mean it isn't true.
5. Therefore, my claims are true.

3 through 5 were only inferred by me but my sense is that this is what he was subtly trying to imply.

I think it's plausible that a person's thoughts can indeed travel the distance between two energy levels in an atom. Now, if we can only test it by getting two people that close to each other...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom