Why not run a series of tests? Pick 10 clearly different objects in advance and then randomly select one of those for each run.
e.g. I have around me now
- screw driver (metal and plastic, empty or full)
- plastic or glass bottle
- paper (single sheets, magazines, newspapers, money notes)
- a crayon (wooden)
- electric iron
- CDs, DVDs
- a rubber stamp (with my address, mostly plastic)
- wii controllers, the remote for my TV, a cordless or mobile phone
- coins (German, either a single coin or a handful of them) or other 'shrapnel' like screws, etc.
- an electric cable (live or dead)
- a can of baked beans (I have a few other options, but not that many right now. and I might want to eat my beans

)
- eggs
- a pair of socks (or other clothes)
- a bit of salt (or a lot, if i am allowed to keep it in the mill)
- a stone (vulcanic lava or whatever i can pick up outside)
... well, you get the idea. I've tried to list a few items that are very distinct one way or another in size, shape, material, purpose, weight, organic vs unorganic etc.
Many of the items I listed can be arranged with specific colours, too, to distinguish them further.
Even if what the psychic can see is relatively vague it should be possible for them to distinguish the items since they would know the list in advance.