A skeptic tests psychic ability

martinv

Scholar
Joined
Feb 1, 2008
Messages
71
Hi Brian and all my fellow skeptics

I am the founder of a group called the James Randi Psychic Proof. I am a psychic, medium, and skeptic and have started to bring together Ph.D. researchers, psychics, scientists, skeptics, you name it, in order to come up with some psychic tests that are designed from the psychics point of view.

A non-psychic might design a test, with absolutely outstanding experimental design and get a perfect "no" answer and think they have now shown something. But imagine a person who has never seen a color trying to create a scientific test to determine color or some other sense. They might come up with questions like:
what does green smell like? How tall is a c# note?
They run their tests, triple blind, and the get the absolute perfect answer that green does not have a smell. Or C# does not have a height. Great question, built on a poor foundation.

I run tests every single week with non-psychics and psychics for 2 hours. For example, to an outside a zener card deck might seem like a good design for sending and receiving. From my tests, circle is fine. Plus is fine. However, square, star and wavy lines all are received as a set of angles by most of the psychics I have tested. The main difference is the degree of the angle and that is hard to get. How is that 6 out of 7 of my psychics get the angles, but almost all will fail trying to name the shape.

We are now in the process of creating a series of tests to assess psychic ability but designed from the psychics point of view. It is an interesting twist, but we are seeing interesting results.

Now the reason for this post. I am looking for some scientific and skeptically minded folks who can help me skeptically tweak my original test ideas into great tests to put these psychics through.

One of the first things I have created is a standard psychic protocol. It is designed to make sure a person who goes to a psychic reading knows what a cold reading is, knows what a psychic reading should look like, and makes sure the results given during the reading are vetted to not be coming from the person being read.

I decided to call this protocol a "Martin Reading". It is still in its draft form, but I was hoping some of my JREF buddies could help me toughen this up. Think of it this way. If you were a skeptic (what do you know, you already are) and you were going to a psychic for a reading, what would you want to have happen to show you a successful reading that your fellow skeptics could also believe in.
Or to think of it another way, if psychics were going to be regulated by the federal government, what protocol would they want to have to ensure a person got a real reading and kept the fakes away.

Please look at this protocol I have posted on our blog.
I welcome your comments.

psychicproof.blogspot.com/2008/02/martin-reading-ver-10.html
 
Why so quick to write off his idea? Doesn't sound very skeptic-y. I thought that skepticism takes and analyzes the evidence with fair weight given to both sides.

So martinv claims to be a two things that, in our current understanding, don't mesh well together. He's trying to take the logical route with his tests. We should be encouraging this type of analysis, not ridiculing.

Kudos martinv.
 
Why so quick to write off his idea? Doesn't sound very skeptic-y. I thought that skepticism takes and analyzes the evidence with fair weight given to both sides.
I suggest that alfaniner has, in fact, given fair weight to each side.

But, I will happily read through your link this evening and let you know what I think. But, I suspect others will beat me to it.

ETA: but, from the get-go this "skeptic" assumes psychics are genuine.. something not at all skeptical.
 
Last edited:
martinv said:
I run tests every single week with non-psychics and psychics for 2 hours. For example, to an outside a zener card deck might seem like a good design for sending and receiving. From my tests, circle is fine. Plus is fine. However, square, star and wavy lines all are received as a set of angles by most of the psychics I have tested. The main difference is the degree of the angle and that is hard to get. How is that 6 out of 7 of my psychics get the angles, but almost all will fail trying to name the shape.
Welcome to the boards.
You fail to realize that the psychic/medium/whatever gets his saying as to the test protocol as much as the JREF. The protocol is agreed upon by both parties before the test.
I suggest you first read the MDC rules and find out what's it really about.
 
I am a psychic, medium, and skeptic and have started to bring together Ph.D. researchers, psychics, scientists, skeptics, you name it, in order to come up with some psychic tests that are designed from the psychics point of view.


Since you've already decided that psychics exist, I don't exactly see your claim of wanting test for psychic ability to be credible.
 
Hi All,
I love you guys. Some are taking this seriously, others are just seriously funny. I am seeing "Appeal to Ignorance", "Ad Hominem", "Appeal to Authority", "Non-Sequitur" and a couple of others so far.
I will chime in when I see a few more real entries. Logical fallacies I thought were for the woo-woo crowd.
 
If the "angly" shapes give you trouble (unlike the plus and circle), you obviously need to replace your Zener cards with something that you can distinguish. Perhaps cards with different colours? Or combine colours with shapes- have six cards with a red circle on a white background, a green circle on a yellow background, a white circle on a blue background (and the other three the same colour combinations with a plus sign).

Or if you're doing this from a distance, maybe you could have five different smells? A rose, a cup of coffee, sour milk, crayons, and a skunk?
 
If the "angly" shapes give you trouble (unlike the plus and circle), you obviously need to replace your Zener cards with something that you can distinguish. Perhaps cards with different colours? Or combine colours with shapes- have six cards with a red circle on a white background, a green circle on a yellow background, a white circle on a blue background (and the other three the same colour combinations with a plus sign).

Or if you're doing this from a distance, maybe you could have five different smells? A rose, a cup of coffee, sour milk, crayons, and a skunk?

Excellent Reply Madalch:

As a matter of fact we don't use zener cards any more. Have not for a while. But serves my point of test design. We actually do some tests similar to your suggestion. One of the my psychic development groups favorite is trying to determine an object placed in a small box on the center of the table. The person who put it in there transmits the contents telepathically to the group to try to pick up.

We also do photographs inside sealed envelopes. Everybody in the group brings in photographs. One person is the test admin and places the photos into identical envelopes and numbers them randomly. The envelopes are sealed and handed around the room to everyone in random order. Then everyone is given a recording sheet with the numbers from the envelopes and has to record as much detail from the photos as they can. Then we pass the photos to our right, and evaluate the next photo handed to us. It makes for a reasonable size dataset to get reasonable statistics.

Then after the test is over and all the sheets are collected, we open the envelopes to see what pictures were in which envelope and then we collectively score the sheets to reduce grading bias. It is a lot of fun.
 
Last edited:
One of the my psychic development groups favorite is trying to determine an object placed in a small box on the center of the table. The person who put it in there transmits the contents telepathically to the group to try to pick up.

We also do photographs inside sealed envelopes. Everybody in the group brings in photographs. One person is the test admin and places the photos into identical envelopes and numbers them randomly. The envelopes are sealed and handed around the room to everyone in random order. Then everyone is given a recording sheet with the numbers from the envelopes and has to record as much detail from the photos as they can. Then we pass the photos to our right, and evaluate the next photo handed to us. It makes for a reasonable size dataset to get reasonable statistics.

Then after the test is over and all the sheets are collected, we open the envelopes to see what pictures were in which envelope and then we collectively score the sheets to reduce grading bias. It is a lot of fun.

In neither of the two experiments you described is the individual who knows the answer sequestered from the individual being tested. Forget whether psychics can distinguish a triangle from wavy lines; you've actually created a situation where outright cheating is simple, easy and devastating to your results.

My impression so far is that you're goal is to twist and tweak the scientific method just enough to get the results you already want.

You could dispel this impression but, since I'm right, you won't.
 
Last edited:
Loss leader, nice try, but a miss.
The experiment is actually triple blind and my goal is to remove all chances at cheating. What fun is it to cheat. I might as well not waste my time or yours.

Triple blind. The objects are dropped randomly into paper bags, the bags are placed on a table out of site of the subjects. They are randomized by shuffling them on the table. Contents are similar size and weight and are slid into box so I won't know what is in container either.
Blind #1: Test giver is blind to contents
Blind #2: Subjects are bling to contents
Blind #3: I will post my results blind to this forum so the community can be the statistician. Therefore statistician is blind.

Sorry to say not everyone cheats.
Considering our groups are run with PhD scientists and such, we can't tolerate poor scientific methods.
 
Last edited:
You believe yourself to be psychic and a medium why exactly?

When you come here and make an extraordinary claim in the first few sentences of your post " I am a psychic and a medium ", then you go on to say you are trying to develop a testing system for psychics...

Would you pass these tests?

For example, can YOU tell what is in a box on a table, if you do not know the contents?

If the answer is yes, then I must ask you to please tell me what is in the box on my computer desk, if I am to believe your extraordinary claim, or are your psychic powers hindered by distance? If so please explain why.

Thank you.
 
Absolutely brilliant martinv!

In all the years of scientific research into the vailidity no one has thought of addressing the "what does green smell like" before.

Oh. Wait. To take the Million Dollar Challenge you tell Randi what you can do. And then, if the test goes ahead, you agree with Randi how it can be tested. See pictures concealed in envelopes? Go ahead and take the Challenge. Collect the Million. :boggled:

What's all this research you are doing for? :confused:

PS. I did not see any magicans in your list. :jaw-dropp
 
You believe yourself to be psychic and a medium why exactly?

When you come here and make an extraordinary claim in the first few sentences of your post " I am a psychic and a medium ", then you go on to say you are trying to develop a testing system for psychics...

Would you pass these tests?

For example, can YOU tell what is in a box on a table, if you do not know the contents?

If the answer is yes, then I must ask you to please tell me what is in the box on my computer desk, if I am to believe your extraordinary claim, or are your psychic powers hindered by distance? If so please explain why.

Thank you.

1. Would I "pass" "these" tests.
a. Depends on what "these" means, but if you mean the test on Monday. Of course I do that same test every week. We take turns being the person responsible for loading the box. It is just my week to load the box. This is the first time in about 6 weeks that I have loaded it.
b. Depends on what "pass" means. Who decides what pass means? I get hits and misses just as the rest of the group. We did not do the experiment last week. The week before however, for test #1 of 2, I got 2 symbols. Orange and curve shape. The content was a tangerine. For test #2, I got natural, rough - it was a crystal. We did not do a third.

I was not very impressed. It was 2 misses right?
 
Absolutely brilliant martinv!

In all the years of scientific research into the vailidity no one has thought of addressing the "what does green smell like" before.

Oh. Wait. To take the Million Dollar Challenge you tell Randi what you can do. And then, if the test goes ahead, you agree with Randi how it can be tested. See pictures concealed in envelopes? Go ahead and take the Challenge. Collect the Million. :boggled:

What's all this research you are doing for? :confused:

PS. I did not see any magicans in your list. :jaw-dropp

Hi Gord_in_Toronto,
Did you fail to notice that I run the James Randi Psychic Proof group? Did you notice that I have my own Pre-Million Dollar Challenge in the works? Did you notice that I have a training program for myself and others to do not only the MDC but our Proof challenge that is much more difficult?

You have to remember, if you make extraordinary claims, it requires extraordinary proof. I actually expect a team of us to be in the MDC by the end of the year (hopefully). I don't have any rush.

Besides, I am having too much fun right now playing with real psychics every week. MDC is ok. Most of the PhD's I work with say that unless the MDC goes down on something pretty substantial, it is going to be disregarded by the scientific community. I know you would love to see the MDC won (me too), but I don't care who wins (Yes, I would love it to be me - I am not foolish). I would like to see the MDC mean something.

Have you bothered to read all 160 entries posted on the MDC challenge forum. I have, every one. Some of them are very funny (or sad depending on your point of view). It is no wonder the MDC stood for as long as it has.
 
The week before however, for test #1 of 2, I got 2 symbols. Orange and curve shape. The content was a tangerine. For test #2, I got natural, rough - it was a crystal. We did not do a third.

I was not very impressed. It was 2 misses right?


The tests you are describing are not sufficiently controled in that you did not define what a "right" answer would be before you began. Instead, after you made your prediction and found out what was in the box, you added a layer of interpretation that skewed the results.

Does "orange and curve shaped" sufficiently define a tangerine? Maybe, maybe not. You didn't decide before-hand. Would you still count it as a hit if you had just said "orange" or just said "curved"? What if you had said "red and curve shape"? Would that have been a hit as well? The answer is that there is no way to answer the above questions. You didn't decide in advance so no answer you gave that requires any interpretation can count as a hit.

As for crystals being rough - some are and some are not. A diamond seems to me to be very smooth. A pile of salt crystals seems rough (although one single salt crystal might be smooth for all I know).

Once again, you seem intent on creating poor experiments that circumvent the scientific method just enough to give you the results you've already decided you want. That's not science. It's ... well, it's nothing.
 
Last edited:
Did you fail to notice that I run the James Randi Psychic Proof group? Did you notice that I have my own Pre-Million Dollar Challenge in the works? Did you notice that I have a training program for myself and others to do not only the MDC but our Proof challenge that is much more difficult?
As many times as you've spammed mentioned this on the forum...I don't think ANYONE has missed it.

A self proclaimed psychic and medium...who would have thought! Then again, I'm sure you already knew I was going to say that....

Alert the media folks...psychic and medium here! And to think I was here, in the forum, when history was made....wow!!!!

I'd ask why you think you have paranormal abilities, but I'm sure someone has beaten me to it...and to be honest I don't really care to hear the "Cletus the Slack Jawed Yokel" story I'm sure you have that conclusively proves your abilities.
 
Loss leader,

Your comment:
The tests you are describing are not sufficiently controled in that you did not define what a "right" answer would be before you began. Instead, after you made your prediction and found out what was in the box, you added a layer of interpretation that skewed the results.

Actually: We had already determined what hits and misses were before hand. I just did not post it here.

Actually: I only posted results here. Orange is orange. Curve is curve. those were the actual results. You are "projecting" an idea that there was a skewed result. Actually this was a baited posting. The results real and were just laid out there, waiting for a fallacy to land upon it. Nice job making up a fallacy. Not a bad logical fallacy, but I've seen better fallacies.

Your comment:
Does "orange and curve shaped" sufficiently define a tangerine? Maybe, maybe not.
Actual: question does orange and curve shaped fit "green toy soldier", "red silk carnation", "clear glass ball","small brown book", or "tangerine". These were the objects that were in the potential dataset to be sampled.

Your comment:
You didn't decide before-hand. Would you still count it as a hit if you had just said "orange" or just said "curved"? What if you had said "red and curve shape"? Would that have been a hit as well? The answer is that there is no way to answer the above questions. You didn't decide in advance so no answer you gave that requires any interpretation can count as a hit.
Actual: As a good skeptic, the next line to me should have been a question for YOU to make a better decision on a hit.

Your Comment:
As for crystals being rough - some are and some are not. A diamond seems to me to be very smooth. A pile of salt crystals seems rough (although one single salt crystal might be smooth for all I know).
Actual: You should have asked me about the nature of the crystal. I was asking YOU to make a decision on success or failure.

Your Comment:
Once again, you seem intent on creating poor experiments that circumvent the scientific method just enough to give you the results you've already decided you want. That's not science. It's ... well, it's nothing.
Actual: Again it was more bait. I purposely said I failed, yet the overall tone of your comment was as if I said I succeeded. I said the opposite.
Actual: What psychic would want to fail?

Loss leader this is fun. So back to my question to YOU.

You have sufficient information on the tangerine. Here is the missing information regarding the crystal. It was a piece of quartz crystal about 3" long, 1" wide, and full of jagged lines and edges. It did not have a smooth or clear surface.

How did I do? How would YOU rate the 2 test results?
I know how I actually rated them that evening.
 
Hi Gord_in_Toronto,
Did you fail to notice that I run the James Randi Psychic Proof group? Did you notice that I have my own Pre-Million Dollar Challenge in the works? Did you notice that I have a training program for myself and others to do not only the MDC but our Proof challenge that is much more difficult?

I did not notice any of that. Was I supposed to?

[Gord reads you blog]
[Gord staggers back from reading blog]

My Brane Hertz!

You have to remember, if you make extraordinary claims, it requires extraordinary proof. I actually expect a team of us to be in the MDC by the end of the year (hopefully). I don't have any rush.

Why do you think you will have any success? Many have tried. Poor old JB Rhine spent years of his life on psychic research -- results = zero. The "Best of British Luck" to you Sir.

Besides, I am having too much fun right now playing with real psychics every week. MDC is ok. Most of the PhD's I work with say that unless the MDC goes down on something pretty substantial, it is going to be disregarded by the scientific community. I know you would love to see the MDC won (me too), but I don't care who wins (Yes, I would love it to be me - I am not foolish). I would like to see the MDC mean something.

So you have found not just one "real psychic" but many? Funny. No one else has found one. Do they all pass your Martin test?

Have you bothered to read all 160 entries posted on the MDC challenge forum. I have, every one. Some of them are very funny (or sad depending on your point of view). It is no wonder the MDC stood for as long as it has.

I did at one time read them all. My conclusion:
-- The deluded may approach the test.
-- The scammers stay as far any from it as possible (unless they come from a region of the World that has never heard of Randi).

Let me know when you win the Million. :rolleyes:
 
A self proclaimed psychic and medium...who would have thought! Then again, I'm sure you already knew I was going to say that....

I'd ask why you think you have paranormal abilities, but I'm sure someone has beaten me to it

Locknar Buddy,
Glad to see you getting in on the game here. How about you tell me how I did on the tests just mentioned with the tangerine and crystal. What is your take? You have all the data? Make the call?

But remember, I am a skeptic too. So I am looking for a good solid logical argument on your decision. I will rip your fallacies apart (thats always fun part of being a skeptic).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom