Hi Brian and all my fellow skeptics
I am the founder of a group called the James Randi Psychic Proof. I am a psychic, medium, and skeptic and have started to bring together Ph.D. researchers, psychics, scientists, skeptics, you name it, in order to come up with some psychic tests that are designed from the psychics point of view.
A non-psychic might design a test, with absolutely outstanding experimental design and get a perfect "no" answer and think they have now shown something. But imagine a person who has never seen a color trying to create a scientific test to determine color or some other sense. They might come up with questions like:
what does green smell like? How tall is a c# note?
They run their tests, triple blind, and the get the absolute perfect answer that green does not have a smell. Or C# does not have a height. Great question, built on a poor foundation.
I run tests every single week with non-psychics and psychics for 2 hours. For example, to an outside a zener card deck might seem like a good design for sending and receiving. From my tests, circle is fine. Plus is fine. However, square, star and wavy lines all are received as a set of angles by most of the psychics I have tested. The main difference is the degree of the angle and that is hard to get. How is that 6 out of 7 of my psychics get the angles, but almost all will fail trying to name the shape.
We are now in the process of creating a series of tests to assess psychic ability but designed from the psychics point of view. It is an interesting twist, but we are seeing interesting results.
Now the reason for this post. I am looking for some scientific and skeptically minded folks who can help me skeptically tweak my original test ideas into great tests to put these psychics through.
One of the first things I have created is a standard psychic protocol. It is designed to make sure a person who goes to a psychic reading knows what a cold reading is, knows what a psychic reading should look like, and makes sure the results given during the reading are vetted to not be coming from the person being read.
I decided to call this protocol a "Martin Reading". It is still in its draft form, but I was hoping some of my JREF buddies could help me toughen this up. Think of it this way. If you were a skeptic (what do you know, you already are) and you were going to a psychic for a reading, what would you want to have happen to show you a successful reading that your fellow skeptics could also believe in.
Or to think of it another way, if psychics were going to be regulated by the federal government, what protocol would they want to have to ensure a person got a real reading and kept the fakes away.
Please look at this protocol I have posted on our blog.
I welcome your comments.
psychicproof.blogspot.com/2008/02/martin-reading-ver-10.html
I am the founder of a group called the James Randi Psychic Proof. I am a psychic, medium, and skeptic and have started to bring together Ph.D. researchers, psychics, scientists, skeptics, you name it, in order to come up with some psychic tests that are designed from the psychics point of view.
A non-psychic might design a test, with absolutely outstanding experimental design and get a perfect "no" answer and think they have now shown something. But imagine a person who has never seen a color trying to create a scientific test to determine color or some other sense. They might come up with questions like:
what does green smell like? How tall is a c# note?
They run their tests, triple blind, and the get the absolute perfect answer that green does not have a smell. Or C# does not have a height. Great question, built on a poor foundation.
I run tests every single week with non-psychics and psychics for 2 hours. For example, to an outside a zener card deck might seem like a good design for sending and receiving. From my tests, circle is fine. Plus is fine. However, square, star and wavy lines all are received as a set of angles by most of the psychics I have tested. The main difference is the degree of the angle and that is hard to get. How is that 6 out of 7 of my psychics get the angles, but almost all will fail trying to name the shape.
We are now in the process of creating a series of tests to assess psychic ability but designed from the psychics point of view. It is an interesting twist, but we are seeing interesting results.
Now the reason for this post. I am looking for some scientific and skeptically minded folks who can help me skeptically tweak my original test ideas into great tests to put these psychics through.
One of the first things I have created is a standard psychic protocol. It is designed to make sure a person who goes to a psychic reading knows what a cold reading is, knows what a psychic reading should look like, and makes sure the results given during the reading are vetted to not be coming from the person being read.
I decided to call this protocol a "Martin Reading". It is still in its draft form, but I was hoping some of my JREF buddies could help me toughen this up. Think of it this way. If you were a skeptic (what do you know, you already are) and you were going to a psychic for a reading, what would you want to have happen to show you a successful reading that your fellow skeptics could also believe in.
Or to think of it another way, if psychics were going to be regulated by the federal government, what protocol would they want to have to ensure a person got a real reading and kept the fakes away.
Please look at this protocol I have posted on our blog.
I welcome your comments.
psychicproof.blogspot.com/2008/02/martin-reading-ver-10.html
