A skeptic tests psychic ability

Loss leader, nice try, but a miss.
The experiment is actually triple blind and my goal is to remove all chances at cheating. What fun is it to cheat. I might as well not waste my time or yours.

Triple blind. The objects are dropped randomly into paper bags, the bags are placed on a table out of site of the subjects. They are randomized by shuffling them on the table. Contents are similar size and weight and are slid into box so I won't know what is in container either.
Blind #1: Test giver is blind to contents
Blind #2: Subjects are bling to contents
Blind #3: I will post my results blind to this forum so the community can be the statistician. Therefore statistician is blind.

Sorry to say not everyone cheats.
Considering our groups are run with PhD scientists and such, we can't tolerate poor scientific methods.

You are leading a group of PhD researchers, but you have no idea what the criteria are for a blinded study? This makes no sense. You are either a troll or talking through your hat.
 
Hi All,
Just logged in.
Sounds like some fun.
I am in for the game.

And I am not afraid of being wrong (I don't care if I am right or wrong, I just say what I get).
Actually, I bet you are looking forward to proving me wrong.

One thing I realized this morning as I was reviewing last nights posting in my mind, was that right now we still have the issue of non-psychics and psychics speak different languages. Subtle but different.

For example - Technically there is no such thing as "psychic". That is really a catch all term for the field. It is usually too much work to say clairvoyant, clairsentient, remote viewing, telepathic, empathic. Each has its own language and definitions.

For example clairvoyant and remote viewing are very, very similar, but have some differences. Clairvoyance is being able to SEE an object with out knowledge of that object having to come from another person. Usually (but not always) clairvoyance is experienced from the reader as a perceived distance of 3-6 feet. Generally small objects (1 inch and up) can be reasonably be seen. Reading text is almost impossible (some one may, but I have never met one). 1" resolution is repeatable, but 3"+ is better. Subtle patterns are difficult to see, think of it like what could you resolve through a fog or theater scrim. Clairvoyance is not experienced as a human (ie feet on the floor, observing from 5 feet), so you could see from any direction (above, below, beside...but usually not chosen by viewer).

Remote viewing is another way to sense visual information. The sensing distance is from about 30-50 feet away, but the location can be actively moved by the viewer to other orientations and distances, but still usually not closer than about 5 feet. Remote viewers can usually see images with a little more detail than a clairvoyant, but still generally fuzzy. Can name the object, but pretty limited on naming certain characteristics of objects.

For a clairvoyant or RVer, seeing a shape, texture, outline, color, is what is mostly perceived when they unfold the download. Some who have been practicing reading the download longer, can actually get the specific object archetypes or even describe the specific object.

NOTE: A point about the above observations. I am only stating distances and measurements from what I have personally experienced, or those I have directly had practice sessions with. I do not state theory, nor do I say what I said is all inclusive. Their may be other Clairvoyants or RVers who have different experiences, but I am not allowing myself to speak outside my scope of knowledge or experience.

To a skeptic who says that only naming the specific object is true psychic ability, that is a very high standard. Not impossible, but they will have to wait a lot longer to get their confirmation.

The question is are you willing to accept an exceptional statistical value on subjective data? For example
Picking one edge shape out of 100, Then to name the color out of a set of 7 primary colors, produces a probability (with out all the weighting and other statistical adjustments) of 1 out of 700. That was the result I achieved with the box test 2 weeks ago. I would rather leave it at the 1:700, but if we actually get into the statistics of the test, the number goes much higher, but that is meaningless.

I would really like to get some good statistical folks involved in our game. So we could come up with something mathematical to talk about.
Since we know going into the game I don't get exact objects but shapes, textures, etc, we have to define a scoring system for these values and a range of potential to measure against.
Getting a curve, with a bunch of eggs, oranges, bananas is a totally useless test. With a test of bananas, oranges, grapefruits.

Close your eyes an imagine the color orange. How orange is orange to call it orange, or is it gold, or yellow, or goldenrod? What color does someone call out to a group of skeptics. I can see it, but I can't show it to you, so I have to pick a color symbol to represent my experience. Then you have to receive that color into your mind, and interpret it to your experience.

So for example with color there would need to be a defined range of a color symbol, with an upper bound and lower bound value. Because, I bet I could bring in 5 sheets of paper into everyones office, and very few would write down the same color. So we need a way to translate a subjective value to an objective value.

Please don't say real science does not do that. You experience it everyday. Your computers use 0 volts for off, and 5 volts for on.

Anyone have some good ideas here we can use?
 
Last edited:
We are now in the process of creating a series of tests to assess psychic ability but designed from the psychics point of view. It is an interesting twist, but we are seeing interesting results.

Now the reason for this post. I am looking for some scientific and skeptically minded folks who can help me skeptically tweak my original test ideas into great tests to put these psychics through.

One of the first things I have created is a standard psychic protocol. It is designed to make sure a person who goes to a psychic reading knows what a cold reading is, knows what a psychic reading should look like, and makes sure the results given during the reading are vetted to not be coming from the person being read.

I suggest you abandon the idea of trying to tweak a poorly designed test and start over.

Start with your claim (or hypothesis). State specifically what it is you think you can do. Then design the test in such a way that the outcome is evident (either you did or did not do what you claimed).

As I said in the ferj thread, the problem I see with the tests you're mentioning is that they're simply open invitations to retrofitting and cherry picking.

The protocol should be set up so that no judgment or interpretation of results is needed.

By the way, in discussing testing protocols, please spare us all the lectures about how the mind is like a TV or the difference between "psychic" and "clairvoyant". The task is to prove whether or not something paranormal is happening at all. If you pass a well-designed test, then and only then will I engage in that sort of talk. Otherwise, you're professing expertise in a field of study whose main subject is--at best--unproven.

In your ferj post, it was difficult to figure out what the test was with all that intervening nonsense. (You put an object in a box at a certain time and invite people to write down whatever thoughts, images, etc. pop into their head. Then you'll reveal the object and you'll judge the results. Is that an honest restating of the procedure you described in the ferj thread? You don't see any problems with a lack of hypothesis or claim and lack of any way of quantifying the results? That's without even considering the question of how you judge a hit, assuming at some point you'd be counting hits and misses.)
 
I have just sent three questions for martinv to Loss Leader.

Martinv: is anything coming across? Can you say anything about my questions, or provide answers to them?
 
I can do it.
Maybe I will try it on JREF boards later for fun.

Yes I knew, but did not take a psychic for that.

Time/space does not matter.

It is actually easier when you are not around the person. Chat rooms, work great. They could be in China. Does not matter.

Someone can actually write a question for a skilled psychic tomorrow and it can be answered today. A real twist to get your brain around.
Hi All,
Just logged in.
Sounds like some fun.
I am in for the game.


(snip)

I would really like to get some good statistical folks involved in our game. So we could come up with something mathematical to talk about.
Since we know going into the game I don't get exact objects but shapes, textures, etc, we have to define a scoring system for these values and a range of potential to measure against.
Getting a curve, with a bunch of eggs, oranges, bananas is a totally useless test. With a test of bananas, oranges, grapefruits.

Close your eyes an imagine the color orange. How orange is orange to call it orange, or is it gold, or yellow, or goldenrod? What color does someone call out to a group of skeptics. I can see it, but I can't show it to you, so I have to pick a color symbol to represent my experience. Then you have to receive that color into your mind, and interpret it to your experience.
(snip)


How about a scoring system where the answer is definitely right or definitely wrong? Or correct me if I'm wrong, but are these two sets of statements unrelated?
 
Welcome to the forums, martinv.
Do you agree that this testing system is fair to the applicant? If not, why, and how would you change it?

Here is a direct quote from the MDC application.

All tests must be designed in such a way that the results are self-evident, so that no judging or voting process is required.

On the surface this seems reasonable, however, their is a clause missing in that statement.

... the results are self-evident to _____ (who)
what does self-evident mean? Yes I know what it means, but if you were in a court of law.

... For example, what if I said it was self-evident to my 3 year old child who was going to decide is that ok? What if I said it was self evident to a extreme religious zealot who thinks all things unexplainable are evil.

Who declares that self-evident is met. What if 20 people in the room feel that self-evident was met, but not JR. What if 100 people feel that it was met but not JR.

Maybe self-evident should be decided by a panel, so that no one person holds all the power. It has to be self-evident to a committee.

That to me is reasonable.

No, but wait .... Lets leave it. When I take the test, I am going to assign my 3 year old to be the self-evident decision maker. That is my plan. The agreement does not say I can't do that, I will put that in my protocol.
 
Last edited:
How about a scoring system where the answer is definitely right or definitely wrong?

That is what we are trying for. We just are working on finding a way to take the info I receive and being able to drop it into precise buckets of right and wrong.

But even before, right and wrong, there is still the issue of probabilities.

If I guess (not psychic) something that had a 1 in a million chance and got it right. That was impressive. Lucky. But not psychic. You have got to have solid statistics around you buckets to make sure that you can even get a meaning ful result. You hold up 5 fingers, I pick you pointer finger (actually probably would have been another one, but we will leave that for another day). That was a 1 out of 5 result. What does that mean. We had good buckets of right and wrong.

I don't have it in me to do 30 clairvoyance tests. Maybe 2 or 3, so we have to come up with some ways to make the statistic meaningful for such a small dataset.
 
That is what we are trying for. We just are working on finding a way to take the info I receive and being able to drop it into precise buckets of right and wrong.

But even before, right and wrong, there is still the issue of probabilities.

If I guess (not psychic) something that had a 1 in a million chance and got it right. That was impressive. Lucky. But not psychic. You have got to have solid statistics around you buckets to make sure that you can even get a meaning ful result. You hold up 5 fingers, I pick you pointer finger (actually probably would have been another one, but we will leave that for another day). That was a 1 out of 5 result. What does that mean. We had good buckets of right and wrong.

I don't have it in me to do 30 clairvoyance tests. Maybe 2 or 3, so we have to come up with some ways to make the statistic meaningful for such a small dataset.

If you only have two or three in you, I might suggest to pick only one set of questions. Either from myself, LL, Lochnar, or Michael C. Focus on that one person. But do say who you're going to focus on. And the answer must be unambiguous. If someone asked "What is in my hand?" and the answer is "A cup of coffee," your answer must be "A cup of coffee" or even just "coffee". But an answer of "black... inorganic... smooth..." won't be a match. That could also be used to describe a stapler, a CD case, my dictionary... shoot, half the things around me.
 
What are the answers to the questions held by Loss Leader?

How would I know. I have never calibrated to him before. You asking for telepathy. I prefer to working on an experiment in clairvoyance. Not the same thing. I have already stated previously, my telepathy is not very good. But my clairvoyance is decent. At least as of my skills as I have experienced the as of 12:33 today.

A telepathic test with me will probably fail.
I am ok to test it in public, but expecting it to fail, seeing it fail, does not prove anything.

For me, this stuff is a skill. I am still moving up the learning curve on the telepathy skill set. When I get reasonable results we can play the answer my question game with an expectation of good results. Are you willing to play for a while with poor results? That is how I learn. I get better over time.

We may be able to do the question game if we can define the nature of questions that would produce results that I can interpret.

I am not quite sure of how we will pick the target objects.
Naming a physical object or phrasing a question around a physical object. There are going to be some pretty specific bounds to make the results meaningful.

I really do want to play this, so don't take anything as trying to weasel out. I play this stuff for 2 hours every monday. It is just that you guys are a much tougher crowd and my results have to razor sharp. And I am cool with that.
 
Last edited:
If you only have two or three in you, I might suggest to pick only one set of questions. Either from myself, LL, Lochnar, or Michael C. Focus on that one person. But do say who you're going to focus on. And the answer must be unambiguous. If someone asked "What is in my hand?" and the answer is "A cup of coffee," your answer must be "A cup of coffee" or even just "coffee". But an answer of "black... inorganic... smooth..." won't be a match. That could also be used to describe a stapler, a CD case, my dictionary... shoot, half the things around me.

Baron, we would need to move you to another place, because what you described is probably exactly the kind of results I would return. So we would want to make sure test conditions did not have noise that would skew my results.
 
Last edited:
Here is a direct quote from the MDC application.



On the surface this seems reasonable, however, their is a clause missing in that statement.

... the results are self-evident to _____ (who)
what does self-evident mean? Yes I know what it means, but if you were in a court of law.

... For example, what if I said it was self-evident to my 3 year old child who was going to decide is that ok? What if I said it was self evident to a extreme religious zealot who thinks all things unexplainable are evil.

Who declares that self-evident is met. What if 20 people in the room feel that self-evident was met, but not JR. What if 100 people feel that it was met but not JR.

Maybe self-evident should be decided by a panel, so that no one person holds all the power. It has to be self-evident to a committee.

That to me is reasonable.

No, but wait .... Lets leave it. When I take the test, I am going to assign my 3 year old to be the self-evident decision maker. That is my plan. The agreement does not say I can't do that, I will put that in my protocol.

I'm not sure what you're getting at here, as I see it the point is that you clearly define beforehand what constitutes a right answer. If your answer doesn't meet these predefined criteria, it's a miss.

This is why your example earlier with 'orange' 'curved' etc was said to be meaningless. You did not define what would constitute a 'hit' or 'miss', therefore when you gave your answers then the situation you mentioned does arise, who decides if you passed? It's open to interpretation. Of course maybe you did predefine what would constitute a 'hit' or 'miss', but you did not say you did.

I'd also like to add to what others have mentioned about naming your group James Randi Psychic Proof. I don't think it's right or necessary to invoke Randi's name, and the name also seems to suggest you have proof, whereas at the moment it's still a process of experimentation surely, which may or may not result in proof.
 
Baron, I did like the idea of someone holding something in their hand. That would be easy for me to target in on. That was a good idea.
 
I have received several questions. The OP is free to psychically sense the questions and provide his answers. He may focus on Locknar and Baron Samedi or he may focus on me.

In the case of the Baron, I only have the questions. If the OP is trying to sense the answers, he must look to Baron himself or to the person Baron sent the answers.
I dunno about anyone else...but I feel a odd tingling sensation today; perhaps its my new shampoo *lol*
 
I'd also like to add to what others have mentioned about naming your group James Randi Psychic Proof. I don't think it's right or necessary to invoke Randi's name, and the name also seems to suggest you have proof, whereas at the moment it's still a process of experimentation surely, which may or may not result in proof.

I sent an email to James Randi when I formed the group and told him about us and the tests we were running. I also told him that I would change the name of our group if he asked us to. He seems to be ok with it. His main comment to me about the group was

The "statistics" are not at all as important as the actual experimental protocol

Our group is trying to gather the proof and we chose the James Randi name in our title because we are trying to live up to the high standard he set and we are very closely correlated to the JREF mission.
 
Our group is trying to gather the proof and we chose the James Randi name in our title because we are trying to live up to the high standard he set and we are very closely correlated to the JREF mission.

I really would like to get a lot of the JREF folks involved in that psychic proof group. JREF is a no BS kind of group and I need that.

It does not do me any good to have these great conversations with the woo-woo crowd. They are all out in the 'cold' and go running when talked to seriously.
 
Baron, I did like the idea of someone holding something in their hand. That would be easy for me to target in on. That was a good idea.
Funny you didn't mention this when you casually accept the challange. However, can do...wrt all my questions, there is something I can directly touch, hold, or see and will do so today. Any special time I sould do this, to make it as easy as possible for you?
 
I can do it.
Maybe I will try it on JREF boards later for fun.

...

It is actually easier when you are not around the person. Chat rooms, work great. They could be in China. Does not matter.

Someone can actually write a question for a skilled psychic tomorrow and it can be answered today. A real twist to get your brain around.
Well heck, why wait...lets do it now? What do you say...you game?

How about I PM Loss Leader a question, and you PM him an answer....and he can disclose all right here in this thread. What ya say....(of course, you knew I was going to ask this....)
It is a little late for me to be wrong tonight.
I would much rather be wrong when I am a little fresher.
I'll send LL 3 questions in any event...and say give you until Monday noon to provide LL answers, you can post them here in the forum if you like.
I'm willing to play too, if you need another volunteer and a question or two
I have received several questions. The OP is free to psychically sense the questions and provide his answers. He may focus on Locknar and Baron Samedi or he may focus on me.
Hi All,
Just logged in.
Sounds like some fun.
I am in for the game.

And I am not afraid of being wrong (I don't care if I am right or wrong, I just say what I get).
I have just sent three questions for martinv to Loss Leader.

Martinv: is anything coming across? Can you say anything about my questions, or provide answers to them?
What are the answers to the questions held by Loss Leader?
How would I know. I have never calibrated to him before. You asking for telepathy. I prefer to working on an experiment in clairvoyance. Not the same thing. I have already stated previously, my telepathy is not very good. But my clairvoyance is decent. At least as of my skills as I have experienced the as of 12:33 today.

A telepathic test with me will probably fail.
I am ok to test it in public, but expecting it to fail, seeing it fail, does not prove anything.


Martinv - you publicly agreed to provide the answers to questions that had been sent to my mailbox. You stated that conditions where the person is not in the same room with you are actually better than when he is. You mentioned a chat room with a subject in China. You were too tired last night but your first post today said that you would attempt it. I collected questions from Locknar, Baron and Michael C. Now, you claim that you cannot do such a test, that you would probably fail and that you cannot sense the questions or answers because you have not "calibrated" to me.

You agreed to a small test and now you are refusing to do it. You have changed the rules and now want people to hold objects.

My first posts in this thread stated that I believed that you would do anything to reinforce your preconceptions while avoiding any real inquiry. I can only conclude that I was exactly right.

If you would like to guess the answers to the questions asked by these posters, I can assure you that all the answers are straightforward and, require no interpretation. You are free to make your guesses like you said you would.

Otherwise, your statements on this thread have had no effect on me other than to make it more likely that all so-called "psychics" are either active frauds or seriously self-deluded.
 
You are free to make your guesses like you said you would.
The word for today is...."guesses".

Whelp I've done my part...provided questions, even offered to hold/touch/look at objects directly related to my questions, have given you (Martinv) till noon on Monday. So are you saying you can't "calibrate" in the time alloted? Though I thought you mentioned something about doing this in chat room with from China so I'm not sure how much time you really need.

Heck....I'm a lot closer then China. In fact have spent a fair amount of time in Frederick in the past, have ties to there now; what more do you need to "calibrate" (short of me just giving you the answers that is)?
 
Last edited:
Martinv - you publicly agreed to provide the answers to questions that had been sent to my mailbox. You stated that conditions where the person is not in the same room with you are actually better than when he is. You mentioned a chat room with a subject in China. You were too tired last night but your first post today said that you would attempt it. I collected questions from Locknar, Baron and Michael C. Now, you claim that you cannot do such a test, that you would probably fail and that you cannot sense the questions or answers because you have not "calibrated" to me.
Sounds good. Lets start by calibrating.
Loss leader, Here is what I need, give me some sort of spatial coordinate to find you. City, state is nice (no I am not going to do some cold,warm, hot anything) Will have nothing to do with questions.

I have your alias. Hopefully, with a name, location and time I can find you. The calibration test will help. If not, we might need to find someone else to target. But hopefully I can get you.
At 1:46 I will try to tune in and find you. I need you to both tell me a question (with an visible object) and the answer. I want you to hold both those in your mind until 1:48. I will try to see if I can pick you up with that question and answer. I also want you to send me another question without an answer. Hold that question in your mind from 1:50 to 1:53.


I need:
1. your city,state
2. a question
3. answer to #2
4. another question

Thanks
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom