Rob,
Welcome to the thread. I love poking fun at myself. You can too.
Many skeptics come from the fallacy of "Appeal to Ignorance", "Confusion of Correlation and Causation" and "Excluded Middle".
Nice to see your only part way there. There is hope for you yet.
Sounds like your biggest fallacy is the "Appeal to Ignorance" (that sounds so bad, sorry, it is just what the type is called).
Most people have never met a real psychic. If they have, it has usually been the professional types with a lot of cold stuff mixed in.
Most real psychics I have met, have never seen a client in their life, and rarely tell their family or friends.
Your comment:
Myself, I think the chance of psychic phenomena existing *and* being detectable is pretty close to zero
Answer:
you have nothing to go on. I doubt you or most people have bothered to actually read any of the peer reviewed journals on this stuff. And if you are getting it from the popular media - ugh!
Skeptics for years have been beating the snot out of anyone even slightly hinting at psychic. Those who are willing to say it better have skin of iron and sharp wit. There are so many fakes out there.
That is why I am such a huge Randi fan. He is on my side, and I am on his. I am even willing to say that I am not very good.
I have thought about going with the name "Martin, the bad psychic". It gives me such freedom, plus I get the benefit of the play on the meaning 'bad'. I am still thinking about it.
The day you get to meet some of the psychics I work with you will have to pickup your jaw from the ground. How do they get these hits so accurate. I guess it is a lot different when everybody is not so serious and having fun with this stuff.
Yeah, we have the serious science side, but all work and no play ...
well you know. Oh by the way you are psychic too. Always have been. Problem is nobody ever taught you.
Sort of like being born Mozart, but living in the desert with camels. If you would have only had someone show you a piano and how it works.
Great post though. Thanks