A skeptic tests psychic ability

So can you do this? Of course, you probably knew I was going to ask right?

Do you need to meet the person, just be in proximity of them, be around places they use to be, etc.?

I can do it.
Maybe I will try it on JREF boards later for fun.

Yes I knew, but did not take a psychic for that.

Time/space does not matter.

It is actually easier when you are not around the person. Chat rooms, work great. They could be in China. Does not matter.

Someone can actually write a question for a skilled psychic tomorrow and it can be answered today. A real twist to get your brain around.
 
Glenn,
Thanks for taking the time to look at the protocol. It means a lot to me.

You have to remember, the protocol is designed for someone who has come to a psychic looking for information.

Just because somebody walks into a room and sits down does not tell the psychic that they want to know what happened to their lost child. or where is my diamond ring I lost 4 years ago.

A psychic needs a question, because that determines the psychic payload that gets dumped into the mind to be untangled.

Asking a question does not invalidate a test. Asking a question is the same as a scientist who poses a question as a hypothesis they need to test. How do you run a scientific test with out question. How does Edison run a test for a light bulb, unless he asks the question, I wonder if this material will work?

Let me put it this way. There is no such thing as an answer with out a question. There are statements. But what does that mean.

Let me try it your way. No question.

You walk into a room we have setup. There is a lone chair in the center of the room. The psychic is behind a screen so they cannot see you. The test begins.

The psychic starts giving statements. Blue, Metal, Curvy, "some sort of car".
Test is over. How did that seem to you?

I don't get it. What just happened? I sure don't know.

Lets change it slightly. Same setup.

You sit down. The question is written on a piece of paper and handed to the psychic. the same stuff is called out.
What was written on the paper: what was my first car?
What was the answer, a blue Volkswagen beetle.

Now those statements make sense. They can be evaluated against something.
Will it be subjective? Depends on how you setup the test evaluation beforehand.

Are you ready to blow your mind. A decent psychic can tell you the answer before you hand them the paper or before the person enters the room. How cool is that.

Your Comment:
In addition, there should be multiple clients...subjects isolated...readings should be written down and randomized etc.
I agree. I was looking more at a protocol that would be applied to each test. You repeat the protocol to make sets as you said, and randomized.

Excellent posting. Thank you.

To me, there is a big difference between a test and a psychic reading. If there were proof of someone being psychic, then questions could be asked and answers given.

However, scientific proof must be more strict. The type of reading must be defined first. Then a minimum of 10 random clients would need to be selected and each given a blind reading with zero questions and zero feedback during the reading. After the psychic writes everything down, then the clients could select which reading is theirs. The psychic would have to give specific details howver, no vague statements allowed.

If the psychic were really psychic, no questions would need be asked since the psychic is claiming to read the person. Why would questions be needed when someone is reading your inner being--they should see clearly the missing child or the missing diamond.

Now, a fixed set of questions could be useful in a different protocol...but again...multiple clients and double blind with essentially Yes Or No results only. If a psychic guessed 10 out of 10 "what's your first car" questions with 10 random people, then I would start see some light assuming the make and model were correctly stated. Add 10 more questions randomly selected from a group of 100 questions and some statistical evidence, then the MDC would be easy to win.

Have to get some sleep....sorry I couldn't be more comprehensive right now.

glenn
 
Why do I get the overall impression many of these posts are "You claim to be psychic? Well we have nothing to discuss until you admit you're a fool." How about politely and constructively investigating the claims, asking for more data, and suggesting changes where they are needed?

Myself, I think the chance of psychic phenomena existing *and* being detectable is pretty close to zero, however I think its always a wonderful experience to engage with someone who genuinely seeks to legitimize his/her exploration by being open to dialogue with the scientifically skeptic. Either they will be the first to succeed, or they will add to the thoroughness of the valid, yet failed attempts. Either way its a positive outcome.

martinv, you claim many of your test subjects view the images not in clear visions, but hazy description (angle lines, etc). Might I suggest spending some time with the group thinking of the most disjointed set of 5 symbols you can picture. The set of symbols should be different in shape, colour, usage and emotional content. For example, a laughing baby, a rusty set of leg irons, a microchip, a poluted river, a tangerine.

Like some others mentioned, make the list known ahead of time, so to avoid any need for re-interpretation. Record all testing for a complete statistical history, etc.

Cheers,
Rob.
 
I can do it.
Maybe I will try it on JREF boards later for fun.

Yes I knew, but did not take a psychic for that.

Time/space does not matter.

It is actually easier when you are not around the person. Chat rooms, work great. They could be in China. Does not matter.

Someone can actually write a question for a skilled psychic tomorrow and it can be answered today. A real twist to get your brain around.
Well heck, why wait...lets do it now? What do you say...you game?

How about I PM Loss Leader a question, and you PM him an answer....and he can disclose all right here in this thread. What ya say....(of course, you knew I was going to ask this....)
 
Rob,
Welcome to the thread. I love poking fun at myself. You can too.

Many skeptics come from the fallacy of "Appeal to Ignorance", "Confusion of Correlation and Causation" and "Excluded Middle".

Nice to see your only part way there. There is hope for you yet.
Sounds like your biggest fallacy is the "Appeal to Ignorance" (that sounds so bad, sorry, it is just what the type is called).

Most people have never met a real psychic. If they have, it has usually been the professional types with a lot of cold stuff mixed in.
Most real psychics I have met, have never seen a client in their life, and rarely tell their family or friends.

Your comment:
Myself, I think the chance of psychic phenomena existing *and* being detectable is pretty close to zero
Answer:
you have nothing to go on. I doubt you or most people have bothered to actually read any of the peer reviewed journals on this stuff. And if you are getting it from the popular media - ugh!

Skeptics for years have been beating the snot out of anyone even slightly hinting at psychic. Those who are willing to say it better have skin of iron and sharp wit. There are so many fakes out there.
That is why I am such a huge Randi fan. He is on my side, and I am on his. I am even willing to say that I am not very good.

I have thought about going with the name "Martin, the bad psychic". It gives me such freedom, plus I get the benefit of the play on the meaning 'bad'. I am still thinking about it.

The day you get to meet some of the psychics I work with you will have to pickup your jaw from the ground. How do they get these hits so accurate. I guess it is a lot different when everybody is not so serious and having fun with this stuff.

Yeah, we have the serious science side, but all work and no play ...
well you know. Oh by the way you are psychic too. Always have been. Problem is nobody ever taught you.

Sort of like being born Mozart, but living in the desert with camels. If you would have only had someone show you a piano and how it works.

Great post though. Thanks
 
Well heck, why wait...lets do it now? What do you say...you game?

How about I PM Loss Leader a question, and you PM him an answer....and he can disclose all right here in this thread. What ya say....(of course, you knew I was going to ask this....)

It is a little late for me to be wrong tonight.
I would much rather be wrong when I am a little fresher.
At this point, I don't have any sense that anything I would produce would be considered right.
When my spidey senses say its right, we'll play.
I am looking forward to it.
Got to go to bed.

Signed,
Martin, the bad psychic
(what do you think of the tag? should I keep it?)
I will check back tomorrow.
Good night all.
 
Last edited:
Rob,
Welcome to the thread. I love poking fun at myself. You can too.

Many skeptics come from the fallacy of "Appeal to Ignorance", "Confusion of Correlation and Causation" and "Excluded Middle".

Nice to see your only part way there. There is hope for you yet.
Sounds like your biggest fallacy is the "Appeal to Ignorance" (that sounds so bad, sorry, it is just what the type is called).

Most people have never met a real psychic. If they have, it has usually been the professional types with a lot of cold stuff mixed in.
Most real psychics I have met, have never seen a client in their life, and rarely tell their family or friends.

Your comment:
Myself, I think the chance of psychic phenomena existing *and* being detectable is pretty close to zero
Answer:
you have nothing to go on. I doubt you or most people have bothered to actually read any of the peer reviewed journals on this stuff. And if you are getting it from the popular media - ugh!

Skeptics for years have been beating the snot out of anyone even slightly hinting at psychic. Those who are willing to say it better have skin of iron and sharp wit. There are so many fakes out there.
That is why I am such a huge Randi fan. He is on my side, and I am on his. I am even willing to say that I am not very good.

I have thought about going with the name "Martin, the bad psychic". It gives me such freedom, plus I get the benefit of the play on the meaning 'bad'. I am still thinking about it.

The day you get to meet some of the psychics I work with you will have to pickup your jaw from the ground. How do they get these hits so accurate. I guess it is a lot different when everybody is not so serious and having fun with this stuff.

Yeah, we have the serious science side, but all work and no play ...
well you know. Oh by the way you are psychic too. Always have been. Problem is nobody ever taught you.

Sort of like being born Mozart, but living in the desert with camels. If you would have only had someone show you a piano and how it works.

Great post though. Thanks

You are just spouting anecdotal rubbish.

You have produced nothing palpable here that would convince anyone that you are anything other than a bat*poop* crazy woo, who knows what a logical fallacy is.

Being able to counter others by claiming that they are using a logical fallacy is pretty much moot, because the burden of proof is on YOU ! You have proven nothing. You have done nothing but produce cute anecdotal accounts of your psychic adventures with your hyper educated, highly qualified sidekicks.

I expect that you will quote me and call me out for my Ad Hominem ( or whatever other debating crimes I am guilty of ), yet offer absolutely nothing of substance in defense of your own extraordinary claims.
 
I can do it.
Maybe I will try it on JREF boards later for fun.

Yes I knew, but did not take a psychic for that.

Time/space does not matter.

It is actually easier when you are not around the person. Chat rooms, work great. They could be in China. Does not matter.

Someone can actually write a question for a skilled psychic tomorrow and it can be answered today. A real twist to get your brain around.

Well heck, why wait...lets do it now? What do you say...you game?

How about I PM Loss Leader a question, and you PM him an answer....and he can disclose all right here in this thread. What ya say....(of course, you knew I was going to ask this....)

Sounds like a good idea. I'd play too. Several people could each PM a question to a person who accepts to be the arbitrator (I'm happy with Loss Leader) and Martinv could PM the replies. Then the arbitrator would publish the results here.

A simple test, quite easy to organise. Do you want to give it a go, Martin?
 
martin, is there a reason that you posted this in the Skeptoid section? I don't see the relevance. Would you mind if I asked that it be moved to the general skepticism & paranormal subforum, where many more people will see it?
 
Welcome to the forums, martinv.

Hi Brian and all my fellow skeptics

I am the founder of a group called the James Randi Psychic Proof. I am a psychic, medium, and skeptic and have started to bring together Ph.D. researchers, psychics, scientists, skeptics, you name it, in order to come up with some psychic tests that are designed from the psychics point of view.

1) Why is this named after James Randi? What's it got to do with him? Don't you think it would be a good idea to differentiate your group from Mr. Randi and the JREF, for ethical and legal reasons, since both groups are involved in testing paranormal claims?

2) The test protocols for the JREF $1 million challenge are designed by the applicants: "from their point of view." Of course the JREF has input in this process, but the applicant must agree that every part of the protocol is satisfactory to them. This process has sometimes taken years. Then, the test doesn't take place unless the applicant agrees that all conditions at the test location are to their satisfaction and that they know of nothing that will interfere with the performance of their claimed ability. Where applicable a "dry run" will be performed before the test. For example, someone dowsing for gold will try their ability against gold in a location that's known to them, to be sure they are properly "tuned in." After the real test, the applicant is asked to certify that the test was performed according to the protocol they designed and approved.

Do you agree that this testing system is fair to the applicant? If not, why, and how would you change it?
 
Hi Gord_in_Toronto,
Did you fail to notice that I run the James Randi Psychic Proof group? Did you notice that I have my own Pre-Million Dollar Challenge in the works? Did you notice that I have a training program for myself and others to do not only the MDC but our Proof challenge that is much more difficult?
In fact there should be nothing "difficult" about the MDC, since it tests only what the applicants say they can do, according to the protocol they designed, and under conditions that they've agreed are propitious to their success. Do you agree with that statement? Yet no one has even passed a simple preliminary test. Why do you suppose that is?

You have to remember, if you make extraordinary claims, it requires extraordinary proof. I actually expect a team of us to be in the MDC by the end of the year (hopefully). I don't have any rush.
Yes, you do. The MDC is ending in less than two years.

Since you claim to be a psychic, and since protocols sometimes take significant time to be worked out, why not apply now? (I assume your psychic abilities have garnered you some media attention!)
 
Last edited:
I have no problem witgh any of this. The OP won't do it, but I have no problem collecting questions and answers if he does.

I doubt I would count "blue, metal and curvy" as three hits on the question "What was my first car." I don't know of many cars that aren't metal and curvy. And I suspect about 20% of them are blue.
 
Last edited:
It is a little late for me to be wrong tonight.
I would much rather be wrong when I am a little fresher.
At this point, I don't have any sense that anything I would produce would be considered right.
When my spidey senses say its right, we'll play.
I am looking forward to it.
Got to go to bed.

Signed,
Martin, the bad psychic
(what do you think of the tag? should I keep it?)
I will check back tomorrow.
Good night all.
Wow...who would have guessed a "woo woo" ducking a test on their self proclaimed powers.

I'll send LL 3 questions in any event...and say give you until Monday noon to provide LL answers, you can post them here in the forum if you like.
 
I'm willing to play too, if you need another volunteer and a question or two

ETA: Would it be prudent to have an additional level of blinding, as in I'd send one person the questions, and another person would receive my answers?
 
Last edited:
Gord_in_Toronto:
You sound like a kindred spirit. Glad to have you on my team.

{Gord examins his previous post very carefully}

{Gord contacts the the Spirit of Anne Shirley and reads the entire thread to this point to her and then asks, "Anne, does this sound like I am a kindred spirit of Mr V?". Anne has a brief response, "No".}

BTW: Don't go looking for professional psychics. They are forced to use way to much cold material in their routine to stay in business.

Mr Rhine used students picked at random for most of his work.

In my development group, I get them when the are still kind of in the rough and can be polished and tuned up.

Do you advertise for them? Have you tried Craig's List?

So I 100% agree with you the general public won't find them. As far as the martin test. If they want to stay in my development group, it is all that is allowed, if they can't do it that way the are kicked out.

The general public does not find them for the same reason I can't -- there aren't any.

So you have a number of psychics who have passed your test as documented on your site?

Forget Randi, the NOBEL PRIZE is yours. :boggled:
 
Gravy beat me to it. What is this "James Randi Psychic Proof" group? For all I know I can't imagine him giving his name for that group.
 
I have received several questions. The OP is free to psychically sense the questions and provide his answers. He may focus on Locknar and Baron Samedi or he may focus on me.

In the case of the Baron, I only have the questions. If the OP is trying to sense the answers, he must look to Baron himself or to the person Baron sent the answers.
 
I'll volunteer

Interesting thread folks.

I'd like to volunteer as an outsider to collect questions and answers. I'm on pins and needles here to see what will happen.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom