A skeptic tests psychic ability

Locknar Buddy,
Glad to see you getting in on the game here. How about you tell me how I did on the tests just mentioned with the tangerine and crystal. What is your take? You have all the data? Make the call?

But remember, I am a skeptic too. So I am looking for a good solid logical argument on your decision. I will rip your fallacies apart (thats always fun part of being a skeptic).


Well, speaking of fallacies, you have felt the need to appeal to the authority of your supposed position, and the PHD's of all your companions many times over.

Just something to think about.
 
Gord_in_Toronto:
You sound like a kindred spirit. Glad to have you on my team.

BTW: Don't go looking for professional psychics. They are forced to use way to much cold material in their routine to stay in business.
In my development group, I get them when the are still kind of in the rough and can be polished and tuned up.
So I 100% agree with you the general public won't find them. As far as the martin test. If they want to stay in my development group, it is all that is allowed, if they can't do it that way the are kicked out.
 
Gate2501:
Your comment:
Well, speaking of fallacies, you have felt the need to appeal to the authority of your supposed position, and the PHD's of all your companions many times over.
Actual: it is only a fallacy if I am using the PhD's as an authority figure. I am actually using them, because they have the scientific credentials, training, and background to make sure I do good science.
Actual: I can care less whether they influence your decision. I just wanted people to know that I have people staring over my shoulder keeping me in check. Basically, it is more peer review without the publishing.
 
Nice job making up a fallacy. Not a bad logical fallacy, but I've seen better fallacies.


What is the name of the logical fallacy I committed?


How did I do? How would YOU rate the 2 test results?
I know how I actually rated them that evening.


I would rate them as nothing. They are meaningless. They are utterly and completely without merit, worth or value.
 
I just wanted people to know that I have people staring over my shoulder keeping me in check. Basically, it is more peer review without the publishing.

This is the internet.

I am an astronaut and I also fight in the UFC and am married to a supermodel.

Welcome to the internet.

The reason you are posting about these PHD's and your alleged position with this psychic test foundation, is to bolster your own credibility with anecdotal references. A wall to duck behind when the flamethrowers begin belching forth upon you on the JREF forums.
 
Last edited:
Locknar Buddy,
Glad to see you getting in on the game here. How about you tell me how I did on the tests just mentioned with the tangerine and crystal. What is your take? You have all the data? Make the call?
My take? I'm thinking the Radio Shack at FSK Mall needs you back pronto!

But remember, I am a skeptic too. So I am looking for a good solid logical argument on your decision.
Humm....a skeptic too eh? This seems unlikely as you are not only a self professed psychic and medium, you claim to have found others...yet nobody else has. Why waste time, apply for the MDC now!!

Maybe it is something in the air from the BP Solar plant there is causing this psychic outbreak?

I will rip your fallacies apart (thats always fun part of being a skeptic).
Magic 8-ball says "Very doubtful".

So exactly what kind of psychic/medium are you? Without blabbering on and on about how you "discovered" your "powers"...what do you claim to be able to do with them?
 
Last edited:
How about you tell me how I did on the tests just mentioned with the tangerine and crystal. What is your take? You have all the data? Make the call?
Any test that requires judgements like does "orange and curved" describe a tangerine is always going to be open to criticism.

Why not give the participants a list of objects before hand and make them choose the object from the list? No judgement required.

In fact it would be interesting to run both types of tests and see if there is any difference in the results between the two.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
No WAY! You too? What are the odds!!!!

BTW, its "Internet"...with a capitol "I"; but being a fellow astronaut I'll let it slid, this time *lol*

Argh... I am ashamed to say that I have never in my life capitalized the I in Internet !

But you sir have spelled capital as "capitol" when referring to said uppercasery ! THE DAY IS MINE ! * flies away on rocket ship *
 
I would rate them as nothing. They are meaningless. They are utterly and completely without merit, worth or value.

Very interesting. Says a lot about you.

Why would you pick such strong words for such tiny results? Hmmm. Such an emotional response.

Let me flip this back to you.
You are having such a hard time because I loaded the deck with saying it was a miss.

Now you are left with 2 choices agree with me that it was a miss. However, your decision is based on having to ignore the actually pretty good dataset I provided.

Or you would have to disagree with my decision and say the results looked rather psychic and agree with the probablities of the result set.

Instead you chose door #3.
and said I will ignore and disregard actual data.

A good skeptic would still try to come up with a value for my results.

Here let me give you some bait to come at me. These are fun.

Just for the fun of it. "I now say it was a hit."
Prove me wrong.

Skeptics like this side of the fence. Show me statistically why I am deluding myself and that those results are not psychic.
 
Argh... I am ashamed to say that I have never in my life capitalized the I in Internet !

But you sir have spelled capital as "capitol" when referring to said uppercasery ! THE DAY IS MINE ! * flies away on rocket ship *
I meant to do that, so you would feel better about your faux pas *lol*
 
Locknar,

I am impressed by the FSK posting.

2 Ad Hominems, A strawman, Special Pleading, and a Non-Sequitur all in one post. good job.
 
Locknar,

I am impressed by the FSK posting.

2 Ad Hominems, A strawman, Special Pleading, and a Non-Sequitur all in one post. good job.
Aye, but falls short of posts containing total delusion and/or falsehoods.

So now that that is out of the way, how about answering the question at hand...what kind of psychic/medium are you, what do you claim to be able to do?
 
Well, I went through the protocol and I must say that it doesn't come close to being any type of scientific test. The entire protocol is subjective.

First off, the client should not have to ask any questions at all. This alone invalidates the test.

In addition, there should be multiple clients...subjects isolated...readings should be written down and randomized etc. There is no statement of what is being read even.

glenn
 
Last edited:
I am a decent clairvoyant and clairaudient.
My telepathy is weak but gaining rapidly
Automatic writing is decent

Negligible on clairgustance and clairsentience.

Mediumship. That one is very interesting for me.
I am definitely getting very good quality hits,
however, I have yet to determine if it is a true medium hit
or a regular psychic phenomenon.

The mediumship stuff is something I plan on putting through
its paces over the next month.

For example. Can I get a reading on someone who has passed away
who was good at math, but the person I am reading is not,
then see if I can pose a question to the "supposed" spirit with a
question such as what is the square root of 64. The person would have no idea of what I am asking, but the "spirit" would probably find it easy - right? If they were good at math.

So the honest answer for the medium is I really don't know.
That is something I want real answers for.
How do you figure out if a medium is real.
Supposedly what I am getting is real medium stuff.

I wish we did not have to cancel our guest at the last psychic development meeting. We were supposed to do a reading on a person who would be a very interesting client.
We were going to have about 6 regular medium folks PLUS 1 or 2 people who can ACTUALLY SEE spirits as clear as you or me.

How cool would that be to have 6-8 people trying to come up with all kinds of stuff. I had so many questions I wanted to ask with all of us around. Did we all get the same impressions? Did we all sense the same spirit? What did you see? What did you hear?

So disappointed. That would have been so cool.

Well, I am planning on rescheduling that event.
Forget the ghostbuster folks with their electronic dodads.
We were looking to get into real conversations, or at least try.

I am not great at this stuff. I just do it for fun.
But I do get to meet some people who can seriously kick my bu** when we run trials.
 
Just for the fun of it. "I now say it was a hit."
Prove me wrong.


You are not wrong. You are not right. You're results are nothing. They do not exist in any calculable or weighable manner. They are as absent as if you had give no answers at all. They are as absent as if you had not even appeared that day for the test.

And, speaking of logical fallacies, it is not my burden to prove you wrong. It is your burden to substantiate your cliams.

By the way, you accused me of some vague logical fallacy. I asked you to name the exact fallacy I committed. I note that you did not.
 
I am a decent clairvoyant and clairaudient.
My telepathy is weak but gaining rapidly
Automatic writing is decent <snip>
Yikes! I'm sorry to say I am not up on "gibberish" so I'm having a hard time following. Lets try and focus on just one aspect, say "mediumship". So you can only ask math questions of dead folks?

Without all the rambeling...what speicially do you claim to be able to do "mediumship" wise?
 
Last edited:
Well, I went through the protocol and I must say that it doesn't come close to being any type of scientific test. The entire protocol is subjective.

First off, the client should not have to ask any questions at all. This alone invalidates the test.

In addition, there should be multiple clients...subjects isolated...readings should be written down and randomized etc.

glenn

Glenn,
Thanks for taking the time to look at the protocol. It means a lot to me.

You have to remember, the protocol is designed for someone who has come to a psychic looking for information.

Just because somebody walks into a room and sits down does not tell the psychic that they want to know what happened to their lost child. or where is my diamond ring I lost 4 years ago.

A psychic needs a question, because that determines the psychic payload that gets dumped into the mind to be untangled.

Asking a question does not invalidate a test. Asking a question is the same as a scientist who poses a question as a hypothesis they need to test. How do you run a scientific test with out question. How does Edison run a test for a light bulb, unless he asks the question, I wonder if this material will work?

Let me put it this way. There is no such thing as an answer with out a question. There are statements. But what does that mean.

Let me try it your way. No question.

You walk into a room we have setup. There is a lone chair in the center of the room. The psychic is behind a screen so they cannot see you. The test begins.

The psychic starts giving statements. Blue, Metal, Curvy, "some sort of car".
Test is over. How did that seem to you?

I don't get it. What just happened? I sure don't know.

Lets change it slightly. Same setup.

You sit down. The question is written on a piece of paper and handed to the psychic. the same stuff is called out.
What was written on the paper: what was my first car?
What was the answer, a blue Volkswagen beetle.

Now those statements make sense. They can be evaluated against something.
Will it be subjective? Depends on how you setup the test evaluation beforehand.

Are you ready to blow your mind. A decent psychic can tell you the answer before you hand them the paper or before the person enters the room. How cool is that.

Your Comment:
In addition, there should be multiple clients...subjects isolated...readings should be written down and randomized etc.
I agree. I was looking more at a protocol that would be applied to each test. You repeat the protocol to make sets as you said, and randomized.

Excellent posting. Thank you.
 
Last edited:
Are you ready to blow your mind. A decent psychic can tell you the answer before you hand them the paper or before the person enters the room. How cool is that.
So can you do this? Of course, you probably knew I was going to ask right?

Do you need to meet the person, just be in proximity of them, be around places they use to be, etc.?
 
Loss leader:
Sorry about not defining the fallacy for you. It was a straw man. Did not know you cared so much. It was a nice one though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom