tsg
Philosopher
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2005
- Messages
- 6,771
This the easiest way I know of to explain the difference between choosing a card at random and choosing a card on purpose.
In each case, Tom and Dick are drawing cards from a deck of three, one of which is the Ace of Spades.
Case A: Both Tom and Dick choose a card at random.
Before anyone draws a card, there is a probability of 3/3 that the Ace is in the deck.
After Tom chooses a card, there is a probability of 1/3 that he has the Ace, and therefore 1/3 chance of removing it from the deck, leaving a probability of 2/3 the Ace is still in the deck. After Dick chooses his card (at random), there is a 1/3 probability that he has the Ace and 1/3 that it is still in the deck. When Dick turns over his card to show that it isn't, in fact, the Ace, the odds are 1/3:1/3 or 1:1 = 1/2 that the Ace is in Tom's hand.
Case B: Tom chooses a card at random, Dick chooses a non-Ace on purpose (assuming if they are both non-Aces he will choose one at random).
Before the draw, there is a 3/3 chance the Ace is still in the deck.
After Tom chooses a card, there is a 1/3 chance the Ace is in Tom's hand, and a 2/3 chance the Ace is still in the Deck.
When Dick looks at the cards and chooses a non-Ace, there is 0 chance of the Ace being and Dick's hand and therefore still 2/3 chance the Ace is in the deck.
The odds are then 1/3:2/3 or 1:2 = 1/3 that Tom holds the Ace.
The key is that, in Case A, Dick has a 1/3 chance of removing the Ace from the deck, while in Case B, he does not.
In each case, Tom and Dick are drawing cards from a deck of three, one of which is the Ace of Spades.
Case A: Both Tom and Dick choose a card at random.
Before anyone draws a card, there is a probability of 3/3 that the Ace is in the deck.
After Tom chooses a card, there is a probability of 1/3 that he has the Ace, and therefore 1/3 chance of removing it from the deck, leaving a probability of 2/3 the Ace is still in the deck. After Dick chooses his card (at random), there is a 1/3 probability that he has the Ace and 1/3 that it is still in the deck. When Dick turns over his card to show that it isn't, in fact, the Ace, the odds are 1/3:1/3 or 1:1 = 1/2 that the Ace is in Tom's hand.
Case B: Tom chooses a card at random, Dick chooses a non-Ace on purpose (assuming if they are both non-Aces he will choose one at random).
Before the draw, there is a 3/3 chance the Ace is still in the deck.
After Tom chooses a card, there is a 1/3 chance the Ace is in Tom's hand, and a 2/3 chance the Ace is still in the Deck.
When Dick looks at the cards and chooses a non-Ace, there is 0 chance of the Ace being and Dick's hand and therefore still 2/3 chance the Ace is in the deck.
The odds are then 1/3:2/3 or 1:2 = 1/3 that Tom holds the Ace.
The key is that, in Case A, Dick has a 1/3 chance of removing the Ace from the deck, while in Case B, he does not.