I sadly still don't understand how, after being told that dick will live, Tom can still have survival odds of 2/3, when there aren't even 3 options to choose from anymore. (tom and dick survive, or dick and harry survive)
Are you claiming that any time there are only two options, they
must be of equal probability? There's a 50% chance the sun will rise tomorrow? There's a 50% chance that if I drop a penny at random onto a circle colored 2/3 blue and 1/3 red, the penny will land on blue?
Let's try enumerating the
actual options.
(Tom and Dick survive, the warden says Dick)
(Tom and Dick survive, the warden says Harry)
(Tom and Harry survive, the warden says Dick)
(Tom and Harry survive, the warden says Harry)
(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Dick)
(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Harry)
Do you agree that those are the actual options? Perhaps not, because some won't happen ever. Let's see...
(Tom and Dick survive, the warden says Dick)
(Tom and Dick survive, the warden says Harry) = 0 (CAN'T HAPPEN)
(Tom and Harry survive, the warden says Dick) = 0 (CAN'T HAPPEN
(Tom and Harry survive, the warden says Harry)
(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Dick)
(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Harry)
Fine then, those two things can't happen. So... let's see what's left. Remember that Tom and Dick surviving is a 1/3 chance, and Tom and Harry is a 1/3 chance, and Dick and Harry is a 1/3 chance.
(Tom and Dick survive, the warden says Dick) = 1/3
(Tom and Harry survive, the warden says Harry) = 1/3
(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Dick)
(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Harry)
Uh oh. We know that Dick and Harry surviving is a 1/3 chance, but how to divide it up? So far we've been assuming randomly, so:
(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Dick) = 1/6
(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Harry) = 1/6
Okay. So there are 4 possibilities, with probabilities:
P(Tom and Dick survive, the warden says Dick) = 1/3
P(Tom and Harry survive, the warden says Harry) = 1/3
P(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Dick) = 1/6
P(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Harry) = 1/6
But now we know that the warden says Dick, so only two are left.
P(Tom and Dick survive, the warden says Dick) = 1/3
P(Dick and Harry survive, the warden says Dick) = 1/6
The sum of all probabilities must be 1, so you say to yourself "The first option is twice as likely as the second, so that's 2/3 and 1/3." Or you just divide both by 1/3+1/6. Same answer.
How about that one, anything there that strikes you as wrongheaded or too mathy?