3 prisoner puzzle

I'll read up on Monty Hall then as I've obviously forgotten what the set-up was, then come back later!
 
Besides Baron, someone on the forum in Singapore disagreed with my answer too. He posted this question to me:

If together, Tom and Harry had asked the warden for the name of one of the prisoners who will be set free the next day and the warden had answered that Dick's life would be spared, would the probability for Tom and Harry changed?

Honestly, I don't know if my answer to him is correct but this was what I wrote there:

If both Tom and Harry asked the question at the same time and the warden says it's Dick who will be spared, it would mean, in this instance, that both Tom's and Harry's chances of dying go up from 1/3 to 1/2. Why so, you ask?

If Dick is the one who is going to be executed, the warden cannot answer the question because naming either Tom or Harry will be a dead giveaway to the one named. So when the warden said Dick's life will be spared, it would mean it has to be either Tom or Harry who will hang the next day.


Do you think I'm right on this one?
A simpler way to look at it is that Dick is now ruled out, and all the information is symmetrical with respect to the questioners, so the probabilities must be 1/2 each. This is regardless of whether the warder said in advance that he wouldn't name either of the questioners (which you assumed, but didn't state). Important to bear in mind that 'information' can include such things as who asked the question. That's why this scenario is different from the original one.
 
A simpler way to look at it is that Dick is now ruled out, and all the information is symmetrical with respect to the questioners, so the probabilities must be 1/2 each.

Simpler in the sense of "completely wrong," yes.
 
With respect to the original group (all three) the odds of dying remain 1/3.

The odds of one out of two of the original group (2 possible sets of 2) dying is 1/2 before and after the new information.

No. Because there aren't two sets of two -- there are three sets of two, including one set of two in which no one dies. The problem is that we don't know (although the warden presumably does) which one.

So the probability of one out of two of the original group is either 1/2 or 0, depending upon whether the unlucky person is chosen in the "original group."


The proper analysis, as Cuddles put it, is to group the people into "Tom" and "everyone else." It's "obvious" that the chances of Tom dying are 1/N and the chances of "everyone else" having the victim are (N-1)/N.

This remans true if the warder chooses to reveal one of of the people who will not die in the second group.
 
It's very easy to settle this conclusively - just make a table of all the possibilities and count them. There are three possibilities to start with (Tom, Dick, or Harry will be killed). In those three cases the warden will answer Dick or Harry (presumably with 50% probability), Harry, and Dick respectively. But regardless of his answer, in only one of the three cases will Tom be killed.

Case closed.

But I think part of the issue here is that the problem the way it was stated is a little ill-posed. In the Monty Hall problem the gameshow host is required by the rules to open one of the other two doors. That makes it a well-posed problem. But here, we don't really know the warden's motives. Why did he refuse to answer the first question?

If we assume it's because the warden is following the rules of the Monty Hall problem, then the answer given by the OP is correct (as you can see from my analysis above).
 
Last edited:
Simpler in the sense of "completely wrong," yes.
I suggest you look at my post again and see which question I was responding to.

If you really are arguing with that response then it is you who are "completely wrong".
 
It's very easy to settle these questions conclusively - just make a table of all the possibilities and count them.

No. Actually, that's a very BAD way, because people make tables with events that are not equiprobable.

Example
  • I am Wonder Woman
  • I am Spider-man
  • I am Batman
  • I am Hawkgirl
  • I am Obi-wan Kenobi
  • I am none of the above.

See? The chances are at least 5/6 that I am a superhero of some sort! Since I left out Superman and Wolverine, the chances are probably even higher than that.....
 
If you really are arguing with that response then it is you who are "completely wrong".

The information is not symmetric w.r.t. all participants. In particular, only one participant is known to have asked the warden a question, and only that one participant is known to have received a response --- therefore, the information is not symmetric between the questioner and the non-questioners, regardless of the answer recieved.

Ergo, you are "competely wrong."
 
I knew I was missing something (the odds of the groups of 2 being 1/2 or 0), thank you drkitten.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the answer, Lucky. So I was right but the logic behind my answer was different from yours. I would say, going by how I posted the puzzle, having stated clearly that the warden refused to answer Tom's first question, one can safely assume that he will never name the questioner or questioners.

Anyway, I have another question for the good folks here. Someone over at the forum in Singapore kept insisting that the 3 prisoner puzzle is a variant of the famous Schrödinger's Cat Paradox. This is what he wrote:

This can be presented as a variant of the famous Schrödinger's Cat Paradox. Base on that conjecture, the probability of their living or dying would have been determined the moment someone made a decision (or "observation"). So even if Harry does not know, his chances is also determined when the "observation" was made.

When I told him that it does not take quantum mechanics to solve the puzzle, he wrote this:

exactly, quantum mechanics is probabilistic. it has to do with the philosophical question, when does a random probabilistic function becomes deterministic, as in when does it comes determined that tom, dick, or harry will be the one to die.

I kind of suspect he's trying to do a Deepak Chopra on me, if you know what I mean. Can someone please weigh in on this as I have no idea what the famous Schrödinger's Cat Paradox is all about? But please bear in mind I'm likely to copy your post and paste it over there. Thank you.
 
Who goes free? Three combinations:

The guard will definitely say Harry if Tom/Harry group
The guard will definitely say Dick if Tom/Dick group
The guard will say Dick or Harry if Dick/Harry group

Tom will go free for 2 out of 3 of these group combinations. His odds of death are 1/3.

The guard will say Harry or Dick with equal probability with neither answer the guard gives favoring Tom's odds of being executed. The guard's answer does not change the probability of Tom being executed. Tom's odds of execution are 1/3

However, because the guard will answer Tom and say Harry or Dick it removes one of the 3 possibilities of their freedom and their odds are disadvantaged.
 
Last edited:
The information is not symmetric w.r.t. all participants. In particular, only one participant is known to have asked the warden a question, and only that one participant is known to have received a response --- therefore, the information is not symmetric between the questioner and the non-questioners, regardless of the answer recieved.

Ergo, you are "competely wrong."
(my bold)

Sigh.

Oh dear. Let me try again.

Here is timebomb's second question, which I was addressing (and which I quoted in full in my post):
If together, Tom and Harry had asked the warden for the name of one of the prisoners who will be set free the next day and the warden had answered that Dick's life would be spared, would the probability for Tom and Harry changed?


It really is not possible that you actually read my post before (rudely and foolishly) assuming I was wrong (twice). I very specifically pointed out the difference in symmetricality between the original question and the second one, and explained why it changed the answer.

It will be a cold day in hell when I make a mistake in a probability puzzle (hint: it's my bread and butter).
 
Yep, got it. Now there's evidence I'm telling the truth when I say I'm rubbish at stats.
 
I wonder based on the solutions to these types of puzzles, can we philosophically make a strong assertion that extra pertinent information will always work to our benefit? That is it will always lead to better made choices because of how probability is altered with future information.

Monty Hall means information helps you to switch; this sorta tells you you shouldn't switch if you were Tom.

It's almost scientific where we can say "I know what it likely isn't" with our unknown possible outcomes.
 
"If you won't tell me if I'm the one, then please at least give me the name of one of the other 2 who will be set free tomorrow?" The warden thought for a while and said, "Tomorrow, Dick's life will be spared".

That leaves us with two possible outcomes for who survives {Tom, Dick} {Dick, Harry}. => Tom has 50% chance to survive.
 
Last edited:
Yep, got it. Now there's evidence I'm telling the truth when I say I'm rubbish at stats.

I took two semesters of statistics in college, got an A both times, and this one still got me the first time I saw it.

I think it mostly has to do with people thinking about what the probabilities would be if the information revealed had been random (i.e. it had included the chance of revealing a hit). Since the reveal is predetermined to be a miss, the information it actually shows us is different.
 
Last edited:
It will be a cold day in hell when I make a mistake in a probability puzzle (hint: it's my bread and butter).

Heh. Me too. But I can tell you from experience that it won't stop many of the folks here from arguing with you for dozens of thread-pages even when (to you and me) they're obviously wrong.
 
Thanks for the answer, Lucky. So I was right but the logic behind my answer was different from yours. I would say, going by how I posted the puzzle, having stated clearly that the warden refused to answer Tom's first question, one can safely assume that he will never name the questioner or questioners.

Anyway, I have another question for the good folks here. Someone over at the forum in Singapore kept insisting that the 3 prisoner puzzle is a variant of the famous Schrödinger's Cat Paradox. This is what he wrote:

This can be presented as a variant of the famous Schrödinger's Cat Paradox. Base on that conjecture, the probability of their living or dying would have been determined the moment someone made a decision (or "observation"). So even if Harry does not know, his chances is also determined when the "observation" was made.

When I told him that it does not take quantum mechanics to solve the puzzle, he wrote this:

exactly, quantum mechanics is probabilistic. it has to do with the philosophical question, when does a random probabilistic function becomes deterministic, as in when does it comes determined that tom, dick, or harry will be the one to die.

I kind of suspect he's trying to do a Deepak Chopra on me, if you know what I mean. Can someone please weigh in on this as I have no idea what the famous Schrödinger's Cat Paradox is all about? But please bear in mind I'm likely to copy your post and paste it over there. Thank you.


I'll take a shot at it.

First of all, Schroedinger's Cat is a thought experiment to show how poorly quantum theory scales up into the macro. It isn't a suggestion that the cat is both alive and dead until someone looks in the box and "collapses the waveform".

Probability is about the likelihood of an event given certain information. From Tom's point of view, his chances of surviving the morning are 1/3. From the Warden's point of view, who already knows who's going to be hung, they are either 100% or 0%. That's because he has more information. If he were to tell Tom he was going to be hung (ignoring any chance the warden was lying or wrong), he would know his chances of surviving are 0. Not because any waveform collapsed, but because he has more information.
 
That leaves us with two possible outcomes for who survives {Tom, Dick} {Dick, Harry}. => Tom has 50% chance to survive.

No. Having two possibilities doesn't mean they are equally likely.

Play the game 99 times, and make random choices:

1) Pick randomly a prisoner who will die.

2) Of the renakming two names, chose any name that isn't "Tom". (i.e. chose randomly from the two names if they are "Dick" and "Harry", or chose whichever name isn't "Tom" if that's one of the two names.)

Count. Count in how many of the cases where the name in step two is "Dick", the name from the first step is "Tom".
 
The guard will say Harry or Dick with equal probability with neither answer the guard gives favoring Tom's odds of being executed. The guard's answer does not change the probability of Tom being executed. Tom's odds of execution are 1/3

This is incorrect because (You said this yourself by the way :D):

However, because the guard will answer Tom and say Harry or Dick it removes one of the 3 possibilities of their freedom and their odds are disadvantaged.

Giving him 50% chance to survive after he hears the guards answer. I agree.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom