3 prisoner puzzle

This is incorrect because (You said this yourself by the way :D):



Giving him 50% chance to survive after he hears the guards answer. I agree.

It's already been explained why this isn't correct. If you still doubt it, then do the card experiment I described in my first post.
 
It's already been explained why this isn't correct. If you still doubt it, then do the card experiment I described in my first post.

Perhaps you missed post #35. But I'll make a post where I'll explain myself more thoroughly.
 
Thanks for the answer, Lucky. So I was right but the logic behind my answer was different from yours.
You were right, but your explanation only works in the situation where the warder can name Dick or nobody. The answer's still true even if we remove that restriction. It's often useful with probability questions to try completely different logical routes and check that they give the same answer.


I would say, going by how I posted the puzzle, having stated clearly that the warden refused to answer Tom's first question, one can safely assume that he will never name the questioner or questioners.
It's best not to assume anything in probability puzzles if it's not explicitly stated. Or, at least, you should be aware what assumptions you're making – they may not be what the puzzler intended. One of the reasons the Monty Hall problem causes so much confusion is that we need to know Monty's intentions, and in many settings (including Marilyn vos Savant's original one) it's ambiguous.


It will be a cold day in hell when I make a mistake in a probability puzzle (hint: it's my bread and butter).
Heh. Me too. But I can tell you from experience that it won't stop many of the folks here from arguing with you for dozens of thread-pages even when (to you and me) they're obviously wrong.
To be fair to drkitten (though I'm damned if I can see why I should be – he hasn't acknowledged his mistake yet), it wasn't the probability he got wrong, he just failed to notice what question I was answering, even after this was pointed out to him (because he arrogantly assumed he didn't need to actually read my post before asserting that I was wrong).

I remember several threads on probability where a number of people (including me) have gone to great lengths to clear up basic misunderstandings, only to have a different set of posters immediately repeating exactly the same errors. It can certainly get a bit frustrating.
 
Last edited:
Why would we assume anything but a fair coin?

Because we know better. We know the warden isn't randomly picking a name but has to follow some contraints that depend on the situation.

I guess we can agree that initially, Tom's chances of being killed were 1/3, right?

Now, in that one case the warden could freely chose whether to name Dick or Harry as one of the two survivors. (So, he'll name "Harry" in 1/6 of the cases so far.)

In the other 2/3 of all cases, the warden can't chose. One of the two survivors is Tom, and he has to name the other. Half the time he has to name Dick, and the other half, he has to name Harry. (That is another 1/3 of the cases where he'll name Harry)

So, half the time the warden will name Harry. (1/6 + 1/3 or 3/6 or 1/2) There is two different situations in which that will happen. Sometimes, thew warden will chose to name Harry, in other cases he'll have no choice - those being the ones where Tom will survive. But both cases do not occur at the same rate!
 
Perhaps you missed post #35. But I'll make a post where I'll explain myself more thoroughly.

* hastily switching sides *

You'd be right if the decision who to hang had not yet been taken. If the guard only knew that Dick would not be hanged and the decision who to hang would occur the next day then it would be 1/2.

But the decision who to hang has already been made. That leaves Tom with a 1/3 chance of being hanged and Harry with 2/3.
 
There are 3 combinations to walk free before the warden reveals his information. {Tom, Dick} {Dick, Harry} {Harry, Tom} Tom has now 1/3 chance of dying.

Now let's see. 1/3 of the time the warden has to say Dick. 1/3 of the time he has to say Harry. 1/3 of the time he can say either Dick or Harry. Now the probability after the answer depends wether the warden favors either name in this last situation. But I assume a fair coin. So he says: 1/3(Dick) + 1/6(Dick) = 1/3(Harry) + 1/6(Harry). Now with a fair coin the warden is equally likely to say either Dick or Harry.

That leaves our two remaining survival groups {Tom, Dick} {Dick, Harry} equally likely. Giving Tom a 50% chance to survive after he hears the wardens answer.

Edit:
So my answer to OP is: Tom is correct if the warden acts like a fair coin. Tom is incorrect if the warden favors either name.
 
Last edited:
Because we know better. We know the warden isn't randomly picking a name but has to follow some contraints that depend on the situation.

I guess we can agree that initially, Tom's chances of being killed were 1/3, right?

Now, in that one case the warden could freely chose whether to name Dick or Harry as one of the two survivors. (So, he'll name "Harry" in 1/6 of the cases so far.)

In the other 2/3 of all cases, the warden can't chose. One of the two survivors is Tom, and he has to name the other. Half the time he has to name Dick, and the other half, he has to name Harry. (That is another 1/3 of the cases where he'll name Harry)

So, half the time the warden will name Harry. (1/6 + 1/3 or 3/6 or 1/2) There is two different situations in which that will happen. Sometimes, thew warden will chose to name Harry, in other cases he'll have no choice - those being the ones where Tom will survive. But both cases do not occur at the same rate!

I missed this before I posted earlier. Post #48 explains my position more thoroughly.
 
No. Actually, that's a very BAD way, because people make tables with events that are not equiprobable.

If you make the table wrongly, you get the wrong answer. Was that your point?

In this case it's trivial, as I just demonstrated. There are three entries with equal probabilities - Tom, Dick, or Harry will be killed. From each of those three you can determine the guard's answer, and you can see immediately that it does not give you any information about which of the three options you are in.

Case closed.
 
Here's the question: Is Tom correct to say that? From his perspective, has his chances of being executed really gone up?

Second question: What about Harry who does not know that Dick isn't the one who's going to be hanged? From our perspective, has his chances changed?[/I]Can you spot anything wrong with my answer?
From Tom's perspective his chances of being executed have increased. From our perspective Dick's changes of being executed are now at 0. Yes, I see a problem with your answer. Moral of the story. Don't ask a question if you might not like the answer.
 
No. Actually, that's a very BAD way, because people make tables with events that are not equiprobable.

Example
  • I am Wonder Woman
  • I am Spider-man
  • I am Batman
  • I am Hawkgirl
  • I am Obi-wan Kenobi
  • I am none of the above.

See? The chances are at least 5/6 that I am a superhero of some sort! Since I left out Superman and Wolverine, the chances are probably even higher than that.....

Your post turns me on, Hawkgirl. ;)
 
It's already been explained why this isn't correct. If you still doubt it, then do the card experiment I described in my first post.

Or even better, write a computer script to do a few million trials. I did this a while ago when I came up with a similar problem and couldn't understand how the logical answer (as opposed to the intuitive one) could be correct; (it formed some bizarre mathematical Necker cube in my brain). It was a similar problem ~

When two dice are thrown they are more likely to add up to 7 than any other number. That's a fact. So intuitively (and incorrectly) one might think that if you reveal a single die after throwing both and subtract the value from 7 you would be able to predict the value of the second die with increased accuracy. Which of course is impossible. But I still needed to prove it to myself logically and seeing my stats is rubbish, PHP was the best bet!
 
Last edited:
That leaves our two remaining survival groups {Tom, Dick} {Dick, Harry} equally likely. Giving Tom a 50% chance to survive after he hears the wardens answer.

No, that is your mistake.

Look -

1/3 of the time it's {Dick, Harry}. Then the guard says Dick 1/6th of the time from this possibility, and by the same token Harry 1/6th of the time (assuming he picks one randomly).

1/3 of the time it's {Tom, Harry}, so from this we get a 1/3rd that the guard says Harry.

1/3 it's {Tom, Dick}, so 1/3rd guard says Dick.

Now, IF the guard says Dick, there is a (1/3)/(1/3+1/6) = 2/3 chance it's {Tom, Dick}, and a (1/6)/(1/3+1/6) = 1/3 change it's {Dick, Harry}. So Tom still has a 1/3 chance of dying.

Get it?
 
Last edited:
That leaves our two remaining survival groups {Tom, Dick} {Dick, Harry} equally likely. Giving Tom a 50% chance to survive after he hears the wardens answer.


How can that even be?

If his chances are 50% *regardless of the answer*, then his total chances would also have to be 50%!

Tom has a total chance of 1/3 of being killed, yet your explanation always plays out the same way and he always ends up with a 50% chance?

How can that be? How can he die in a third of all the cases, and yet have a 50% chance in all the cases, too?
 
No, that is your mistake.

Look -

1/3 of the time it's {Dick, Harry}. Then the guard says Dick 1/6th of the time from this possibility, and by the same token Harry 1/6th of the time (assuming he picks one randomly).

1/3 of the time it's {Tom, Harry}, so from this we get a 1/3rd that the guard says Harry.

1/3 it's {Tom, Dick}, so 1/3rd guard says Dick.

Now, IF the guard says Dick, there is a (1/3)/(1/3+1/6) = 2/3 chance it's {Tom, Dick}, and a (1/6)/(1/3+1/6) = 1/3 change it's {Dick, Harry}. So Tom still has a 1/3 chance of dying.

Get it?


Please read post #48. It should reveal to you why this post is incorrect.
 
Please read post #48. It should reveal to you why this post is incorrect.

I would assume that he did read post #48 considering that he explained to you exactly why it was wrong.

I could explain so too, but I probably couldn't do a better job than what has already been done.

If you continue to doubt what we are saying, then do the experiment.
 
How can that even be?

If his chances are 50% *regardless of the answer*, then his total chances would also have to be 50%!

Tom has a total chance of 1/3 of being killed, yet your explanation always plays out the same way and he always ends up with a 50% chance?

How can that be? How can he die in a third of all the cases, and yet have a 50% chance in all the cases, too?

Yes, he has 50% chance to survive after he hears the answer. It doesn't matter which name the warden gives since we assumed he doesn't favor either of the names.

There is no contradiction since he has 2/3 chance to survive with 3 unknows and a 1/2 chance to survive when there are only 2 unknowns.
 
Please read post #48. It should reveal to you why this post is incorrect.

I did read it, and I just showed you precisely what's wrong with it. I even used your notation to make it easier for you.

If you can't understand that, and you also refuse to do the simple card experiment which you could do in five minutes and would show you that you're wrong, there's no point in continuing the dialog.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom