Rasmus
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jul 27, 2005
- Messages
- 6,372
Yes, he has 50% chance to survive after he hears the answer. It doesn't matter which name the warden gives since we assumed he doesn't favor either of the names.
There is no contradiction since he has 2/3 chance to survive with 3 unknows and a 1/2 chance to survive when there are only 2 unknowns.
I'll just chime in: Do the experiment!
As far as the contradiction is concerned: No!
If there are some cases where his chances increase from 2/6 initially to 3/6 there must be other cases where his chances decrease!
Let's look at 9 cases. We agree that initially Tom will die in three of these cases.
But you give him 50% every time halfway through. So in the end he will die 4.5 times according to you.
Where do the additional 1.5 deaths come from?
Besides being wrong, which the experiment would demonstrate nicely, you are being plain illogical here.