Hi, folks,
I read Marilyn von Savant's 3 prisoner puzzle in her book, "The power of logical thinking" and posted it on a discussion board based in my home country of Singapore. If you have not heard of the puzzle, it's a variation of the Monty Hall problem. In her puzzle, Ms Marilyn didn't name the prisoners but I did. Because I thought that with names, it would be easier to explain the logic behind the puzzle later. Anyway, here's how I posted it:
There are 3 prisoners, Tom, Dick and Harry. One day, the warden comes up to their cell and says, "One of you will be hanged tomorrow morning, the other 2 will be set free". Naturally, all 3 prisoners become very anxious.
Tom who's the most anxious of all, managed to pull the warden to one corner and asked him privately, "Please tell me if I'm the one who will be executed tomorrow?". The warden refused to tell him the answer. Tom, who does not give up easily, asked again, "If you won't tell me if I'm the one, then please at least give me the name of one of the other 2 who will be set free tomorrow?" The warden thought for a while and said, "Tomorrow, Dick's life will be spared".
"Alas", cried Tom, "Now that I know it won't be Dick, it would mean it's either Harry or me who will hang tomorrow. My chances of dying has gone up from 1/3 to 1/2".
Here's the question: Is Tom correct to say that? From his perspective, has his chances of being executed really gone up?
Second question: What about Harry who does not know that Dick isn't the one who's going to be hanged? From our perspective, has his chances changed?
After much discussion and arguments, I posted the answer which was:
Tom learned nothing new when the warden said Dick's life would be spared. The warden gave him a name (Dick's) but he could have said Harry and it wouldn't make any difference to Tom. Because whichever name was given out, the warden could have definitely name one from the other 2 prisoners. So if he didn't learn anything new, how could Tom's probability of dying the next day change? In other words, from Tom's perspective as well as from ours, his probability of being executed remains the same, at 1/3.
But what about Harry? From his perspective, nothing has changed. He wasn't aware of the conversation between Tom and the warden so he did not know that Dick's life will be spared. But from our perspective, Harry's probability of being executed has now doubled from 1/3 to 2/3. Look at it this way - Divide the 3 prisoners into 2 groups. Group 1 consists only of Tom. He has a 1/3 chance of dying. Group 2 consists of Dick and Harry. Collectively, this second group has a 2/3 chance of dying. But now that we know Dick's probability of dying has gone down to zero, Harry would have to shoulder the whole thing by himself. In other words, he takes over Dick's probability as well.
Can you spot anything wrong with my answer?
I read Marilyn von Savant's 3 prisoner puzzle in her book, "The power of logical thinking" and posted it on a discussion board based in my home country of Singapore. If you have not heard of the puzzle, it's a variation of the Monty Hall problem. In her puzzle, Ms Marilyn didn't name the prisoners but I did. Because I thought that with names, it would be easier to explain the logic behind the puzzle later. Anyway, here's how I posted it:
There are 3 prisoners, Tom, Dick and Harry. One day, the warden comes up to their cell and says, "One of you will be hanged tomorrow morning, the other 2 will be set free". Naturally, all 3 prisoners become very anxious.
Tom who's the most anxious of all, managed to pull the warden to one corner and asked him privately, "Please tell me if I'm the one who will be executed tomorrow?". The warden refused to tell him the answer. Tom, who does not give up easily, asked again, "If you won't tell me if I'm the one, then please at least give me the name of one of the other 2 who will be set free tomorrow?" The warden thought for a while and said, "Tomorrow, Dick's life will be spared".
"Alas", cried Tom, "Now that I know it won't be Dick, it would mean it's either Harry or me who will hang tomorrow. My chances of dying has gone up from 1/3 to 1/2".
Here's the question: Is Tom correct to say that? From his perspective, has his chances of being executed really gone up?
Second question: What about Harry who does not know that Dick isn't the one who's going to be hanged? From our perspective, has his chances changed?
After much discussion and arguments, I posted the answer which was:
Tom learned nothing new when the warden said Dick's life would be spared. The warden gave him a name (Dick's) but he could have said Harry and it wouldn't make any difference to Tom. Because whichever name was given out, the warden could have definitely name one from the other 2 prisoners. So if he didn't learn anything new, how could Tom's probability of dying the next day change? In other words, from Tom's perspective as well as from ours, his probability of being executed remains the same, at 1/3.
But what about Harry? From his perspective, nothing has changed. He wasn't aware of the conversation between Tom and the warden so he did not know that Dick's life will be spared. But from our perspective, Harry's probability of being executed has now doubled from 1/3 to 2/3. Look at it this way - Divide the 3 prisoners into 2 groups. Group 1 consists only of Tom. He has a 1/3 chance of dying. Group 2 consists of Dick and Harry. Collectively, this second group has a 2/3 chance of dying. But now that we know Dick's probability of dying has gone down to zero, Harry would have to shoulder the whole thing by himself. In other words, he takes over Dick's probability as well.
Can you spot anything wrong with my answer?
