Umm, no, sorry. There is no difference between the odds as seen by someone outside and the odds as seen by Tom - the odds are the odds.
Well... No. This is one of the things that confuses: the odds as seen from your viewpoint change depending on what information you have.
True, and the way sol invictus expressed his point could add to the confusion, as badnewsBH and possibly OneShotKi11 seem not to understand that probability is a function of the
available information, and therefore in principle varies between different individuals at the same time, and over time for the same individual – it is
not a property of the event itself.
However (as sol invictus presumably meant), in this case there is no difference in the odds as calculated by Tom and as calculated by the audience, as we have the same information.
The Warren has nothing to do with the situation!!!!
Whether he has already chosen who is going to be executed or not has no baring on the probability Tom is facing.
Tom has been told that 2 men are being set free and 1 will die.
He looks at his 2 buddies and knows for aFACT one of them is a freeman.
He also realizes that it leaves him to battle with the one remaining man in the group.
2 people are all that matter in this secnario. Tom and Harry.
You actually dont need to know who is being set free to solve this.
Its tom vs the other man not being set free.
OneShotKi11,
you are completely wrong, and
I am completely confident that I can explain why, to your satisfaction. All you have to do is stop arguing and start listening, then I guarantee the penny will drop.
In my experience, when someone has got stuck with a false perception in a probability question, there are two stages to setting them straight. First, get them to see that their 'answer' must be wrong; second, show why the right answer is right.
We will have to go slowly, and make sure you are in agreement at each step before proceeding. First, do you accept that the unlucky prisoner has been selected, and his identity is known to the warden,
before the conversation between Tom and the warden takes place? And therefore, before the conversation, for each of Tom, Dick and Harry the probability according to the warden is either 0 or 1? And further, according to Tom, Dick, Harry or
anyone who hasn't been told the identity of the unlucky one, the probability is 1/3 for each prisoner?
If not, you don't understand the problem, and we will have to start from there. Actually, I know you don't understand it, as you can't see that it's formally equivalent to the Monty Hall problem.
Perhaps the reason you can't see the formal equivalence is that you are trying to map Tom to the contestant. That is wrong (see previous posts below). Tom, Dick and Harry actually correspond to Monty Hall's
doors, and there is no 'contestant' other than us (the people trying to solve the puzzle).
It's actually exactly the same as the Monty Hall puzzle, with getting hanged being the 'prize'

(), getting reprieved being the goats, Tom being the door chosen by the contestant, and Dick and Harry being the other two doors (Dick corresponding to a goat).
You just have to ignore the fact that the 'prize' isn't a car but a hanging! Tom corresponds not to the contestant but to the contestant's chosen door – there actually isn't anyone corresponding to the contestant in the prisoner version. Well, except that we do, I suppose – if we're trying to guess the unlucky recipient then we should switch our guess from Tom to Harry after the warden's answer.
Now, have another think:
using the correct mapping can you see the formal equivalence between the two puzzles yet?
eta: OneShotKi11, just saw your "Ok I am wrong...." post.
If you understand the Monty Hall puzzle then this post will show you (I hope) why you should use exactly the same reasoning in the prisoners puzzle. The probability of {(contestant's chosen door)|Tom} is 1/3, not 1/2, for exactly the same reason.