3 prisoner puzzle

I hope i was able to clear this situation up for you and show you that you were the one slightly off on the scenario.

Umm, no, sorry. There is no difference between the odds as seen by someone outside and the odds as seen by Tom - the odds are the odds.

You could ask about the situation in which the warden flips a coin, heads Tom dies, tails one of Dick or Harry dies, but that wasn't the scenario.

The warden rolls an ordinary six-sided die. If he gets 1 or 2, Tom dies tomorrow. 3 or 4, Harry dies, 5 or 6, Dick dies. Tom knows that's how the warden decides (but not what he rolled). What are Tom's odds of dying tomorrow?
 
Step B is where your problem lies. We are told clearly that one of the three prisoners has been randomly selected to be hanged. How you translate that into 50/50 is beyond me.

Funny enough, a couple weeks ago I was discussing Monty Hall with my parents, and my pops was quite insistent that it was 1/2 from the beginning. It took 24 trials with 2 jokers and an ace to convince him otherwise.

Don't get caught up in the differences in scenarios, look at the similarities. Let's turn the 3 prisoners into Monty Hall. If you can correctly bet which prisoner is hanged, you'll win a kajillion bucks. You choose Tom. Monty says, well, I'll tell you, it's not Dick. Would you like to change your bet?
 
I'm sure somebody's already said this, but I haven't read the thread, so... sorry in advance for repeating. :)

IMO, nothing has changed, because this isn't a question about probability at all. Harry's "chances" of being executed are either 100% or 0%, depending on whether he's the guy who's gonna get hung. The warden already knows what the outcome is, so there's nothing random about it.

From Harry's perspective, it's gonna be a long night. :p
 
IMO, nothing has changed, because this isn't a question about probability at all. Harry's "chances" of being executed are either 100% or 0%, depending on whether he's the guy who's gonna get hung. The warden already knows what the outcome is, so there's nothing random about it.

So if the warden hasn't rolled the dice yet (or made his decision some other way) and he doesn't know what the outcome is, Harry's chances of are still either 100% or 0% because he's either going to get hung or not?
 
Last edited:
You are correct that from the beginning it's Tom v. Harry + Dick, but it's 1/3 Tom and 2/3 Harry + Dick. When Tom receives the new information, his odds of being hanged remain at 1/3, while Harry's odds go up to 2/3, just like the Monty Hall problem.

Just like Monty Hall, it can help to understand if you increase the number of prisoners (doors). If there were 1000 prisoners, and Tom asks the guard the question, and the guard gives the names of 998 prisoners that will go free, what are Tom's chances of being hanged?

It is so simple and i dont know how else to explain it to you guys.

This is totally different then the Monty Hall problem and scenario. The Monty Hall problem is very simple and i get that concept completely.

Harry and dick make up 2/3 of the parties involved but that does not mean the probability is 2/3 because they do so. We know for sure that one in the 2/3 group is not being hung all while we have no clue of Toms outcome.

From the start Tom knows one of them is going home free so he knows for sure that they can not have a 2/3 probability of being hung. He can know this because he already knows that one of them is going home thus eliminating your possible answer.
No way can it possibly be 2/3 odds from the get go so you can not be correct!

This is so simple and i cant understand why not a single person here can grasp this. You guys are comparing it to much to the Monty Hall problem when it is infact is different.

Like i said the Monty hall scenario gives an outsider a choice at guessing a 1/3 probability.

While this Problem is giving an individual in the scenario insider information before any Odds are even available!!!!


For the scenario to be the same as the Mony Hall scenario it would have to follow like this....

There are 5 individuals. There are 3 prisoners a Warren, and then a spectator.
The warren then walks up to the spectator and says "2 out of the 3 prisoners will go home tomorrow while one is hung, can you guess which one?" The spectator would then make his guess with no other variables to effect the situation.
His odds would then be 1/3 of being correct. If the warren now took a prisoner and told the spectator this man will be set free, do you want to change your pick with this new information?

Now the odds would be 2/3 like you have stated, and the situation would have had to go down like this in order to compare it to the Monty Hall situation.

Tom is not trying to guess the probability of 3 people for he knows one is not being included from the start. He is only figuring the probability of 2 people.
Himself and the man from the opposing group who he is not sure if he is going home.
 
Umm, no, sorry. There is no difference between the odds as seen by someone outside and the odds as seen by Tom - the odds are the odds.

You could ask about the situation in which the warden flips a coin, heads Tom dies, tails one of Dick or Harry dies, but that wasn't the scenario.

The warden rolls an ordinary six-sided die. If he gets 1 or 2, Tom dies tomorrow. 3 or 4, Harry dies, 5 or 6, Dick dies. Tom knows that's how the warden decides (but not what he rolled). What are Tom's odds of dying tomorrow?

Yes there is a difference and im guessing you dont understand the different variables scenario that is poised in these type of questions.

Again i completely understand how Monty Halls scenarios works. You keep talking to me like i dont know.

Picture that you are Tom and you are sitting with Harry and Dick.
The warrden comes to you and says "tomorrow 2 of you will go home while one will be executed."
Can you now guess your odds?
You look over at Harry and Dick and know that one of them is going home for sure!
What you dont know is if the other individual in the group or yourself will be executed. Thats all you dont know. There are really only 2 people in this situation. Tom and the man who isnt going home for sure in the other group!

The secnario is

TOM vs Opposing individual

With one man being set free already and is now not part of the equation!
 
So if the warden hasn't rolled the dice yet (or made his decision some other way) and he doesn't know what the outcome is, Harry's chances of are still either 100% or 0% because he's either going to get hung or not?

The Warren has nothing to do with the situation!!!!
Whether he has already chosen who is going to be executed or not has no baring on the probability Tom is facing.

Tom has been told that 2 men are being set free and 1 will die.
He looks at his 2 buddies and knows for aFACT one of them is a freeman.
He also realizes that it leaves him to battle with the one remaining man in the group.

2 people are all that matter in this secnario. Tom and Harry.

You actually dont need to know who is being set free to solve this.

Its tom vs the other man not being set free.
 
The secnario is

TOM vs Opposing individual

With one man being set free already and is now not part of the equation!
But it's also Harry versus opposing individual and Dick versus opposing individual. In the scenario you just laid out 3 people have a 50/50 chance of being executed. That doesn't add up.
 
From the start Tom knows one of them is going home free so he knows for sure that they can not have a 2/3 probability of being hung. He can know this because he already knows that one of them is going home thus eliminating your possible answer.
No way can it possibly be 2/3 odds from the get go so you can not be correct!

Sure, there is a 100% chance at least one of them will go free...and there is a 2/3 chance that one will die.

Make it ten, no, make it Tom vs. 99 other people. At least one of the other people will go free. At least 98 of the other people will go free. So what? Tom has a 1% chance of being the unlucky sole and the others, 99%.

Even if the warden is kind enough to name 98 of the others as "not it", that still leaves Tom at 1% (and the unfortunate one other remaining at 99%).
 
Last edited:
Yes there is a difference and im guessing you dont understand the different variables scenario that is poised in these type of questions.

Again i completely understand how Monty Halls scenarios works. You keep talking to me like i dont know.

Picture that you are Tom and you are sitting with Harry and Dick.
The warrden comes to you and says "tomorrow 2 of you will go home while one will be executed."
Can you now guess your odds?

Assuming a fair selection process: 1/3.

You look over at Harry and Dick and know that one of them is going home for sure!

Meanwhile, Harry is looking at Dick and myself, knowing for sure that one of us is going home.

Dick is glancing over at Harry and me, certain in the knowledge that one of the two of us is going home.

What you dont know is if the other individual in the group or yourself will be executed.

What I also don't know is who of the other two will be the lucky one. Dick or Harry? (Or both?)

Thats all you dont know. There are really only 2 people in this situation. Tom and the man who isnt going home for sure in the other group!

The secnario is

TOM vs Opposing individual

In a way, yes. But that doesn't mean anything, since you can look at the scenario in three different ways, from the viewpoint of each of the three prisoners.

With one man being set free already and is now not part of the equation!

But nobody is set free already. The prisoners are all clueless about the outcome. Nobody can point at either one and know that that person will go free.
 
Umm, no, sorry. There is no difference between the odds as seen by someone outside and the odds as seen by Tom - the odds are the odds.?

Well... No. This is one of the things that confuses: the odds as seen from your viewpoint change depending on what information you have.

- At the beginning, before the warden rolls the die, the odds of each prisoner being executed are 1/3 as seen both from the viewpoint of the warden and from the viewpoints of all three prisoners.

- When the warden has rolled the die, he knows who will die. Let's say it's Harry. The odds as seen from the warden's viewpoint are now 1 (certainty) that Harry is going to be executed and zero for the other two prisoners. Since the prisoners have no new information, each prisoner still calculates his odds to be 1/3.

- When the warden says to Tom "Dick goes free", Tom gets new information about Dick and Harry. The odds of being executed as seen from Tom's viewpoint are now Dick zero, Harry 2/3 and Tom 1/3. The other two prisoners, having no new information, still consider their odds to be 1/3.

The odds that an outside person calculates also depends on what information they are given. As the problem is stated, we get just the information that Tom gets, so we calculate the odds as Tom does.

And yes: the basic principle is the same as in the Monty Hall problem.
 
Last edited:
From the start there chances of [tom] being hung were always 50% and not 33% like most will claim.
Huh?

The reason being is that you can automatically eliminate one of the other prisoners from the equation once the guard informed them that 2 would go home and one would die, thus making it now down to a 50-50 chance..

Why is this? Why is Tom special in this way? Can't I apply the same logic to Dick and Harry? Thus giving each of Tom, Dick and Harry 50% chance of being hung? (Which is absurd, because probabilities must sum to unity of course.)
 
Well... No. This is one of the things that confuses: the odds as seen from your viewpoint change depending on what information you have.

Yes, of course - that's the whole point. But given the same information, everyone computes the odds the same way (unless they do it wrong, as oneshot is doing).
 
Harry and dick make up 2/3 of the parties involved but that does not mean the probability is 2/3 because they do so. We know for sure that one in the 2/3 group is not being hung all while we have no clue of Toms outcome.

From the start Tom knows one of them is going home free so he knows for sure that they can not have a 2/3 probability of being hung. He can know this because he already knows that one of them is going home thus eliminating your possible answer.
No way can it possibly be 2/3 odds from the get go so you can not be correct!

Can you answer this? If Tom thinks he has a 50% chance of dying, what do Dick and Harry think? Remember, they're in precisely the same situation as Tom.

According to you they must also think they have a 50% chance of dying, right? But now it's obvious that all three are wrong, because the odds must add up to 100%.

See?

If you don't believe me, do an experiment with cards. You'll convince yourself in 5 minutes.
 
The warden rolls an ordinary six-sided die. If he gets 1 or 2, Tom dies tomorrow. 3 or 4, Harry dies, 5 or 6, Dick dies. Tom knows that's how the warden decides (but not what he rolled). What are Tom's odds of dying tomorrow?

Tom knows that Dick will not be the one that dies. What is the probability that the die rolled a 1 or 2 given that the die did not roll a 5 or 6? This makes it look easy but it is an incorrect way to state the problem because it doesn't cover all the cases.

If Tom is the one that dies, the warden will have to choose between Harry and Dick to say which will be set free. Lets assume that the warden flips a coin to make this decision.

Case Die Coin
a. 1,2 H Tom dies, warden says Dick will be freed (P=2/6 * 1/2 = 1/6)
b. 1,2 T Tom dies, warden says Harry will be freed (P=2/6 * 1/2 = 1/6)
c. 3,4 - Harry dies, warden says Dick will be freed (P=2/6 = 1/3)
d. 5,6 - Dick dies, warden says Harry will be freed (P=2/6 = 1/3)

These are the probabilities for all possible outcomes before the die is rolled and before the coin is flipped. (P = 1/6 + 1/6 + 1/3 + 1/3 = 1)

When Tom hear the warden say Dick will be freed, only cases A and C are now possible. Probability that Tom dies given that warden says Dick will be freed: P(a)/P(a+c) = 1/6 / (1/6+1/3) = 1/3.

If you ignore that extra coin flip you incorrectly conclude that the probability for Tom dying is 1/2.
 
Assuming a fair selection process: 1/3.
How did i assume a fair selection? What does that even mean? Your comment doesnt make sense.


Meanwhile, Harry is looking at Dick and myself, knowing for sure that one of us is going home.

Dick is glancing over at Harry and me, certain in the knowledge that one of the two of us is going home.

I agree, what is your point? Are all 3 not completely correct when they state one of the other 2 will be going home?
The scenario is only asking about Tom as well.


What I also don't know is who of the other two will be the lucky one. Dick or Harry? (Or both?)
It is not asking for you to guess who of the other 2 will be the lucky one to go home, so why does this concern you?
It asks what is Toms odds. Which breaks down to him being able to guess if he himself is going home.
If you are actually considering this to help solve the problem it means you are adding things not required to solve the equation.



In a way, yes. But that doesn't mean anything, since you can look at the scenario in three different ways, from the viewpoint of each of the three prisoners.
Again it doesnt not ask you anything else about these people. Who cares about them they are just numbers now.
One of which wont be there in the morning and Tom already knows this so he can assume its left between him and one other person.



But nobody is set free already. The prisoners are all clueless about the outcome. Nobody can point at either one and know that that person will go free.
Yes this is true but again we are only talking about Tom and Tom already knows that one man is going free from the remaining 2 so you must subtract that individual from the start. Thus bringing this equation down to only 2 prisoners. Doesnt matter which prisoners, just know 2 are left.
Whats are the odds left between these 2 people?
 
Tom knows that Dick will not be the one that dies. What is the probability that the die rolled a 1 or 2 given that the die did not roll a 5 or 6? This makes it look easy but it is an incorrect way to state the problem because it doesn't cover all the cases.

That wasn't the question I posed. Oneshot was claiming that FROM THE BEGINNING the odds were 1/2, before he even talks to the warden. I was just trying to show him why that's wrong.

<snip>
If you ignore that extra coin flip you incorrectly conclude that the probability for Tom dying is 1/2.

No you won't, not unless you do it wrong. You don't need to pay any attention to the warden's decision process, unless you know that it's asymmetrical between Dick and Harry.
 
We start by dividing the three people in to two groups. The group that contains Tom and the group that contains Dick and Harry. Tom knows that he will be facing one man from the other group in what appears to be a 50/50 chance. However, the chance that the excuted prisoner is in the two man group is 2/3, while the chance that the excuted prisoner is in the one man group is 1/3. So the chance that the executed prisoner is in the group that Tom faces (regardless of how many people are in that group at the end) is 2/3 while the chance that his group (consisting of himself) contains the executed prisoner is 1/3. This is more obvious if you start with 10 people and divide them into two groups - one containing Tom and one containing all the rest. The chance that Tom's group contained the person chosen for execution is 1/10, while the chance that the other group contains the executed person is 9/10. If the warden starts eliminating people for Tom, so that at the end only one person is left, that 9/10 probability rests on one man's shoulders.

Linda
 
Ok i am wrong....

Why was my initial answer of there being a 50% chance of him being executed wrong?
Why did i get that answer?

What is the answer when the warren first tells him the scenario?

Then what is the answer at the end of the story?

Can some just simply put the answers for me so that i dont have to read through your mathematics. I just want to see the answer to each question.
 
Umm, no, sorry. There is no difference between the odds as seen by someone outside and the odds as seen by Tom - the odds are the odds.
Well... No. This is one of the things that confuses: the odds as seen from your viewpoint change depending on what information you have.
True, and the way sol invictus expressed his point could add to the confusion, as badnewsBH and possibly OneShotKi11 seem not to understand that probability is a function of the available information, and therefore in principle varies between different individuals at the same time, and over time for the same individual – it is not a property of the event itself.

However (as sol invictus presumably meant), in this case there is no difference in the odds as calculated by Tom and as calculated by the audience, as we have the same information.


The Warren has nothing to do with the situation!!!!
Whether he has already chosen who is going to be executed or not has no baring on the probability Tom is facing.

Tom has been told that 2 men are being set free and 1 will die.
He looks at his 2 buddies and knows for aFACT one of them is a freeman.
He also realizes that it leaves him to battle with the one remaining man in the group.

2 people are all that matter in this secnario. Tom and Harry.

You actually dont need to know who is being set free to solve this.

Its tom vs the other man not being set free.
OneShotKi11, you are completely wrong, and I am completely confident that I can explain why, to your satisfaction. All you have to do is stop arguing and start listening, then I guarantee the penny will drop.

In my experience, when someone has got stuck with a false perception in a probability question, there are two stages to setting them straight. First, get them to see that their 'answer' must be wrong; second, show why the right answer is right.

We will have to go slowly, and make sure you are in agreement at each step before proceeding. First, do you accept that the unlucky prisoner has been selected, and his identity is known to the warden, before the conversation between Tom and the warden takes place? And therefore, before the conversation, for each of Tom, Dick and Harry the probability according to the warden is either 0 or 1? And further, according to Tom, Dick, Harry or anyone who hasn't been told the identity of the unlucky one, the probability is 1/3 for each prisoner?

If not, you don't understand the problem, and we will have to start from there. Actually, I know you don't understand it, as you can't see that it's formally equivalent to the Monty Hall problem.

Perhaps the reason you can't see the formal equivalence is that you are trying to map Tom to the contestant. That is wrong (see previous posts below). Tom, Dick and Harry actually correspond to Monty Hall's doors, and there is no 'contestant' other than us (the people trying to solve the puzzle).
It's actually exactly the same as the Monty Hall puzzle, with getting hanged being the 'prize' (:(), getting reprieved being the goats, Tom being the door chosen by the contestant, and Dick and Harry being the other two doors (Dick corresponding to a goat).
You just have to ignore the fact that the 'prize' isn't a car but a hanging! Tom corresponds not to the contestant but to the contestant's chosen door – there actually isn't anyone corresponding to the contestant in the prisoner version. Well, except that we do, I suppose – if we're trying to guess the unlucky recipient then we should switch our guess from Tom to Harry after the warden's answer.

Now, have another think: using the correct mapping can you see the formal equivalence between the two puzzles yet?

eta: OneShotKi11, just saw your "Ok I am wrong...." post.

If you understand the Monty Hall puzzle then this post will show you (I hope) why you should use exactly the same reasoning in the prisoners puzzle. The probability of {(contestant's chosen door)|Tom} is 1/3, not 1/2, for exactly the same reason.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom