DevilsAdvocate
Philosopher
- Joined
- Nov 18, 2004
- Messages
- 7,686
The confusion in both the Monty Hall and 3 Prisoners riddles is the difference between possibilities and probabilities.
There are 100 prisoners, each in confined cells with no communication with the other prisoners. The warden announces that at the end of the week, 99 prisoners will be release and 1 prisoner will be hanged. The warden cannot reveal to any prisoner their fate before the end of the week. The warden randomly selects the prisoner to be hanged: Arthur Dent.
The prisoners get rowdy and demand some information. The warden gives each prisoner a list of 98 prisoners that will be released. To comply with the law, the list provided to each prisoner does not include that prisoner or the prisoner that will be hanged. So, for each prisoner, the list of prisoners that could be hanged would include their name and Arthur Dent, except for Arthur Dent which would include his name and another prisoner. There are only two names not on the list, and you are one of them. Therefore, each prisoner could conclude that his probability of being hanged has just gone from 1% up to 50%!!!!
Each prisoner is in a position where the person hanged is him or one other prisoner. It has to be one of those two. So it is 50%. But how can it be that each of 100 prisoners now has a 50% chance of being hanged when we know that only 1 out of 100 prisoners will actually be hanged?
The probabilities and possibilities have become confused. From the start, the probabilities of getting hanged is 1% (1 prisoner out of 100 prisoners). Also from the start, the possibilities of getting hanged is 50% (Hanged/Not Hanged).
From the start, each prisoner has a 50% possibility of getting Hanged/Hot hanged. However, the probability for the Hanged possibility is 1% and the probability for the Hot hanged possibility is 99%.
In order for the warden to not violate law and give anything away, he can only give enough information so that the probabilities do not exceed the possibilities. We know that at least 98 other prisoners will be released. If the warden gives us the 98 names, it doesn’t matter. From your perspective, it comes down to you and another person, so the probability is still the same at 50%.
Here’s another way to look at the significance of “you” asking the question: The Warden can’t tell you your fate. You are the last to know your fate. So, you have 100 prisoners listed from 1 to 100. You are number 100. Every hour, for 100 hours, a prisoners name is drawn to be not released. The warden then goes down the list of prisoners, and the first prisoner who has not already been released and who’s name has not been drawn, is released. So, as the prisoners are released, we get down to something like:
98. Dick
99. Harry
100. You
A number is drawn. If 98 is drawn, 99 Harry is released. If 99 or 100 is drawn, 98 Dick is released. No matter what the previous draws are, the final draw will come down to 100 You and someone else. So, from the very get-go, 100 You has a 50% chance of being the one hanged. This can be presented to each prisoner where “You” is that prisoner’s name at position 100. So each prisoner could conclude they have a 50% probability of being hanged.
But this is not the case because probability is based on a set number of circumstances. In this case, each prisoner has a DIFFERENT set of circumstances. Each prisoner has a 1% probability of being hanged, but a 50% possibility of being hanged. When only 3 prisoners are involved, the 50% possibility and the 50% probability can be easily confused.
CONCLUSION: If Tom, Dick, or Harry will be executed, Tom gains no information about his own fate by knowing that either Dick or Harry will not be executed. However, if the person to be executed has already been determined, if Tom learns that another prisoner will be not be executed means that the other prisoner who is not to be not executed is more likely to be executed. That doesn’t change Tom’s position. So if the warden told Tom that Dick would be set free, then it is 2/3 likely that Harry will be executed, and still 1/3 likely that Tom will be executed.
However, if the “prisoner to not be set free” is determined each time, then both Tom and Harry are 1/2 likely to be hanged. If Tom is in the “special” position where his fate will not be revealed until the end, then his fate has nothing to do with how many prisoners there are but only with the options for his fate, which is 50% hanged.
Don’t confuse probabilities with possibilities.
There are 100 prisoners, each in confined cells with no communication with the other prisoners. The warden announces that at the end of the week, 99 prisoners will be release and 1 prisoner will be hanged. The warden cannot reveal to any prisoner their fate before the end of the week. The warden randomly selects the prisoner to be hanged: Arthur Dent.
The prisoners get rowdy and demand some information. The warden gives each prisoner a list of 98 prisoners that will be released. To comply with the law, the list provided to each prisoner does not include that prisoner or the prisoner that will be hanged. So, for each prisoner, the list of prisoners that could be hanged would include their name and Arthur Dent, except for Arthur Dent which would include his name and another prisoner. There are only two names not on the list, and you are one of them. Therefore, each prisoner could conclude that his probability of being hanged has just gone from 1% up to 50%!!!!
Each prisoner is in a position where the person hanged is him or one other prisoner. It has to be one of those two. So it is 50%. But how can it be that each of 100 prisoners now has a 50% chance of being hanged when we know that only 1 out of 100 prisoners will actually be hanged?
The probabilities and possibilities have become confused. From the start, the probabilities of getting hanged is 1% (1 prisoner out of 100 prisoners). Also from the start, the possibilities of getting hanged is 50% (Hanged/Not Hanged).
From the start, each prisoner has a 50% possibility of getting Hanged/Hot hanged. However, the probability for the Hanged possibility is 1% and the probability for the Hot hanged possibility is 99%.
In order for the warden to not violate law and give anything away, he can only give enough information so that the probabilities do not exceed the possibilities. We know that at least 98 other prisoners will be released. If the warden gives us the 98 names, it doesn’t matter. From your perspective, it comes down to you and another person, so the probability is still the same at 50%.
Here’s another way to look at the significance of “you” asking the question: The Warden can’t tell you your fate. You are the last to know your fate. So, you have 100 prisoners listed from 1 to 100. You are number 100. Every hour, for 100 hours, a prisoners name is drawn to be not released. The warden then goes down the list of prisoners, and the first prisoner who has not already been released and who’s name has not been drawn, is released. So, as the prisoners are released, we get down to something like:
98. Dick
99. Harry
100. You
A number is drawn. If 98 is drawn, 99 Harry is released. If 99 or 100 is drawn, 98 Dick is released. No matter what the previous draws are, the final draw will come down to 100 You and someone else. So, from the very get-go, 100 You has a 50% chance of being the one hanged. This can be presented to each prisoner where “You” is that prisoner’s name at position 100. So each prisoner could conclude they have a 50% probability of being hanged.
But this is not the case because probability is based on a set number of circumstances. In this case, each prisoner has a DIFFERENT set of circumstances. Each prisoner has a 1% probability of being hanged, but a 50% possibility of being hanged. When only 3 prisoners are involved, the 50% possibility and the 50% probability can be easily confused.
CONCLUSION: If Tom, Dick, or Harry will be executed, Tom gains no information about his own fate by knowing that either Dick or Harry will not be executed. However, if the person to be executed has already been determined, if Tom learns that another prisoner will be not be executed means that the other prisoner who is not to be not executed is more likely to be executed. That doesn’t change Tom’s position. So if the warden told Tom that Dick would be set free, then it is 2/3 likely that Harry will be executed, and still 1/3 likely that Tom will be executed.
However, if the “prisoner to not be set free” is determined each time, then both Tom and Harry are 1/2 likely to be hanged. If Tom is in the “special” position where his fate will not be revealed until the end, then his fate has nothing to do with how many prisoners there are but only with the options for his fate, which is 50% hanged.
Don’t confuse probabilities with possibilities.