10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

And when the class bullies drown the class nerdwimp in a trough full of pudding, what will you say then, hm? Think of the children, for God's sake!!! We need to ban all weapons, including pudding and troughs.

Except butterscotch pudding, of course. Yum.

When you outlaw pudding, only outlaws will have pudding.
 
And when the class bullies drown the class nerdwimp in a trough full of pudding, what will you say then, hm? Think of the children, for God's sake!!! We need to ban all weapons, including pudding and troughs.

Except butterscotch pudding, of course. Yum.

ButterSCOTCH!?!?!? That would violate the ZT policy against drugs and alcohol, no doubt! Think man, think!
 
You simply want people with your biases to be in charge and use your biases to base their decisions on.
Nope--
We just want your ilk to quit finding excuses to bring everybody down to the lowest common denominator. Placing a 10 year old girl at the "criminal" level will certainly make her want to stay in school and graduate. She is now a CRIMINAL, you fool! That puts her on a par with the drug dealers and cutpurses, as far as the law goes!
What a miserable life you must lead. But it is one may to enforce equality:Make everybody a crimina!
 
Again we are getting into mixed definitions here. A pen and pencil are not considered weapons by any law classifying objects as weapons for the purposes of determining what is legal to carry.

The definition of weapon in Florida school system has been posted here before, why do you fail to see it? The knife in question is clearly classed as a weapon by Florida laws with regards to being in school.


Florida law, as cited earlier in this thread. Bolding mine.

law said:
(13) “Weapon” means any dirk, knife, metallic knuckles, slungshot, billie,
tear gas gun, chemical weapon or device, or other deadly weapon except
a firearm or a common pocketknife, plastic knife, or blunt-bladed table knife


Leaving aside for the moment the fact that they are using the word to define itself (something my English teachers told me was an absolute no-no), I can certainly imagine a pencil being used as a deadly weapon. According to Florida state law, and you, pencils should therefore be banned.

Once again, is a pencil a weapon? How do you define weapon? (How do you define it?)

Suppose this girl were an expert at kickboxing. Do you think she should be arrested because she used her "weapons" to play kickball at recess?


ETA: How come the word "banned" showed up as a link to a definition? Is this a new feature?
 
Last edited:
ButterSCOTCH!?!?!? That would violate the ZT policy against drugs and alcohol, no doubt! Think man, think!
The gods do not deduct from a man's allotted years on earth the time he spends eating butterscotch pudding.
 
Then why are you bothered by simply stateing that you want a biased system?

I'm not. I am only reluctant to agree to the term "bias" as you are using it to imply, without basis in fact, it is necessarily a bad thing that will be abused.

Whether you realize it or not, any solution to this problem is going to have inherent bias starting with the assertion that there's even a problem to solve. The people who wrote the law defining a steak knife as a weapon but an ordinary pocket knife is not used their judgment and discretion to make that determination. The school board that decided every infraction, no matter how minor, would be punished to the extent of the law was using their judgment and discretion to make that decision. The teachers that called the police used their judgment and discretion to decide to follow the policy rather than risk their jobs (I assume). And you are using your biases to assert that the people who directly witnessed the infraction and were in the best position to determine whether or not she was a threat are the least qualified to make the decision to prosecute it.
 
Leaving aside for the moment the fact that they are using the word to define itself (something my English teachers told me was an absolute no-no), I can certainly imagine a pencil being used as a deadly weapon. According to Florida state law, and you, pencils should therefore be banned.

And the point is that the knife she had was exlicitly mentioned. If it did not have that then you can bring an axe to school as it is not a " dirk, knife, metallic knuckles, slungshot, billie, tear gas gun, chemical weapon or device".
 
I'm not. I am only reluctant to agree to the term "bias" as you are using it to imply, without basis in fact, it is necessarily a bad thing that will be abused.

I am using it as it is used in scientific investigations all the time.
Whether you realize it or not, any solution to this problem is going to have inherent bias starting with the assertion that there's even a problem to solve. The people who wrote the law defining a steak knife as a weapon but an ordinary pocket knife is not used their judgment and discretion to make that determination. The school board that decided every infraction, no matter how minor, would be punished to the extent of the law was using their judgment and discretion to make that decision. The teachers that called the police used their judgment and discretion to decide to follow the policy rather than risk their jobs (I assume). And you are using your biases to assert that the people who directly witnessed the infraction and were in the best position to determine whether or not she was a threat are the least qualified to make the decision to prosecute it.
It will be built on their biases, but it does permit more clarity.

For example sure it is very illegal for two underage people to have sex, they both are committing statutory rape. The current system depends on the selectively choosing to not prosecute those cases where people think there is not a clear victim, like two people of the same age. But that breaks down when the one deciding the when to apply the law sees things differently and then people go to prison for years.

If you don't want prosecutors and such to have the ability to do things like that the solution is better laws, not depending on those prosecuting the law to have the same biases as you.
 
And the point is that the knife she had was exlicitly mentioned. If it did not have that then you can bring an axe to school as it is not a " dirk, knife, metallic knuckles, slungshot, billie, tear gas gun, chemical weapon or device".

Please show me where "steak knife" is explicitly mentioned.

And if by "explicitly" you mean the reference to "knife" in the law, well, then I maintain that the feet of a 10-year old girl who kick-boxes is also explicitly mentioned, where it says "other deadly weapons".
 
What it comes down to is this: the purpose of the law is to prevent anyone from hurting anyone else.

I don't think there is anyone involved in this news story who seriously thinks the girl was intending, planning, or even capable of using that steak knife to hurt anyone, except the cow, who was already dead and roasted.

Therefore, common sense should win out over the letter of the law. Just like a cop may give you a warning for speeding, rather than a citation, the teachers could have (and should have) easily said "We're taking that knife from you, don't bring it again."
 
Please show me where "steak knife" is explicitly mentioned.

And if by "explicitly" you mean the reference to "knife" in the law, well, then I maintain that the feet of a 10-year old girl who kick-boxes is also explicitly mentioned, where it says "other deadly weapons".

Knife is mentioned, with an exception made for pocketknives. Seems pretty clear that all knives that are not pocket knives are illegal.

THe kick boxing thing is a stupid urban legend, no matter what you do, your natural appendages are not considered weapons.
 
Just like a cop may give you a warning for speeding, rather than a citation, the teachers could have (and should have) easily said "We're taking that knife from you, don't bring it again."
Couldn't agree more. One word: sanity.
 
Please show me where "steak knife" is explicitly mentioned.

And if by "explicitly" you mean the reference to "knife" in the law, well, then I maintain that the feet of a 10-year old girl who kick-boxes is also explicitly mentioned, where it says "other deadly weapons".
A student was charged in NM last year for carrying a weapon--a cut-off baseball bat.
It was his baseball trophy--the miniature bat that came with it.
Zero Tolerance. They gave it to him, fer cryin' out loud! Ill try to find a link..
 
I think in such things there's room for SOME discretion, and SOME specific guidelines for the sake of consistency and fairness. You need that, but you also can't have a rule that covers every single situation. Every time you try something comes up that doesn't fit.

In the case of objects that have legitimate purposes besides harming someone, it would make sense to consider the student's behavior and history. If they were not threatening anyone, and had not been caught with a banned knife before, a first offense would naturally seem to be confiscation/warning.
 
10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School
What would have happened if she had cut the cheese?


A note on weapons:

A very innovative weapon I saw in action in fifth grade was a compass, the 15 cent sort that you use in math class to draw circles, and that you stuck your own pencil into, then clamp it down.

The sharp and pointy end was, well, sharp and pointy.

A November afternoon, waiting for the school bus to go home. Dirk was being his usual assholy self to Mike. He'd been picking on Mike for a couple of days over Mike being a fan of the New Orleans Saints. ( An expansion team, not all that good.)

Mike had, unbeknownst to the rest of us, his compass unfolded in his pocket.

Dirk came over and started to tease Mike, who told him to leave him alone.

Dirk pushed him, as he had on other days.

Mike came up off the ground with the compass in his hand and tackled Dirk, stabbing his right thigh a few times (I was stunned, a spectator to something I didn't expect) before the compass gave way and ended up stuck in Dirk's leg.

Dirk could not believe what was sticking in his leg. While he stared at it, Mike kicked him as hard as he could, in the face.

Blood flew. Dirk was not doing too hot, holding his hands to his face. Mike started kicking him in the back.

The Patrols at this time arrived, and broke up this fight. Teachers arrived.

I got to miss the school bus home while we all sat there, me and three other witnesses, Dirk, and Mike, and explain what went on to the Principal.

Mike got suspended for three days.

Dirk's face looked like crap for a week or so as it healed.

Dirk didn't screw with Mike much after that.

I didn't either.

DR
 
Last edited:
I am using it as it is used in scientific investigations all the time.

This isn't a scientific investigation.

It will be built on their biases, but it does permit more clarity.

For example sure it is very illegal for two underage people to have sex, they both are committing statutory rape. The current system depends on the selectively choosing to not prosecute those cases where people think there is not a clear victim, like two people of the same age. But that breaks down when the one deciding the when to apply the law sees things differently and then people go to prison for years.

It appears there are only a handful of states that even classify sex between two minors as statutory rape without there being at least a 2 year difference in ages, so your example isn't even true for the most part. Secondly, the appropriateness of underage sex in any case is a much more hotly debated topic than the threat level of this ten-year-old, so your assertion that bias will necessarily adversely affect the decision to prosecute is unfounded.
 
So you think that children should be able to bring weapons to school with out limit?
Actually, apparently children can bring weapons to school. Nobody stopped this girl at the door with it, it was only found after she took it out to cut her meat. A student who brought a weapon to school to do harm would have done so despite the asinine law.

The law nor the enforcement of it didn't make one single child in the school safer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom