10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

No it isn't. You see steak really shouldn't be tough like shoe leather requireing a special knife to cut it.

:-/

So which fixed blade knives with a blade legth up to 6" are acceptable to bring to school?

All I did was define a steak knife in the fashion a law would. Many here say that she should have been able to bring the knife to shool with out problem so it is a position that they hold if they do not articulate in the fashion of an actual legal ruleing.
 
Last edited:
Without checking them all, 17 out of 50 I think qualifies as a handful. And even if it doesn't, it still doesn't support your point.

So 25% of the population is a handfull, and a third of the states is a handful?
 
Apologies if someone else has pointed this out, as I've not read the entire thread, but less than a week earlier in the same state a 10 year old was injured by a knife she found on a school bus:

http://www.news4jax.com/news/14839200/detail.html

Seems to me that, while a felony charge (if the girl was actually indicted) may be a bit extreme, but bringing in the police to highlight the potential seriousness of young children carrying knives is not.
 
Ya know, this is just in passing... but seriously PT, how old are you? How can we possibly take you seriously when you're incapable of either spelling properly in the first place (USING, not "useing", for example), or at the very least using a spell checker?

This may sound like an ad hom. attack, but I think it's a legitimate question. How can you take someone's arguments 100% seriously when they demonstrate a basic lack of capability to spell properly? This isn't the first time I've noticed this with your posts, and one reason I have learned to pretty much ignore whatever you say.

Seriously, you type like you're 16.

And how seriously can we take you when you refuse to even do the most basic research?
 
Really....

1/4 of under aged in this country have only the good will of prosecutors preventing them from being charged for having consensual sex with people their own age. When prosecutors use their wisdom and judgment and prosecute these people how is that not exactly the thing you want to happen? You want people to have that kind of discretion then you need to support their use of it as they see fit. Not as you see fit.
 
1/4 of under aged in this country have only the good will of prosecutors preventing them from being charged for having consensual sex with people their own age. When prosecutors use their wisdom and judgment and prosecute these people how is that not exactly the thing you want to happen? You want people to have that kind of discretion then you need to support their use of it as they see fit. Not as you see fit.

Assumptions, assumptions.

But, as I said, I'm done.
 
Last edited:
After 6 pages of bickering, doesn't it come down to the fact that, yes, preventing knives in school is not a bad idea, but calling the cops is really dumb?

Given that being the case, then the complaint here should be against the Florida legislature that passed the law requiring the schools to call the cops, not against the teachers/administrators that did it.

I think that is PT's main point.

Next time, maybe she should just use her pocket knife to cut the steak?
Problem solved!
(unless she forgot to wash it after field dressing the deer she got with her paperclip slingshot...:D)
 
So you can now only ban weapons in schools if you search all students?
Of course you can prohibit weapons, or even steak knives. But this doesn't prevent weapons from being brought to school, just as the Virginia Tech prohibition didn't keep a nut job from killing a bunch of people. The problem comes when a banned object is blown all out of proportion and police are called and a 10 year old girl is arrested on a felony charge. This is idiocy, plain and simple. And the people who thought up the one size fits all policy that led to the police being called are idiots.

Take away the knife, explain the "no knives" policy to the parents, and the problem is solved and no idiocy takes place. And the kids are every bit as safe as they are without the mindless policy.

I really fear for the kinds of laws that will be passed when the kids who grew up in the "zero tolerance" era take the reins of power thinking that draconian punishments for minor offenses are normal and proper, and common sense and informed judgement takes a back seat to one size fits all policy.
 
No it isn't. You see steak really shouldn't be tough like shoe leather requireing a special knife to cut it.

I am sorry that this is news to you.
I see in the ivory tower only prime filet mignon is served. :rolleyes:

Fact is, you don't know if it was steak, ham, chicken, or pork. You don't know that most people can't afford to buy the finest cuts of meat, you don't know that even the best piece of steak cooked by the finest chef will require a sharp knife when eaten a day later cold.
 
It's interesting how this thread has brought together people from right across the political spectrum. I couldn't agree more with Wildcat's last two posts, and for once, I'm standing shoulder to shoulder with Beeps too.
 
It's interesting how this thread has brought together people from right across the political spectrum. I couldn't agree more with Wildcat's last two posts, and for once, I'm standing shoulder to shoulder with Beeps too.
You can join JoeEllison and Tony and me in the shower...
 
All this fuss makes one realize how times have changed. I recall forty years ago when I brought an inert 4.5 inch Howitzer round to school for "show and tell". The worst that happened was that my presentation bored everyone including the teacher. It occurred to me that if we had the same rules back then as we do today I would probably be lucky to just be getting out of prison by now ... :)
 
Apologies if someone else has pointed this out, as I've not read the entire thread, but less than a week earlier in the same state a 10 year old was injured by a knife she found on a school bus:

http://www.news4jax.com/news/14839200/detail.html

Seems to me that, while a felony charge (if the girl was actually indicted) may be a bit extreme, but bringing in the police to highlight the potential seriousness of young children carrying knives is not.

Had she been stuck by the springs of the seat when she stuck her hand down into the seat should the school system than ban all seats with springs?
 
Had she been stuck by the springs of the seat when she stuck her hand down into the seat should the school system than ban all seats with springs?

Yes, of course. And if she gets sunburned on school property then all children should be required to attend school at night also. What's your point? That children should be allowed to carry knives to school?
 
Yes, of course. And if she gets sunburned on school property then all children should be required to attend school at night also. What's your point? That children should be allowed to carry knives to school?

Of course children should be allowed to carry knives to school.
 
Yes, of course. And if she gets sunburned on school property then all children should be required to attend school at night also. What's your point? That children should be allowed to carry knives to school?

The current mantra is that a kid with any knife, including a penknife, is carrying it with deadly intent.

But we don't care if these same kids cart around a baseball bat.
 
I don't see how anyone can honestly believe that these ZT policies are anything but ridiculous and harmful.

Yeah, I understand that people do. I just don't understand why they do.

ZT policies teach kids 2 things, and 2 things only:

1. Adults have no ******* sense.

2. The rules are arbitrary.

I don't think it's productive to give kids that message.

It doesn't encourage respect for adults, respect for teachers and principals and police and courts in particular, respect for authority in general, or a respect for the law.

And it certainly doesn't encourage free enquiry, or any sense of personal responsibility, or the notion that we all have to communicate and compromise and consider each other's circumstances if we're all going to get along.

Instead, it encourages a disdain for authority and drives home the message that if you want to live your life in a sensible way, you'd better try to dodge the rules, because they're unreasonable.

Even a child can see this is ridiculous.

I don't mean it should be anything-goes. When I was a kid, there wasn't a day at school that I didn't have a knife in my pocket. And sure, some kids had guns in their cars.

Most of us used these "weapons" for mundane purposes.

But then again, we also had stabbings and shootings at my schools. So I'm not opposed to banning knives and guns from schools. No one really needs these things in class.

But this business of "we had no choice" is totally bogus. ZT produces that. If there's a ZT rule, we adults get the luxury of not having to think, or deal with gray areas. But our kids pay the price.

We need to be adults. We need to be the grown-ups. And that means judging the circumstances and coming to a decision based on the facts, not just throwing up our hands and saying "we had no choice".

That's a sorry dodge, and an evasion of responsibility, and even a schoolkid can see that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom