10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

I am sorry if this has been covered and I missed it. It said the girl bought the steak? Did she buy it in school? And if she did, is the cutlery in school not adequate to deal with the cookery in school?
 
I am sorry if this has been covered and I missed it. It said the girl bought the steak? Did she buy it in school? And if she did, is the cutlery in school not adequate to deal with the cookery in school?

I think she brought it as opposed to bought it.
 
After 6 pages of bickering, doesn't it come down to the fact that, yes, preventing knives in school is not a bad idea, but calling the cops is really dumb?

Given that being the case, then the complaint here should be against the Florida legislature that passed the law requiring the schools to call the cops, not against the teachers/administrators that did it.

The law does not require that each and every case be prosecuted to the fullest extent. The policy by the administrators does.
 
Strawman.

Nope observation on how people behave.


Strawman.
So you objected to the charge because she was found when useing it in a non threatening manner, but searching them to find things before they take them out is a strawman?

What the hell are they supposted to do? It really seems that the only time something can be taken away is after they attack someone with it.


If that is your position state it.
 
They can just take it away for return to her parents. This is an issue where even the involvement of the principal would be over the top.
 
You could populate the whole da*n State of Kansas with Scarecrows using the straw you put forth.
And YOU are one of the people we entrust with the education of our future?
No wonder science is dying and the Twoof movement has adherents. Our teachers are incapable of independent and critical thought.
Welcome to Ignore

So asking people to support their claims is a strawman now?
 
But not necessarily in the west. Though with the invention of the telegram and the train and then automobile, it was getting harder and harder to commit crimes.

Regardless, there were a reason things like derringers were made. And it wasn't for reading cards better with.

But the period of the wild west was also a period where justice was handled by vigilance committees in many communities. Because of the relative lack of official law enforcement.

Sometimes these committees worked out well, at least for a while. There is a strong desire expressed by many here for people resolving their disputes themselves violently, that seems to be fitting perfectly with in a context of a vigilance committee.
 
I just want to add that "damn" is not a censored word here, so there is no need for the asterisk to beat the censor.

You may resume your attack on stupidity.

Hahaha, that would be hilarious if a skeptical site, where many members are atheists, actually bothered to censor a swear word that is ONLY a swear word because it's an affront to god. :)
 
Nope observation on how people behave.



So you objected to the charge because she was found when useing it in a non threatening manner, but searching them to find things before they take them out is a strawman?

What the hell are they supposted to do? It really seems that the only time something can be taken away is after they attack someone with it.


If that is your position state it.

I'm objecting to your unsupported assertions of others' positions.
 
So asking people to support their claims is a strawman now?

Making unsupported assertions as to what other people's positions are so you can represent them as unreasonable is building a strawman.

Putting a question mark on the end doesn't change that.
 
I can never find the laughing dog smiley when I need it.

This is a joke, now, right? Go back and read what you wrote. "A steak shouldn't need a steak knife." I'm trying hard not to laugh out loud, so as not to disturb my co-workers.

I suppose her mother should have put the steak in a blender and given the girl a straw? After all, a fork can be used to stab somebody.

No it isn't. You see steak really shouldn't be tough like shoe leather requireing a special knife to cut it.

I am sorry that this is news to you.
 
After 6 pages of bickering, doesn't it come down to the fact that, yes, preventing knives in school is not a bad idea, but calling the cops is really dumb?

No it is that students need to be able to carry fixed blade knives with a blade length up to 6" to school with out any legal action.
 
What are you afraid of?

There is nothing wrong with a pocket knife. I carried my Boy Scout folding knife in my pocket from agest 11-14, to school. (Three inch folding blade, cork punch, bottle opener, can opener.)

No one got hurt. I only got in trouble once, for carving my name in a tree on the playground. The took the knife, gave it to the assistant principle, who would not return it to me until I arrived with my dad to get it.

Yes, dad warmed my rear end for being an idiot.

@pgwenthold: yes, nice summary. Stupid rules make for strange outcomes.

DR


And by florida law you would be fine with that.
 
I'm objecting to your unsupported assertions of others' positions.

People are saying all kinds of things. Like that steak knives are not weapons. It then logical falls out that the man those police shot was for no legitimate reason because steak knives are not dangerous weapons and just because he stabbed a police officer with one was no reason to shoot him.
 
Strawman.

So which fixed blade knives with a blade legth up to 6" are acceptable to bring to school?

All I did was define a steak knife in the fashion a law would. Many here say that she should have been able to bring the knife to shool with out problem so it is a position that they hold if they do not articulate in the fashion of an actual legal ruleing.
 
So you objected to the charge because she was found when useing it in a non threatening manner, but searching them to find things before they take them out is a strawman?

What the hell are they supposted to do? It really seems that the only time something can be taken away is after they attack someone with it.

Ya know, this is just in passing... but seriously PT, how old are you? How can we possibly take you seriously when you're incapable of either spelling properly in the first place (USING, not "useing", for example), or at the very least using a spell checker?

This may sound like an ad hom. attack, but I think it's a legitimate question. How can you take someone's arguments 100% seriously when they demonstrate a basic lack of capability to spell properly? This isn't the first time I've noticed this with your posts, and one reason I have learned to pretty much ignore whatever you say.

Seriously, you type like you're 16.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom