10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

You're not even pretending to be reasonable anymore.
Fixed for you. He stopped pretending to be reasonable somewhere around the middle of page 2, which is why some of us aren't even bothering to reply to his posts in this thread any more.
 
The states that this is the case Arizona, Delaware, Georgia, Indiana, Kansas, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota, South Carolina, Utah, Texas, Vermont, Virginia, Wisconsin.
link

So I count 17 states. Less that I thought, but more than the handful you imply.

See that is an example of how people want children to learn to settle their problems in the manner of adults, with violence.

So you can now only ban weapons in schools if you search all students?

Ah so your claim is that not enough people carry guns with them even when they are allowed to?

Evidence? How old is the mother?

So the solution is to bring back the wild west as that was the safest time in America. You solved your problems yourself with local vigilance committees, what is a more democratic form of justice than that?

That is a different question.

And I guess you really do think that it was a wrongful shooting that guy just because he stabbed the cop with a steak knife. They wouldn't have shot him if it had only punched the cop right?

Also apparently peoples abillity to cook. A steak shouldn't need a steak knife.

You could populate the whole da*n State of Kansas with Scarecrows using the straw you put forth.
And YOU are one of the people we entrust with the education of our future?
No wonder science is dying and the Twoof movement has adherents. Our teachers are incapable of independent and critical thought.
Welcome to Ignore

Da*n. tsg beat me to it.
Strawman.



Strawman.



Strawman.



Strawman.



Strawman.


You're not even pretending to be reasonable anymore.
 
rwguinn said:
You could populate the whole da*n State of Kansas with Scarecrows using the straw you put forth.

I just want to add that "damn" is not a censored word here, so there is no need for the asterisk to beat the censor.

You may resume your attack on stupidity.
 
So the solution is to bring back the wild west as that was the safest time in America. You solved your problems yourself with local vigilance committees, what is a more democratic form of justice than that?

The "wild west" was a safe time in America. I would suggest you not get your history from fiction books, television, and movies.
 
The "wild west" was a safe time in America.

But not necessarily in the west. Though with the invention of the telegram and the train and then automobile, it was getting harder and harder to commit crimes.

Regardless, there were a reason things like derringers were made. And it wasn't for reading cards better with.
 
Last edited:
I just want to add that "damn" is not a censored word here, so there is no need for the asterisk to beat the censor.

You may resume your attack on stupidity.
[martyr mode] You may insert an "M" or an "r" for the "*" as you mood takes you.
I was trying to be nice! And all I get is criticism!
Bah. Humbug. Boo-hoo[/martyr mode]
 
Whose words? If you can't be bothered to read your own posts to see if they make any sense, why should anyone else?

I apologize. I confused you with someone else. You, however, ignored the context in which my comment was made. Fault one for both sides.
 
Also apparently peoples abillity to cook. A steak shouldn't need a steak knife.

I can never find the laughing dog smiley when I need it.

This is a joke, now, right? Go back and read what you wrote. "A steak shouldn't need a steak knife." I'm trying hard not to laugh out loud, so as not to disturb my co-workers.

I suppose her mother should have put the steak in a blender and given the girl a straw? After all, a fork can be used to stab somebody.
 
I think the real question here is what kind of child gets a steak for lunch in school?? All I got where ham sandwiches and the worlds smallest cheapest chocolate bar.
 
I suppose her mother should have put the steak in a blender and given the girl a straw? After all, a fork can be used to stab somebody.

Thats right the only two possible choices available were to take the knife to school or to liquidize the steak and suck it through a straw.

After all everyone knows that steak knifes are only capable of cutting meat on school premises and/or immediately prior to consumption, which explains why she or her mother couldn't have cut it into bite size pieces at home.
 
All I can add to this discussion, having done the majority of my school years in Florida, is that the Florida education system has been a mess since the '80s, and I see no sign of that ever stopping. Many of the schools I attended had at one time or another been test schools for every possible inane policy possible - from year-round schooling, to rotating school years, to 'gradeless' education....

I started encountering zero-tolerance weapon policies in fifth grade, when scissors were routinely locked up in a cabinet behind the teacher, and signed out to each student as needed. For a short time, boots with laces were forbidden because the laces were easier to use to strangle someone. My high school seriously considered trying to replace pencil-and-paper lessons with computer lessons - not to meet the demands of a high-tech society, but to remove pencils from school.

Sounds like things haven't changed.
 
After 6 pages of bickering, doesn't it come down to the fact that, yes, preventing knives in school is not a bad idea, but calling the cops is really dumb?

Given that being the case, then the complaint here should be against the Florida legislature that passed the law requiring the schools to call the cops, not against the teachers/administrators that did it.

I think that is PT's main point.
 
Do you mean that this incident caused a change in your behavior towards Mike?
Yeah. I did not particularly care for him, and had on occasion given him crap. I saw what length he was willing to go on that score, and did not have the will to take my teasing to the point of weapons.

He established that he was willing to go a step beyond fisticuffs. That is as far as I was interested in taking scraps.

DR
 
It is absolutely nothing to do with her capability to use a steak knife.

It is the level of stupidity required to think taking one to school is a good idea.
What are you afraid of?

There is nothing wrong with a pocket knife. I carried my Boy Scout folding knife in my pocket from agest 11-14, to school. (Three inch folding blade, cork punch, bottle opener, can opener.)

No one got hurt. I only got in trouble once, for carving my name in a tree on the playground. The took the knife, gave it to the assistant principle, who would not return it to me until I arrived with my dad to get it.

Yes, dad warmed my rear end for being an idiot.

@pgwenthold: yes, nice summary. Stupid rules make for strange outcomes.

DR
 
Last edited:
Looking at the picture, I'm pretty sure any adult caught carrying that knife in public would be arrested in the UK.
I suspect once the initial report was made, nobody did have much room for initiative.
In my day, the school would have confiscated the knife and phoned my mother.
Who would have told my father.
Who would have given me a hiding.

This may not be pc, but probably wouldn't make the internet, either.

ETA- DR-Your old man sounds a lot like my old man. And here we are, damned sceptics and hoodlums to boot.
 
Last edited:
What are you afraid of?

Being paralysed in an accident. How about you? And how does that have any bearing on this thread?

There is nothing wrong with a pocket knife. I carried my Boy Scout folding knife in my pocket from agest 11-14, to school. (Three inch folding blade, cork punch, bottle opener, can opener.)

As this thread is not about a pocket knife (and indeed the definition of weapon specifically provides that it does not cover pocket knifes) how does this have any relevance to this thread?

I said it was stupid to take a steak knife to school. Do you disagree?
 
No, I entirely agree.

Stupid 10 year old brat. Should've had tons of brains and known that everyone is paranoid of a girl with a steak knife.
 
No, I entirely agree.

Stupid 10 year old brat. Should've had tons of brains and known that everyone is paranoid of a girl with a steak knife.

If you think you need "tons of brains" to work out that taking a knife to a school with a "no weapons" policy is an unwise thing to do, we may have different definitions on what "tons of brains" means.
 
If you think you need "tons of brains" to work out that taking a knife to a school with a "no weapons" policy is an unwise thing to do, we may have different definitions on what "tons of brains" means.
"unwise to bring to school" != "warrants police involvement"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom