10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

I can see the new school policy formulating now. "Zero Tolerance Ban on steak, ham, hard cheese and any other food product that necessitates the use of a weapon for consumption". The little kiddies are going to be stuck eating only peanut butter, marshmallows and Spam water with their fingers until they finish college ...
Fixed. Don't you know some people are allergic to peanuts, and they must be banned from schools? Marshmallows are almost pure sugar; what were you thinking of? And Spam? Are you trying to give kids arteriosclerosis?

Jeeze. Think before you post.

Butterscotch pudding is okay, though. Yum.
 
Fixed. Don't you know some people are allergic to peanuts, and they must be banned from schools? Marshmallows are almost pure sugar; what were you thinking of? And Spam? Are you trying to give kids arteriosclerosis?

Jeeze. Think before you post.

Butterscotch pudding is okay, though. Yum.

Hey, that peanut thing is serious :mad: .

Why won't you think of the children?
 
Jeeze. Think before you post.
Butterscotch pudding is okay, though. Yum.

Okay, my bad. Suppose we could agree upon Butterscotch pudding, Cream of Wheat and grits eaten through a "bendy" straw? Variety's important y'know...
 
I think it highly presumptuous of you to make any judgment about her capability of using a steak knife or her parents' judgment in letting her use one without knowing anything about her except that she's ten.

It is absolutely nothing to do with her capability to use a steak knife.

It is the level of stupidity required to think taking one to school is a good idea.
 
Some kid was cutting a "flacid straw" with meat in it, with a steak knife, and butterscotch came out?
Every now and then someone puts up a post that cuts right through all the confusion and the diversions, to the heart of an issue, and provides a moment of incandescent clarity.

This is such a post.
 
This isn't a scientific investigation.



It appears there are only a handful of states that even classify sex between two minors as statutory rape without there being at least a 2 year difference in ages, so your example isn't even true for the most part.

The states that this is the case Arizona, Delaware, Georgia, Indiana, Kansas, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota, South Carolina, Utah, Texas, Vermont, Virginia, Wisconsin.
link

So I count 17 states. Less that I thought, but more than the handful you imply.
 
...while the girl in this thread gets suspended for ten for attacking a piece of dead beef.

Good on Mike.

Do you mean that this incident caused a change in your behavior towards Mike?

See that is an example of how people want children to learn to settle their problems in the manner of adults, with violence.
 
Actually, apparently children can bring weapons to school. Nobody stopped this girl at the door with it, it was only found after she took it out to cut her meat. A student who brought a weapon to school to do harm would have done so despite the asinine law.

The law nor the enforcement of it didn't make one single child in the school safer.

So you can now only ban weapons in schools if you search all students?
 
Might that have anything to do with the fact that off duty police officers carry guns?

Now imagine many citizens also carrying guns. How many more crimes would be thwarted?

Ah so your claim is that not enough people carry guns with them even when they are allowed to?
 
But it's even more insidious than that - it give people a FALSE sense of security - laws, rules, zero tolerance will and can never protect anybody from anyone who want to harm other people. You can not legislate that people not harm each other.

So the solution is to bring back the wild west as that was the safest time in America. You solved your problems yourself with local vigilance committees, what is a more democratic form of justice than that?
 
And why shouldn't they be? They could be at least as dangerous as a steak knife, if not more so.

That is a different question.

And I guess you really do think that it was a wrongful shooting that guy just because he stabbed the cop with a steak knife. They wouldn't have shot him if it had only punched the cop right?
 
My 6-year-old can competently handle a steak knife to cut his food. I'm not saying I would send it to school with him, because that introduces other variables beyond my control (other kids who may not be competent), but judging ability based on age is not wise.

Also apparently peoples abillity to cook. A steak shouldn't need a steak knife.
 
The states that this is the case Arizona, Delaware, Georgia, Indiana, Kansas, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota, South Carolina, Utah, Texas, Vermont, Virginia, Wisconsin.
link

So I count 17 states. Less that I thought, but more than the handful you imply.

Without checking them all, 17 out of 50 I think qualifies as a handful. And even if it doesn't, it still doesn't support your point.
 
See that is an example of how people want children to learn to settle their problems in the manner of adults, with violence.

Strawman.

So you can now only ban weapons in schools if you search all students?

Strawman.

Ah so your claim is that not enough people carry guns with them even when they are allowed to?

Strawman.

So the solution is to bring back the wild west as that was the safest time in America. You solved your problems yourself with local vigilance committees, what is a more democratic form of justice than that?

Strawman.

That is a different question.

And I guess you really do think that it was a wrongful shooting that guy just because he stabbed the cop with a steak knife. They wouldn't have shot him if it had only punched the cop right?

Strawman.


You're not even pretending to be reasonable anymore.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom