10 year old Arrested for Cutting Meat in School

I believe that the majority of people don't quite understand the purpose of rules such as these. "Gun Free Zones" and "Zero Tolerance Policies" are implemented not so much to promote public safety but rather to maintain the "illusion" of public safety. Folks inclined to violent crime are not detered by rules. This is a fact that the rule makers would rather the masses remain ignorant of. It's this ignorance that encourages the rule makers to implement ridiculous, inneffective laws. It's all about sustaining the illusion. It keeps folks happy...
But it's even more insidious than that - it give people a FALSE sense of security - laws, rules, zero tolerance will and can never protect anybody from anyone who want to harm other people. You can not legislate that people not harm each other.
 
By the way, in case any of you have kids in school, be advised that laser pointers are considered a dangerous object, the same as a knife or a gun! They can be pointed at someone's eyes and cause injury, so they're banned in schools.

Is this even true? I've never really bought the whole 'laser pointers are dangerous' theory...

A real laser, maybe, and i suppose its possible that there may have been a batch that had slightly too powerful lasers in them, but your average run-of-the-mill laser pointer? (Are they even real lasers?)
 
I think the consensus here is that sending a ten-year-old to school with a steak knife was incredibly stupid.

Automatically assuming a person's competence based solely on age might not be the ideal basis for an argument. I responsibly carried a pocket knife my whole life since the age of seven. At twelve years of age I could safely operate one ton trucks, dump trucks, cars and tractors. Also at that age my father took me to his shop on Saturdays where I worked at dismounting, repairing and remounting tires on heavy construction trucks (using all sorts of "pointy" tools and equipment). OTOH, there are some 45 year old adults that I wouldn't trust with a sharpened toothpick...
 
Sorry, I don't buy your position, especially since I usually take reference to "political correctness" as a sign that a person hasn't really given things very much thought.

If you'd like to do some reading on the subject, click the linky-dink.:D
So anyone who uses the expression "political correctness" is automatically suspect? Never mind that the influence of the phenomena of political correctness in American culture is blindingly obvious virtually everywhere you look. And, of course, we all know that our public schools and universities are bastions of right wing thinking. No, I'm afraid that your notion that zero tolerance and "weapons" bans have their roots in the right doesn't begin to hold water. I'm neither right nor left and think both ends of the spectrum have their heads up their butts. They are both proponents of social engineering of one sort of another - but this zero tolerance stuff and this baby boomer hysteria about virtually everything has its roots in the left.
 
Last edited:
My question still remains because even your answer still doesn't make any sense. I don't want to blame the kid but for christ's sake parents use common sense. Giving a ten yearl old a steak knife is stupid for ooo so many reasons the least of which is having it used as a weapon.
Is it? Why? I used steak knives perfectly competently when I was ten. Why shouldn't a ten year old be allowed to bring a knife to school to cut her meat? Is there really any reasoning behind it? I might add that I got my first 22 when I was ten and went out shooting all the time. Didn't kill myself or anybody else. We have extended infancy well into our childrens teens. Baby boomer are far more hysterical than our parents were. Safety above all else!!! There is no tolerable risk!!! Why don't we just clothe our kids in bubble wrap?
 
Last edited:
Knife is mentioned, with an exception made for pocketknives. Seems pretty clear that all knives that are not pocket knives are illegal.

THe kick boxing thing is a stupid urban legend, no matter what you do, your natural appendages are not considered weapons.

And why shouldn't they be? They could be at least as dangerous as a steak knife, if not more so.

Pah, I spit on your excessively complex, failure-prone weaponry. We built weapons using nothing more than common, ordinary, everyday school supplies doubtless found in every single classroom in America - paper and rubber bands.

Take a piece of paper - about 4" x 6" does very nicely - and fold it over and over until you can't fold it any more, and you have a nice solid, V-shaped projectile.

Loop a rubber band around your thumb and index finger. You now have a mini slingshot. Fit the projectile into the rubber band. Draw back on it as far as you can go without breaking the rubber band. Choose your target and release. Guaranteed to raise welts at any distance under six feet.

Paper? Is that the best you can do?

Ha.

We shot paper clips.
 
Is it? Why? I used steak knives perfectly competently when I was ten. Why shouldn't a ten year old be allowed to bring a knife to school to cut her meat? Is there really any reasoning behind it?

Zero reasoning that could not be applied to another tool which would be considered acceptable.

This is an example of Orwell's prediction concerning the training of thought and use of language.
 
My question still remains because even your answer still doesn't make any sense.

Why not? Isn't that what one does with a steak knife? Isn't that what she was doing with it?

I don't want to blame the kid but for christ's sake parents use common sense. Giving a ten yearl old a steak knife is stupid for ooo so many reasons the least of which is having it used as a weapon.

I think it highly presumptuous of you to make any judgment about her capability of using a steak knife or her parents' judgment in letting her use one without knowing anything about her except that she's ten.
 
Last edited:
Since we're telling stories about impromptu weapons...

Other than the time in 4th grade when I knocked out a kid's tooth in one of those "I hit him, he hit the ground" moments... I haven't really been much in to fighting. I was the quiet kid, constantly picked on, bullied, shunned, no friends, etc... the outcast kid that no one wanted to try to socialize with because they'd be picked on too... right?

Well, living 3 doors down from me was a Sean... a kid who was adopted out of the foster system, who had a chip on his shoulder against the world, and let me tell ya, it was a large chip...

He constantly picked on me on the bus... One time he asked to see my trumpet. He hadn't been TOO mean to me recently so I let him check it out. He took the valve oil out of the case at one point, and proceeded to squirt it in my face.

Now, I have 20/12 vision... and let me tell ya, the thought of mineral oil in my eyes freaked me out... I didn't want to be blinded (I never did find out if mineral oil would harm the eyes or not... hmmm)

I reacted instinctively... and swung my trumpet case at his head. I gashed open his head with it. Blood was everywhere (head wounds DO bleed a lot!)...

He got a week suspension, I got off with what amounted to a warning to try to be more diplomatic next time. :)

ETA: Oh yeah, and Sean hardly messed with me from that point on.

Education is an important part of all children's lives. Sometimes it comes from swiftly moving hard objects!!
 
Is this even true? I've never really bought the whole 'laser pointers are dangerous' theory...

A real laser, maybe, and i suppose its possible that there may have been a batch that had slightly too powerful lasers in them, but your average run-of-the-mill laser pointer? (Are they even real lasers?)
There's a federal requirement that they be labeled as such. All I can say is I spent a reasonable amount of time with red ones pointed at my eyes (very good for the image of your retina viewing!) and - given my eyes - have observed no additional damage from that over about 11 years.:)
 
My question still remains because even your answer still doesn't make any sense. I don't want to blame the kid but for christ's sake parents use common sense. Giving a ten yearl old a steak knife is stupid for ooo so many reasons the least of which is having it used as a weapon.

My 6-year-old can competently handle a steak knife to cut his food. I'm not saying I would send it to school with him, because that introduces other variables beyond my control (other kids who may not be competent), but judging ability based on age is not wise.
 
Last edited:
The funny thing is that when I read the post title, my first thought was that the term "cutting meat" was an euphemism for something sexual-related.
 
The funny thing is that when I read the post title, my first thought was that the term "cutting meat" was an euphemism for something sexual-related.

That's only because everything is a euphemism for something sexual related.

That reminds me, I have to give my wife a good euphemising.
 
Cutting steak, apparently.

I can see the new school policy formulating now. "Zero Tolerance Ban on steak, ham, hard cheese and any other food product that necessitates the use of a weapon for consumption". The little kiddies are going to be stuck eating only peanut butter, marshmallows and Spam with their fingers until they finish college ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom