Zohran Mamdani

10 to 1 you have never read Karl Marx. Much of what he wrote is spot on. He gave one of the greatest compliments to capitalism and free markets any economist has ever written. He also recognized its limitations. Many of the dangers of unfettered capitalism he predicted has come true.

Every modern nation on the planet has embraced a few of Marx's ideas. Including the United States. Few will admit it though. I believe in a free market economy. But that really isn't what we have.
 
Last edited:
Can't I say, "Yes and?", Trump is the worst, MAGA is terrible, and the DSA is bad, and Marxists are terrible?

You can say what you like.

People on the far right of the political spectrum will lap it and help console themselves that Zohran's actions are drawing international admiration, while their own heroes have been savaged by voters.

Other people will have a different analysis. I think it's hilarious.
 
Setting aside your uncalled for incivility and insults… do you acknowledge that republicans are also not monolithic in their views and beliefs, and that MAGA is separate from republicans as a whole, and people who voted for republicans in general?
In addition to not being able to remember what you were claiming, you also apparently aren't reading my responses. I already volunteered that Republicans are not monolithic.

Do you allow that even people who assert they are MAGA can have a wide variety of views and beliefs, with very diverse priorities when it comes to policy, thus resulting in many different valid reasons for their vote?
No. Acknowledging diversity of belief does not imply that those beliefs are "valid" reasons for their vote. There are a million and one kinds of Christian, and I think they'd all be fundamentally misconstruing their role as public citizens in a secular democracy if they voted against gay marriage for religious reasons.

People who voted for Trump the second time around, unique and beautiful snowflakes that they are, were unconscionably stupid. The good news is that they don't have to remain that way.
 
10 to 1 you have never read Karl Marx. Much of what he wrote is spot on. He gave one of the greatest compliments to capitalism and free markets any economist has ever written. He also recognized its limitations. Many of the dangers of unfettered capitalism he predicted has come true.

Every modern nation on the planet has embraced a few of Marx's ideas. Including the United States. Few will admit it though. I believe in a free market economy. But that really isn't what we have.
Depends, I have not read Capital in total, I have read the Communist Manifesto, not all of it sounds bad. Don't see how that matters.
 
I get it, my side can do no wrong, your side can do no right, there is nothing to be concerned about over here because the other side is so bad. Is there an opposite to both sides? The other side is so bad that my side can do no wrong?

I mean, classic cult behavior...my guy can do no wrong seems more in line with cult behavior than both sides have some bad even if one side is currently worse.
 
Last edited:
Depends, I have not read Capital in total, I have read the Communist Manifesto, not all of it sounds bad. Don't see how that matters.
It matters because you're labeling others as his acolyte. And you're also doing it as a pejorative. It matters because you don't hear them using that label. It lacks nuance.

I don't care what you label an economic policy. I care if it benefits the most amount of people. And clearly, how capitalism is functioning in the US, it doesn't do that. It's great for a few. But it isn't good for a majority. The US has lots of socialist policies and has had since Abraham Lincoln. Even before Karl Marx.
 
I get it, my side can do no wrong, your side can do no right, there is nothing to be concerned about over here because the other side is so bad. Is there an opposite to both sides? The other side is so bad that my side can do no wrong?

I mean, classic cult behavior...my guy can do no wrong seems more in line with cult behavior than both sides have some bad even if one side is currently worse.
Now you've gone off the deep end.
 
It matters because you're labeling others as his acolyte. And you're also doing it as a pejorative. It matters because you don't hear them using that label. It lacks nuance.

I don't care what you label an economic policy. I care if it benefits the most amount of people. And clearly, how capitalism is functioning in the US, it doesn't do that. It's great for a few. But it isn't good for a majority. The US has lots of socialist policies and has had since Abraham Lincoln. Even before Karl Marx.
See, I am not labeling anyone other than what they have labeled themselves. I don't think Marx or Engles meant for millions of folks to be killed in their name. That just seems to have been a consequence of their ideas. That there are people currently still calling themselves Marxists, is a mystery to me on that account. It suggests to me that they are not especially opposed to killing millions of people.

I don't even think that's all of the DSA but the DSA seems ok with having those folks among them. That is concerning.

None of that implies or suggests that I think MAGA is good or worth voting for. That is the thing the cultists seem to miss. I can dislike Trump, MAGA, and Socialists. Disliking socialists does not mean I support fascists. Especially now that MAGA has had its ass handed to it so thoroughly that not even Trump is pretending otherwise.

I'd say that you've gone off the deep end, but you did that a while ago, the inability to accept that someone can think you are wrong, the DSA is wrong and Trump is even more wrong.

I really don't know how to make this clearer. I think socialism in all its forms has been demonstrated to produce poverty at best and mass murder at worst. I also think Fascism has done the same.

This is both siderism in that I think there is an authoritarian illiberal strain on both sides. The inability to accept that without assuming I'm on the other side is evidence that I am correct.
 
It matters because you're labeling others as his acolyte. And you're also doing it as a pejorative. It matters because you don't hear them using that label. It lacks nuance.

I don't care what you label an economic policy. I care if it benefits the most amount of people. And clearly, how capitalism is functioning in the US, it doesn't do that. It's great for a few. But it isn't good for a majority. The US has lots of socialist policies and has had since Abraham Lincoln. Even before Karl Marx.
The DSA's national political committee, the nearest thing they have to leadership, is about half people who call themselves Marxists. Forgive me if I take them at their word and label them Marx's acolytes.
 
See, I am not labeling anyone other than what they have labeled themselves. I don't think Marx or Engles meant for millions of folks to be killed in their name. That just seems to have been a consequence of their ideas. That there are people currently still calling themselves Marxists, is a mystery to me on that account. It suggests to me that they are not especially opposed to killing millions of people.

I don't even think that's all of the DSA but the DSA seems ok with having those folks among them. That is concerning.
Painting all of the DSA with a broad brush. Got it.
None of that implies or suggests that I think MAGA is good or worth voting for. That is the thing the cultists seem to miss. I can dislike Trump, MAGA, and Socialists. Disliking socialists does not mean I support fascists. Especially now that MAGA has had its ass handed to it so thoroughly that not even Trump is pretending otherwise.
How is the DSA wrong?

I really don't know how to make this clearer. I think socialism in all its forms has been demonstrated to produce poverty at best and mass murder at worst. I also think Fascism has done the same.
Then you're blind. The fact is, it hasn't. In countless ways the opposite is the truth. Everything from Social Security, Unemployment Insurance, Child labor laws, the Minimum Wage, OSHA, Graduated Income Tax, the Rural Electrification Act, the Bonneville Power Administration, the Interstate Highway Project, VA loans, Public Utilities, and so much more were all labeled as socialism by their opponents. And the opponents were not wrong. They are socialist. And actually advance society not cause poverty.
This is both siderism in that I think there is an authoritarian illiberal strain on both sides. The inability to accept that without assuming I'm on the other side is evidence that I am correct.
I agree. But recognizing that the present economic system is in serious need of reform is myopic. Our health care system is a disaster. A system where government contractors make campaign donations to politicians. Where judges accept free travel and lodging not to mention gifts and honorariums from companies and organizations and then make rulings that directly benefits them.
 
Last edited:
The DSA's national political committee, the nearest thing they have to leadership, is about half people who call themselves Marxists. Forgive me if I take them at their word and label them Marx's acolytes.
No they don't.
 
See, I am not labeling anyone other than what they have labeled themselves. I don't think Marx or Engles meant for millions of folks to be killed in their name. That just seems to have been a consequence of their ideas. That there are people currently still calling themselves Marxists, is a mystery to me on that account. It suggests to me that they are not especially opposed to killing millions of people.

I don't even think that's all of the DSA but the DSA seems ok with having those folks among them. That is concerning.

None of that implies or suggests that I think MAGA is good or worth voting for. That is the thing the cultists seem to miss. I can dislike Trump, MAGA, and Socialists. Disliking socialists does not mean I support fascists. Especially now that MAGA has had its ass handed to it so thoroughly that not even Trump is pretending otherwise.

I'd say that you've gone off the deep end, but you did that a while ago, the inability to accept that someone can think you are wrong, the DSA is wrong and Trump is even more wrong.

I really don't know how to make this clearer. I think socialism in all its forms has been demonstrated to produce poverty at best and mass murder at worst. I also think Fascism has done the same.

This is both siderism in that I think there is an authoritarian illiberal strain on both sides. The inability to accept that without assuming I'm on the other side is evidence that I am correct.
You seem to think that socialism is synonymous with Marxism or similar communist philosophies, but the are democratic socialists and social democrat states (common in Europe). Your comments about Marx could as well be made about Christ. 'I don't think Christ meant for millions of folks to be killed in his name. That just seems to have been a consequence of his ideas. That there are people currently still calling themselves Christians, is a mystery to me on that account. It suggests to me that they are not especially opposed to killing millions of people.'

I think DSA as their name implies are seeking social democracy;
Social Democracy: Often practiced in nations like Sweden and Denmark, this approach maintains an overall capitalist economic framework while using extensive state regulation, progressive taxation, and strong welfare programs to ensure income fairness.
 
“Trump is worse than tyrannical communists and/or terrorists” is an interesting belief.
However

Trump is far more antidemocratic and authoritarian and generally simply worse than any democrats with any chance of serious power. If you want to focus on the extremes of the DSA, you should include the Klan* on the Republican side


*Do I need to add that the Klan is obscene.
 
Last edited:
However

Trump is far more antidemocratic and authoritarian and generally simply worse than any democrats with any chance of serious power. If you want to focus on the extremes of the DSA, you should include the Klan* on the Republican side


*Do I need to add that the Klan is obscene.
Or Vladimir Putin? Or Kim Jon Un? Or Netanyahu? Or Pol Pot? Or Idi Amin? Or Al Quaeda? Or the Catholic Church?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom