Zohran Mamdani

ahhell would not be able to distinguish an early Trump rally speech to the nascent MAGA community from one from Bernie Sanders -
what MAGA movement claims is its agenda is almost entirely in line with a more socialist agenda:
- restricting the power of Big Business, forcing them to sell shares to the government
That's not what DSA wants. They want to NATIONALIZE big companies and completely take control of them:
Establish public ownership of the largest corporations and essential industries to ensure democratic control and accountability to the people.
- dictating prices on drugs, electricity, insurance premiums
DSA doesn't want to dictate prices, they want NO PRICES at all:

You have no debt. You don’t need health insurance. You don’t pay a mortgage or have a landlord, because comfortable housing is a human right. Your retirement is publicly funded. Food, education, energy, medicine, and transportation aren’t for-profit businesses; they are common goods and utilities.
Guarantee universal healthcare at no cost to individuals, including complete access to reproductive and gender-affirming care. Expand healthcare access and quality by investing in new public hospitals and clinics. Make all medical education and training public and free.
- demanding that companies reduce their commitments overseas and bring jobs back to the US
That's not something DSA has stated that they want in any fashion. Not anywhere I've been able to find. Domestication of industry and labor doesn't seem to be a priority.
 
I expect a lot of MAGA voters will start voting for DSA and DSA adjacent candidates.
I would be absolutely shocked if that were true. I can't imagine that any material portion of people who are actually MAGA voters (as opposed to independents who voted republican) would completely flip their values of liberty, nationalism, and capitalism and hop on board with a platform of socialism-as-a-stepping-stone-to-global-communism that wants to completely dismantle substantial portions of the US constitution.
 
I would be absolutely shocked if that were true. I can't imagine that any material portion of people who are actually MAGA voters (as opposed to independents who voted republican) would completely flip their values of liberty, nationalism, and capitalism and hop on board with a platform of socialism-as-a-stepping-stone-to-global-communism that wants to completely dismantle substantial portions of the US constitution.

I don't know about MAGA voters becoming DSA voters, but the rest of this post is just an absolutely breath-taking denial of reality.
 
Here's Emily's Cat in 2024 telling everyone to calm down about Trump (and getting pretty much every prediction spectacularly wrong):
Trumps direct administration still can't get things accomplished without support from Congress. And realistically, even if Trump were to get re-elected, which I don't particularly want, they're going to be tied u pin never-ending investigations, scrutiny, and challenges to every single action they take for the whole time. I expect that even *less* would be effectively accomplished than the first time around.

I mean, seriously - were Trump to get in office again... do you think Democrats and the general public are going to just step back and let Trump do stuff?


Trump can make whatever idiotic claims they want - at the end of the day, their beliefs are irrelevant to whether or not they would be able to actually accomplish anything.

It's not a reliance on Trump's incompetence - it's a reliance on the desire of Democrats, the Press, and half the US population to oppose Trump's every move at every step.

Here's Emily's Cat in 2026 suggesting that eight DSA members in Congress has put the United States on the path to become Soviet Russia:
Depends on whether you think USSR, CCP, and DPNK are examples of great governance and freedom I suppose.
 
Last edited:
It's really gratifying to see people who supported the worst president ever try to smear a bloke who's already changing the face of New York, on the basis that he has ties to an organisation that even at its worst, is still infinitely less harmful than MAGA..

Do carry on...
 
Why is it a meaningful distinction that DSA isn't technically a party?
That was not the distinction being made.

Well... other than the ones that ran against Republicans I guess? And the ones from other states who won seats?
Try to read for comprehension: I explicitly said the DSA members in New York. None of them won in districts where the Republicans had a chance.

And DSA candidates in other states also tend to compete with more traditional Democrats. Who did Nithya Raman just defeat in LA?

I think it's as reasonable of me to have issues with the DSA program as it is for all of us to have issues with Project 2025. I have issues with the policies, and with the people pushing those policies.
You have the memory of a goldfish. You can be critical of the DSA all day long, but that does not make Mamdani a liar, which was the stupid claim in question.

It's crazy, I know, but I continue to be opposed to communism and all of the efforts to usher in communism by a different name. Consistency is just so inconvenient.
You aren't being consistent, for the reason already pointed out.

There's a difference between being critical of communism and being mindlessly critical of democratic socialism.

Depends on whether you think USSR, CCP, and DPNK are examples of great governance and freedom I suppose.
Laughable. We're talking about small numbers of representatives in pre-electoral coalition within one of our major political parties. The appropriate comparison would be the democracies of Western and Northern Europe, which routinely admit socialist parties to governing coalitions, and which are all more functional than our own (and I don't think that's a coincidence).
 
Last edited:
It's really gratifying to see people who supported the worst president ever try to smear a bloke who's already changing the face of New York, on the basis that he has ties to an organisation that even at its worst, is still infinitely less harmful than MAGA..

Do carry on...
“Trump is worse than tyrannical communists and/or terrorists” is an interesting belief.
 
You have the memory of a goldfish. You can be critical of the DSA all day long, but that does not make Mamdani a liar, which was the stupid claim in question
Setting aside your uncalled for incivility and insults… do you acknowledge that republicans are also not monolithic in their views and beliefs, and that MAGA is separate from republicans as a whole, and people who voted for republicans in general? Do you allow that even people who assert they are MAGA can have a wide variety of views and beliefs, with very diverse priorities when it comes to policy, thus resulting in many different valid reasons for their vote?
 
It’s funny that you think my opposition to both selective ethics and motivated reasoning is “inconsistent”. The only thing I’m “inconsistent” about is parroting empty virtue in support of what you think I ought.
Cool story, bro.

We can read your posts, and we can read your old posts as well. @johnny karate's quotations of your posts showed you engaging in both selective ethics and motivated reasoning. You thought it would be no big deal to re-elect Trump, because "Democrats, the Press, and half the US population" would "oppose Trump's every move at every step." But now you think Mamdani's election is a threat worthy of comparison to "USSR, CCP, and DPNK".

That's another example of your long history of consistently parroting empty virtue, not in support of what I think you ought, but in support of what you think you ought.
 
Why is it a meaningful distinction that DSA isn't technically a party?

A political party picks the candidates who will represent it in government and determines the issues the candidates will work on in the government, but with a tradeoff you need to reach voters which takes quite a bit of effort and you need agenda expressed as a platform.

A political faction, a subdivision of a political party, places candidates of their choice in the primaries but must support the winning candidate if their candidate does not win, and also gets to bring issues to the agenda, but doesn't get to set the agenda.


The DSA as a political party has a rather detailed platform. The DSA, as a subdivision of the Democratic Party, has a rather undefined agenda in the form of a program. A hundredfold decrease in detail, leaving much to the imagination because they don't need to convince the voters to vote for them.

They trade control for influence. As an independent party they have no say over the leadership of another party, but as a subdivision of a political party they can influence who gets elected to the leadership. Notice the troubles of Chuck and Hakeem.


Maybe it's just a meaningful distinction for me.
 
“Trump is worse than tyrannical communists and/or terrorists” is an interesting belief.
How many wars has China started, or Cuba, or North Korea? How many people have died as a result of their actions? Yes, they are bad people. but at least they keep their oppression internal. Have they bombed a school? Kidnapped a foreign leader and boasted about how they are making billions from that war?
 
How many wars has China started, or Cuba, or North Korea? How many people have died as a result of their actions? Yes, they are bad people. but at least they keep their oppression internal. Have they bombed a school? Kidnapped a foreign leader and boasted about how they are making billions from that war?
You forgot 240+/- extra-judicial murders.
 
“Trump is worse than tyrannical communists and/or terrorists” is an interesting belief.

:dl:

If I thought you had a single shred of self-awareness, I'd point out how laughable you make yourself with idiotic comments like that so that you don't embarrass yourself in the real world.

"tyrannical communists and terrorists"

Pure Gold!
 
A political party picks the candidates who will represent it in government and determines the issues the candidates will work on in the government, but with a tradeoff you need to reach voters which takes quite a bit of effort and you need agenda expressed as a platform.
A political faction, a subdivision of a political party, places candidates of their choice in the primaries but must support the winning candidate if their candidate does not win, and also gets to bring issues to the agenda, but doesn't get to set the agenda.


The DSA as a political party has a rather detailed platform. The DSA, as a subdivision of the Democratic Party, has a rather undefined agenda in the form of a program. A hundredfold decrease in detail, leaving much to the imagination because they don't need to convince the voters to vote for them.

They trade control for influence. As an independent party they have no say over the leadership of another party, but as a subdivision of a political party they can influence who gets elected to the leadership. Notice the troubles of Chuck and Hakeem.


Maybe it's just a meaningful distinction for me.
Highlighted bit means that neither the Democrats nor Republicans in the United States are political parties. The Dems are a little closer, I guess.
 
How many wars has China started, or Cuba, or North Korea? How many people have died as a result of their actions? Yes, they are bad people. but at least they keep their oppression internal. Have they bombed a school? Kidnapped a foreign leader and boasted about how they are making billions from that war?
China, 10s of millions of people have died as a direct result of the policies of the Chinese communist party. If by internal, you mean, Tibet, Cambodia, Vietnam.... And I guess it doesn't count as long as the folks you kill are inside the border you claim, guess then the Chi Coms have barely killed anyone. So, I guess I shouldn't be worried about the Marxists in the DSA, they'll only kill people inside the US.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom