Zohran Mamdani

I don't disagree. At least not entirely. But since usage changes definitions, nailing down what was meant when the term was used is crucial.
Sure, that's why we have an entire profession for that. And that's why (usually, ideally) that profession is tasked with writing dictionaries.

I'm saying the words "socialism and Marxist" have been so abused that their original meanings has been obscured. And their original meaning varied a lot even when the terms were coined.
Ok, but that's pretty far removed from saying that Marxists don't exist. And I don't think it's that obscured. Quantum mechanics has been conflated with all sorts of nonsense, but it's not that hard to sort the real stuff from the ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊. You can just ask a quantum physicist.
 
Last edited:
Sure, that's why we have an entire profession for that. And that's why (usually, ideally) that profession is tasked with writing dictionaries.


Ok, but that's pretty far removed from saying that Marxists don't exist. And I don't think it's that obscured. Quantum mechanics has been conflated with all sorts of nonsense, but it's not that hard to sort the real stuff from the ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊. You can just ask a quantum physicist.
They might exist in the sense that some individuals may self identify as Marxist. What I don't buy is when others do that for them.
 
Now to get back to Zohran Mamdani - probably the weirdest thing about him is his relationship with Trump.

His ability to talk calmly to even the biggest bigots of them all is outstanding. It looks to me like he gained an extra 90 days for stores to comply with new SNAP rules.

Legendary.
 
Now to get back to Zohran Mamdani - probably the weirdest thing about him is his relationship with Trump.

His ability to talk calmly to even the biggest bigots of them all is outstanding. It looks to me like he gained an extra 90 days for stores to comply with new SNAP rules.

Legendary.
Really appreciate him taking one for the team there. I would not be able to do it.
 
That's Webster's definition. It is not an authority. It usually is known for tracking usage. But from the same source, it says;

"Far more common are social democracies, such as Sweden and Denmark: democratically elected governments that employ some socialist practices but within a capitalist framework in the belief that extensive state regulation paired with limited state ownership produces a fair distribution of income without impairing economic growth."
You just claimed that socialism isn't socialism, by supplying a description of something that isn't socialism.
 
Some businesses SHOULD be publicly owned.

For example, I live in Washington State where almost all of the electric companies are publicly owned and managed by Public Utilities Districts. They deliver 80 plus percent of the electricity in our state. And they do it inexpensively. Average price per KWh of electricity supplied by those PUDs in Washington is 10.1 cents. The few privately owned electricity providers in our state on average charge 16.5 cents.

Tell me, what is better?
It's fairly well accepted that natural monopolies are more efficient and cost effective when they're publicly owned or government administered. I don't think anyone disagrees with that. Most utilities are already municipal, and it doesn't make sense to try to have competition for them since they need to use the same delivery mechanisms (roads, water and sewage pipes, electrical lines, gas mains, etc.).

But it's rather a different thing to suggest that all large private companies should be seized regardless of whether they're natural monopolies or not.
 
My point is the word means nothing. That it is amorphous and used pejoratively and with a very broad brush.
Except that it DOES mean something, and the thing that it actually means is exactly what DSA preaches and seeks to make into policy. DSA isn't after "socialism light because municipal utilities and social safety nets are beneficial". They're literally after seizing the means of production.

They are literally and exactly the textbook definition of actual socialism.

Pretending that they aren't advocating socialism just because someone else uses the term incorrectly is poor logic. I'm sure it's some kind of fallacy, but I can't be bothered to go look it up. Just know that your argument is about as watertight as a fishing net.
 
Now to get back to Zohran Mamdani - probably the weirdest thing about him is his relationship with Trump.

His ability to talk calmly to even the biggest bigots of them all is outstanding. It looks to me like he gained an extra 90 days for stores to comply with new SNAP rules.

Legendary.
He's laying the ground work for the incoming congress. Show them how easy it is to manipulate Trump. we already knew he was malleable as clay, he's proving that it can be done to benefit the American people not just dictators or billionaires.
 
The problem isn't that they define the world for me. It's that they affect how words are used by a great many people. You see, words don't have hard definitions, they have usages.
I always find it interesting how selective people are about which words they're will to let be redefined and which they want to stick to a strict historical definition for. I'm as guilty of this as anyone else, I have a handful of terms that make me bristle when they get pulled and twisted all out of shape to a point where they no longer have any utility. What's surprising to me is the volume of people who aren't aware that they have specific biases and think they're being consistent.

I'm all for hewing to an accurate definition of socialism. But that also means acknowledging that DSA are using the accurate definition of socialism, and hence calling them socialists is a completely rational and appropriate thing to do. It's what they are, in the literal meaning of the word.
 
They might exist in the sense that some individuals may self identify as Marxist. What I don't buy is when others do that for them.
A substantial chunk of DSA members self identify as Marxists in the actual correct meaning of the word. Why are you arguing against that?

ETA... I'll also note that you don't appear to have the same degree of complaint when others label people in ways that you happen to agree with, even if such labels are similarly stretched and figurative in nature.
 
Last edited:
capitalism grinds to a halt in the absence of high progressive taxation and continuous wealth distribution, as everyone who has ever played Monopoly knows instinctively. And that will only happen if capitalism operates within a Democracy independent and powerful enough to control and restrict capitalism.
Socialism is just the acknowledgement that capitalism will devour the society and itself if left to its own devices.
 
A substantial chunk of DSA members self identify as Marxists in the actual correct meaning of the word. Why are you arguing against that?

ETA... I'll also note that you don't appear to have the same degree of complaint when others label people in ways that you happen to agree with, even if such labels are similarly stretched and figurative in nature.

Genuinely curious what labels are being referred to here, because labels like "authoritarian" and "fascist" and white supermacist" and "Nazi" are accurate when it comes to Republican Party.

Happy to provide receipts to anyone who disagrees.
 
Now to get back to Zohran Mamdani - probably the weirdest thing about him is his relationship with Trump.

His ability to talk calmly to even the biggest bigots of them all is outstanding. It looks to me like he gained an extra 90 days for stores to comply with new SNAP rules.

Legendary.

It's psychological warefare. He knows exactly how to manipulate Trump and does so perfectly.
 
It's psychological warefare. He knows exactly how to manipulate Trump and does so perfectly.

I like Mamdani, but playing Trump isn't that tough. It's not even a challenge if you think about it. It's the same with the reporters that know how to push his buttons so that he gets pissed, does something stupid, they take him to court, the court makes Trump look stupid, rinse, repeat.

Mamdani is getting some pretty glowing reviews though.
 
I like Mamdani, but playing Trump isn't that tough. It's not even a challenge if you think about it. It's the same with the reporters that know how to push his buttons so that he gets pissed, does something stupid, they take him to court, the court makes Trump look stupid, rinse, repeat.

Mamdani is getting some pretty glowing reviews though.

Yes agreed, he's definitely playing on easy mode. But it's still fun to watch.
 
It isn’t that hard, but it’s interesting how many people accept Trump’s invitation to reality TV hostility.

Despite the association between socialism and idealism, Mamdani is one of the most pragmatic politicians I’ve ever seen. He understands that Trump has basically two modes, where he wants a fight or to be charmed and feted (charmless and fetid though he may be). That, and he’s got a good ass.
 
During his second term, President Donald Trump's administration has aggressively acquired equity stakes, warrants, and golden shares in private companies. [1, 2]
According to tracking by the Cato Institute's Government Ownership Dashboard and reports from the Wall Street Journal, the federal government has established equity positions or deal agreements spanning more than 40 companies (up to 41–43 tracked deals) across sectors like semiconductors, critical minerals, rare earths, energy, and quantum computing, totaling roughly $30 billion in investment activity. [1, 2, 3]

The guy you support is the real socialist.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom