Zohran Mamdani

Then you're blind. The fact is, it hasn't. In countless ways the opposite is the truth. Everything from Social Security, Unemployment Insurance, Child labor laws, the Minimum Wage, OSHA, Graduated Income Tax, the Rural Electrification Act, the Bonneville Power Administration, the Interstate Highway Project, VA loans, Public Utilities, and so much more were all labeled as socialism by their opponents. And the opponents were not wrong. They are socialist. And actually advance society not cause poverty.
Those aren’t socialism. Those are social safety nets and regulations.

Don’t adopt someone else’s inaccurate use of terms just because it helps you bolster a poor argument.

Seizing private companies and industries and making them state or employee owned is socialism. And it almost always results in reduced productivity and widespread suffering.
 
Those aren’t socialism. Those are social safety nets and regulations.

Don’t adopt someone else’s inaccurate use of terms just because it helps you bolster a poor argument.

Seizing private companies and industries and making them state or employee owned is socialism. And it almost always results in reduced productivity and widespread suffering.
No, that's not socialism. You don't have a clue what you're talking about.
 
Those aren’t socialism. Those are social safety nets and regulations.

Don’t adopt someone else’s inaccurate use of terms just because it helps you bolster a poor argument.

Seizing private companies and industries and making them state or employee owned is socialism. And it almost always results in reduced productivity and widespread suffering.
You need to read about social democracy, the type of socialism in Scandinavia and NW Europe in general (as exemplified by the post WW2 Labour government). There is a balance between social ownership of natural monopolies (e.g. not for profits, co-ops) and communism. As I posted elsewhere the US air traffic control is nationalised, paid for by tax payers and not fit for purpose, whilst Europe makes the user pay not the tax payer, more capitalist. The NHS in the UK is socialist, but nearly all family practitioners are independent businesses, it was only the hospitals that were nationalised. Most of Europe has a mixed health economy far more cost effective and delivering better outcomes than the US health care system. US education is not the best in the world (using PISA).

A bit of socialism would make the US stronger.
 
Last edited:
That's Webster's definition. It is not an authority. It usually is known for tracking usage. But from the same source, it says;

"Far more common are social democracies, such as Sweden and Denmark: democratically elected governments that employ some socialist practices but within a capitalist framework in the belief that extensive state regulation paired with limited state ownership produces a fair distribution of income without impairing economic growth."
 
From your definition; that you failed to quote from.
Since the term socialism entered English around 1830, it has consistently referred to a system of social organization in which the ownership of property and the distribution of income are subject to social rather than private control. The conception of that control, however, has varied, and socialism has been interpreted in widely diverging ways, ranging from statist to libertarian, from Marxist to liberal. In the modern era, "pure" socialism has been seen only rarely and usually briefly in a few Communist regimes. Far more common are social democracies, such as Sweden and Denmark: democratically elected governments that employ some socialist practices but within a capitalist framework in the belief that extensive state regulation paired with limited state ownership produces a fair distribution of income without impairing economic growth. While in the past social democracy and democratic socialism both referred to movements seeking a fully socialist system, the two terms have diverged. Today's social democracies retain a capitalist system overall, while democratic socialism rejects capitalism fully, and seeks to establish a decentralized socialist economic system within a democratically run government.
 
Marxism is an amorphous label used by the right to villify anyone that might embrace progressive policies.
Ok, but it's also a label that people who hew closely to Marx' political philosophy and methods use for themselves.

I mean, the right has also spent decades villifying anyone who thinks public schools are worth having as socialists. That's dumb, but it doesn't follow that there's no such thing as a socialist.
 
Ok, but it's also a label that people who hew closely to Marx' political philosophy and methods use for themselves.

I mean, the right has also spent decades villifying anyone who thinks public schools are worth having as socialists. That's dumb, but it doesn't follow that there's no such thing as a socialist.
I'm sorry. But I don't understand your point.
 
Some businesses SHOULD be publicly owned.

For example, I live in Washington State where almost all of the electric companies are publicly owned and managed by Public Utilities Districts. They deliver 80 plus percent of the electricity in our state. And they do it inexpensively. Average price per KWh of electricity supplied by those PUDs in Washington is 10.1 cents. The few privately owned electricity providers in our state on average charge 16.5 cents.

Tell me, what is better?
 
My point is that there is such a thing as Marxists, so it's very weird to say there isn't. "Birds aren't real" levels of weird.
My point is the word means nothing. That it is amorphous and used pejoratively and with a very broad brush.
 
It's very true. I just spent months seeing non-stop Republican attack ads labeling almost every Democrat Marxists out to destroy America.
That's not a credible way of evaluating a lexicon. Back in the 80s and early 90s Republicans pretty successfully turned 'liberal' into a pejorative, and applied it broadly. It nevertheless was the case that 'liberal' meant something, and that liberals existed. Anti-semites use 'Jew' as a pejorative, but it doesn't follow that there's no such thing as a Jew.

You shouldn't let professional ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ define the world for you.
 
Last edited:
That's not a credible way of evaluating a lexicon. Back in the 80s and early 90s Republicans pretty successfully turned 'liberal' into a pejorative, and applied it broadly. It nevertheless was the case that 'liberal' meant something, and that liberals existed. Anti-semites use 'Jew' as a pejorative, but it doesn't follow that there's no such thing as a Jew.

You shouldn't let professional ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ define the world for you.
The problem isn't that they define the world for me. It's that they affect how words are used by a great many people. You see, words don't have hard definitions, they have usages.
 
The problem isn't that they define the world for me. It's that they affect how words are used by a great many people. You see, words don't have hard definitions, they have usages.
Yes. Those usages are catalogued in dictionaries. Where you will find Marxist defined to properly reflect its actual, serious usage.

A mistake that people often make after (laudably) taking on a descriptivist rather than prescriptivist view of language is to conclude that anything goes. No, this isn't the case. It is possible to be in error about how a word is used. It is possible to lie. We do not need to update our lexicons just because some Republican operative is completely full of ◊◊◊◊.
 
Last edited:
Yes. Those usages are catalogued in dictionaries. Where you will find Marxist defined to properly reflect its actual, serious usage.

A mistake that people often make after taking on a descriptivist rather than prescriptivist view of language is to conclude that anything goes. No, this isn't the case. It is possible to be in error about how a word is used. It is possible to lie. We do not need to update our lexicons just because some Republican operative is completely full of ◊◊◊◊.
I don't disagree. At least not entirely. But since usage changes definitions, nailing down what was meant when the term was used is crucial. And we've been arguing what the founders meant in the Constitution for more than two centuries. And in many cases we still don't agree on what they meant.

I'm saying the words "socialism and Marxist" have been so abused that their original meanings has been obscured. And their original meaning varied a lot even when the terms were coined.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom